Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

I'm not getting that publication. I get a megaupload.com when I click the link.

It's there: you just need to follow the instructions (Please enter XXX here...) at the top of the page.

Look for the small type below the ad for the filename and description.
 
Good job, Pipirr. Note the first paragraph of section 2 where the HITRAN database's use in the radiative model is discussed, and the fact that the coefficient is clearly shown to be derived from the model, and is not part of it. That should close the discussion on this matter.

Was 5.35 supposed to have been a secret or something? It was lowered from ~6.75 or thereabouts from IPCC 1995. What is the big deal? What effect do negative feedbacks have on this? None?

There is that inconvenient issue of Schwartz to contend with.

Are all these quantified in climate models?
Solar flux
Gravity, Pressure
Temperature
Density
Humidity
Earth's rotation
Surface temperature
Currents in the Ocean (e.g., Gulf Stream)
Greenhouse gases
CO2 dissolved in the oceans
Polar ice caps
Infrared radiation
Cosmic rays (ionizing radiation)
Earth's magnetic field
Evaporation
Precipitation
Cloud formation
Reflection from clouds
Reflection from snow
Volcanoes
Soot formation
Trace compounds

Until climate models can demonstrate skillfulness by including all forcings and feedbacks, they are but an expensive video game for unlicensed software engineers to fiddle with parameters until they achieve results satisfactory to their own liking. Without perpetual tuning, hindcasting would be an exercise in futility. They are not "validated".

How many climate models predicted the current apparent stalling of warming? None I would expect. In order to demonstrate reliability, climate models should have predicted this. What happened?

What prompted Hadley Centre to not once but twice develop a 'new and improved' climate model to fill in the gaps Hadley said was in previous GCM's? The first was in 2003, then in January 2007 predicted 2007 global temperatures would exceed 1998. Failing that, they announced yet another 'new and improved' model, stated there will be a temporary cooling, then extreme warming will return.

No derivative of "validate" with respect to climate models can be found in AR4.

Even using UHI infested HadCRUT3 data, it sure looks like something is about to happen wouldn't you agree? It's peaked, SH is falling, NH has stalled. Which way will it go? Up? There are no volcanoes to blame. What is causing it?
 
Was 5.35 supposed to have been a secret or something?
Nope. It's in the report, right there in black and white. Pipirr found a copy of one of the papers referenced, right there in black and white, right on the same page.

It was lowered from ~6.75 or thereabouts from IPCC 1995. What is the big deal?
The inputs to the climate models were improved, and the models improved, and the number was changed. It's called "science." They do that. You're apparently not familiar with the process.

What effect do negative feedbacks have on this? None?
Why do you expect negative feedbacks would have any effect on it?

There is that inconvenient issue of Schwartz to contend with.
What inconvenient issue of Schwartz, and how does that have anything to do with a coefficient that was provided so that non-scientist consumers of the report would have some idea how to gauge what effect any changes they might suggest or choose to make would have?

Are all these quantified in climate models?
Solar flux
Yep.
What's gravity got to do with it? If you mean gravity wave effects in the stratosphere, yep. Otherwise, no, not really- I wouldn't put a term for electromagnetism into a paper on the population dynamics of the vole, why, would you?
Yep.
Temperature
Yep.
Yep.
Not as humidity, it's represented as water vapor concentration, but since they amount to the same thing, yep.
Earth's rotation
Coriolis force? Yep.
Surface temperature
Yep, three different ways: ice, SST, and LST.
Currents in the Ocean (e.g., Gulf Stream)
Greenhouse gases
The particular model we're discussing, the GISS GCM, I'm not sure has a great deal of that; recent work has created newer models that integrate ocean circulation models with global atmospheric circulation models, so yep. There's an ocean model module in ModelE, I just don't know how sophisticated it is. I'd go check if I thought you were serious.
CO2 dissolved in the oceans
Yep.
Polar ice caps
What about them, specifically? There's quite a bit in the model regarding ice, and snow, and radiative transfer, and convective transfer. Did you have something in particular in mind?
Infrared radiation
Yep.
Cosmic rays (ionizing radiation)
I didn't see anything for that. I don't think it's been established to the satisfaction of the community either that they have a quantifiable effect, or that if they do, it's not already modeled with different parameters. The papers I've seen linked here had serious defects, including one that showed anti-correlation over the most recent period of record. Protests were registered by other scientists when one of the authors was invited to speak at a conference and the invitation was withdrawn. You'll need to show credible evidence both that they have some effect, and that that effect isn't already modeled.
Earth's magnetic field
Why would Earth's magnetic field have anything to do with circulation of either water or air, since neither contains much in the way of charged particles? This is the electromagnetic field and the voles again.
Evaporation
Yep.
Precipitation
Yep.
Cloud formation
Yep. There's a whole module for clouds, including formation, coverage, aerosol effects both on formation and several other parameters, and an entire section of the radiative codes dealing with cloud radiative transfer.
Reflection from clouds
Yep.
Reflection from snow
Yep.
Volcanoes
Yep.
Soot formation
Yep.
Trace compounds
What trace compounds specifically?

Until climate models can demonstrate skillfulness by including all forcings and feedbacks,
How does 1995 grab you?

they are but an expensive video game for unlicensed software engineers
What's an "unlicensed" software engineer? What planet do you live on?

to fiddle with parameters until they achieve results satisfactory to their own liking.
You mean like accurately predicting the degree of climate change over a twenty year period? Yeah, I guess they like that.

Without perpetual tuning, hindcasting would be an exercise in futility. They are not "validated".
One rather suspects that, given accurate predictions over a twenty year period, there is basically no level of "validation" that would satisfy you. Luckily, climate scientists don't particularly care if they impress you.

How many climate models predicted the current apparent stalling of warming? None I would expect.
Since it hasn't gone on for a decade yet, none would be correct. Climate models don't predict on a year-to-year basis, as you've been told more times than I can count.

In order to demonstrate reliability, climate models should have predicted this.
Oh, really? And why is that? This looks like an unsupported assertion to me. Why don't you provide some support for it and then we'll see.

What happened?
You tell us, you're the one making the unsupported assertion.

What prompted Hadley Centre to not once but twice develop a 'new and improved' climate model to fill in the gaps Hadley said was in previous GCM's? The first was in 2003, then in January 2007 predicted 2007 global temperatures would exceed 1998. Failing that, they announced yet another 'new and improved' model, stated there will be a temporary cooling, then extreme warming will return.
It's called "science." You seem unfamiliar with the process. I suggest you read up on it.

No derivative of "validate" with respect to climate models can be found in AR4.
Neither can any derivative of "deliquesce," or quite a few other words. Did you have a point?

Even using UHI infested HadCRUT3 data, it sure looks like something is about to happen wouldn't you agree? It's peaked, SH is falling, NH has stalled. Which way will it go? Up? There are no volcanoes to blame. What is causing it?
Wow, word salad much?

Do try to follow the conversation a little more closely moving forward, can you? We're talking about science here; you could probably have figured that out had you read the title of the thread, not to mention the name of the forum.
 
Got it. Thanks for the coaching. I was putting the publication name into the first download box when I figured out that it was an anti-bot box for putting in the three letters next to it. I know, I know...

Read the paper and that clears up that mystery. So, if I understand correctly, for every per cent that CD goes up, we have to factor that by 5.35 to estimate its effects on its contributive forcing power. Is that right? So, its efficiency as a thermal barrier is 16 times greater than its closest competitor, CFC-12, whose alpha is 0.33.
 
Was 5.35 supposed to have been a secret or something? It was lowered from ~6.75 or thereabouts from IPCC 1995. What is the big deal? What effect do negative feedbacks have on this? None?

There is that inconvenient issue of Schwartz to contend with.

Are all these quantified in climate models?
Solar flux
Gravity, Pressure
Temperature
Density
Humidity
Earth's rotation
Surface temperature
Currents in the Ocean (e.g., Gulf Stream)
Greenhouse gases
CO2 dissolved in the oceans
Polar ice caps
Infrared radiation
Cosmic rays (ionizing radiation)
Earth's magnetic field
Evaporation
Precipitation
Cloud formation
Reflection from clouds
Reflection from snow
Volcanoes
Soot formation
Trace compounds

Until climate models can demonstrate skillfulness by including all forcings and feedbacks, they are but an expensive video game for unlicensed software engineers to fiddle with parameters until they achieve results satisfactory to their own liking. Without perpetual tuning, hindcasting would be an exercise in futility. They are not "validated".

How many climate models predicted the current apparent stalling of warming? None I would expect. In order to demonstrate reliability, climate models should have predicted this. What happened?

What prompted Hadley Centre to not once but twice develop a 'new and improved' climate model to fill in the gaps Hadley said was in previous GCM's? The first was in 2003, then in January 2007 predicted 2007 global temperatures would exceed 1998. Failing that, they announced yet another 'new and improved' model, stated there will be a temporary cooling, then extreme warming will return.

No derivative of "validate" with respect to climate models can be found in AR4.

Even using UHI infested HadCRUT3 data, it sure looks like something is about to happen wouldn't you agree? It's peaked, SH is falling, NH has stalled. Which way will it go? Up? There are no volcanoes to blame. What is causing it?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_10323472004f51f632.jpg

I'm going out on a limb here, I know, but you don't have any idea what you are talking about.
 
Nope. It's in the report, right there in black and white. Pipirr found a copy of one of the papers referenced, right there in black and white, right on the same page.

The inputs to the climate models were improved, and the models improved, and the number was changed. It's called "science." They do that. You're apparently not familiar with the process.

Why do you expect negative feedbacks would have any effect on it?

What inconvenient issue of Schwartz, and how does that have anything to do with a coefficient that was provided so that non-scientist consumers of the report would have some idea how to gauge what effect any changes they might suggest or choose to make would have?

Yep.
What's gravity got to do with it? If you mean gravity wave effects in the stratosphere, yep. Otherwise, no, not really- I wouldn't put a term for electromagnetism into a paper on the population dynamics of the vole, why, would you?
Yep.
Yep.
Yep.
Not as humidity, it's represented as water vapor concentration, but since they amount to the same thing, yep.
Coriolis force? Yep.
Yep, three different ways: ice, SST, and LST.
The particular model we're discussing, the GISS GCM, I'm not sure has a great deal of that; recent work has created newer models that integrate ocean circulation models with global atmospheric circulation models, so yep. There's an ocean model module in ModelE, I just don't know how sophisticated it is. I'd go check if I thought you were serious.
Yep.
What about them, specifically? There's quite a bit in the model regarding ice, and snow, and radiative transfer, and convective transfer. Did you have something in particular in mind?
Yep.
I didn't see anything for that. I don't think it's been established to the satisfaction of the community either that they have a quantifiable effect, or that if they do, it's not already modeled with different parameters. The papers I've seen linked here had serious defects, including one that showed anti-correlation over the most recent period of record. Protests were registered by other scientists when one of the authors was invited to speak at a conference and the invitation was withdrawn. You'll need to show credible evidence both that they have some effect, and that that effect isn't already modeled.
Why would Earth's magnetic field have anything to do with circulation of either water or air, since neither contains much in the way of charged particles? This is the electromagnetic field and the voles again.
Yep.
Yep.
Yep. There's a whole module for clouds, including formation, coverage, aerosol effects both on formation and several other parameters, and an entire section of the radiative codes dealing with cloud radiative transfer.
Yep.
Yep.
Yep.
Yep.
What trace compounds specifically?

How does 1995 grab you?

What's an "unlicensed" software engineer? What planet do you live on?

You mean like accurately predicting the degree of climate change over a twenty year period? Yeah, I guess they like that.

One rather suspects that, given accurate predictions over a twenty year period, there is basically no level of "validation" that would satisfy you. Luckily, climate scientists don't particularly care if they impress you.

Since it hasn't gone on for a decade yet, none would be correct. Climate models don't predict on a year-to-year basis, as you've been told more times than I can count.

Oh, really? And why is that? This looks like an unsupported assertion to me. Why don't you provide some support for it and then we'll see.

You tell us, you're the one making the unsupported assertion.

It's called "science." You seem unfamiliar with the process. I suggest you read up on it.

Neither can any derivative of "deliquesce," or quite a few other words. Did you have a point?

Wow, word salad much?

Do try to follow the conversation a little more closely moving forward, can you? We're talking about science here; you could probably have figured that out had you read the title of the thread, not to mention the name of the forum.

There is a standard of validation that satisfies the scientific method.

I'll await the evidence to show IPCC models account for all the forcings and feedbacks. That's odd, IPCC only lists a few.....what's this, they have a low scientific understanding of several? How'd you miss that?
So, you're saying the climate models account for all the forcings and feedbacks, yet IPCC doesn't understand many of them and doesn't even mention several? Wow, those climate modelers must be really smart!
 
There is a standard of validation that satisfies the scientific method.

I'll await the evidence to show IPCC models account for all the forcings and feedbacks. That's odd, IPCC only lists a few.....what's this, they have a low scientific understanding of several? How'd you miss that?
So, you're saying the climate models account for all the forcings and feedbacks, yet IPCC doesn't understand many of them and doesn't even mention several? Wow, those climate modelers must be really smart!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1032347201d4cab00d.jpg

They are smart enough to tell you the limits of their knowledge, but you aren't smart enough to understand that they told you all that for a reason.
 
Got it. Thanks for the coaching. I was putting the publication name into the first download box when I figured out that it was an anti-bot box for putting in the three letters next to it. I know, I know...
Don't feel bad- I read and responded to two threads, went back and looked at it, and went, "Hey, it's not doing anything, what's the problem here?" before I figured it out. And totally forgot about the anti-bot thing when I responded to you, too. :P

Read the paper and that clears up that mystery. So, if I understand correctly, for every per cent that CD goes up, we have to factor that by 5.35 to estimate its effects on its contributive forcing power. Is that right?
Mmmmm, I wouldn't say percent. There's that ln in there, and I think C and C0 are in ppmv. It's not a linear relation.

So, its efficiency as a thermal barrier is 16 times greater than its closest competitor, CFC-12, whose alpha is 0.33.
No. There's no ln in the expression for CFC-12. Because of that, not only is it not linear, the relation between CO2 and CFC-12 wouldn't be either.
 
There is a standard of validation that satisfies the scientific method.
There sure is- and when you make predictions that work over a twenty year period, everyone but the woos figures you met it.

I'll await the evidence to show IPCC models account for all the forcings and feedbacks.
First, what IPCC models? The IPCC doesn't make models.

Second, that would be because you can't read the source code in the model for yourself and figure out what forcings and feedbacks it models? The download link for it is right there, and FORTRAN isn't a very difficult language, and modelling is a particularly simple use of FORTRAN. We're not talking anything that makes a GUI or does anything particularly complicated; the complications are in the necessary equations, that is, in the math, not in the program. I'm used to looking at things that have all sorts of tricky pointer arithmetic and composite data structures and stuff like that- this is pretty easy code, just a bunch of math. Pretty straignt-to-the-point. The most complicated control structure in it is the MAIN, and all it does is call the right stuff in a couple loops.

That's odd, IPCC only lists a few.....what's this, they have a low scientific understanding of several? How'd you miss that?
I'm sorry, I didn't understand what you were trying to say here. You'll have to write using English syntax.

So, you're saying the climate models account for all the forcings and feedbacks, yet IPCC doesn't understand many of them and doesn't even mention several?
Wherever did you get that impression? I made no statements about what forcings and feedbacks IPCC talks about. If you want to talk about the IPCC report, feel free, but I'm talking about the model source code for the GISS GCM simulation model, which has been used by scientists working for NASA, primarily Jim Hansen, to do some of the science that the IPCC report talks about. I'm not really interested in the IPCC report any more; it's written for politicians. We're talking about science here, not politics. The politics forum is over there ->.

Wow, those climate modelers must be really smart!
It looks to me like the complicated part is figuring out what equations to use, not writing the program that uses them. Knowing the physics involved is the key; programmers they ain't. There's a fair bit of cruft in that code. Not bad, overall; I've seen (and fixed) worse. Not pros at the programming part, though.
 
There sure is- and when you make predictions that work over a twenty year period, everyone but the woos figures you met it.

Various people keep making these claims about the climate model predictions being so correct.

Perhaps that should be critically examined. Of course we would have to all be aware of the problems in hindcasting, picking the right answer out of a muddled group of answers generated in the past.

Let's put it this way. Here's our favorite little 60-80 year climate cycle chart (it just won't seem to go away). Let's say I was a Russian fisherman looking at one of the reports that generated this chart. I produce some crude estimates for the next two decades (they give me this job because I'm one of the few guys on the boat that can read).

Do the climate models do better than this crude forecast by people who have virtually no knowledge of climate models and who could not care less about them?

Double click to enlarge.


 
Oh, just one more thing. Note the fisherman has no problem predicting the downturn in temperature (which allegedly we are now beginning to experience). There should be numerous climate models outputs on the web which show this downturn - outputs made say from 1990-2000.

Where are the graphs that show the downturn from climate models?

Or did the nearly illiterate fisherman just beat them?
 
There sure is- and when you make predictions that work over a twenty year period, everyone but the woos figures you met it.

Everyone but the woos? Schneib, you may well want to reconsider that statement since it's underlying premises appear to be incorrect. I assume you do not want to argue with Trenberth, do you?

From Locri's post #2085 GW thread I cut this...
Originally Posted by CapelDodger
The bulk of the evidence is in observation. The theory behind AGW is well-established, as described in IPCC reports. Climate models are physical models, not statistical models.
​
I think you may be somewhat backwards in your thinking on things... the models are models OF physical things, yes, but they are not physical models themselves. The models need to use some sort of statistical analysis along with what (little) they understand about how the aspects of the worlds environment interacts with the climate in order to attempt to predict things.

Which, according to a recent article backed up by someone in the IPCC they apparently don't do. If you believe that.

http://www.news.com.au/couriermail/s...-27197,00.html

Quoting from the article (Trenberth is a major guy in climate models)
In a remarkable contribution to Nature magazine's Climate Feedback blog, Trenberth concedes GCMs cannot predict future climate and claims the IPCC is not in the business of climate prediction. This might be news to some people.

Among other things, Trenberth asserts ". . . there are no (climate) predictions by IPCC at all. And there never have been". Instead, there are only "what if" projections of future climate that correspond to certain emissions scenarios.

According to Trenberth, GCMs ". . . do not consider many things like the recovery of the ozone layer, for instance, or observed trends in forcing agents".

"None of the models used by IPCC is initialised to the observed state and none of the climate states in the models corresponds even remotely to the current observed climate.

"The state of the oceans, sea ice and soil moisture has no relationship to the observed state at any recent time in any of the IPCC models.

"There is neither an El Nino sequence nor any Pacific Decadal Oscillation that replicates the recent past; yet these are critical modes of variability that affect Pacific rim countries and beyond . . . the starting climate state in several of the models may depart significantly from the real climate owing to model errors" and "regional climate change is impossible to deal with properly unless the models are initialised".

GCMs "assume linearity" which "works for global forced variations, but it cannot work for many aspects of climate, especially those related to the water cycle . . . the science is not done because we do not have reliable or regional predictions of climate".
​
It could not be said more clearly, could it? GCMs are not predictive models of climate. Nearly illiterate Russian fisherman wins by default since he has NO competition from climate models.

 
And you keep posting graphs that prove us right.

What is right?

January 2007
http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/index.cfm?id=15862007
2007 set to be the world's hottest ever year
Oops, missed it by that much.

"There is no natural weather any more. It is man-made and the current heavy rainfall and gales is symptomatic of climate change. We will be facing a future of warmer summers and milder winters with more rain and storms. I'm very pleased with this Met Office forecast. Although it is really devastating, it shows that every one of us needs to change the way we live."


2003
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2003/05/030521092312.htm
For the first time, scientists have incorporated multiple human and natural factors into a climate projection model.


2003
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn4161.html
A key use of climate models is to estimate how much the Earth's temperature will rise as the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere increases. Different models suggest that a warming of 1.4 to 5.8 °C is likely over the next 100 years. But no-one knows how accurate these predictions are.
"We just give the forecasts, with no idea of how likely or unlikely that outcome is," admits Mat Collins, from the Hadley Centre for Climate Prediction and Research in Bracknell, Berkshire, UK. Putting error bars on the estimates is now "a real priority" he says.

What climate models predicted the current stagnant temperatures?

August 2007
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/conte...el&searchid=1&FIRSTINDEX=0&resourcetype=HWCIT
Previous climate model projections of climate change accounted for external forcing from natural and anthropogenic sources but did not attempt to predict internally generated natural variability. We present a new modeling system that predicts both internal variability and externally forced changes and hence forecasts surface temperature with substantially improved skill throughout a decade, both globally and in many regions. Our system predicts that internal variability will partially offset the anthropogenic global warming signal for the next few years. However, climate will continue to warm, with at least half of the years after 2009 predicted to exceed the warmest year currently on record.

Translation: climate models are unreliable, including our last latest and greatest from 2003, and did not foresee the current non-warming, but our ‘new and improved’ climate model will be right this time, just you wait and see!

Referring back to January 2007 prediction from the same Hadley Centre:
2007 set to be the world's hottest ever year

"There is no natural weather any more. It is man-made and the current heavy rainfall and gales is symptomatic of climate change. We will be facing a future of warmer summers and milder winters with more rain and storms. I'm very pleased with this Met Office forecast. Although it is really devastating, it shows that every one of us needs to change the way we live."

Do you think it's warming now? Are the oceans warming?

 
Hurricanes

http://www.coaps.fsu.edu/~maue/tropical/
Unless a dramatic and perhaps historical flurry of activity occurs in the next 11 weeks, 2007 will rank as a historically inactive TC year for the entire Northern Hemisphere. During the past 30 years, only 1977, 1981, and 1983 have had less activity to date (Jan-December). For the period of June 1 - October 25, 2007, only 1977 experienced LESS tropical cyclone activity.
Northern Hemisphere = -32% **** 316 (464) (Historic inactivity, 16% of season to go)
North Atlantic = -28% **** 63 (88) (Bill Gray wants 4 more (huh?, Season 91% over)
Eastern Pacific = -60% **** 52.2 (129) (Kiko made like a ghost, Season 95% over)
Western Pacific = -26% **** 179 (241) (Still 21% of yearly activity to go)

Now for the question:
What have climate models been predicting? I’ll bet it wouldn’t take long to find one that says global warming causes increases in hurricane activity, and another that says just the opposite. Who cares to find out?
There’s enough monkeys at the keyboards of the 23+ global climate models whereby no matter what happens, it can be said “that is what the climate models predict”.

Can someone guess why the U.S. Southwest is dry? Did AGW cause the California wild fires? There’s no shortage of those who think it did (watch the news), but what are the real reasons?
 
Last edited:
And you keep posting graphs that prove us right.



Think carefully before you re affirm that the graph proves (your "us") right...

Here are some takeoffs -
  1. Peak - 1880
  2. Trough - 1904
  3. Peak - 1940
  4. Trough - 1970
  5. Peak - 2005
Most people asked to measure a cycle would go for one sine wave. Hansen uses #2 to #5, and #4 to #5.

The often batted about number of 0.6C for the current century (#2 to #5). Is that a good number or is there a better one?

The "unprecedented warming" in the last several decades (#4 to #5). Is there a better way to look at it?
 
Your ability to look at that graph and claim it's not getting warmer amazes me. It's really simple: left side low, right side high. There's not much more to be said unless you're trying to obfuscate.
 
Various people keep making these claims about the climate model predictions being so correct.

Perhaps that should be critically examined. Of course we would have to all be aware of the problems in hindcasting, picking the right answer out of a muddled group of answers generated in the past.

That's why the Hansen et al 1988 model is such a treasure. The most sophisticated model, the best resourced, the best connected, the best publicised - and quite possibly the only one at the time. It has performed remarkably well. A very robust performance. To you, maybe it could just be luck.

A gem in the hindcasting world is the Solar Cycling Club of Copenhagen. There are some few varying predictions still extant, so some of them will probably be right about the next cycle (cycles are numbered from trough to trough, arbitrarily).

Let's put it this way. Here's our favorite little 60-80 year climate cycle chart (it just won't seem to go away). Let's say I was a Russian fisherman looking at one of the reports that generated this chart. I produce some crude estimates for the next two decades (they give me this job because I'm one of the few guys on the boat that can read).

One thing you can say about the USSR, literacy rates always outstripped the US. Maybe you should make this an Alaskan fisherman? Verisimilitude helps set the scene.

Do the climate models do better than this crude forecast by people who have virtually no knowledge of climate models and who could not care less about them?


Who are these people with their forecast? Did Eskimos draw that graph? WTF are you on about?

Climate model predictions only go back to 1984, and they've been just as good so far. The difference comes right about now, I'd say. The 60 year-ish cycle suggests a definite cooling by 2010. Hansen et al 1988 doesn't, as I recall. Recent model predictions from the Hadley Centre are of a two-year pause, then an upturn. By 2012 there should be no remaining doubt which is the dominant influence.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom