Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Where does the carbon go?

There are a lot of possible sites of carbon dioxide loss in deep ice horizons that I can theorize offhand. Even some that have to do with sampling error and bias. That's why I would like to review the study reports. Do you have any?

And entropy keeps increasing.

Entropy is a stochastic phaenomenon. Which is to say, agreed, but lets not forget entropy. Because, be assured, it will not forget you.

That would be swimming up the entropy stream. Life can do that, but it's a lot more complicated than ice-pack that's cold and way out of reach of the sun.

Don't forget that we're discussing an open system here. Due to the pressures exerted on deep ice, there's enough warmth generated to fuel many reactions and phase changes. (Actually, it's the reactions and phase changes that produce the heat so that's exactly backwards.)

Hydrocarbons are volatile - unless you're talking tar - so they'd show up in the mass-spectrometer readings as hydrocarbons spikes. Which would draw attention. No such attention having been drawn, I think your thought-experiment has run out of legs.

Unless you were involved in these studies, you are assuming way too much. I don't think that casebro had hydrocarbons in mind as much as carbohydrates. The latter is what CO2 would probably form, unless it was really, really deep ice. The simplest carbohydrate is ethylene glycol, which is not a gas at room temperature, even less in ice. I don't know what the measurement device or method was for the carbon dioxide, do you? A mass spec or any detector will only see what it's set up to see. An assumption that someone allowed a chromatograph running for hours per sample in order to see everything that might come off the column is nonsense. If the mass spec was set up to only scan for carbon dioxide, it would probably ignore carbohydrates and hydrocarbons, especially as the tuning would have to be very precise in the low MW range. If the analysts did see extraneous peaks, how do we know they didn't assume those were lab contamination anyway? (Hey, Mac, look ethane. Huh, I wonder where thay came from? Ah, probably exhaust from the truck!)

I have done a lot of environmental chemistry and I have a lot of experience coring soil to see how molecules behave at different horizons. Seems like a simple thing but it's not. Unless you do it just right, you can get contamination at the bottom from the top via the cascading of particles as you pull the corer up. If you're in an area with a high water table. you're done as all you've got is tea permeating your core. Now, that's for non-volatile substances in a stable matrix. I can't even conceive how I would core ice without completely screwing up the lower core due to the heat of the coring device itself, the exposure of the lower core to atmospheric pressure that would induce instantaneous outgasing and exposure to light and surface temperatures.

I really need to see the study publication to determine if the researchers had accounted for all sources of bias. If it's not in the publication, then I'd have to look at the raw data.

Heat-flux from Planet Earth's internal processes is miniscule, and ice is a good insulator. Heat-flux from the Sun - the stuff the surface gets - is immense. The only "of course" involved is that you're talking nonsense.

Has anyone said anything about relying on the earth's core to produce losses of carbon dioxide? You're the first. Obviously, the sun would have nothing to do with it either. Hmm, what's left? Why are glaciers moving? (Cue David Bowie to start singing Pressure.)

I only bring this up because Slimething found it thought-provoking. It's very clear that neither of you have even the vaguest understanding of physics.

Since you've gotten personal, all I can tell you is that you are the ignorant one. What's under the ice cap at the North Pole? Water! But that would mean that your idiotic entropy argument doesn't hold. What's under the earth's mantle? Molten rock! Oh, dear, is your thought-experiment legless now? Stick to believing anything you read as thinking isn't your strong suit. :boggled:
 

Yeah, I think you care a great deal about this subject and have studied it diligently. You express your point of view very honestly and capably. I am very impressed.

You would have to refer to a scientist for that, and even then, the topic covers several fields of specialisation so that you really should be referring to several scientists for mastery. In fact, it would be good if several scientists who are specialists in their fields to put together a report that covers the whole span of the topic.

In my book, anyone who uses the scientific method is a scientist. All you need is a need to learn, said method and the will to work long hours.

We've already prepared one before the show, and here it is. http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html.

I can't argue that the link represents good work. However, I am experienced in environmental sampling and casebro's idea has struck a cord. I want to know how the ice cores were taken and how the researchers overcame the obvious hurdles, if they did. That really is all I can offer to this effort.

That someone has to go to as looney a bunch of nutcases as LaRoche to get his work publised tells you a lot about the author, IMHO.

You and I share the same opinion of LaRouche. Frankly, he's like comic relief.

A simple and easily understood reason is given for the need to move the dates, the air still mixes with the upper layers. We know that Mauna Loa is a valid reading, because it has been verified with the Cape Grimes site.

Like I said, my interest is piqued right now in the sampling technique only. How the data fit or don't is a different subject. I merely want to know how effectively the sampling was done.
 
Hmm...

Shoji, H. and C.C. Langway Jr., Volume relaxation of air inclusions in a fresh ice core. Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1983. 87: p. 4111-4114.

Neftel, A., et al., Evidence from polar ice cores for the increase in atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature, 1985. 315: p. 45-47.

Friedli, H., et al., Ice core record of the 13C/12C ratio of atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature, 1986. 324: p. 237-238.
 
Hmm...

Shoji, H. and C.C. Langway Jr., Volume relaxation of air inclusions in a fresh ice core. Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1983. 87: p. 4111-4114.

Neftel, A., et al., Evidence from polar ice cores for the increase in atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature, 1985. 315: p. 45-47.

Friedli, H., et al., Ice core record of the 13C/12C ratio of atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature, 1986. 324: p. 237-238.

And your point is???
 
Significant warming of the Antarctic Troposphere.

http://www.realclimate.org/index.ph...-warming-of-the-antarctic-winter-troposphere/

The "iconic" Antarctic temperature trends are the large warming seen on the Antarctic Peninsula, which has had various repercussions including the collapse of several ice shelves (some documented in a previous post). Elsewhere, though, the pattern of surface warming is more complex - trends are smaller, and while more are positive than negative they are generally not significant - see this map. Contrary to what you might have heard, this is in general agreement with model predictions. But meanwhile, there is a record for the upper atmosphere derived from radiosondes, which we have been working on - finding old datasets and digitising them to fill in gaps. What this shows is that around East Antarctica there is a general warming of the troposphere, greatest at around mid-height (at 600 hPa) at 0.7 ºC/decade over the last 30+ years.
In itself, this is an interesting observation. The obvious question is, what does it mean? Is this natural variability; is it a response to global warming, or to changes in ozone; or something else? Ozone is unlikely, because this is winter (which conveniently means that the radiosonde temperature corrections, often a source of potential trouble, are not a problem). Two ways of trying to interpret the record are to see what GCMs run for the same period show; or to look at the re-analyses (essentially, the archived outputs from the weather-prediction models). The latter, of course, incorporate many of the radiosonde observations that we are using, and so don't count as independant. Despite this, the ECMWF re-analyses show *greater* trends than we see in the observations; and a maximum trend over West Antarctica (which has no radisonde stations to allow us to verify this). A climate model (HadCM3, with an ensemble of four members) shows similar patterns to the observations, but this time too little warming; and a good deal of variation between the ensemble members. So neither of these is helps much with the interpretation.
 
a_unique_person said:
Hmm...

Shoji, H. and C.C. Langway Jr., Volume relaxation of air inclusions in a fresh ice core. Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1983. 87: p. 4111-4114.

Neftel, A., et al., Evidence from polar ice cores for the increase in atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature, 1985. 315: p. 45-47.

Friedli, H., et al., Ice core record of the 13C/12C ratio of atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature, 1986. 324: p. 237-238.

And your point is???


Argument by citation again? Argument by Web of Science keyword? Google Scholar fight?

Some explanation would be nice.
 
If CapelDodger is right, and the ice cores are checked for carbon, and NOT CO2, then the scientists would have to control for soot. Forest fires, and volcanoes would contribute. And, once the soot is in the ice, it could combine with the oxygen in the water to make CO2. Or not. But I am leery of any 'control'-ing. Figures don't lie, but liars figure...
 
If CapelDodger is right, and the ice cores are checked for carbon, and NOT CO2, then the scientists would have to control for soot. Forest fires, and volcanoes would contribute. And, once the soot is in the ice, it could combine with the oxygen in the water to make CO2. Or not. But I am leery of any 'control'-ing. Figures don't lie, but liars figure...
http://www.ifa.hawaii.edu/UHNAI/NAIweb/presentations/25-Thorsteinsson-icephysII.pdf

Very nice discussion of ice core drilling, including lots of fun pictures and issues about air pockets.
 
Yeah, I think you care a great deal about this subject and have studied it diligently. You express your point of view very honestly and capably. I am very impressed.

Like I said, my interest is piqued right now in the sampling technique only. How the data fit or don't is a different subject. I merely want to know how effectively the sampling was done.

:D

Regarding the issues of sampling techniques, criticisms of them, with respect to the various shallow ice core projects - go to www.climateaudit.org, do a search at the upper right hand box on "ice core". That's a pretty good start.
 
If CapelDodger is right,

I wouldn't worry too much about that possibility. CD seems to want to take a lot on faith. The statements about mass spectrometry were very revealing as to CD's knowledge of analytical chemistry. The entropy thing was worse as it puts CD in the same league as woos of other leanings who like to alllude to the more esoteric concepts in thermodynamics and quantim mechanics.

and the ice cores are checked for carbon, and NOT CO2, then the scientists would have to control for soot. Forest fires, and volcanoes would contribute. And, once the soot is in the ice, it could combine with the oxygen in the water to make CO2. Or not.

One would not use a mass spectrometer to check for carbon unless you wanted to differentiate different forms of carbon (graphite, buckeyballs, etc.) Given the various possible sources of carbon existing in ice strata from sources other than carbon dioxide, I sincerely doubt that a sane scientist would choose carbon as their measurement target. As I've written previously, carbon dioxide would be devilishly hard to sample quantitatively by bringng a deep core to the surface, given the pressure differentials involved.

Yes, it's fairly easy to quantify the concentration of carbon dioxide once a sample is inside a gas-tight vessel. However, what does that sample truly represent? That curve looks a little familiar to me. It looks like about every first-order decay curve I've ever seen which indicates to me that the measurements taken may not be due to any human activity whatsoever.
 
:D

Regarding the issues of sampling techniques, criticisms of them, with respect to the various shallow ice core projects - go to www.climateaudit.org, do a search at the upper right hand box on "ice core". That's a pretty good start.

Thanks for the link, mhaze. I did some perusing under the "data" link and found some good discussions. I'll have to look more fully once I'm outta da office.
 
Argument by citation again? Argument by Web of Science keyword? Google Scholar fight?

Some explanation would be nice.

Why don't you use your Web of Science and tell us what these articles have to say about the issues we have been discussing?

Or is your job to see that skeptics of established climate science are leaned on and required to authenticate every last reference and argument, while any supposedly with the consensus view are given a free pass?
 
You don't agree that the plots in post #98 look like a first order decline? Why not? :confused:

Here's the function: ln[CO2] = kt + C. Wiki article here.
I was laughing in agreement with you on the resembles.

Knew I'd seen that curve somewhere.....

Oh yeah....seen it everywhere....
 
I was laughing in agreement with you on the resembles.

Knew I'd seen that curve somewhere.....

Oh yeah....seen it everywhere....

Yup, it's pretty ubiquitous. It's kind of a thermodynamic catch-all as even very complicated systems that have several n-order reactions usually combine to present a pseudo-first-order profile. But you probably already knew that.

At first blush, I would say that, if natural degradation of carbon dioxide were occuring in ice (per casebro), this curve is exactly what science would predict. No human contribution would be necessary to account for it.
 
Why don't you use your Web of Science and tell us what these articles have to say about the issues we have been discussing?


That was the point? You know, you could have just written something like

"I think these references might be pertinent to the discussion. Could someone with access to the Web of Science and the journals take a look and tell me?"

I'd be happy to help.

Or is your job to see that skeptics of established climate science are leaned on and required to authenticate every last reference and argument, while any supposedly with the consensus view are given a free pass?

No, it's not my job.

I would simply like to know more about the arguments that you are making. The 'established climate science', I can read all about that in the IPCC reports, but your objections require a little more searching around than that.

I didn't think asking for a link or two counts as leaning.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom