Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Actually methane is much worse than CO2 as a greenhouse gas. link
You're correct in absolute terms, the point I was trying to make (and made a bad job of) is that it's a less powerful forcing because it's present in the atmosphere at a much lower concentration.
 
Thanks, casebro, I had forgotten foam insulation. I was thinking of fiberglass blankets and the like. These products depend on trapped gases for insulating power because gases are such poor conductors of heat.

However, the claim here is that cabon dioxide has an unusually potent characteristic in that it will very efficiently reradiate heat. Radiate it so efficiently that, at even double the concentration (approaching 600 ppmv), the planet would rise significantly in temperature. Well, if it will do that at that concentration, could you imagine what it would do for home insulation if you blanketed a home with 100% carbon dioxide with one side of the layer comprised of a very efficent IR reflector? To keep heat out of something, you'd have to make the reflective side the inner side. We may even be able to "heat" real greenhouses with dry ice.

As a partial explanation of the vast difference in opinion on the subject of the potency of CO2, I am reprinting these two blog posts from Climateaudit here. My intent is to show that the differences seem to exist in the literature itself. Then, people reading one side or the other of the literature, promulgate divergent views of reality (apparently).

Both are very credible and intelligent individuals. Bold is mine. CD = carbon dioxide.

Nasif Nahle says: October 21st, 2007 at 10:33 pm
John V.,
I could not say that the “errors” in the models are intentional or not. However, things go straight and extremely simple: Some AGW supporters are modeling a relation CD-Tropospheric Temperature introducing unreal ciphers to their models. For example, many AGW authors consider the absorptive power of CD is 0.9, when the charts, tables, etc. obtained by observation-experimentation indicate that the absorptivity of CD, at its current concentration in the atmosphere, is 0.0009, that is 0.00002 lesser power than the emissivity of CD. By that reason, CD cannot store exceeding energy for too long periods. Consider that CD is not a blackbody, but a real body and that many “constants” have not a clear origin, suggesting that those ciphers were invented intentionally to fit perfectly in something.

# 113 John V.,
Those numbers seem incredible — the models are wrong by 10000x? I’d like to read more. Do you have a reference?
​
Response from Nasil-

Yes, reality looks incredible; models looks credible. Do you like books? References: Pitts, Donald and Sissom, Leighton. Heat Transfer. 1998. McGraw-Hill. Pp. 289-325.
Modest, Michael F. Radiative Heat Transfer. 2003. Elsevier Science. San Diego California.
Manrique, José Ángel V. Transferencia de Calor. 2002. Oxford University Press. England.
Bakken, G. S., Gates, D. M., Strunk, Thomas H. and Kleiber, Max. Linearized Heat Transfer Relations in Biology. Science. Vol. 183; pp. 976-978. 8 March 1974.
Finally, the mother of all analogous continuums:
Hottel, H. C. Heat Transmission. 1959. McGraw-Hill. New York.

Comments?
 
For example, many AGW authors consider the absorptive power of CD is 0.9, when the charts, tables, etc. obtained by observation-experimentation indicate that the absorptivity of CD, at its current concentration in the atmosphere, is 0.0009, that is 0.00002 lesser power than the emissivity of CD.
I'd like to know in exact terms what this claim means. Is this a pure ratio, that is, there is a claim here that climate models are being used that parameterize the absorption of infrared photons 90% of the time by individual CO2 molecules when they pass them? Or only IR photons that are of the correct frequency? Is this a claim that the models say that 90% of the time, somewhere in the atmosphere between the time the IR photons are emitted by the Earth and the time they would otherwise have reached space, these IR photons are absorbed? Or is it only photons that are of the correct frequency to interact with CO2 in the bending or asymmetric stretching mode? Or is this 0.9 supposed to have some units attached to it, to indicate under precisely what circumstances this occurs? Which model specifically, and where is this published?

By that reason, CD cannot store exceeding energy for too long periods. Consider that CD is not a blackbody, but a real body and that many “constants” have not a clear origin, suggesting that those ciphers were invented intentionally to fit perfectly in something.
I have no idea what this means. The interaction of CO2 with IR photons is well documented and well understood. A photon of the correct frequency to interact with a CO2 molecule strikes such a molecule. If its phase is correct with respect to the orientation of the molecule at that moment of encounter to interact with that molecule and excite it in either of the bending modes, or the asymmetric stretching mode, depending on the frequency of the photon, then it does so and is absorbed; if the phase is wrong, then it just keeps going.

Clearly, since the CO2 molecule can be in many orientations that will not interact with the photon no matter its phase, and only a few that will, and even if it is, the phase must not be crossing zero, there can be nothing like a 90% probability; I'd be surprised if it were as high as 1%. 90% would be a ridiculous claim. However, if there is CO2 in the atmosphere, it's likely that such a photon will encounter more than one, most likely more than a thousand, since it will go by trillions of molecules of the various gases in the atmosphere. Even with a very low probability of interaction in any one encounter, the law of large numbers means that there is a significant probability of interaction over many encounters. And that probability will increase with the concentration of the CO2, since an increased concentration will mean that more CO2 molecules will be encountered.

What that has to do with black body radiation or absorption I have no idea; it sounds to me like someone has confused the use of black body radiation from the Earth to determine the radiation peak frequency, with absorption by CO2. What that has to do with "storing" energy, which in terms of atmospheric temperature is a matter not of molecular excitation, but of average molecular kinetic energy, I also have no idea. Since the "constants" spoken of are not specified, I have no idea what they refer to either. Overall, this doesn't seem to have a great deal to do with anything that anyone who is making climate models is claiming, unless the 90% figure (assuming it's dimensionless- a very large assumption) is what the poster claims that climate models use for the probability that an IR photon of the correct frequency will fail to escape to space. That might be a correct assertion, but I'd want to see satellite data to evaluate the spectral extinction for the bending mode frequency, and input parameters to the model to see if that's the value that's being used in them. I've seen some spectrograms that might be interpretable that way.

Given the level of confusion here, I suspect that the poster has had some language difficulty in evaluating the claims being made in the literature, and some further language difficulty in expressing hirself as to the problems s/he sees with those claims.

# 113 John V.,
Those numbers seem incredible — the models are wrong by 10000x? I’d like to read more. Do you have a reference?
​
Response from Nasil-

Yes, reality looks incredible; models looks credible. Do you like books? References: Pitts, Donald and Sissom, Leighton. Heat Transfer. 1998. McGraw-Hill. Pp. 289-325.
Modest, Michael F. Radiative Heat Transfer. 2003. Elsevier Science. San Diego California.
Manrique, José Ángel V. Transferencia de Calor. 2002. Oxford University Press. England.
Bakken, G. S., Gates, D. M., Strunk, Thomas H. and Kleiber, Max. Linearized Heat Transfer Relations in Biology. Science. Vol. 183; pp. 976-978. 8 March 1974.
Finally, the mother of all analogous continuums:
Hottel, H. C. Heat Transmission. 1959. McGraw-Hill. New York.

Comments?
These are references on the mechanics of heat transfer. No references to support claims about what climate scientists are saying are presented. In addition, since extinction is at issue, satellite measurements of surface and atmospheric temperature, and direct measurements with thermometers or thermocouples, as well as satellite measurements of the IR spectrum and extinction measurements from balloons and towers, would be necessary to establish what's happening beyond a doubt. Theory is all well and good, but what is needed (and as far as I know it's available- references that provide such information have been linked in this thread) is empirical data on the extinction ratio.

Given that we have satellites that are known to be collecting such data, and given that we have towers and balloons that have measured both temperature and IR, why would anyone assume that this is not a well-known parameter, and how could anyone escape detection if they tried to falsify it?

This is the sort of thing that I find non-credible, and a good overview of my reasons for finding it so. I suppose someone could go check what the extinction ratio has been measured to be, and what the climate models are using, but it seems like a waste of time since the goal is to produce predictive climate models, and using incorrect parameters isn't going to achieve that goal, which will make the climate scientist who publishes results from the model look like an idiot. One rather likes one's output to have the real measurements within its error bars. If references can be produced that show that the extinction ratio is not 90%, AND that 90% is being used in climate models (or that the correct ratio is something else, and that isn't being used), then we have something to go on. Otherwise, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and there is none.
 
1. The assertion that the planet is warming without a mechanism to define a value for the temperature of the planet.

There's consistent convention being used that involves temperatures at points averaged across all points. No points are favoured over others. The result is consistent - whatever it actually means as a temperature - and can be used to present a time-series. That's been done for some time now, and the evidence is that the world is warming.

2. The assumption that the causative agent is carbon dioxide, given that it's the only IR-active gas in sufficient concentrations to cause the effect. That's a circular argument.

The argument starts from the fact that CO2 is a greenhouse gas ("IR-active" in your parlance). Increasing its concentration by a third is a significant change, so unless it was already a saturated greenhouse gas (which it isn't even yet) its greenhouse influence will increase significantly. That can be calculated within very close bounds. The amplification by positive feedbacks cannot be so accurately calculated, but they'll be there - water-vapour if nothing else. (A warmer atmosphere is a wetter atmosphere, given all that ocean surface to feed from.)

Remember that the recent and continuing warming trend was predicted by the science behind greenhouse warming. Science predicts that it will continue simply because of AGW - short of an asteroid-strike or nuclear war. That's by a linear argument.

There's a much more retrograde nature to the contrarian camp, which has been faced with explaining the warming after the event. Twenty years ago they were happily encamped in the distant past and speculation about the number of sunny Medieval days there were, but this stuff is real and right now. It's so much easier to sell "it won't happen" than "OK, it happened, but for another reason. Which we'll get bcak to you on".

Those are the two biggies. Others have more to do with the seemingly haphazard conduct of the science.

I don't doubt the conduct has been so presented to you, but it's not so. Science is anything but haphazard. It could not possibly have made the fantastic progress it has over the last few centuries if it was.



That statement cuts both ways.

Well, at least it's not circular. Nor does it really cut both ways.

When a theoretician lacks a mechanism that does not make the theory wrong.

Indeed not, but lacking both a mechanism and a reason why another well-established and understood mechanism isn't acting really does put you out on the fringe. The normal approach is to examine the consensus, find it wanting for some reason, find an alternative, then present both findings.

Most hypotheses begin without establishing a mechamism of cause.

See above. The hypothesis we're discussing is introduced where there's already a scientifically well-supported mechanism. Unlike, say, Continental Drift.

For example, Darwin had absolutely no explanation as to how an organism evolved, only that it did.

Of course he did, it's in the title. The mechanism is Natural Selection. There was already established backing for the evolution of species as a hypothesis to explain observations before Darwin's time. Erasmus Darwin was prominent in the field. Darwin's contribution was towards identifying and providing support for a mechanism. Variation and Natural Selection. He didn't present a mechanism for the variation, but it was the observed variation that prompted the question in the first place.

I would argue that, without clear evidence that a certain factor is behind the broadening of the probability curve, it should be left unstated.

See how it's not cutting both ways? Sorry, but this is gibberish.

I am not completely sure, but I have seen no reason to assume that carbon dioxide is the driver behind GW. The assumption that carbon dioxide is the driver is necessary only if you want to turn GW into AGW. And, frankly, its unsupported.

I suspect you're looking for a reason to believe that AGW isn't true, and you'll always be more comfortable with reasons to believe it's not happening.

No, sorry. Again the circularity rears its ugly head.

Lopped off earlier.

In your statement, you are assuming that the biological uses of carbon dioxide have anything to do with raising the temperature of the planet.

No I wasn't. I was responding to your "it's a very small number and therefore insignificant" point - as did a_unique_person before me.


And, you have stated the assumption very well in your last sentence. Except that it may not be the only viable candidate. It is the only obvious candidate if you want to assume AGW.

Where's left for a viable candidate to hide? You should check out the satellites up there, they're watching everywhere. Clouds, CO2, temperatures, the cryosphere, the Sun. Down on Planet Earth cosmic rays are being measured - since the 50's, and no noticeable trend. Where's the viable theory hiding that explains why a third more CO2 wouldn't warm the planet, let alone another that explains why it is warming very much along the predicted lines? There's been no lack of effort put into conjuring them up. Yet they're nowhere to be seen.

AGW really is the only viable candidate. I'm convinced, and I'm nobody's fool. Ask anybody. I also hate to be wrong, and hope to live long enough that I could be proved wrong on this. But this limb I go out on for no better reason than to defend Science and its reputation.
 
Now, now, no scienciness ad argumentum attacks. We'll just evaluate it dispassionately for truthiness.
 
I went to the link and it's not convincing because it begins with a statement that the belief that carbon dioxide is the driver is based on atmospheric models. I'm not convinced because, as we've seen before, even the IPCC admits that none of the models are validated yet.

However, I did find a link in the Q&A to here where the equations used to calculate forcing are listed. I noticed that carbon dioxide is the only gas that has a non-linear equation to its forcing although I don't know why that would be. No explanation is given. However, it's a permutation of Beer's Law where the Absorbance of material in solution (a gaseous solution, in this case) is given by the log of the ratio of initial light flux to the emerging power flux. I noticed, however, that the terms are reversed, maybe to indicate emission but that would not explain the alpha constant at 5.35. That means that carbon dioxide forces 5.35 J for every 1 J reradiated? I find that fairly difficult to believe, mainly because of the First Law which has been discussed in this thread ad nauseam.

From...http://www.biocab.org/Emissivity_CO2.html

Link below details committee decision on 5.35.

[FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]the value for the total emittancy (€) given by some authors from the IPCC -5.35 W/m^2- is not the actual value, but an adaptation to make the numbers agree with pre-assumed and subjective numbers. The IPCC team of experts has changed the radiative forcing so many times that the IPCC team have had to [/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]admit publicly the fact that the numbers are not real[/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif].[/FONT]
 
From...http://www.biocab.org/Emissivity_CO2.html

Link below details committee decision on 5.35.

[FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]the value for the total emittancy (€) given by some authors from the IPCC -5.35 W/m^2- is not the actual value, but an adaptation to make the numbers agree with pre-assumed and subjective numbers. The IPCC team of experts has changed the radiative forcing so many times that the IPCC team have had to [/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]admit publicly the fact that the numbers are not real[/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif].[/FONT]

Framing, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.
 
Framing, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.

Framing???
 
However, I did find a link in the Q&A to here where the equations used to calculate forcing are listed. I noticed that carbon dioxide is the only gas that has a non-linear equation to its forcing although I don't know why that would be. No explanation is given.
The approach of extinction toward saturation is not linear, and the reason should be obvious if you look at the logarithm in Beer's Law. If you use the transmissivity form,

T = I/I0 = 10^-(alc)
Where,
T is the transmissivity, a pure ratio
I is the outgoing intensity
I0 is the incoming intensity
a is the coefficient of absorption
l is the length of the optical path
and
c is the concentration of the material under analysis.

Obviously, the concentration increases the absolute value of the exponent, which decreases the value of the transmissivity toward zero logarithmically, never reaching it. This is, therefore, a non-linear expression.

However, it's a permutation of Beer's Law where the Absorbance of material in solution (a gaseous solution, in this case) is given by the log of the ratio of initial light flux to the emerging power flux. I noticed, however, that the terms are reversed, maybe to indicate emission but that would not explain the alpha constant at 5.35. That means that carbon dioxide forces 5.35 J for every 1 J reradiated? I find that fairly difficult to believe, mainly because of the First Law which has been discussed in this thread ad nauseam.
Alpha is a proportionality constant, since the ordinary output of Beer's Law is a pure ratio, to convert it to watts per square meter, as is indicated in the chart in the reference you gave. The logarithm of the ratio of the current concentration of CO2 to the "unperturbed" (see the footnotes) concentration must be a pure ratio, but the desired output must give the radiative forcing in power per area and is therefore not dimensionless; the constant of proportionality must therefore be multiplied by the ratio given by Beer's Law to yield the amount of radiative forcing expected for the current concentration of CO2.

As far as the terms being reversed, what are you talking about? Which terms are reversed from what?
 
Last edited:
Alpha is a proportionality constant, since the ordinary output of Beer's Law is a pure ratio, to convert it to watts per square meter, as is indicated in the chart in the reference you gave. The logarithm of the ratio of the current concentration of CO2 to the "unperturbed" (see the footnotes) concentration must be a pure ratio, but the desired output must give the radiative forcing in power per area and is therefore not dimensionless; the constant of proportionality must therefore be multiplied by the ratio given by Beer's Law to yield the amount of radiative forcing expected for the current concentration of CO2.

So you agree, alpha is basically just a made up number.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
From...http://www.biocab.org/Emissivity_CO2.html

Link below details committee decision on 5.35.

[FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]the value for the total emittancy (€) given by some authors from the IPCC -5.35 W/m^2- is not the actual value, but an adaptation to make the numbers agree with pre-assumed and subjective numbers. The IPCC team of experts has changed the radiative forcing so many times that the IPCC team have had to [/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif]admit publicly the fact that the numbers are not real[/FONT][FONT=Georgia, Times, serif].[/FONT]
​
Framing, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.

Framing, what? "had to admit publicly". What a joke. The whole matter of climate sensitivity is, and always has been, and always will be, (until we get to that actual date somtime in the future), an estimate. *not real*. That's just an outright, fraudulent misrepresentation of the IPCC reports.

I see your point in terms of how things are phrased. Of course that works both ways. Is all AUP does on JREF framing? Most people would not like such an argument placed back on them.

But those issues do not seem important because the question is:
  • are the numbers right or not?
Ego, personality, and political spin is not part of the equation.
 
So you agree, alpha is basically just a made up number.
This is quite possibly the stupidest thing I've ever seen you say. What do you mean, "made up number?" Watts are a made up number; so are meters. Do you imagine that there's some absolute scale of units that we DON'T "make up?" What, maybe Jebus appeared in a burning test tube and gave them to the First Sciencetist or something? :boggled:

The data from which alpha was "made up" were collected here, among other similar places. Note that vibrational-mode transport was calculated from the thermal conductivity variation function with temperature; this is the data required to calculate the radiative efficiency of CO2. This work was done in 1975. Scientists do that kind of thing from time to time; it's called "experimenting." You might have heard of that somewhere or other.

As I've been telling you all along, if you imagine that we haven't done extensive investigation of the physical properties of most if not all of the simple gases in the laboratory long ago, you're insane. That paper is the proof of it. Did you think I just made up my claim? I can only say that this makes it clear how YOU proceed in an argument.

And I ask you again: do you actually suppose that CO2 somehow does something in the atmosphere that we haven't seen in the lab? You have GOT to be kidding. Scientists don't just make this stuff up, the way you do.
 
So you agree, alpha is basically just a made up number.

I am leaning in that direction. I was too tired to post last night but I did a lot of research on where that number came from. The conversion explanation is unlikely or that number would appear in the equations for all the other GH gases in that table.

The closest I got to an origin is that 5.35 is an average of coefficients assumed by climate models that presume AGW. If true, it's really dishonest. I was hoping that this number would have been determined empirically as it's not very difficult to do. Why in all get out is a simple measurement being modeled?

This is what I meant by getting at the assumptions. There are simply too many assumptions in the AGW models. That's not to say that they're wrong but your hypothesis is only as strong as its underlying facts and every single assumption weakens your case.

Beer's law is really, really simple and it needs no coefficients. If you want to insert a conversion factor, that's fine, but you have to use the same conversion factor for all GH gases, not just CD. So why is it missing as a term for all the other gases?

As far as a response, does anyone have direct measurments of CD emissivity that support this number? or the lack thereof for the other GH gases?

BTW, I saw a table during my research that confirms one of Schneibster's points. It appears that CD does indeed re-emit every photon it absorbs, making my guesses at possible inefficiencies incorrect. My sincerest apologies for that, Schneibster.
 
a, l, and c look like coefficients to me. There are simple forms of Beer's Law, specifically the transmissivity relation to the input and output intensity, but the derivation of the one used in the IPCC report section linked above is logarithmic, and that points to the optical form, which uses coefficients that must be empirically determined; the link I presented in my response to mhaze is to the abstract of a paper detailing empirical determination of the coefficient from which the alpha coefficient is determined.

ETA: the a coefficient is unique per compound, per temperature, per pressure, and per spectral line, and that's why it must be empirically determined. We have already discussed the reasons this must be so, which include spectral line spreading from Doppler and pressure effects, Lorentz spreading, and so forth. You can see therefore why there would need to be a separate coefficient for each gas. I also left out consideration of the fact that there are temperature and pressure gradients in the atmosphere, which would make this value be derived from an integral to express how these vary, and how the coefficient varies in turn.

All of that said, I am still hunting the exact derivation of this approximate expression for the radiative forcing; it appears to be linked to radiative efficiency (which is tied up in this coefficient), Beer's Law, the depth and density and temperature gradient in the atmosphere, and something else that I haven't identified yet. I'm probably going to wind up having to pay for some articles to see exactly how they're deriving these simplified expressions. I was disappointed not to find this information in the IPCC report.

You never answered what terms you thought were out of order.

Thanks for the apology, accepted and returned. I was nasty and I regret it. I'll try to be more polite from now on.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom