Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

That is why the positive feedback mechanisms are important. Without them, the climate sensitivity would be low. Albedo is one, water vapour another.

You're talking a heck of a lot of Joules to heat up the environment that much. Has anyone published the calculations? Why arent' we using carbon dioxide to insulate homes?
 
... Why arent' we using carbon dioxide to insulate homes?

We do. The most efficient insulation is foam, the bubbles are CO2 gas. But then, what about the positive feedback loop when used it to insulate coolers? How do it know?
 
:rolleyes: Come on, you can do better than that.

No, seriously. It's a real question. Why don't we use carbon dioxide to insulate homes? You are telling me that 280 ppmv will essentially insulate the planet and cause a massive warming due to its re-radiative properties. It would be no problem at all to manufacture thermal pillows which are silvered on one side but full of nearly pure carbon dioxide. Per your hypothesis, that would be a much better insulator for homes than the trapped air we currently use. What's so ridiculous about that? I'm just trying to find a practical use for what you are saying.
 
Realclimate has had several topics on this.

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2006/03/climate-sensitivity-plus-a-change/

For a climate scientists point of view.

I went to the link and it's not convincing because it begins with a statement that the belief that carbon dioxide is the driver is based on atmospheric models. I'm not convinced because, as we've seen before, even the IPCC admits that none of the models are validated yet.

However, I did find a link in the Q&A to here where the equations used to calculate forcing are listed. I noticed that carbon dioxide is the only gas that has a non-linear equation to its forcing although I don't know why that would be. No explanation is given. However, it's a permutation of Beer's Law where the Absorbance of material in solution (a gaseous solution, in this case) is given by the log of the ratio of initial light flux to the emerging power flux. I noticed, however, that the terms are reversed, maybe to indicate emission but that would not explain the alpha constant at 5.35. That means that carbon dioxide forces 5.35 J for every 1 J reradiated? I find that fairly difficult to believe, mainly because of the First Law which has been discussed in this thread ad nauseam.
 
We do. The most efficient insulation is foam, the bubbles are CO2 gas. But then, what about the positive feedback loop when used it to insulate coolers? How do it know?

Thanks, casebro, I had forgotten foam insulation. I was thinking of fiberglass blankets and the like. These products depend on trapped gases for insulating power because gases are such poor conductors of heat.

However, the claim here is that cabon dioxide has an unusually potent characteristic in that it will very efficiently reradiate heat. Radiate it so efficiently that, at even double the concentration (approaching 600 ppmv), the planet would rise significantly in temperature. Well, if it will do that at that concentration, could you imagine what it would do for home insulation if you blanketed a home with 100% carbon dioxide with one side of the layer comprised of a very efficent IR reflector? To keep heat out of something, you'd have to make the reflective side the inner side. We may even be able to "heat" real greenhouses with dry ice.
 
Schneibster, this is one comment that I can fully support and it's the very message that I've been touting, derails aside. I haven't read Tsonas in depth but your statement fully supports my view that there are too many assumptions in the AGW hypothesis for it to be considered a closed case at this point in time. Is it fair to say that Tsonas has alit on an acceptable hypothesis but the mechanism is still in question?
IMHO, Tsonas has hit on a different means of analyzing the data, and a good one, but when all is said and done, what will be found will be common causes, and they will most likely be CO2.

I think that we've got a lot to figure out yet about climate, but I think there's enough evidence to conclude in broad strokes that if the CO2 goes up, it will get warmer, and that CO2 has gone up, and that it has gotten warmer. I don't think it's clear how fast that will get bad, but I think it's clear if we don't do something, it will get bad. I don't know how bad, but considering the size of the problem, and that we've frittered away a decade or more fussing about whether it's really happening, and considering we're watching the whole Arctic melt, I think the time for discussing whether it's happening or not is past.

I disagree with your opinion that there are too many assumptions involved, but I don't think you're trivially wrong. It's an incredibly complex system, and there are elements of the situation that involve both chaos, which we are still figuring out, and finite element analysis of Navier-Stokes equations, which we are also still figuring out. By no means do we have a clear idea of all the likely consequences. Again and again we hear, "we need more information." And that's true; if we want to get pretty solid projections, we DO need more information.

Above, you have laid out exactly what has been bothering me about the entire issue of AGW and that is a wholesale assumption that, because carbon dioxide is the only viable candidate in the gas phase to make the hypothesis correct, that gas is chosen as the most probable cause despite its rarity in the atmosphere (at 300 - 600 ppmv, it's a difficult cause ot make for any single gas that its blanketing effect is efficient enough to heat up a massive system like the surface of the planet even one inch deep).
I can see why you think that way, in all honesty. It IS a massive system we're talking about here. And it's a complex system, perhaps the most complex we have ever tried to analyze in the history of science.

I have some points I'd like to make, and I'll ask you to think about them honestly and tell me what you think.

1. The Earth absorbs an enormous amount of energy every day from the Sun, and an enormous amount of energy gets radiated away. As with any such system, where energy goes in, goes through various processes, and goes out, an equilibrium will be reached where the system gets to a particular point of temperature, and at that temperature, the incoming will equal the outgoing.

2. When any of the parameters of the processes change, the equilibrium will change. The longer that change stays, the closer the system will get to the new equilibrium; but of course, that only happens if the change stops. If it keeps going, the system will keep changing too, and it will keep changing after the new value is reached, until it reaches equilibrium.

3. Complex systems are often sensitively dependent upon initial conditions; small changes in parameters, in other words, can have large effects on outcomes, and the effects they have often increase over time.

4. Even a small increase in the rate of incoming energy, or decrease in outgoing energy, adds up over a long enough time to a lot, because there's nowhere for it to go.

5. The specific heat of rock and earth is about 0.8J/gK; the specific heat of liquid water is about 5J/gK; and the specific heat of air is about 1J/gK. But the specific gravity of earth is about 1.7, and rock is about 2.8; overall, call it about 2. The specific gravity of water is 1 by definition. But the specific gravity of air is about 0.0012 (on the scale where water is 1). (All at, say, 15C or so.) So that means that by volume, the relative heats have water the highest, with about twice the volumetric heat capacity of earth and rock, and air by far the lowest with perhaps a thousandth the volumetric heat capacity of water.

6. The thermal conductivity of air is lower than that of earth and rock, and much lower than that of water.

Now, I'm not going to draw any conclusions here for you. Just think about these facts and tell me what you think is going to happen, assuming that CO2 is a greenhouse gas, and assuming it's increasing, and has been for a hundred and fifty years.

So, are we finally on the same page?
No, but I don't think that means we have to keep slanging each other. Perhaps I'll convince you. Perhaps you'll convince me. Perhaps we'll agree to disagree. But let's discuss this seriously.
 
No, seriously. It's a real question. Why don't we use carbon dioxide to insulate homes? You are telling me that 280 ppmv will essentially insulate the planet and cause a massive warming due to its re-radiative properties. It would be no problem at all to manufacture thermal pillows which are silvered on one side but full of nearly pure carbon dioxide. Per your hypothesis, that would be a much better insulator for homes than the trapped air we currently use. What's so ridiculous about that? I'm just trying to find a practical use for what you are saying.

It only works at a specific range of frequencies, for one thing. For another, there are many kilometers of atmosphere available to trap the radiation.
 
True, if you are thinking of physical effect as a "nearly in time cause."

Large scale shifts such as he discusses would seem in the 20th century to not have CO2 as a cause although he notes there may have been some coincident CO2 effect.

If I am getting the general message.
Let me put it this way: Tsonas says there's a connection between certain locations in the atmosphere. I think he's right. He doesn't say what it is. I don't think there's enough information to say what it is, in his papers.

That connection can't be CO2. But that doesn't mean that the origin of the signal isn't CO2; just that the connection has to transfer heat. So I'm not convinced there's enough information in Tsonas' work to conclude AGW or non-A GW, or non-GW. There might be enough to conclude GW, or at least to imply it. There's certainly enough to conclude that there is a connection between remote parts of the atmosphere.
 
We are not discussing the quantity of total carbon on the planet. We're discussing how much is actually in gaseous form. Let's leave the biota out of it unless you have a point to make that the carbon in biota will also warm the planet.
Hmmmm, I think you missed the point- the point is, it doesn't matter how small it is, if it's enough, and it's enough for all the world's plants to use it as pretty much their only source of carbon. But it's not that important a point, in the direction I'm going.

Actually, no you're not talking about a few percent here. I know a few people have already posted the theoretical temperature of the Earth's surface without an atmosphere. I don't know where that came from but I suppose it would be the steady-state temperature due to only the average solar flux.
According to Wikipedia's article on the Moon, and it agrees well with my recollection from astronomy books, the mean temperature of the surface of the Moon is 220K. The mean temperature of the surface of the Earth, on the other hand, according to the same source, is 287K. So that means that the Earth is 67K (which is, of course, 67C) warmer than the Moon, despite being the same distance from the Sun. The difference here is the atmosphere; and it's enough of a difference to make the Earth 67 degrees warmer than it would be without an atmosphere. There's the greenhouse effect right there.

Anyway, that's your starting point, not 0 K. I don't believe that the difference between what was stated (- 19 C or somewhere around there) and today's "average" temperature is more than 36 K. I've heard from some sources that the planet is going to warm by +10 C and that's a heck of a lot more than 2%.
The estimates of warming due to increased AGWGs (all of them, not just CO2) from AR4 are on the close order of 2.8C, with a range from 1.8C to 4C. That's 2.8/67=4.179%, with a range from 1.8/67=2.687% to 4/67=5.970%. This is estimated over the course of the 21st Century. For CO2 alone, the figure is about half of that; there is methane, and halocarbons, and ozone, and other things to consider. Water vapor is left out, because in this scenario, it's a feedback, not a driver. So if CO2 is half the effect, it's between 1.4% and 2.9%, with a most probable value of about 2.1%; and it might not be all of half. AUP's guesstimate looks pretty good.

Remember that: CO2 isn't the only anthropogenic greenhouse gas. There are others.

Given the mass of the atmosphere and the top, say, six inches of the Earth, the blanketing efficiency of all greenhouse gases combined would have to be astronomical to cause that effect.
The specific gravity and relative density of the atmosphere is given above. There's something else to consider. The total incoming and outgoing energy are enormous; far more than the top two inches of the ground are affected, and change every day. The atmosphere warms and cools by several C or more between night and day. What's being proposed here is that over a hundred years, enough heat will build up to raise the temperature by less than the daily variation.
 
Let's see if we can't give some reasonable answers here.
1. The assertion that the planet is warming without a mechanism to define a value for the temperature of the planet.
The data to do this is available, and has been since 2001. A few hundred thousand data ensembles a day are available, and they cover multiple data points at different altitudes. We have a satellite, AIRS, that has been collecting them. We use that data for weather prediction. I would say that's enough data, accurately determined, and widely used for accurate weather forecasts, to give a pretty clear idea.

Prior to that, we used lower resolution satellite data; and prior to that, still lower resolution weather station data. Still, it's a lot of data, and it goes back over a hundred years. I would say that based on instrumental data alone, we could make extremely high resolution determination of global temperature back to 2001, high resolution back to the late 1980s, excellent estimates back to the late 1950s, very good estimates back to the 1930s, good estimates back to the beginning of the 20th century, and reasonable estimates back to the US Civil War. And we can check how accurate the weather station data is back to the late 1980s by comparing it with the satellite data. Given computer data processing, do you really think it's reasonable to call this an assumption?

2. The assumption that the causative agent is carbon dioxide, given that it's the only IR-active gas in sufficient concentrations to cause the effect.
In fact, that's not being asserted at all. There are quite a few GWGs, and CO2 is only the most important one. It's also the one that's the hardest to control; the halocarbons are being reduced substantially by the Montreal Protocol. Methane is also hard to control, but it's not as powerful as CO2. And we make a LOT of CO2. Cement manufacture creates CO2, power generation creates CO2, steel manufacture creates CO2, and cars create CO2, and those are four very important industrial processes that can have a very bad effect on our economy if we stop them, and also four processes that we do a lot of to support industrial civilization. If we're going to pick the one that will make the most difference, though, it's going to be CO2.

That's a circular argument.

Those are the two biggies. Others have more to do with the seemingly haphazard conduct of the science.
I don't think you've investigated the science yet, in depth. That's not a hit on you; there's a lot of it.

That statement cuts both ways. When a theoretician lacks a mechanism that does not make the theory wrong. Most hypotheses begin without establishing a mechamism of cause.
Right, but I don't think Tsonas comes to any conclusion with a high degree of probability other than that there are areas of the atmosphere that can affect one another that are remote from one another. I read four of the papers, and that was all I got. One of them concluded that global warming could be causing greater variations in the weather and short-term climate. Maybe I missed something.

I'll leave the rest for CD. It's along his line of argument, not mine. This one is mine.
 
Thanks, casebro, I had forgotten foam insulation. I was thinking of fiberglass blankets and the like. These products depend on trapped gases for insulating power because gases are such poor conductors of heat.
And that's a key quality. Remember, GW is mostly the atmosphere getting warmer. It makes sense, since the conductivity of the atmosphere is low, and its specific heat is also low.

However, the claim here is that cabon dioxide has an unusually potent characteristic in that it will very efficiently reradiate heat.
Not really. Now, we had a fight about this, and I made fun of you, and I apologize for that. This here, this is serious. I think you've honestly misunderstood, and I'm going to try to explain it.

The key point here is that every gas either re-radiates heat it absorbs as IR photons, if it's capable of absorbing IR photons, or distributes that heat among the molecules of the gas. That's simple conservation of energy. Excited states are not stable; either the energy leaves as radiation, or it's distributed among the other molecules of the gas as kinetic energy. The effect doesn't really depend upon CO2 being an efficient re-radiator; only on how often it absorbs a passing IR photon. CO2 need not be any more or less efficient at absorbing passing photons than any other molecule to create part of the greenhouse effect. All it has to do is absorb one every so often, and either make the atmosphere warmer, or re-radiate one; half the time, that one will go back to the Earth, half the time to space. Assuming, of course, it doesn't get absorbed by another one before either of those alternatives.

I hope that helps.
 
What assumptions behind AGW bother you?

Tsonas doesn't only lack a mechanism to explain why the current warming is occurring, it also lacks an explanation for why increased CO2-load wouldn't cause warming despite the well-supported mechanism that AGW posits.

Wrong. Have you heard of the idea of people doing research on climate without the entire thing being wrapped around the "Yes it's CO2"/"No it's not CO2" point of view?
 
Thanks, casebro, I had forgotten foam insulation. I was thinking of fiberglass blankets and the like. These products depend on trapped gases for insulating power because gases are such poor conductors of heat.

However, the claim here is that cabon dioxide has an unusually potent characteristic in that it will very efficiently reradiate heat. Radiate it so efficiently that, at even double the concentration (approaching 600 ppmv), the planet would rise significantly in temperature. Well, if it will do that at that concentration, could you imagine what it would do for home insulation if you blanketed a home with 100% carbon dioxide with one side of the layer comprised of a very efficent IR reflector? To keep heat out of something, you'd have to make the reflective side the inner side. We may even be able to "heat" real greenhouses with dry ice.

Some foam has CO2 and that is NOT related to trying to enhance insulative properties.
 
Right, but I don't think Tsonas comes to any conclusion with a high degree of probability other than that there are areas of the atmosphere that can affect one another that are remote from one another. I read four of the papers, and that was all I got. One of them concluded that global warming could be causing greater variations in the weather and short-term climate. Maybe I missed something.

I'll leave the rest for CD. It's along his line of argument, not mine. This one is mine.


It's going to take me until the end of this week to read all of these papers and understand them in more than a fairly shallow manner, although I will grant that Tsonis does a very good job of presenting the relevant graph theory in a way that is comprehensible to the layman. Or he tries.

(bold is mine)
From "A new dynamical mechanism for major climate shifts"

Tsonis et al. writes “We find that in those cases where the synchronous state was followed by a steady increase in the coupling strength between the indices, the synchronous state was destroyed, after which a new climate state emerged. These shifts are associated with significant changes in global temperature trend and in ENSO variability. The latest such event is known as the great climate shift of the 1970s.”

Two other times between 1900 and 2000 had the same alignment when synchronization was following by an increase in coupling strength. One occurred ~1912, and the Earth warmed steadily for the next 30 years, while the other occurred in ~1941, and the temperature of the Earth remained remarkably steady for a 30 year period. Furthermore, Tsonis et al. ran a global climate model over a 100 year period and found that each time synchronization was followed by an increase in coupling strength, the Earth’s climate seemed to move into a new state defined by warming or cooling.

Tsonis et al. end their article noting that while “The standard explanation for the post 1970s warming is that the radiative effect of greenhouse gases overcame shortwave reflection effects due to aerosols,” their result “suggests an alternative hypothesis, namely that the climate shifted after the 1970s event to a different state of a warmer climate, which may be superimposed on an anthropogenic warming trend.”
​
As I noted, Tsonis does not refute the CO2 hypothesis except in certain particulars, such as the (already fairly weak) argument that the warming since the 1970s "must be due to CO2 because it wasn't solar and there isn't anything else".

Now there is something else to explain the post 1970's warming. Seems to me that's a pretty big deal. Am I off base here?
 
I went to the link and it's not convincing because it begins with a statement that the belief that carbon dioxide is the driver is based on atmospheric models. I'm not convinced because, as we've seen before, even the IPCC admits that none of the models are validated yet.

However, I did find a link in the Q&A to here where the equations used to calculate forcing are listed. I noticed that carbon dioxide is the only gas that has a non-linear equation to its forcing although I don't know why that would be. No explanation is given. However, it's a permutation of Beer's Law where the Absorbance of material in solution (a gaseous solution, in this case) is given by the log of the ratio of initial light flux to the emerging power flux. I noticed, however, that the terms are reversed, maybe to indicate emission but that would not explain the alpha constant at 5.35. That means that carbon dioxide forces 5.35 J for every 1 J reradiated? I find that fairly difficult to believe, mainly because of the First Law which has been discussed in this thread ad nauseam.

If it is of any interest I can drag back up a very comprehensive discussion on Climateaudit about "where did they get the constants" in that equation. Short story, who knows...
 
It's going to take me until the end of this week to read all of these papers and understand them in more than a fairly shallow manner, although I will grant that Tsonis does a very good job of presenting the relevant graph theory in a way that is comprehensible to the layman. Or he tries.
One of the things I think he might have trouble with is that he isn't clear on the fact that representing it as a network is only a different representation. No new physical law is proposed; it's just another way of looking at how changes propagate through the atmosphere.

(bold is mine)
From "A new dynamical mechanism for major climate shifts"

Tsonis et al. writes “We find that in those cases where the synchronous state was followed by a steady increase in the coupling strength between the indices, the synchronous state was destroyed, after which a new climate state emerged. These shifts are associated with significant changes in global temperature trend and in ENSO variability. The latest such event is known as the great climate shift of the 1970s.”

Two other times between 1900 and 2000 had the same alignment when synchronization was following by an increase in coupling strength. One occurred ~1912, and the Earth warmed steadily for the next 30 years, while the other occurred in ~1941, and the temperature of the Earth remained remarkably steady for a 30 year period. Furthermore, Tsonis et al. ran a global climate model over a 100 year period and found that each time synchronization was followed by an increase in coupling strength, the Earth’s climate seemed to move into a new state defined by warming or cooling.

Tsonis et al. end their article noting that while “The standard explanation for the post 1970s warming is that the radiative effect of greenhouse gases overcame shortwave reflection effects due to aerosols,” their result “suggests an alternative hypothesis, namely that the climate shifted after the 1970s event to a different state of a warmer climate, which may be superimposed on an anthropogenic warming trend.”
​
As I noted, Tsonis does not refute the CO2 hypothesis except in certain particulars, such as the (already fairly weak) argument that the warming since the 1970s "must be due to CO2 because it wasn't solar and there isn't anything else".
I think you missed that last part about "superimposed on an anthropogenic warming trend." That would be what you claim is refuted. It looks more to me like the thing that's refuted is the aerosols hypothesis for the lack of warming from the 40s to 70s.

Now there is something else to explain the post 1970's warming. Seems to me that's a pretty big deal. Am I off base here?
I think so. Tsonis (sorry for the earlier mispeling) appears to be a bit coy about all of this. He also doesn't sufficiently support the hypothesis that an outside influence would be indicated by a bifurcation, nor IMO does he show that in fact one did not occur both in the 1910s and the 1970s. I see some evidence of bifurcation and rapid ascent to high frequency oscillation followed by loss of the signal in both of those. Furthermore, his conclusions about what happened in the 1940s and 50s are weak; another mechanism is apparently at work there, since we see a shift after a much shorter time, and a long stable period, which I don't see an explanation for from him.

I suspect that there may be more to it than he has found yet, and that bifurcations may be occurring that his model does not have enough detail to represent, but I couldn't prove it without a model of my own and a computer to play with. At any rate, superimposing it on anthropogenic warming is needed to make it look like what we see, so it's certainly not proof there's no global warming, nor even that anthropogenic GHGs aren't causing warming. At most it causes one to question the aerosol hypothesis for the 1940s-70s flatness.
 
One of the things I think he might have trouble with is that he isn't clear on the fact that representing it as a network is only a different representation. No new physical law is proposed; it's just another way of looking at how changes propagate through the atmosphere.

I think you missed that last part about "superimposed on an anthropogenic warming trend." That would be what you claim is refuted. It looks more to me like the thing that's refuted is the aerosols hypothesis for the lack of warming from the 40s to 70s.

I think so. Tsonis (sorry for the earlier mispeling) appears to be a bit coy about all of this. He also doesn't sufficiently support the hypothesis that an outside influence would be indicated by a bifurcation, nor IMO does he show that in fact one did not occur both in the 1910s and the 1970s. I see some evidence of bifurcation and rapid ascent to high frequency oscillation followed by loss of the signal in both of those. Furthermore, his conclusions about what happened in the 1940s and 50s are weak; another mechanism is apparently at work there, since we see a shift after a much shorter time, and a long stable period, which I don't see an explanation for from him.

I suspect that there may be more to it than he has found yet, and that bifurcations may be occurring that his model does not have enough detail to represent, but I couldn't prove it without a model of my own and a computer to play with. At any rate, superimposing it on anthropogenic warming is needed to make it look like what we see, so it's certainly not proof there's no global warming, nor even that anthropogenic GHGs aren't causing warming. At most it causes one to question the aerosol hypothesis for the 1940s-70s flatness.

Well, it was about time that aerosol hypothesis went out the window.:)

Clearly Tsonis's concepts are related to the subject I have often quoted of "climate cycles" and the little simple sine wave curve fit on 60-80 year cycles. That, also, does not negate the possibility of there being some AGW component superimosed on top of the curve.

I pointed out in my second post on Tsonis that he doesn't negate or confirm any particular AGW hypothesis, in fact is not focusing on that issue at all.

Unquestionably this is just the beginning and these concepts have yet to be incorporated into models. As noted in the MS thesis of one of his students (one of the PDFs) "there is almost no literature on networks and climate".

The estimate for climate sensitivity figured from an AGW trend superimosed on the natural trend would be quite a bit less than if AGW got "the whole hog". Unless the natural trend was extremely weak and inconsequential, but that does not appear to be the case here.

In general, though I would agree that it is way to early to grasp what effect this new use of mathematics may have on the subject at hand. Given a year it would be much clearer.
 
Well, it was about time that aerosol hypothesis went out the window.:)

Clearly Tsonis's concepts are related to the subject I have often quoted of "climate cycles" and the little simple sine wave curve fit on 60-80 year cycles. That, also, does not negate the possibility of there being some AGW component superimosed on top of the curve.
I don't think I've seen anybody argue that such cycles don't exist, merely that they don't account for all the warming.

I pointed out in my second post on Tsonis that he doesn't negate or confirm any particular AGW hypothesis, in fact is not focusing on that issue at all.
OK. I think I'd agree with that; I'll point out however that he includes AGW as a signal in his models, as an afterthought (as you say, to him, that's not what's important about what's happening) so that other scientists can match what he's gotten out of his model runs up with measurements.

I'm still trying to get my head around what he's talking about, but he might be saying that this persistent pattern of synchronizations and losses of synchronization started when global warming did, in the 1850s or 60s; he might even be hinting that the start of it might be the cause of the pattern in the first place. He's got a bit of a way to go before he convinces me. Not to mention before he's clear on just what he's talking about.

Unquestionably this is just the beginning and these concepts have yet to be incorporated into models. As noted in the MS thesis of one of his students (one of the PDFs) "there is almost no literature on networks and climate".
That's true, but it's very important to understand that incorporating such features into models is counter-productive and could be seen as circular reasoning. Instead, what you're looking at here is a novel method of analyzing the output of the models.

Part of the problem with dealing with models of this complexity is that it's very difficult to get your head around what is happening. It's also very difficult to follow how signals propagate through the elements of such a complex model. Network analysis permits the identification of major features of the model, and the analysis of the interaction of those features. It does not speak to the mechanism of that interaction, but it tells you where to look for it. When you find a parameter in your model that varies during the period between when one node changes and another changes, if that parameter can reasonably be expected to change the behavior of the second node, then you've got a presumptive fit for the mechanism; you can then go about verifying that by more traditional methods.

The estimate for climate sensitivity figured from an AGW trend superimosed on the natural trend would be quite a bit less than if AGW got "the whole hog". Unless the natural trend was extremely weak and inconsequential, but that does not appear to be the case here.
Part of what you do in network analysis is look for inflections. You're not looking for a trend; you're looking for a change. Network analysis can't explain trends; it explains the propagation of changes, and shows how subsystems interact within the system when changes occur. You still need something to explain the trend in the first place.

In general, though I would agree that it is way to early to grasp what effect this new use of mathematics may have on the subject at hand. Given a year it would be much clearer.
I think you're expecting this type of analysis to explain something it's not capable of explaining. In fact, I think even expecting it to explain anything is off base. What it will do is tell us where to look for explanations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom