Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Your ability to look at that graph and claim it's not getting warmer amazes me. It's really simple: left side low, right side high. There's not much more to be said unless you're trying to obfuscate.

It looks like a 60-year maximum cycle to me. Definitely nothing around 80. If this cycle is about to assert itself we'll know about it soon - last peak in 1940, 2007 now. A long cycle already.

(Interjection only. Please carry on :).)
 
Peak - 1880
Trough - 1904
Peak - 1940

Warmer than 1880 peak.


Trough - 1970

Warmer than 1904 trough.

Peak - 2005

Warmer than 1940 peak. And we still don't know that it's peaked, do we?

You favour the Laplanders version, as it's been presented to you, which means this issue will soon be resolved. I'll go with the science, of course, and (willy-nilly) with the Solar Cyclists who predict continued warming. The safe bet. We shall soon see.


Most people asked to measure a cycle would go for one sine wave. Hansen uses #2 to #5, and #4 to #5.

Lets not get into sophistication. Dismiss the Hansen et al model results so far as luck. They just happened to coincide with the upswing of a 60-year cycle. From about now, they don't.
 
http://www.coaps.fsu.edu/~maue/tropical/


Now for the question:
What have climate models been predicting? I’ll bet it wouldn’t take long to find one that says global warming causes increases in hurricane activity, and another that says just the opposite.

Climate models don't say anything about hurricanes. Hurricane people do hurricane models.

Who cares to find out?
There’s enough monkeys at the keyboards of the 23+ global climate models whereby no matter what happens, it can be said “that is what the climate models predict”.

They're all in broad agreement on continued warming. You seem to have given up on an outbreak of cooling. Which model is going to claim victory then?

Whatever happens in the next Solar Cycle - warming, cooling, Rapture - there'll be winners, but an overall cooling would blow all the models out of the water. After all, aren't they all tweaked (for nefarious but unspecified purposes) to demonstrate warming?

Can someone guess why the U.S. Southwest is dry?

Because it ranges from arid to semi-arid? As I understand the geography, it depends on high-ground snow because the low-grounds don't get much rain. More recently, of course, there's been the option of water-mining from aquifers, but it quickly evaporates. It's a place that's meant to be dry for the sake of classic Westerns.

Did AGW cause the California wild fires? There’s no shortage of those who think it did (watch the news), but what are the real reasons?

I watch CNN, so I've not come across this claim. It's mostly been human interest stuff. And celebrity stuff, of course, this being California. And political stuff - this being California. With lots of dramatic footage, so the talking-head count is drastically reduced.

Once the flames die down the talking-head thing will be back en masse.

What climate change predicts is that unusual weather-related events will become more common. Change is like that; it redefines the norm. These fires are an unusual weather-related event, but related to other things as well. Such as the folly of building property in fire-prone areas.
 

I wouldn't put my money on a local newspaper report. From January 2007? If it turns out right there's a "told you so" in it, if not, who remembers? Scotland, January ... nobody's taking much in.


More media.



2003
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn4161.html


What climate models predicted the current stagnant temperatures?

Climate models don't make predictions over short periods, such as a few years. 2005 was about as warm as '98, 2006 was a little cooler but warmer than 2004, 2007 isn't in yet. Hansen et al model predictions don't include solar cycles; as far as I know, the pattern was even more speculative back then than it is today.

This is a slow time in the solar cycle, and yet with it comes not cooling but stagnation. A pause, not a retreat. We'll soon enough see what's unleashed by the solar upswing.

On an historical note : efforts to find a climate signal from solar cycles goes back to their discovery, and it's been a bear-pit. Some people set 'em up, others knock 'em down. It never attracted much attention until recently. Nowadays, every argument's getting drafted into service. Signs of a crisis.


"Previous climate model projections of climate change accounted for external forcing from natural and anthropogenic sources but did not attempt to predict internally generated natural variability. We present a new modeling system that predicts both internal variability and externally forced changes and hence forecasts surface temperature with substantially improved skill throughout a decade, both globally and in many regions. Our system predicts that internal variability will partially offset the anthropogenic global warming signal for the next few years. However, climate will continue to warm, with at least half of the years after 2009 predicted to exceed the warmest year currently on record. "

Translation : models have improved so much over the last twenty years that we're prepared to predict the coming decade. While we're young enough to be embarrassed by being horribly wrong. Which we won't be.

... including our last latest and greatest from 2003, and did not foresee the current non-warming, but our ‘new and improved’ climate model will be right this time, just you wait and see!

2003 is very recent. I doubt the model has yet diverged significantly from the outcome. 2005 - the mid-point - was the warmest. 2006 was cooler, but warmer than 2004. 2007 isn't in yet.

Is "non-warming" and "stagnation" all there is for you now? No validation through cooling, such as mhaze is grasping at? It's as if you're waiting for the storm to break, but until it actually does it still might not and so there's still hope.
 
People keep making these claims about the climate model predictions being so correct.

Perhaps that should be critically examined.
One more time.
People keep making these claims about the climate model predictions being so correct. Perhaps that should be critically examined.
 
One more time.
People keep making these claims about the climate model predictions being so correct. Perhaps that should be critically examined.
One more time. The evidence you have presented does not support your argument; your graph is lower on the left than on the right. You claim it shows decreasing temperature. That's obvious denial of reality. You are either insane or lying.
 
Don't feel bad- I read and responded to two threads, went back and looked at it, and went, "Hey, it's not doing anything, what's the problem here?" before I figured it out. And totally forgot about the anti-bot thing when I responded to you, too. :P

Mmmmm, I wouldn't say percent. There's that ln in there, and I think C and C0 are in ppmv. It's not a linear relation.

No. There's no ln in the expression for CFC-12. Because of that, not only is it not linear, the relation between CO2 and CFC-12 wouldn't be either.

Aye, ya got me on all counts, Lad! Wine and math don't mix. Now, THAT's sad. :(
 
One more time. The evidence you have presented does not support your argument; your graph is lower on the left than on the right. You claim it shows decreasing temperature. That's obvious denial of reality. You are either insane or lying.

Perhaps the models don't have the necessary resolution to predict a meandering, asypmtotic approach, if that is indeed what's happening. Have the model authors published any type of guide as to what their immediate accuracy is for year-to-year consideration?

I don't believe that a slowly-warming planet will evidence a linear ramping because of all the variable involved therein. Still, I'm uneasy about the realtive brevity of our database. (The one we have that everyone agrees is accurate.)
 
Aye, ya got me on all counts, Lad! Wine and math don't mix. Now, THAT's sad. :(
LOL, not to mention the occasional Belgian Trippel. :D

On a more serious note, I welcome your questions; you're pushing into areas that require serious research, and I have to say that I've found out more answering them in the last couple of weeks than I'd figured out in the previous year. So keep asking.
 
LOL, not to mention the occasional Belgian Trippel. :D

On a more serious note, I welcome your questions; you're pushing into areas that require serious research, and I have to say that I've found out more answering them in the last couple of weeks than I'd figured out in the previous year. So keep asking.

:)
 
Perhaps the models don't have the necessary resolution to predict a meandering, asypmtotic approach, if that is indeed what's happening. Have the model authors published any type of guide as to what their immediate accuracy is for year-to-year consideration?
Nobody's figured things out enough to have a year-to-year model. It's not clear to me whether they know how to write the program but don't have enough computer to run it, or they don't know enough geophysics to write it. I suspect the former, but I don't have anything to base that on other than the fact that I can see details they seem to have left out, that anyone who knows much physics would put in. Not to mention, the number of layers they're modeling in the atmosphere seems a bit limited to me.

I don't believe that a slowly-warming planet will evidence a linear ramping because of all the variable involved therein. Still, I'm uneasy about the realtive brevity of our database. (The one we have that everyone agrees is accurate.)
I don't think anyone expected to see a smooth linear ramp. The Sun varies on an 11-year cycle. But that's not the dominant signal; the dominant signal right now is GWGs. That's the whole point.
 
... I don't think anyone expected to see a smooth linear ramp ...

An old editor of mine advised me, "There are no stupid questions, just stupid people asking questions."

I've got a few.

When carbon dioxide levels are measured in the atmosphere, is that figure an average? Is atmospheric chemistry the same worldwide, barring altitude variance? Or is there a greater concentration of carbon dioxide near its sources? How long does it take for CO2 to become evenly diffused?

Are the models based on an even distribution of CO2? If there is a moderately long time frame (decades?) for a global CO2 equalization to be reached, would that effect the models' accuracy within that period, although not in the long run?

Hypothetically and on a different note, if humans had perfected renewable energy sources during the Industrial Age -- if we hadn't been pouring crud and corrosives into the atmosphere for the past few hundred years -- what kind of climate change could we expect to be seeing today? Would a slower warming rate be going on in this interglacial period, or would we expect to see stable temperatures for some indeterminant period?
 
One more time. The evidence you have presented does not support your argument; your graph is lower on the left than on the right. You claim it shows decreasing temperature. That's obvious denial of reality. You are either insane or lying.

I do like the way you phrase things.

Red is your interpretation if I understand correctly, you consider perfectly valid the use of 1900 on for the baseline, and 1970 on for the current trend.

Blue is mine.

Questions? Comments? Insults?

What is so complicated about this?


 
Perhaps the models don't have the necessary resolution to predict a meandering, asypmtotic approach, if that is indeed what's happening. Have the model authors published any type of guide as to what their immediate accuracy is for year-to-year consideration?

I don't believe that a slowly-warming planet will evidence a linear ramping because of all the variable involved therein. Still, I'm uneasy about the realtive brevity of our database. (The one we have that everyone agrees is accurate.)

All valid concerns. When I said
"People keep making these claims about the climate model predictions being so correct. Perhaps that should be critically examined."
​
I was thinking that possibly it was feasible to find a published set of climate model predictions for a number of years and compare them with actuality.

That is, say, predications made in 1990, 1995, 2000, 2005.

Basically my question is, can these "assertion" that climate models are "dead on", "spot on", "highly accurate" be taken out of the realm of fancy words and grammer and quantified. I have no idea what the results would be, it just seems like an obvious question.

Conversely, if this isn't possible for whatever reason (say there is no clear data repository for predictions, or the predictions are all over the map, or such) then the assertions in favor of climate models as predictive of global climate seem inappropriate.

Does that make sense?
 
I do like the way you phrase things.

Red is your interpretation if I understand correctly, you consider perfectly valid the use of 1900 on for the baseline, and 1970 on for the current trend.

Blue is mine.
Then you are even more dishonest or mentally defective than I had thought; blue also is lower on the left than on the right, and you are claiming there's no global warming.
 
Then you are even more dishonest or mentally defective than I had thought; blue also is lower on the left than on the right, and you are claiming there's no global warming.

:confused: I am? Where do you get that from? I've been pretty consistent on my comments about such things. Would you perhaps be referring to the recent discussion about (going from memory and paraphrasing here) "no global warming in the last 6 or 8 years or decade?"

If that is so, yes, the lines are pretty much flat in that time period. That corresponds to a peak on the little cycles graph. As you have noted the general trend of the graph is up. I presume we are just miscommunicating a bit here.

Also, for your information, when asked I've repeatedly said there might be somewhere between 0 and 1C total effect including feedbacks from CO2's effect. Some effect, but decidedly minor and essentially negligible.
 
An old editor of mine advised me, "There are no stupid questions, just stupid people asking questions."

I've got a few.

When carbon dioxide levels are measured in the atmosphere, is that figure an average?
In what way do you mean "average?"

There are multiple different ways of measuring it. For example, there are the two observatories on Mauna Loa and Cape Grim; there are ongoing experiments on aircraft, in which aircraft from Europe (Lufthansa) and Asia (JAL) automatically take samples and bring them back for analysis; and IIRC there are some satellite observations that are also used, although I'm not sure of the details there. Between these and observations made on the ground in various locations, quite likely in weather stations and ad-hoc experiments, as well as balloons and towers, geophysicists have a very good idea how much CO2 there is in most locations, and therefore how well the Mauna Loa Observatory and Cape Grim observations reflect the base CO2 concentration in the atmosphere; and the answer is, quite well.

Is atmospheric chemistry the same worldwide, barring altitude variance? Or is there a greater concentration of carbon dioxide near its sources?
How close? You might want to have a good look at this abstract. They indicate that CO2 levels were as much as 45ppmv above ambient at 15km downwind from Prudhoe Bay. So the answer to your question appears to be, there are significantly greater concentrations of CO2 close to major sources of it; on the other hand, 15km isn't very far on a global scale, and diffusion takes place quite quickly, so again, what do you mean by "close?"

How long does it take for CO2 to become evenly diffused?
Good question, I'd have to do some research to find that out. I suspect the answer is on the close order of a couple weeks, from looking at the code.

Are the models based on an even distribution of CO2?
No. The data decks provided include geographical distribution of CO2 levels (as well as the other GWGs) and there are routines that describe diffusion of these gases as a function of time in ModelE; see ATURB.f for examples. See here for details on the input data decks. Below the four graphs, in a section titled Updates, you will find a description of how the data in the data decks was handled to estimate and account for geographical variances.

If there is a moderately long time frame (decades?) for a global CO2 equalization to be reached, would that effect the models' accuracy within that period, although not in the long run?
Your hypothetical addresses something that cannot exist. CO2 and other GWGs are being continuously emitted (and continuously absorbed/destroyed). There is no equilibrium for CO2 as long as we keep emitting it in the quantities we do today.

CO2 is a "well-mixed gas." That means that it diffuses quickly, on the order of days and weeks, not on the order of years or decades. In the absolute scale of the energy that Earth absorbs and emits each day, the difference CO2 makes is minuscule. But if you keep adding that minuscule amount day after day for a century, then it's going to get significantly warmer. Not only that, but even if we stopped emitting all anthropogenic CO2 today, heat equilibrium (which is a very different thing from CO2 equilibrium) would not be reached for quite some time; decades, most likely; and that's another consequence of the fact that only a minuscule amount is added each day.

I believe that you have confused thermal equilibrium with CO2 concentration equilibrium, and drawn the incorrect conclusion that CO2 takes a long time to diffuse into the atmosphere.

Hypothetically and on a different note, if humans had perfected renewable energy sources during the Industrial Age -- if we hadn't been pouring crud and corrosives into the atmosphere for the past few hundred years -- what kind of climate change could we expect to be seeing today? Would a slower warming rate be going on in this interglacial period, or would we expect to see stable temperatures for some indeterminant period?
I don't know that this has been tested. The answer is something that would require a run of a climate model, so there's no answer I can give you off the top of my head. There are many more things going on with climate than AGW. However, climate has been relatively stable since the end of the glacial-interglacial transition 5000 years ago, so I suspect that we would see relatively stable temperatures rather than the rising ones we see now.
 
:confused: I am? Where do you get that from?
From looking at the graph and reading what you say.

Also, for your information, when asked I've repeatedly said there might be somewhere between 0 and 1C total effect including feedbacks from CO2's effect. Some effect, but decidedly minor and essentially negligible.
And yet again, what you say and what the graph you posted shows are not connected to one another. I repeat, you are insane, or lying.

And as if that weren't enough, you claim that 1C is "negligible." It appears from the evidence to be enough to melt the entire Arctic icecap. So much for "negligible."
 
Your ability to look at that graph and claim it's not getting warmer amazes me. It's really simple: left side low, right side high. There's not much more to be said unless you're trying to obfuscate.

This is what I don't get about it. The graph shows a clear warming trend. Anyone can see that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom