Actually methane is much worse than CO2 as a greenhouse gas. linkMethane is also hard to control, but it's not as powerful as CO2.
Actually methane is much worse than CO2 as a greenhouse gas. linkMethane is also hard to control, but it's not as powerful as CO2.
You're correct in absolute terms, the point I was trying to make (and made a bad job of) is that it's a less powerful forcing because it's present in the atmosphere at a much lower concentration.Actually methane is much worse than CO2 as a greenhouse gas. link
Thanks, casebro, I had forgotten foam insulation. I was thinking of fiberglass blankets and the like. These products depend on trapped gases for insulating power because gases are such poor conductors of heat.
However, the claim here is that cabon dioxide has an unusually potent characteristic in that it will very efficiently reradiate heat. Radiate it so efficiently that, at even double the concentration (approaching 600 ppmv), the planet would rise significantly in temperature. Well, if it will do that at that concentration, could you imagine what it would do for home insulation if you blanketed a home with 100% carbon dioxide with one side of the layer comprised of a very efficent IR reflector? To keep heat out of something, you'd have to make the reflective side the inner side. We may even be able to "heat" real greenhouses with dry ice.
I'd like to know in exact terms what this claim means. Is this a pure ratio, that is, there is a claim here that climate models are being used that parameterize the absorption of infrared photons 90% of the time by individual CO2 molecules when they pass them? Or only IR photons that are of the correct frequency? Is this a claim that the models say that 90% of the time, somewhere in the atmosphere between the time the IR photons are emitted by the Earth and the time they would otherwise have reached space, these IR photons are absorbed? Or is it only photons that are of the correct frequency to interact with CO2 in the bending or asymmetric stretching mode? Or is this 0.9 supposed to have some units attached to it, to indicate under precisely what circumstances this occurs? Which model specifically, and where is this published?For example, many AGW authors consider the absorptive power of CD is 0.9, when the charts, tables, etc. obtained by observation-experimentation indicate that the absorptivity of CD, at its current concentration in the atmosphere, is 0.0009, that is 0.00002 lesser power than the emissivity of CD.
I have no idea what this means. The interaction of CO2 with IR photons is well documented and well understood. A photon of the correct frequency to interact with a CO2 molecule strikes such a molecule. If its phase is correct with respect to the orientation of the molecule at that moment of encounter to interact with that molecule and excite it in either of the bending modes, or the asymmetric stretching mode, depending on the frequency of the photon, then it does so and is absorbed; if the phase is wrong, then it just keeps going.By that reason, CD cannot store exceeding energy for too long periods. Consider that CD is not a blackbody, but a real body and that many “constants” have not a clear origin, suggesting that those ciphers were invented intentionally to fit perfectly in something.
These are references on the mechanics of heat transfer. No references to support claims about what climate scientists are saying are presented. In addition, since extinction is at issue, satellite measurements of surface and atmospheric temperature, and direct measurements with thermometers or thermocouples, as well as satellite measurements of the IR spectrum and extinction measurements from balloons and towers, would be necessary to establish what's happening beyond a doubt. Theory is all well and good, but what is needed (and as far as I know it's available- references that provide such information have been linked in this thread) is empirical data on the extinction ratio.# 113 John V.,Those numbers seem incredible — the models are wrong by 10000x? I’d like to read more. Do you have a reference?Response from Nasil-
Yes, reality looks incredible; models looks credible. Do you like books? References: Pitts, Donald and Sissom, Leighton. Heat Transfer. 1998. McGraw-Hill. Pp. 289-325.
Modest, Michael F. Radiative Heat Transfer. 2003. Elsevier Science. San Diego California.
Manrique, José Ángel V. Transferencia de Calor. 2002. Oxford University Press. England.
Bakken, G. S., Gates, D. M., Strunk, Thomas H. and Kleiber, Max. Linearized Heat Transfer Relations in Biology. Science. Vol. 183; pp. 976-978. 8 March 1974.
Finally, the mother of all analogous continuums:
Hottel, H. C. Heat Transmission. 1959. McGraw-Hill. New York.
Comments?
1. The assertion that the planet is warming without a mechanism to define a value for the temperature of the planet.
2. The assumption that the causative agent is carbon dioxide, given that it's the only IR-active gas in sufficient concentrations to cause the effect. That's a circular argument.
Those are the two biggies. Others have more to do with the seemingly haphazard conduct of the science.
That statement cuts both ways.
When a theoretician lacks a mechanism that does not make the theory wrong.
Most hypotheses begin without establishing a mechamism of cause.
For example, Darwin had absolutely no explanation as to how an organism evolved, only that it did.
I would argue that, without clear evidence that a certain factor is behind the broadening of the probability curve, it should be left unstated.
I am not completely sure, but I have seen no reason to assume that carbon dioxide is the driver behind GW. The assumption that carbon dioxide is the driver is necessary only if you want to turn GW into AGW. And, frankly, its unsupported.
No, sorry. Again the circularity rears its ugly head.
In your statement, you are assuming that the biological uses of carbon dioxide have anything to do with raising the temperature of the planet.
And, you have stated the assumption very well in your last sentence. Except that it may not be the only viable candidate. It is the only obvious candidate if you want to assume AGW.
Actually methane is much worse than CO2 as a greenhouse gas. link
I have no idea what this means.
I went to the link and it's not convincing because it begins with a statement that the belief that carbon dioxide is the driver is based on atmospheric models. I'm not convinced because, as we've seen before, even the IPCC admits that none of the models are validated yet.
However, I did find a link in the Q&A to here where the equations used to calculate forcing are listed. I noticed that carbon dioxide is the only gas that has a non-linear equation to its forcing although I don't know why that would be. No explanation is given. However, it's a permutation of Beer's Law where the Absorbance of material in solution (a gaseous solution, in this case) is given by the log of the ratio of initial light flux to the emerging power flux. I noticed, however, that the terms are reversed, maybe to indicate emission but that would not explain the alpha constant at 5.35. That means that carbon dioxide forces 5.35 J for every 1 J reradiated? I find that fairly difficult to believe, mainly because of the First Law which has been discussed in this thread ad nauseam.
From...http://www.biocab.org/Emissivity_CO2.html
Link below details committee decision on 5.35.
[FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]the value for the total emittancy (€) given by some authors from the IPCC -5.35 W/m^2- is not the actual value, but an adaptation to make the numbers agree with pre-assumed and subjective numbers. The IPCC team of experts has changed the radiative forcing so many times that the IPCC team have had to [/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]admit publicly the fact that the numbers are not real[/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif].[/FONT]
Framing, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.
The approach of extinction toward saturation is not linear, and the reason should be obvious if you look at the logarithm in Beer's Law. If you use the transmissivity form,However, I did find a link in the Q&A to here where the equations used to calculate forcing are listed. I noticed that carbon dioxide is the only gas that has a non-linear equation to its forcing although I don't know why that would be. No explanation is given.
Alpha is a proportionality constant, since the ordinary output of Beer's Law is a pure ratio, to convert it to watts per square meter, as is indicated in the chart in the reference you gave. The logarithm of the ratio of the current concentration of CO2 to the "unperturbed" (see the footnotes) concentration must be a pure ratio, but the desired output must give the radiative forcing in power per area and is therefore not dimensionless; the constant of proportionality must therefore be multiplied by the ratio given by Beer's Law to yield the amount of radiative forcing expected for the current concentration of CO2.However, it's a permutation of Beer's Law where the Absorbance of material in solution (a gaseous solution, in this case) is given by the log of the ratio of initial light flux to the emerging power flux. I noticed, however, that the terms are reversed, maybe to indicate emission but that would not explain the alpha constant at 5.35. That means that carbon dioxide forces 5.35 J for every 1 J reradiated? I find that fairly difficult to believe, mainly because of the First Law which has been discussed in this thread ad nauseam.
Alpha is a proportionality constant, since the ordinary output of Beer's Law is a pure ratio, to convert it to watts per square meter, as is indicated in the chart in the reference you gave. The logarithm of the ratio of the current concentration of CO2 to the "unperturbed" (see the footnotes) concentration must be a pure ratio, but the desired output must give the radiative forcing in power per area and is therefore not dimensionless; the constant of proportionality must therefore be multiplied by the ratio given by Beer's Law to yield the amount of radiative forcing expected for the current concentration of CO2.
Originally Posted by mhazeFraming, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.
From...http://www.biocab.org/Emissivity_CO2.html
Link below details committee decision on 5.35.
[FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]the value for the total emittancy (€) given by some authors from the IPCC -5.35 W/m^2- is not the actual value, but an adaptation to make the numbers agree with pre-assumed and subjective numbers. The IPCC team of experts has changed the radiative forcing so many times that the IPCC team have had to [/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]admit publicly the fact that the numbers are not real[/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif].[/FONT]
Framing, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.
This is quite possibly the stupidest thing I've ever seen you say. What do you mean, "made up number?" Watts are a made up number; so are meters. Do you imagine that there's some absolute scale of units that we DON'T "make up?" What, maybe Jebus appeared in a burning test tube and gave them to the First Sciencetist or something?So you agree, alpha is basically just a made up number.

So you agree, alpha is basically just a made up number.
Now, now, no scienciness ad argumentum attacks. We'll just evaluate it dispassionately for truthiness.
Agreed. Although it is worth noting that CO2 research was very obscure in the 1950s, not exactly something that many people would have cared about.