Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

I don't suppose you have a link. Bearing in mind that they happen with totally unrelated time periods, what precise connection do you propose between the solar cycle and ENSO oscillations?

I have not the slightest idea what you're talking about. I guess a century is a short term on your planet.

That would be the 1500 year climate cycle that peaked five hundred years ago and is supposedly peaking again now? Or was that the 60-80 year climate cycle that had the upward trend that you claim not to be able to see?

Honestly, this is like having a conversation with a cretinist, or a homeopath, or something. You keep pulling these weird claims out and flapping them around like they mean something. How in the world can anyone look at a graph that's lower on the left and higher on the right and claim it's not going up? What kind of idiot would maintain that a climate cycle with a period of 1500 years peaked 500 years ago and is peaking again now? Next you'll be telling us that it's not really getting warmer, Jebus jiggered all the thermometers so now they don't work, or the speed of light is changing and changed the readings on them all, or that the global climatology cabal faked the satellite pictures of the Arctic this summer.

What magnetic effect do you propose drives ENSO on a 3 to 7 year cycle, when the solar cycle is 22 years between magnetic reversals? This is surreal, it's like asking someone why they think the sea is salty and having them reply, "Bees." If you want to have a conversation about this stuff, you need to say things that make sense in the real world.
What kind of idiot would maintain that a climate cycle with a period of 1500 years peaked 500 years ago and is peaking again now?
​
Gosh, I just don't know, Schneib. Who has said that? Next?
How in the world can anyone look at a graph that's lower on the left and higher on the right and claim it's not going up?
​
Gosh, I just know know about that either, Schneib. Maybe it depends on what part of the graph one is talking about? Let's see....that must be the reason we put labels on graphs....

Ooops, we've already done that here. Next?
Next you'll be telling us that it's not really getting warmer, Jebus jiggered all the thermometers so now they don't work, or the speed of light is changing and changed the readings on them all, or that the global climatology cabal faked the satellite pictures of the Arctic this summer.
​
Gibberish ignored. Next?
What magnetic effect do you propose drives ENSO on a 3 to 7 year cycle, when the solar cycle is 22 years between magnetic reversals?
​
And that was in reference to ....

Aren't we about due for a PDO reversal? What does that do to ENSO etc?

Hmm.....The comment seems to have NO relation to the assertion....Hmm....
 
What kind of idiot would maintain that a climate cycle with a period of 1500 years peaked 500 years ago and is peaking again now?
​
Gosh, I just don't know, Schneib. Who has said that? Next?
That would be you, maintaining that a 1500-year cycle is responsible for the MWP and for the current warming. I can go find the post if you really want me to make you look stupid.

How in the world can anyone look at a graph that's lower on the left and higher on the right and claim it's not going up?
​
Gosh, I just know know about that either, Schneib. Maybe it depends on what part of the graph one is talking about? Let's see....that must be the reason we put labels on graphs....

Ooops, we've already done that here. Next?
What PART of the graph? how about the WHOLE GRAPH? You cannot possibly be for real. I mean, I've seen some people say some pretty stupid **** on this forum, but that absolutely takes the cake. What PART of the graph? Were you born like this, or did you have to practice?
 
I heard Newt Gingrich on the radio yesterday and he's got a contract for the environment coming out or some such. Republican leadership on the doing something about global warming.

And did anyone read the latest Rolling Stone article on global warming? A real alarmist there, predicts a human population crash down to 500 million.
 
I heard Newt Gingrich on the radio yesterday and he's got a contract for the environment coming out or some such. Republican leadership on the doing something about global warming.

And did anyone read the latest Rolling Stone article on global warming? A real alarmist there, predicts a human population crash down to 500 million.

I heard that also. Pretty interesting, looks like Newt is going to be the Repub anti-Gore climate voice, 100% pro nuclear power. Talked about what we could do with 100 new nuclear plants. Optimist, not defeatist.

But the 500 million takes the cake.

What's next? Anyone want to go for 5 million?
 
The out put is constant, over each cycle. El Nino years are the years that the output peaks in each cycle. What causes a warming trend is when the cycles are shorter, with peaks more frequent. The El Nino cycles do vary, from 8 to 13 years. So, three peaks within 17 years will heat things up more than two peaks within 14 years. But to Warmers, the "sun's output remains the same".

There's no connection between ENSO and the solar cycle, El Ninos have a completely different frequency and distribution.

El Ninos don't introduce energy into the climate system, they just redistribute it. Heat energy sequestered in the Western Pacific Ocean is transferred to the atmosphere, and the surface world warms up. After the El Nino, heat accumulates in the Western Pacific until the next one. At periods of La Nina the heat accumulates relatively rapidly, so the next El Nino could be a right beast.

The Sun's output has not varied across cycles. there's no increasing trend, and yet over those twenty-odd years the world has accumulated a lot of energy. It's not because energy income has gone up, it's not internally generated (this isn't Jupiter, after all), so it must be down to a reduction in energy outgoings. Step forward : the Greenhouse Effect. Doing just what people said it would do thirty years ago.

I doubt you're convinced, though.
 
I heard Newt Gingrich on the radio yesterday and he's got a contract for the environment coming out or some such.

The pre-announcement that passes for producing something, and gets you radio time. Or was this perhaps mentioned in passing? Was he actually on-air to discuss family values :)?

Republican leadership on the doing something about global warming.

It's gonna get factional, mark my words. Down and dirty, like the good old days. Once they've lost the White House, why not?

And did anyone read the latest Rolling Stone article on global warming? A real alarmist there, predicts a human population crash down to 500 million.

I don't see it going much below 1.2 big ones myself. I'll be long gone by the time it bottoms out so I'll make that kind of glib prediction.

Anyhoo, we seemed to have strayed off the Science of theme.
 
I heard that also. Pretty interesting, looks like Newt is going to be the Repub anti-Gore climate voice, 100% pro nuclear power.

The anti-Gore climate voice would deny AGW as a matter of concern. It wouldn't push a different policy to deal with the matter of concern.

Talked about what we could do with 100 new nuclear plants. Optimist, not defeatist.

Al Gore a defeatist? How many Al Gores do you have in your head?

But the 500 million takes the cake.

It's the cake-eaters that would constitute that last 500 million. The rich, not the poor.

What's next? Anyone want to go for 5 million?

What's your estimate?
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
I heard that also. Pretty interesting, looks like Newt is going to be the Repub anti-Gore climate voice, 100% pro nuclear power.

​
The anti-Gore climate voice would deny AGW as a matter of concern. It wouldn't push a different policy to deal with the matter of concern.

Al Gore a defeatist? How many Al Gores do you have in your head?

What's your estimate?
The anti-Gore climate voice would deny AGW as a matter of concern. It wouldn't push a different policy to deal with the matter
​
Well, I was only reporting what NEWT was saying.
My estimate is 9B by 2050 and a much higher average standard of life than today. More food, less starvation, less malnutrician, less disease, higher education, less war, more capitalism (communism a subject known only in history books).

No concern about a quaint oddity in a small paragraph in the history of science, next to Piltdown man and leeching, called...AGW
 
The anti-Gore climate voice would deny AGW as a matter of concern. It wouldn't push a different policy to deal with the matter
​
Well, I was only reporting what NEWT was saying.
My estimate is 9B by 2050 and a much higher average standard of life than today. More food, less starvation, less malnutrician, less disease, higher education, less war, more capitalism (communism a subject known only in history books).

No concern about a quaint oddity in a small paragraph in the history of science, next to Piltdown man and leeching, called...AGW

If only it wasn't scientists saying AGW is real. I would find it so much more comforting if it was just fuzzy photos.
 
Well, I was only reporting what NEWT was saying.

You went beyond reporting to interpretation with "it looks like ..."
My estimate is 9B by 2050 and a much higher average standard of life than today. More food, less starvation, less malnutrician, less disease, higher education, less war, more capitalism (communism a subject known only in history books).

No concern about a quaint oddity in a small paragraph in the history of science, next to Piltdown man and leeching, called...AGW

Your boundless optimism is now a matter of record. Hopefully we'll be here in 2050 to compare notes. The next three-to-eight years will be interesting enough, though.

AGW isn't going to be lost in science history when it's played such an important role in the scientific world over the last few decades, whatever happens. If AGW turns out to be wrong the post-mortem in the scientific world is going to be a profound affair. How did so many scientists, in so many different fields, all get it so wrong?

Of course, AGW isn't going away. The science is very clear on that.
 
Question. This is something I don't have a good understanding of. (:blush:)

The response of absorption of radiation is logarithmic. But the response for climate sensitivity is linear.

Apparently this is due to

The idea that CO2 absorption is “saturated” in Earth’s atmosphere is wrong. It was developed in the early 20th century in response to Arrhenius’s 1896 global warming paper, and was standard doctrine until more careful spectra of CO2 and H2O were developed in the 1940s, and the process of radiative transfer at many levels in the atmosphere was better understood.

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/04/learning-from-a-simple-model/

Now, can anyone explain that to an amateur like me? It is a recurrent meme from the denier crowd.
 
You went beyond reporting to interpretation with "it looks like ..."


Your boundless optimism is now a matter of record. Hopefully we'll be here in 2050 to compare notes. The next three-to-eight years will be interesting enough, though.

AGW isn't going to be lost in science history when it's played such an important role in the scientific world over the last few decades, whatever happens. If AGW turns out to be wrong the post-mortem in the scientific world is going to be a profound affair. How did so many scientists, in so many different fields, all get it so wrong?

Of course, AGW isn't going away. The science is very clear on that.

Good topics all, but as Fsol notes, we need to keep this thread on track and it is meant to be more pure science with none of the politics etc. My fault partly this time. :)
 
AGW isn't going to be lost in science history when it's played such an important role in the scientific world over the last few decades, whatever happens. If AGW turns out to be wrong the post-mortem in the scientific world is going to be a profound affair. How did so many scientists, in so many different fields, all get it so wrong?

while it is not credible to argue they "all get it wrong" it is conceivable there is something important we left out (i'd be interested what people think the odds are on such a feedback making things "better" or "worse").

a small paragraph in the history of science, next to Piltdown man and leeching, called...AGW

while piltdown man was an intentional hoax, leeching was (i assume) believed.

i wonder how scientists would rank their strength of belief in, say,

smoking-cancer link
the Higgs Boson
AGW
life on mars (ever)

what else should be on that list? could we come up with a skeptical-score card (strength of belief, say giving odds-on?) that would help us distinguish honest scientific skeptics from other-agenda skeptics and nay-sayers?
 
while it is not credible to argue they "all get it wrong" it is conceivable there is something important we left out (i'd be interested what people think the odds are on such a feedback making things "better" or "worse").

Which is New Scientist was asking. Why is the denialist argument so bad? There is a lot of science to be debated on the topic, but so much of the denialist rebuttal is just nonsense, hand waving and grasping at straws.
 
Last edited:
while it is not credible to argue they "all get it wrong" it is conceivable there is something important we left out (i'd be interested what people think the odds are on such a feedback making things "better" or "worse").

Intellectually, that's where I have a problem with accepting the AGW hypothesis as it's being expressed now. I will admit that the hypothesis is intuitive. That is, who's to say that pumping all that gaseous and particulate waste into the air hasn't come home to roost finally? But there's too much supposition in the underlying science and, as an experimentallist, I don't like that. You can't really know something unless you've established all the seminal underpinnings and that hasn't been done yet. And, as there is some information that demonstrates that the currently-chosen underpinnngs are not correct, I remain a fence-sitter.

Which is New Scientist was asking. Why is the denialist argument so bad? There is a lot of science to be debated on the topic, but so much of the denialist rebuttal is just nonsense, hand waving and grasping at straws.

Tnis is an emotional issue for many and that's too bad. You have to ignore the hand-waving on both sides and examine the data that's being presented. Does it really say what they think it says? Was it correctly derived? What other data might exist that would be corroborative and does it corroborate?

One of the great shames of this debate is that it was politicized so early and effectively. Now, it's difficult to hear above the fray. So, best to stick to the data.
 
Intellectually, that's where I have a problem with accepting the AGW hypothesis as it's being expressed now. I will admit that the hypothesis is intuitive. That is, who's to say that pumping all that gaseous and particulate waste into the air hasn't come home to roost finally? But there's too much supposition in the underlying science and, as an experimentallist, I don't like that. You can't really know something unless you've established all the seminal underpinnings and that hasn't been done yet. And, as there is some information that demonstrates that the currently-chosen underpinnngs are not correct, I remain a fence-sitter.
I think first that the underpinnings are correct; to wit,
1. CO2 contributes to the greenhouse effect that makes the Earth's average surface temperature warmer than the Moon's. At this point, this is basically unquestioned by serious geophysicists (not all of whom are climatologists; and keep in mind there are always iconoclasts, their position in the scientific community is respected, and many would argue essential). The mechanism by which this occurs is well-known, and well-accepted. It is based on the physics of CO2 and infrared radiation.
2. The physics of the situation also indicate strongly that an increase in the CO2 concentration will enhance the retention of heat.
3. Basic thermodynamics says that if an object contains more heat, it will be warmer.
Those are the underpinnings. The details are, where does that heat concentrate, i.e., in the atmosphere, in the ground, in the ocean, in what part of each, how does that change the heat-driven processes that determine climate, what will happen as a result, how fast will it happen, etc. But as far as the underpinnings go, I think they're pretty solid.

As a result of this evaluation, my opinion (separate from the demonstrated facts) is that it is not a matter of whether or not that heat will have climatic effects, but when it will. The answer, provided in events that are occurring as we speak, appears to be now. The Arctic melted this summer; the Antarctic has shown several symptoms as well over the past several years, including this one (no, increased ice cover is not necessarily an indication of Antarctic cooling, particularly not in the presence of significant warming in Patagonia and the Antarctic Peninsula; what they don't tell you is that Antarctic sea ice underwent a reduction nearly as dramatic as this year's in the Arctic between 1973 and 1977, but of course all the graphs posted by deniers only go back to 1979); and several large atmospheric climate systems are beginning to show effects that seem to be driven by the availability of additional heat. The time to act most efficiently seems to be a decade or more past. We now appear to be in a situation, due to suppression of science, a massive PR campaign, and the deliberate effort to discredit legitimate research and prevent satellite data gathering, that will be very expensive to address. There is significant reason to believe that there will be some pretty unpleasant economic consequences, and it is entirely possible that there will be tens or hundreds of millions of deaths as a result.

Tnis is an emotional issue for many and that's too bad. You have to ignore the hand-waving on both sides and examine the data that's being presented. Does it really say what they think it says? Was it correctly derived? What other data might exist that would be corroborative and does it corroborate?

One of the great shames of this debate is that it was politicized so early and effectively. Now, it's difficult to hear above the fray. So, best to stick to the data.
The politicization was primarily if not exclusively on one side. Because there's really no way to hide it if the North Pole melts, enough people are starting to get the idea that the people who did it are starting to look for somewhere to hide, but that politicization has turned something that might have meant a few rich people might not get a new Rolls this year ten years ago into something people are liable to die over in droves. It's no big deal, though, they're just brown people.

I consider the loudness, lying, and the use of rhetorical arguments rather than logical and scientific ones highly indicative; I have argued global warming with rather over a hundred different people, and I could count the number that talked science on the fingers of one hand, and of those, more than one wound up convinced it was real. Which is, of course, nothing but anecdote, the plural of which is not evidence. Nevertheless, to ME, it is.

I've made some rater harsh remarks here, Slime, and I want to be sure you know they're not directed at you. Please don't take them that way; we've achieved at least a detente, and I've no wish to disturb it. If I'd say anything directly to you, it's that I think you should do more research. I think you're wrong about it not being pretty clear at this point, but at least you'll have a scientifically-based conversation about it, which is better than I can say for many. It's the subjects you're addressing and the extent to which you've accepted data that appear to me to be unreliable that bothers me, not you personally.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom