Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

If they are written up and published in peer reviewed journals then that will be interesting. If their concerns are laid out in editorial style pieces I will be less than impressed.

Agreed. Although it is worth noting that CO2 research was very obscure in the 1950s, not exactly something that many people would have cared about.
 
No, I don't. I do believe that the lab model is significantly accurate to model the atmospheric response. That is the nature of modelling, not getting it exactly right, but close enough to be useful. The A380 flew, and I am surprised that a project so ambitious doens't seem to have needed any major re-engineering from the first prototypes. That's all due to modeling.

I agree with you about models. I use lots of them myself. Most of them are not very well validated so the results are seen more as an index than a true scalar. Even then, we usually wind up doing the study to find if the model is correct. Sometimes it is; sometimes it isn't.

The models I run don't predict famine, tidal waves, mass extinction and the like. That's why I keep asking you what level of evidence we should expect for a model that does.

No arcane knowledge. You're falling for the smoke screen being laid down by someone who pulls quantum physics out of their posterior whenever they're cornered. I told you that the flaw in his write-up was not germane to the subject but it was germane to his argument. Regardless what anyone else posts, we are not dealing with mystery here. The only mystery to me is why nobody is looking for the temperature of the orb.

I don't know much about Quantum physics, and when I said so, Schneibster helped me out. If there is anything he is specifically wrong about, what is it?

Read my post number 552. As assiduously as schneib has studied quantum mechanics, he's missed whole chapters. I believe part of his problem is that he's convinced himself that all other knowledge stems from physics. If only it were so.

A full report from the IPCC on the projected risks. http://www.ipcc-wg2.org/

Thanks for the link. I hadn't looked at that before. Pretty scary stuff. I sure hope they're wrong.

I have no idea what the actual risk is to our datacentre of it being burned down, but it's pretty damn small. But we back up all our data and ship it off site every day. What are the odds of the IPCC being totally wrong, I would guess, at 1 in 5, 1 in 10? That's a significant risk, still.

There really is no way to estimate the probability of anyone being wrong or right. Remember that the history of science is a series of the majority being proven wrong. How do you calculate that? I wouldn't know or we'd be able to estimate when we're wrong about complex subjects.

As to the triggers and quantifying.... we aren't just talking about a single, specific system. The interactions and breadth of the scope (That is, the globe), make that impossible to nail down.

What do you want to quantify? There are, for practical purposes, an endless number of things to quantify. This is just one more piece of the jigsaw puzzle.

That's one of my points, AUP. Lots and lots of variables here. The thing I would most like to quantify is the temperature of the Earth so we could get a little more precise on this topic.

Another point is that risk assessment is mathematics-driven. You have to start with risk characterization and reduce the probable causes to effect X based on threshold values. Then you have to quantify the contributive factors. Once you're done that, you have to design a probabilistic mechanism to assess how close you get to effect X as you vary causes Y. Running that calculation over, say, 500 replications will give you a statistical result of whether or not causes Y of that magnitude will result in effect X at various confidence intervals. So, at this point, we can't even do risk assessment on GW causative factors. That's what worries me somewhat. Carbon dioxide seems like the likely culprit of AGW, is it exists, but what if someone guessed wrong? I'll leave you with that comforting thought.
 
I think they have been disregarded because even I can see that they can't be valid, when you compare them to Cape Grim and Mauna Loa. CO2 levels just don't behave like that.

I'm merely pointing out that, in science, you can't toss out data just because "it can't be right". As a matter of fact, we often learn something valuable from analyzing bad data because, and I'm not joking, it tells us how not to do something. IOW, how to avoid that particular mistake.

ETA: I thought of a great example of why we don't throw out data just because it looks bad. Kepler used observational data of planetary motion compiled by Tyco Brahe. After Brahe's death, Kepler noted that some of Brahe's observations actually had planets seemingly moving backwards (later known as retrograde motion). Kepler knew that Brahe was so anal about measurements that he accepted the data as fact even though it looked weird. Only one thing could really explain the phenomenon and that was a heliocentric Solar System. Once Kepler had that insight, the rest is history.
 
Last edited:
I can't believe that someone would still claim that the CO2 levels where jumping wildly just until we were measuring them accurately and consistently...
The cognitive dissonance is amazing.

As usual, misrepresenting things I've said. Go back and check.

The question isn't were CO2 levels wildly jumping around, but how accurately and on what basis can we know what they were. Based on that we could establish a range of what they might have been. It could be plus or minus 3 parts per million or plus or minus 300, I don't particularly care, but I would like to know the bounds.

Which you don't want to know, and think it is ridiculous that one might want to understand such a thing.
 
I'm merely pointing out that, in science, you can't toss out data just because "it can't be right". As a matter of fact, we often learn something valuable from analyzing bad data because, and I'm not joking, it tells us how not to do something. IOW, how to avoid that particular mistake.

We did learn something. If you are going to measure atmospheric CO2, make sure you do it in a remote place that won't be contaminated by human and other sources. Hence the setting up of Cape Grim and Mauna Loa.
 
And the 600 ppm readings in the 1940s in Antartica done by chemical means?

That's remote, hence the data should be considered....

Side note: Yes, I realize this sounds insane. Really, I do. But the logical part of me says you just can't throw it out without a reason.....

Hmm.....that nasty little problem of defining "outlier data...."
 
Jeez, fsol, I thought we were all alone in here. Thanks for chiming in. OK. Let's take a look at what Mr. Science wrote, shall we:

As I've indicated before, I've caught schniebster lying previously and this is basically the continuation thereof.
First of all, a technical inaccuracy that has zero effect on the outcome of the discussion looks like a nitpick to me. Note that whether the electron shell that absorbs the photon is the composite shell of the molecule or a shell of one of the atoms, the frequency of the absorbed photon will not be in the infrared; the energy level differences between the orbitals are too high. All such are in the visible or ultraviolet. It is, in other words, for this discussion, totally immaterial; which is pointed out in the post. A basic treatment is all that is required; discussion of the difference between the electron shells of the atoms and the composite electron shell of the molecule is footless if the effect under exposition is vibrational mode absorption and emission.

Making the claim that this is a "lie," therefore, is nothing but exactly the schoolyard crap I said it was in the first place; it's also pedantic, but that's not the point, is it, since this is being used to claim that the exposition is incorrect. It's a totally meaningless criticism, particularly considering that I deliberately avoided discussion of the matter in a post that was already quite long.

The view into the character of this individual is unmistakable. And not complimentary.

He lacks a well-rounded education in even quantum physics.
An unproven assertion. What this individual has proven is that s/he is more interested in personal revenge for being proven wrong earlier than in the facts of the matter, or the discussion underway, not to mention the understanding of anyone else reading the exposition.

Here he again reveals his complete ignorance of molecular orbital theory.
Molecular orbital theory is immaterial if the absorption/emission mode is vibrational.

What should be fairly obvious to anyone is that, in any molecule, the consituent atoms don't behave like they did when they were all alone. There is no such thing as the carbon or the oxygen in carbon dioxide absorbing a photon. The molecule absorbs a photon, not the atoms.
So what? Again, since the vibrational mode is involved, the absorption by an electron shell is immaterial to the discussion.

It's worth noting that the vibrational and rotational excitation modes can actually be described (and underneath, actually are) modes of excitation that also involve the molecular electron shells; pedantically, the difference is that the nuclei are also involved, and the vibrational modes, instead of exciting a single electron in one of the molecular shells excite the nuclei to move relative to one another. However, such an explanation is akin to discussing the motion of a pool ball on a pool table in terms of the motion of its component molecules. There is a much easier way to describe it, and that is the way I've chosen, since it is easier for the non-scientist to understand, and that lets more people follow the conversation; since this is a forum, rather than a private exchange, that seems more appropriate (not to mention polite) to me.

Obviously this individual doesn't care much about being polite, nor about whether others can easily understand what is being discussed without learning half of quantum mechanics. The motive here is plain for all to see. It does not involve accuracy, since the discussion is already sufficiently accurate to yield the most important term in the RTE.

Maybe he can be excused this faux-pas
I cannot begin to express my disdain for whether or not this individual excuses me.

as he's made it quite clear that he only believes in the First Law of Thermodynamics whereas this phenomenon has more to do with the Second Law. (I have hammered him on this before, to no avail.)
Yet another lie. This individual has not "hammered" me; instead, s/he has demonstrated lack of understanding of the nature and character of the 1LOT and 2LOT.

Hir arguments regarding thermodynamics show a deep misunderstanding of the character of the 2LOT. Photons do not lose energy in elastic scattering. The 2LOT applies to ensembles, not individual quantum events, which are what are under discussion here. If one applies the 2LOT to the ensemble of interactions of the infrared radiation leaving the Earth's surface as it passes through the atmosphere, it can only increase the greenhouse effect. Think about it; any energy lost by the photons in any of the inelastic scattering scenarios (quenching and pressure line broadening) MUST STAY IN THE ATMOSPHERE.

So much for the 2LOT.

This is the reason that carbon dioxide is different than carbon monoxide. (Per schniebster, they should both be the same as they both have carbon and oxygen, no? NO!) This is also the reason that table salt is not poisonous. Carbon dioxide is carbon dioxide is carbon dioxide. It is not carbon and oxygen any more than sugar is carbon and water.
Either a misrepresentation of what I said, or, less charitably interpreted, a lie. Again, it is immaterial how electron shell excitation modes work when the modes under discussion are vibrational, since the radiation under discussion is infrared.

So, I wanted schneibster to put his illucid description of how molecules act in schneib-world on Wiki so I could sit back and have some fun.
I have no idea whether it would have flown on Wikipedia; I wouldn't bother to put it there, since I didn't write it for there.

This point is more pedantic but this is yet another sentence written in crayon. I don't think it's accidental in that schneib seems to like to tell only half-truths. An electron does not need to jump to the next orbital. An electron can jump several orbitals or just plain leave the molecule altogether as long as the jump is not prohibited. Including that, of course, would weaken his IR begets IR fallacy.
Again, this mode is immaterial to infrared radiation, which excites molecules in the vibrational modes; no electrons are doing any jumping between orbitals in these modes. If it is even possible for a vibrationally excited molecule to be further excited and convert the vibrational excitation into orbital excitation (and I doubt it, but to be absolutely certain I'd have to go look it up) then there can be no question that it is a process that is extremely rare, at least at STP; all you need to do to figure that out is go outside and look up at the night sky. If this were a common process, then it would be lit up, since the orbital excitation modes involve visible light photons, which would be emitted by the CO2 in the atmosphere.

Yet again, a completely immaterial piece of information is dragged into the conversation in order to make the claim I "lied." Furthermore, the claim is made that this affects whether IR photons are emitted by CO2 atoms in vibrationally excited states or not with sufficient regularity to affect greenhouse warming, an obvious lie since anyone can go outside at night and look up and see that there are no visible light photons pouring down from the CO2 molecules in the atmosphere.

Other things he has posted that are fallacious are that quenching does not occur at room temperature (look up Liquid Scintillation Counting for one example)
A lie, since I never said it did not- in fact, I discussed it explicitly, and stated that it does happen at STP, just not very often.

and that the activity of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere can be predicted from laboratory testing which is done with primary reference standard materials (really, really pure stuff).
And yet another lie, since I spoke of how CO2 behaves in the lab, but never said anything about PURE CO2, and in fact never intended to.

Also, scattering does not have to be elastic.
And yet another lie, since I spoke of inelastic scattering with reference to quenching.

They guy's a gem of scientific illiteracy and it grates on me.
Speaking of scientific illiteracy, please tell us how the 2LOT applies to the scattering of a photon from a CO2 molecule.

For people who want to blindly follow the incomplete data set that currently comprises AGW "science", a fake scientist is better than no scientist at all.
Show where I ever claimed to be a scientist; you, on the other hand, have so claimed. So if there's a fake, I guess we know who it is.
 
Carbon dioxide seems like the likely culprit of AGW, is it exists, but what if someone guessed wrong? I'll leave you with that comforting thought.

If we are wrong, nothing really. Lomborg likes to put up a false dichotomy of we reduce CO2 emissions, or we help people deal with other problems, I don't see it that way. We end up using energy much more efficiently, which will save money, and reduce a lot of the sources of political tensions in the world, which costs a lot in terms of human misery.

If we are right, there is a lot that is going to go wrong.
 
And the 600 ppm readings in the 1940s in Antartica done by chemical means?

That's remote, hence the data should be considered....

Side note: Yes, I realize this sounds insane. Really, I do. But the logical part of me says you just can't throw it out without a reason.....

Hmm.....that nasty little problem of defining "outlier data...."

Another error due to contamination. You really think the global CO2 could jump up that high, then halve again in a matter of years?
 
If we are wrong, nothing really. Lomborg likes to put up a false dichotomy of we reduce CO2 emissions, or we help people deal with other problems, I don't see it that way. We end up using energy much more efficiently, which will save money, and reduce a lot of the sources of political tensions in the world, which costs a lot in terms of human misery.

If we are right, there is a lot that is going to go wrong.

I disagree with your first scenario. If AGW is occuring and humanity targets the wrong cause, AGW continues unabated. And, since no one has done the work necessary to detect AGW in progress, we're all screwed.
 
I disagree with your first scenario. If AGW is occuring and humanity targets the wrong cause, AGW continues unabated. And, since no one has done the work necessary to detect AGW in progress, we're all screwed.

You're wrong there, they are being criticised for doing so much research, it's a 'gravy train'.
 
You're wrong there, they are being criticised for doing so much research, it's a 'gravy train'.

I didn't mean there's now work going on. I meant that no one is working on a method do detect global warming in real time. All the detection right now is secondary and not direct.
 
I didn't mean there's now work going on. I meant that no one is working on a method do detect global warming in real time. All the detection right now is secondary and not direct.

The temperature is measured every day? I don't know what else you want, since any instantaneous measurement is going to statistically invalid, only trends can be used for serious statements.

There was a plan to put a satellite into orbit to directly measure the earth's albedo, but the Republicans killed that because it was AGW research, and they preferred to stick their fingers in their ears and say "I'm not listening".
 
Agreed. Although it is worth noting that CO2 research was very obscure in the 1950s, not exactly something that many people would have cared about.

What about now though? You've shown us Beck, in which he doesn't go into his data selection process at all (from memory) but seems to just think it's all good. We know there are reasons why we might consider the data to not be all good and he doesn't in my opinion address those concerns. If Callendar's work is that fragile, I would have thought that there would be more of a fuss about it from the (what are we meant to call them?) anti-AGWs?
 
The temperature is measured every day? I don't know what else you want, since any instantaneous measurement is going to statistically invalid, only trends can be used for serious statements.

There was a plan to put a satellite into orbit to directly measure the earth's albedo, but the Republicans killed that because it was AGW research, and they preferred to stick their fingers in their ears and say "I'm not listening".

Thanks, AUP, I sit corrected. These efforts would indeed result in real-time assessment tools over time. I would favor the satellite over a synthesized global temperature from separate endpoints because surface-based methods could be changed more readily than a space-borne spectroscopic method. I just hope that the commitment would be there to replace said satellite when needed.

I agree that the GOP is very, very distrustful of anything associated in any way with the UN. Politicized science is worse than no science at all.
 
Thanks, AUP, I sit corrected. These efforts would indeed result in real-time assessment tools over time. I would favor the satellite over a synthesized global temperature from separate endpoints because surface-based methods could be changed more readily than a space-borne spectroscopic method. I just hope that the commitment would be there to replace said satellite when needed.

I agree that the GOP is very, very distrustful of anything associated in any way with the UN. Politicized science is worse than no science at all.

It seems obvious to me that any space based observation of "global warming" would not just focus on the sunlit, day side of the planet.

In fact, that could not accomplish the goal, could it?Isn't a geosynchronous orbit required?
 
It seems obvious to me that any space based observation of "global warming" would not just focus on the sunlit, day side of the planet.

In fact, that could not accomplish the goal, could it?Isn't a geosynchronous orbit required?

You're right. You would only want to associate with The Dark Side. (BWAHAHAHA!!)

The ideal placement would be one where the satellite would always be in line with an imaginary radius drawn from the Sun to the Earth. (There's probably an astronomical term for that but what do "they" know?) Otherwise, you could have it geosynchronous such that you're measuring the same spot all the time but you would only open the shutter when it was in darkness.

Interesting question though. Given a satellite-borne measurement device, would it be more accurate to measure the same scene over time or to meeasure various places and average them? I think it would depend on whether you wanted an absolute value or a consistent index measurement. Where is Phil Plaitt when you need him?
 
You're right. You would only want to associate with The Dark Side. (BWAHAHAHA!!)

The ideal placement would be one where the satellite would always be in line with an imaginary radius drawn from the Sun to the Earth. (There's probably an astronomical term for that but what do "they" know?) Otherwise, you could have it geosynchronous such that you're measuring the same spot all the time but you would only open the shutter when it was in darkness.

Interesting question though. Given a satellite-borne measurement device, would it be more accurate to measure the same scene over time or to meeasure various places and average them? I think it would depend on whether you wanted an absolute value or a consistent index measurement. Where is Phil Plaitt when you need him?

One must measure the rates of temp increases and decreases.
Increases = daytime
Decreases (emissions) = both day and night time.
Or if you wish, albedo, including the subtle changes, over a 24 hour period.

I'm surprised there is nothing in the sky that could be put to this task.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom