Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Cherrypick a quote from the article that seems to fit the argument, ignore the part that blows your argument out of the water.

When called on it, go on a barely coherent ramble about the part you don't like being the authors placating the "global warming industry", vague lies about "research papers blocked" and "funding cut off"...

Par for the course.
 
Here's a bet for you: I bet this is another Diamond drive-by post. When challenged, off he goes, not to be seen again. Present one piece of "evidence," with a huge hole in it, make a bunch of accusations of lying by scientists when the hole is pointed out, and never respond to the fact that the hole exists.

Par for the course.
 
A graph on a chart? That's a pretty simplistic model, how do I know I can trust it?

Well, the chart was stated to have a mid .80s correlation between the curve fit and the raw data. That could be checked easily enough.

As for the other lines, I just drew them. IPCC etc counts temperature from 1900 forward, and the "Alarmist" line starts 30 years back. Those are pretty straightforward. The "correct trend line" going through the center is pretty straightforward. The little black bar over the current 8 year "non warming trend" is pretty simple.

How can you trust a graph or chart? It's a good question, many of them really are very misleading and confusing. Even though the intentions of people producing them may be the very best.
 
Cherrypick a quote from the article that seems to fit the argument, ignore the part that blows your argument out of the water.

When called on it, go on a barely coherent ramble about the part you don't like being the authors placating the "global warming industry", vague lies about "research papers blocked" and "funding cut off"...

Par for the course.

Nonsense. Diamond starts off and notes that 20 years does not make a climatic trend.

A climatic trend is thirty years. What part of 20 years is not 30 years do you not understand?
 
The thing I've most learnt from Capeldodgy and AUP is the amount of armwaving applied instead of evidence. Is this an untapped source of energy?

There's a clear tendency amongst contrarians to prefer indirect measurements, even when direct ones are available. Solar output has been directly measured by satellites, twenty-four hours a day, for over twenty years - two complete solar cycles. No increase in output has been detected.

Recourse to sunspot numbers as a proxy for solar output in preference to direct observations is perverse.
 
...cherry-picked the sop that the authors put in to placate the global warming industry and make sure they don't get their funding cut off, their research papers blocked and their names put on a list of suspected industry-funded skeptics all in league with Big Oil/George W Bush/Satan/delete all that don't apply.
If one were to create a sock puppet for the purpose of discrediting a/gw skepticism, one would have to be truly audacious to write something as starkly ludicrous as this rare gem, posted to a skeptical forum no less.
 
The true crux of the matter as I see it is: Is it really hotter now than ever before? Or are we just going through a spike that wouldn't show in things like ice core samples? or coral. or sediment... How many times has Earth gone through these spikes before?

The crux would be whether anything like this has happened during this inter-glacial (or any other). All the evidence we have indicates it hasn't since the Younger Dryas, and perhaps not even then. This is not just true for the temperature but for the rate of change - and it's the rate of change that's the real problem.

Funny how our AGW only started when we invented the thermometer. Sort of like "I felt fine until I took my temperature". Bunch of hypochondriacs.

Thermometers were first developed in the 16thCE. AGW started to become a mild concern in the 1970's. There's quite a gap there.

There was a concern about AGW back in the 16thCE, but that referred to Angry-God Weather. Nothing to do with thermometers, more to do with Jews and heretics.
 
How about this for starts. The current 8 years of essentially no temperature increase is contrary to AGW predictions of models, and is predicted by the 60-80 year chart. Period.

Of the last eight years (excluding 2007, which isn't quite in yet but hasn't been noticeably cool), 1999 was the coolest, 2005 was the warmest, 2006 next warmest. Of course there's been warming over the last eight years.
 
Nonsense. Diamond starts off and notes that 20 years does not make a climatic trend.

A climatic trend is thirty years. What part of 20 years is not 30 years do you not understand?

What I don't understand is why a trend is thirty years. Is there a law? Or does it just seem conveniently long-term?

It's not enough. The commonly-referred to Modern Warming Period is dated from 1975. In 1998 Hansen's calculations gave a high degree of confidence that AGW was already detectable, and the following two decades have only served to confirm that.

So to be safe you need to go out to forty years as a trend. Not that it matters much, since you've nailed your colours so firmly to the 60-80 year cycle which is about to save us all for no discernible reason. Three-to-eight years should suffice for that, don't you think?
 
Well, the chart was stated to have a mid .80s correlation between the curve fit and the raw data. That could be checked easily enough.

As for the other lines, I just drew them. IPCC etc counts temperature from 1900 forward, and the "Alarmist" line starts 30 years back.

You may find the line alarming, but its an accurate measurement, and it is the relevant period - the present. Anthropogenic CO2 was minimal until the 50's, when the production rate started ramping up. Only from the seventies did it start to have a detectable impact, and only then did the empirical data come in that made it possible to estimate the effect. The results raised a little concern. Subsequent events have demonstrated that it was well-justified.

Diluting the last thirty years warming with 970 years where there wasn't any significant anthropogenic CO2 is wrong-headed and barren. There was no AGW before the CO2 was there to cause it. That's a truism. What matters is what's happened since there has been a significant amount of anthropogenic CO2 - the last thirty years or so. During which time a mild academic concern, dismissed by most, back in the 70's has muscled its way into world centre-stage.

Not because of graphs, but because of the stark physical evidence around us.
 
Yes. 20 years does not make a climatic trend. It also means that for at least 980 years warming of the Earth is correlated with the solar cycle. Where's the AUP comment on that point? Nowhere to be seen. In point of fact, sunspots have waxed and waned over the last 20 years (hardly constant are they?).

Solar output has been observed to vary by 0.1% over the cycle, with a bias towards the ultraviolet (about 0.2%). There has been no observed variation between cycles.

However it is you and your fellow creationists who keep claiming that the climate is naturally stable, and real scientists keep telling you that climate always changes on all timescales.

The climate is naturally stable, it has a lot of inertia. That's why a solar-cycle influence on climate has been so hard to identify until direct measurements of solar output have been available. 0.1% variation over a decade or so isn't going to imprint a strong signal on the climate.

You didn't read the article at all. You just cherry-picked the sop that the authors put in to placate the global warming industry and make sure they don't get their funding cut off, their research papers blocked and their names put on a list of suspected industry-funded skeptics all in league with Big Oil/George W Bush/Satan/delete all that don't apply.

I salute your courage in facing these people down. Unlike Bush, he's folded.

Back to the point: Capeldodgy inserted yet another inconvenient faslehood into an armwaving dismissal of scientific evidence that goes against CD's apocalyptic fantasy.

Things that you deny are not therefore false. Direct observations have shown that there is no trend in solar output over the last twenty years, during which time global warming has been about 0.1C per decade. Which represents a very large amount of energy (in the form of heat) which must have been accumulated somehow. It's not because the Sun's getting hotter and we're getting more energy in. There's no way it's been generated internally. The only alternative explanation is that energy isn't getting out as readily as it used to.

There's no apocalypticism in that. I don't engage in estimates of what'll happen or discussions of what can be done because that's not relevant to the science.
 
That's the problem in a nutshell, AUP. We only have trustworthy readings of temperature for the last 30 years, IIRC.

We have many trustworthy readings from a century back at least. The older ones do tend to cluster around the North Atlantic, but there were weather-stations scattered across the British Empire. So we're definitely not blind back beyond thirty years.

The practical science will improve as time goes on. The real question is whether or not we have the luxury of waiting.

The practical science, and the theoretical and observational, are very good already. Apart from technological advances and the increasing attention paid to climatology, the long-standing policy of "more research is required" has given rise to a lot of research. Observational cover has been good for decades, and has only been getting better, so there's plenty of data to hand. We don't have to wait to observe AGW, we've been living it for several decades.

The real question is whether we had the luxury of waiting this long.
 
We have many trustworthy readings from a century back at least. The older ones do tend to cluster around the North Atlantic, but there were weather-stations scattered across the British Empire. So we're definitely not blind back beyond thirty years.

Since we're constrained in global modeling to consider only well-constructed global temperature, I don't believe anyone would consider a non-uniform temperature record. I realize there is great temptation to do this and call it good but it isn't. There are models that use different classes of data quality and they compensate for this by adding a multiplier to their confidence intervals. If you want a model that does this, fine, but don't expect anyone to take your "class C" predictions seriously.

The practical science, and the theoretical and observational, are very good already.

I can't argue with this statement but I have to point out to you that it's not good enough to persuade many political and business leaders to take action. Schneibster has indeed educated me on what I thought were misleading practices in the models and I admit that they're not rigged. They're just not robust enough yet and that is plainly the message in the IPCC report itself. The models still depend on a number of assumptions but these are necessary because information in those arenas is just not yet available. So, the models are good for certain uses but not good enough for others.

Apart from technological advances and the increasing attention paid to climatology, the long-standing policy of "more research is required" has given rise to a lot of research. Observational cover has been good for decades, and has only been getting better, so there's plenty of data to hand. We don't have to wait to observe AGW, we've been living it for several decades.

You've been living through something, that's for sure. Whether there's an A in GW is debatable.

The real question is whether we had the luxury of waiting this long.

When you and I first discussed this subject, I commented that the fear generated by the public noise being generated by this subject was reminiscent of the Malthusian scare resulting from the prediction that the planet would run out of food about ten years ago. I still believe that's the case although I'm not convinced that there's nothing to the data that support AGW. I would point out to you that the Malthusians were wrong because they only made one unwarranted assumption whereas the AGW hypothesis right now depends on many.

I'll also point out that one of the major proponents of the AGW hypothesis was predicting global cooling not so long ago. That does not disprove AGW but it does underscore what a foundling science global climatology is and how we shouldn't be unduly alarmed about new readings that we don't have enough experience to understand yet.
 
Considering it's warmer now than it was in the mid-nineteenth century by very nearly 1C, and we haven't doubled CO2 yet, I'm not sure what your point is. Particularly considering the melting of the Arctic icecap.

My broad view on that period : the 19thCE saw a lot of volcanic activity, multiple hits, which surely had a cumulative effect. That came to an end with Krakatoa (1887?) since when things have been very quiet. That has to account for a chunk of warming since the mid-19thCE. But it must surely have played out by the 20's to 30's.

At that point we enter the anthropogenic-aerosol age, which overlaps with the CO2-accumulation coming of age. A period of some obscurity, but we're definitely out of the fog now. AGW is doing its thing, regardless of traditional cycles.
 
... Solar output has been directly measured by satellites, twenty-four hours a day, for over twenty years - two complete solar cycles. No increase in output has been detected....


The out put is constant, over each cycle. El Nino years are the years that the output peaks in each cycle. What causes a warming trend is when the cycles are shorter, with peaks more frequent. The El Nino cycles do vary, from 8 to 13 years. So, three peaks within 17 years will heat things up more than two peaks within 14 years. But to Warmers, the "sun's output remains the same".
 
The out put is constant, over each cycle. El Nino years are the years that the output peaks in each cycle. What causes a warming trend is when the cycles are shorter, with peaks more frequent. The El Nino cycles do vary, from 8 to 13 years. So, three peaks within 17 years will heat things up more than two peaks within 14 years. But to Warmers, the "sun's output remains the same".
El Nino and La Nina events occur irregularly at 2 to 7 year intervals; the solar cycle is 11.1 years on average, has been seen at periods as short as 9 years and as long as 14, and has not been below ten years nor above twelve in the last century.

They are not associated with one another.

You haven't the slightest idea what you're talking about, neither about the ENSO nor about "warmers." Basically, you pulled El Nino out when your betters were discussing the solar cycle and flapped it around like it meant something.
 
The out put is constant, over each cycle. El Nino years are the years that the output peaks in each cycle. What causes a warming trend is when the cycles are shorter, with peaks more frequent. The El Nino cycles do vary, from 8 to 13 years. So, three peaks within 17 years will heat things up more than two peaks within 14 years. But to Warmers, the "sun's output remains the same".

I've seen a reference that noted there was always a strong El Nino during solar minimum, and this claimed that those during the minimum were easier to predict than the others.

In a general sense, it has always seemed to me that the pro-AGW or "Warmer" criticism of the Sun was a bit weird. It is as if, an immediate effect of CO2 in radiative energy is sought, also an immediate effect of Sun in radiative energy. No medium or long term effects seem to be considered.

Neither the 60-80 year climate cycles or the approximate 1500 year climate cycles are exactly correlated with solar variation, but they are clearly dynamic effects on the planet. I'm not discounting direct solar effects, just noting that there are other things going on.

Aren't we about due for a PDO reversal? What does that do to ENSO etc? Does anyone even know, since accurate data only goes back to the 1970s?
 
I've seen a reference that noted there was always a strong El Nino during solar minimum, and this claimed that those during the minimum were easier to predict than the others.

In a general sense, it has always seemed to me that the pro-AGW or "Warmer" criticism of the Sun was a bit weird. It is as if, an immediate effect of CO2 in radiative energy is sought, also an immediate effect of Sun in radiative energy. No medium or long term effects seem to be considered.

Neither the 60-80 year climate cycles or the approximate 1500 year climate cycles are exactly correlated with solar variation, but they are clearly dynamic effects on the planet. I'm not discounting direct solar effects, just noting that there are other things going on.

Aren't we about due for a PDO reversal? What does that do to ENSO etc? Does anyone even know, since accurate data only goes back to the 1970s?

If you look at TGGWS, the claim was that the effects were pretty much synchronous. It's their claim, not mine.
 
I've seen a reference that noted there was always a strong El Nino during solar minimum, and this claimed that those during the minimum were easier to predict than the others.
I don't suppose you have a link. Bearing in mind that they happen with totally unrelated time periods, what precise connection do you propose between the solar cycle and ENSO oscillations?

In a general sense, it has always seemed to me that the pro-AGW or "Warmer" criticism of the Sun was a bit weird. It is as if, an immediate effect of CO2 in radiative energy is sought, also an immediate effect of Sun in radiative energy. No medium or long term effects seem to be considered.
I have not the slightest idea what you're talking about. I guess a century is a short term on your planet.

Neither the 60-80 year climate cycles or the approximate 1500 year climate cycles are exactly correlated with solar variation, but they are clearly dynamic effects on the planet. I'm not discounting direct solar effects, just noting that there are other things going on.
That would be the 1500 year climate cycle that peaked five hundred years ago and is supposedly peaking again now? Or was that the 60-80 year climate cycle that had the upward trend that you claim not to be able to see?

Honestly, this is like having a conversation with a cretinist, or a homeopath, or something. You keep pulling these weird claims out and flapping them around like they mean something. How in the world can anyone look at a graph that's lower on the left and higher on the right and claim it's not going up? What kind of idiot would maintain that a climate cycle with a period of 1500 years peaked 500 years ago and is peaking again now? Next you'll be telling us that it's not really getting warmer, Jebus jiggered all the thermometers so now they don't work, or the speed of light is changing and changed the readings on them all, or that the global climatology cabal faked the satellite pictures of the Arctic this summer.

Aren't we about due for a PDO reversal? What does that do to ENSO etc? Does anyone even know, since accurate data only goes back to the 1970s?
What magnetic effect do you propose drives ENSO on a 3 to 7 year cycle, when the solar cycle is 22 years between magnetic reversals? This is surreal, it's like asking someone why they think the sea is salty and having them reply, "Bees." If you want to have a conversation about this stuff, you need to say things that make sense in the real world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom