Schneibster, this is one comment that I can fully support and it's the very message that I've been touting, derails aside. I haven't read Tsonas in depth but your statement fully supports my view that there are too many assumptions in the AGW hypothesis for it to be considered a closed case at this point in time. Is it fair to say that Tsonas has alit on an acceptable hypothesis but the mechanism is still in question?
IMHO, Tsonas has hit on a different means of analyzing the data, and a good one, but when all is said and done, what will be found will be common causes, and they will most likely be CO2.
I think that we've got a lot to figure out yet about climate, but I think there's enough evidence to conclude in broad strokes that if the CO2 goes up, it will get warmer, and that CO2 has gone up, and that it has gotten warmer. I don't think it's clear how fast that will get bad, but I think it's clear if we don't do something, it will get bad. I don't know how bad, but considering the size of the problem, and that we've frittered away a decade or more fussing about whether it's really happening, and considering we're watching the whole Arctic melt, I think the time for discussing whether it's happening or not is past.
I disagree with your opinion that there are too many assumptions involved, but I don't think you're trivially wrong. It's an incredibly complex system, and there are elements of the situation that involve both chaos, which we are still figuring out, and finite element analysis of Navier-Stokes equations, which we are also still figuring out. By no means do we have a clear idea of all the likely consequences. Again and again we hear, "we need more information." And that's true; if we want to get pretty solid projections, we DO need more information.
Above, you have laid out exactly what has been bothering me about the entire issue of AGW and that is a wholesale assumption that, because carbon dioxide is the only viable candidate in the gas phase to make the hypothesis correct, that gas is chosen as the most probable cause despite its rarity in the atmosphere (at 300 - 600 ppmv, it's a difficult cause ot make for any single gas that its blanketing effect is efficient enough to heat up a massive system like the surface of the planet even one inch deep).
I can see why you think that way, in all honesty. It IS a massive system we're talking about here. And it's a complex system, perhaps the most complex we have ever tried to analyze in the history of science.
I have some points I'd like to make, and I'll ask you to think about them honestly and tell me what you think.
1. The Earth absorbs an enormous amount of energy every day from the Sun, and an enormous amount of energy gets radiated away. As with any such system, where energy goes in, goes through various processes, and goes out, an equilibrium will be reached where the system gets to a particular point of temperature, and at that temperature, the incoming will equal the outgoing.
2. When any of the parameters of the processes change, the equilibrium will change. The longer that change stays, the closer the system will get to the new equilibrium; but of course, that only happens if the change stops. If it keeps going, the system will keep changing too, and it will keep changing after the new value is reached, until it reaches equilibrium.
3. Complex systems are often sensitively dependent upon initial conditions; small changes in parameters, in other words, can have large effects on outcomes, and the effects they have often increase over time.
4. Even a small increase in the rate of incoming energy, or decrease in outgoing energy, adds up over a long enough time to a lot, because there's nowhere for it to go.
5. The specific heat of rock and earth is about 0.8J/gK; the specific heat of liquid water is about 5J/gK; and the specific heat of air is about 1J/gK. But the specific gravity of earth is about 1.7, and rock is about 2.8; overall, call it about 2. The specific gravity of water is 1 by definition. But the specific gravity of air is about 0.0012 (on the scale where water is 1). (All at, say, 15C or so.) So that means that by volume, the relative heats have water the highest, with about twice the volumetric heat capacity of earth and rock, and air by far the lowest with perhaps a thousandth the volumetric heat capacity of water.
6. The thermal conductivity of air is lower than that of earth and rock, and much lower than that of water.
Now, I'm not going to draw any conclusions here for you. Just think about these facts and tell me what you think is going to happen, assuming that CO2 is a greenhouse gas, and assuming it's increasing, and has been for a hundred and fifty years.
So, are we finally on the same page?
No, but I don't think that means we have to keep slanging each other. Perhaps I'll convince you. Perhaps you'll convince me. Perhaps we'll agree to disagree. But let's discuss this seriously.