Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

I do like the way you phrase things.

Red is your interpretation if I understand correctly, you consider perfectly valid the use of 1900 on for the baseline, and 1970 on for the current trend.

Blue is mine.

Questions? Comments? Insults?

What is so complicated about this?


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1422447220e253cf49.png

There is othing complicated about it. The graph shows a warming trend for all three lines. I don't understand what you think this proves.
 
From looking at the graph and reading what you say.

And yet again, what you say and what the graph you posted shows are not connected to one another. I repeat, you are insane, or lying.

And as if that weren't enough, you claim that 1C is "negligible." It appears from the evidence to be enough to melt the entire Arctic icecap. So much for "negligible."

Meant perhaps 1C for a doubling of CO2, my bad.
 
Meant perhaps 1C for a doubling of CO2, my bad.
Considering it's warmer now than it was in the mid-nineteenth century by very nearly 1C, and we haven't doubled CO2 yet, I'm not sure what your point is. Particularly considering the melting of the Arctic icecap.
 
When carbon dioxide levels are measured in the atmosphere, is that figure an average? Is atmospheric chemistry the same worldwide, barring altitude variance? Or is there a greater concentration of carbon dioxide near its sources? How long does it take for CO2 to become evenly diffused?

Think how long it takes for a storm to blow across the Atlantic; an even distribution is on that sort of timescale. You can find gross CO2 discrepancies across a city, but not aross a region. The wind always blows, if not across then up or down. Any given pocket of air can travel anywhere in a month or so, and bits of it probably will. Gases are like that.

Liquids - such as the oceans - not nearly so much. Oceans are ponderous; they mix thoroughly over thousands of years.

Hypothetically and on a different note, if humans had perfected renewable energy sources during the Industrial Age -- if we hadn't been pouring crud and corrosives into the atmosphere for the past few hundred years -- what kind of climate change could we expect to be seeing today? Would a slower warming rate be going on in this interglacial period, or would we expect to see stable temperatures for some indeterminant period?

The Industrial Age was launched on renewable energy - wind and water. Particularly water. There just wasn't enough available to satisfy demand.

There's no reason to think that there'd be any noticable climate change going on at this stage in this interglacial without our input. The Sun's quiescent. Vulcanism is low, but that doesn't explain the continuing warming (it's been low for a century and more). Without our influence it ought to be a quiet time.
 
This is what I don't get about it. The graph shows a clear warming trend. Anyone can see that.
I would agree. If you think of the chart as showing the stock price of a stock, it's clear that the overall trend line for the stock price is upwards.
 
In what way do you mean "average?"

The sum of the measurments taken at all of the many collection points divided by the number of those collecting points. But "well-mixed gas" helped my curiosity once I looked it up.

I don't know that this has been tested. The answer is something that would require a run of a climate model, so there's no answer I can give you off the top of my head. There are many more things going on with climate than AGW. However, climate has been relatively stable since the end of the glacial-interglacial transition 5000 years ago, so I suspect that we would see relatively stable temperatures rather than the rising ones we see now.

Probably a scenario better left to a sci-fi thread. Thanks for the links.
 
I would agree. If you think of the chart as showing the stock price of a stock, it's clear that the overall trend line for the stock price is upwards.

Indeed. And as we are coming out of a Little Ice Age, one would expect the trend over a long term to be going up, as do stock prices. Stock prices, though have historically swung up and down around that general curve for various economic reasons. As this trend line seems to.

However, the two red lines misrepresent the true slope of the line and generate a component that is allegedly statistically significant - which is then said to be due to human causes, primarily carbon dioxide.

In particular, the 2nd red line to the far right is misleading. It is used to indicate the recent "alarming and unprecedented man made global warming", and various predications show this line continuing without pause - as I have drawn it.

Actual temperature trends are pretty much flat for the last eight years indicating something different is happening.
 
Indeed. And as we are coming out of a Little Ice Age ...

Refuge in the past.

... one would expect the trend over a long term to be going up, as do stock prices.

If this were some cyclical effect that's supposed to explain the Roman Warm Period, the MWP and the LIA, you would expect the trend to be reducing over the last fifty years. In fact, it's only gone down very recently, quite probably coinciding with the solar minimum.

There are two cycles that you seem fond of - the 1500-year plus or minus 500 and the 60-80 year - which both predict a downturn very soon. The Solar Cyclists - and climate modellers, such as the guys at the Met - have things heading upwards again very soon. Three-to-eight years max, and we'll know for sure, won't we?

Stock prices go up (inflation-adjusted) because of the principle of capital accumulation. Economic growth. If the heat energy in the Earth's essential fluids goes up, it's by the same principle - energy accumulation. Whch has to come from somewhere. It's not from income - the Sun has been directly observed for decades - so it comes from reduced outgoings.

Step forward : the greenhouse effect. As predicted.

Stock prices, though have historically swung up and down around that general curve for various economic reasons. As this trend line seems to.

However, the two red lines misrepresent the true slope of the line and generate a component that is allegedly statistically significant - which is then said to be due to human causes, primarily carbon dioxide.

Screw the true slope, you apparently can't register that they're all going upwards, and whatever you turn to will do the same thing.

In particular, the 2nd red line to the far right is misleading. It is used to indicate the recent "alarming and unprecedented man made global warming", and various predications show this line continuing without pause - as I have drawn it.

Well there's a thing. Do you have any good reason to think it won't? Apart from it alarming you?

Actual temperature trends are pretty much flat for the last eight years indicating something different is happening.

Desperate reach back to the El Nino year of '98, but you fell short. There's a very definite warming trend over the last eight years. David Rodale's current "stagnation" means the last two years, coinciding with the solar minimum. There could well be a link.
 
Screw the true slope, you apparently can't register that they're all going upwards, and whatever you turn to will do the same thing.
Quote:
In particular, the 2nd red line to the far right is misleading. It is used to indicate the recent "alarming and unprecedented man made global warming", and various predications show this line continuing without pause - as I have drawn it.
​
Well there's a thing. Do you have any good reason to think it won't? Apart from it alarming you?

How about this for starts. The current 8 years of essentially no temperature increase is contrary to AGW predictions of models, and is predicted by the 60-80 year chart. Period.

Now let us discuss the 2nd red line. Do I have a good reason to think it will not continue going up? Well, for 8 years it has not gone up.... There are several prior cycles which indicate that it has reached the top and will go done. Clearly that would be very conclusive if we had 10 or 20 cycles of 60-80 years each, instead of just three. Well, we don't have 10 or 20.

I hope that this chart is clearer. My intent in making it was to try to set forth clearly some of these things that we discuss in grammer for which various people may mis interpret the exact meanings.

One example is the various people that have looked at the chart and concluded that temperatures were clearly going up, therefore Warmers were right. (Meanwhile skeptics reach the opposite conclusions). Are there inaccuracies in how I have drawn it at this point or other annotations that should be added?
 
A graph on a chart? That's a pretty simplistic model, how do I know I can trust it?

That's the problem in a nutshell, AUP. We only have trustworthy readings of temperature for the last 30 years, IIRC. I think, but am not sure, on the CD readings because, as many from both the pro and con side on this thread have stated, ice core measurement technique has greatly improved.

The practical science will improve as time goes on. The real question is whether or not we have the luxury of waiting.
 
The true crux of the matter as I see it is: Is it really hotter now than ever before? Or are we just going through a spike that wouldn't show in things like ice core samples? or coral. or sediment... How many times has Earth gone through these spikes before?

Funny how our AGW only started when we invented the thermometer. Sort of like "I felt fine until I took my temperature". Bunch of hypochondriacs.
 
The true crux of the matter as I see it is: Is it really hotter now than ever before? Or are we just going through a spike that wouldn't show in things like ice core samples? or coral. or sediment... How many times has Earth gone through these spikes before?

Funny how our AGW only started when we invented the thermometer. Sort of like "I felt fine until I took my temperature". Bunch of hypochondriacs.

The has had higher and lower temperatures in the past, and the rocks and bacteria are still here and doing fine. The megafauna, not so fine.
 
The Industrial Age was launched on renewable energy - wind and water. Particularly water. There just wasn't enough available to satisfy demand.

There's no reason to think that there'd be any noticable climate change going on at this stage in this interglacial without our input. The Sun's quiescent. Vulcanism is low, but that doesn't explain the continuing warming (it's been low for a century and more). Without our influence it ought to be a quiet time.

Ah yes, classic denialism from Capeldodgy.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/3869753.stm

A new analysis shows that the Sun is more active now than it has been at anytime in the previous 1,000 years.

Scientists based at the Institute for Astronomy in Zurich used ice cores from Greenland to construct a picture of our star's activity in the past.

They say that over the last century the number of sunspots rose at the same time that the Earth's climate became steadily warmer.

The thing I've most learnt from Capeldodgy and AUP is the amount of armwaving applied instead of evidence. Is this an untapped source of energy?
 
Did you read the article?

The data suggests that changing solar activity is influencing in some way the global climate causing the world to get warmer.
Over the past 20 years, however, the number of sunspots has remained roughly constant, yet the average temperature of the Earth has continued to increase.
This is put down to a human-produced greenhouse effect caused by the combustion of fossil fuels.




 
Did you read the article?

Yes. 20 years does not make a climatic trend. It also means that for at least 980 years warming of the Earth is correlated with the solar cycle. Where's the AUP comment on that point? Nowhere to be seen. In point of fact, sunspots have waxed and waned over the last 20 years (hardly constant are they?).

However it is you and your fellow creationists who keep claiming that the climate is naturally stable, and real scientists keep telling you that climate always changes on all timescales.

You didn't read the article at all. You just cherry-picked the sop that the authors put in to placate the global warming industry and make sure they don't get their funding cut off, their research papers blocked and their names put on a list of suspected industry-funded skeptics all in league with Big Oil/George W Bush/Satan/delete all that don't apply.

Back to the point: Capeldodgy inserted yet another inconvenient faslehood into an armwaving dismissal of scientific evidence that goes against CD's apocalyptic fantasy.
 
Yes. 20 years does not make a climatic trend. It also means that for at least 980 years warming of the Earth is correlated with the solar cycle. Where's the AUP comment on that point? Nowhere to be seen. In point of fact, sunspots have waxed and waned over the last 20 years (hardly constant are they?).

However it is you and your fellow creationists who keep claiming that the climate is naturally stable, and real scientists keep telling you that climate always changes on all timescales.

You didn't read the article at all. You just cherry-picked the sop that the authors put in to placate the global warming industry and make sure they don't get their funding cut off, their research papers blocked and their names put on a list of suspected industry-funded skeptics all in league with Big Oil/George W Bush/Satan/delete all that don't apply.

Back to the point: Capeldodgy inserted yet another inconvenient faslehood into an armwaving dismissal of scientific evidence that goes against CD's apocalyptic fantasy.

Is it true that a 1000 year curve of solar effects on the earth looks like....

a hockey stick?

​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom