Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

a, l, and c look like coefficients to me.

Yeah, sloppy writing. I'm refering to the 5.35 factor where none has appeared before because BL is so damned simple. Of course, it would have to be introduced to convert transmittance to forcing power but, man, that's a huge factor, especially compared with the other factors that are being applied to the other GH gases but at first blush I took those factors to be emissivity corrections because they're all less than one.

ETA: the a coefficient is unique per compound, per temperature, per pressure, and per spectral line, and that's why it must be empirically determined.

Exactly what I'm saying. If the accusation that this number was derived from model predictions, that's pretty dishonest.

All of that said, I am still hunting the exact derivation of this approximate expression for the radiative forcing; it appears to be linked to radiative efficiency (which is tied up in this coefficient), Beer's Law, the depth and density and temperature gradient in the atmosphere, and something else that I haven't identified yet. I'm probably going to wind up having to pay for some articles to see exactly how they're deriving these simplified expressions. I was disappointed not to find this information in the IPCC report.

As AUP has pointed out, the IPCC report is greatly simplified. I haven't been able to find some info there that I consider critical. I already looked for this stuff.

You never answered what terms you thought were out of order.

The I and I(0) terms are reversed, ostensibly to yield an equation for emissivity, based on 100% efficiency. Beer's Law is for absorbance. No objections from me.
 
Exactly what I'm saying. If the accusation that this number was derived from model predictions, that's pretty dishonest.

Syntax aside, empirical is the very opposite of modelled. It means direct observation.

The "accusation" is apparently mhaze's that alpha is a made-up number. Where model predictions come into it is anybody's guess (given the syntax problem).
 
Syntax aside, empirical is the very opposite of modelled. It means direct observation.

The "accusation" is apparently mhaze's that alpha is a made-up number. Where model predictions come into it is anybody's guess (given the syntax problem).

I'm not sure that I made an "accusation", more just a simple observation.

Didn't think of it as any big deal, just the way some of these climate scientists operate - slug a value, make it fit. A practice that is not acceptable in accounting or engineering but is apparently acceptable in this general area. I think that's a fair way to put it. Yes, some might find it offensive to put it this way. I am sure there are politically correct was to nuance such a statement.

If Slimething has differing standards that are derived from the standards of his field, then he isn't going to be happy.

Behind the issue of "climate sensitivity", behind the issue of "CO2 absorption", behind the issue of "alpha", Warmer science-ists either -
  1. know how to estimate CO2's behavior in the atmosphere
  2. don't know how to estimate CO2's behavior in the atmosphere
 
Wrong. Have you heard of the idea of people doing research on climate without the entire thing being wrapped around the "Yes it's CO2"/"No it's not CO2" point of view?

Of course I have, Tsonas has done that. The problem is that contrarians are leaping on his work as something that is soooooooooo much about that, and all from the "No its not CO2" point of view. Which is unfair on Tsonas.

Schneibster, on the other hand, has been scrupulously fair to and about Tsonas and his work. It says what it says, which is interesting enough but just confirms that fluid dynamics is a real bitch. There's no shortage of empirical evidence, of course, but gathering it into some sort of order is next to impossible. From the other side. It's seriously fractal; at every scale it throws in something new.
 
Of course I have, Tsonas has done that. The problem is that contrarians are leaping on his work as something that is soooooooooo much about that, and all from the "No its not CO2" point of view. Which is unfair on Tsonas.

Schneibster, on the other hand, has been scrupulously fair to and about Tsonas and his work. It says what it says, which is interesting enough but just confirms that fluid dynamics is a real bitch. There's no shortage of empirical evidence, of course, but gathering it into some sort of order is next to impossible. From the other side. It's seriously fractal; at every scale it throws in something new.

Basically I agree, although in a larger sense, explaining the so called great climate shift of the 1970s is indeed pertinent to both pro and anti AGW advocates of various stripes. In that sense Tsonis is similar to Schwartz, where there are both superficial conclusions that can be reached (which may indeed seem to have some relevance to pro/anti AGW)

and then....there is what he's actually trying to get at.
 
I'm not sure that I made an "accusation", more just a simple observation.

I'm not sure what accusation Slimething was referring to. I remember you claiming that Schneibster had said alpha was just a made-up number. How you mined "So you agree ...?" out of his actual post is anybody's guess.

Didn't think of it as any big deal, just the way some of these climate scientists operate - slug a value, make it fit.

Isn't it a bitch when the people you rely on turn out to be inveterate liars? Thoroughly unreliable? Not a teat to turn to? I wouldn't want to face up to such a thing anymore than you do. Fortunately, I'll never have to.

So these climate scientists that have been doing that for a while now in this warming world - who are they? Just how lucky do you think they've been these last few decades, with their fabricated predictions before the event? Give us names, and stuff they made up. It's an issue that needs to be aired.
 
Yeah, sloppy writing.
It happens. No stress.

I'm refering to the 5.35 factor where none has appeared before because BL is so damned simple. Of course, it would have to be introduced to convert transmittance to forcing power but, man, that's a huge factor, especially compared with the other factors that are being applied to the other GH gases but at first blush I took those factors to be emissivity corrections because they're all less than one.
Well, actually, if you want to get into it, the standard BL is log10, the common logarithm; using the ln (for clarity: loge, the natural logarithm) means that they're deriving from the optical form. The optical form uses the same three coefficients, path length, optical depth, and concentration, but they have to be bumped by ln10, or about 2.3, to account for the different logarithm bases. But they aren't comparing intensities; they're comparing concentrations of CO2. So the C/C0 isn't the I/I0 of the BL, it's the relative concentration with reference to pre-industrial CO2 concentration. IOW, they're talking about the increase in forcing, not the absolute intensity. I think that accounts for the coefficient seeming so weird. Their choice of presentation tends to lead one erroneously to the idea that it's a direct derivation of the BL, which it's not.

Exactly what I'm saying. If the accusation that this number was derived from model predictions, that's pretty dishonest.
The GISS GCM radiative codes use a radiative transfer model that uses the HITRAN database for LBL (Line-By-Line) calculations of IR radiative transfer. This database is available on-line for download, for anyone to use in their radiative transfer code. The HITRAN database is used for a lot of science, much of which has little or nothing to do with climate, much less global warming. Some of the HITRAN data is measured, as in the paper I linked to earlier; some of it is calculated from the quantum mechanics of the molecules involved.

It's important to understand that HITRAN is a database of the spectroscopic properties of all the atomic and molecular elemental gases, and most if not all of the simpler compound gases. Just about any gas you're going to find in the atmosphere in any significant concentration (and by significant I mean measurable) has a complete set of spectral characteristics in it. Basically, it's the state of our total spectroscopic information for gases. Measurements are generally made using FTIRs, which is why they call it "Line-by-line" data.

So when we talk about the radiative transfer codes in any of the major climate models in use, we're just about always talking about a piece of software that does the calculations using HITRAN or a similar database, and these days, it's just about always HITRAN. And you can find literature of discussions that the people who develop these RT code segments have written, describing the various updates to HITRAN or whatever database they're using, and the addition of newly discovered radiative transfer details due to isotopic line widening, and on and on into the night.

Long story short, they're doing numerical simulation of radiative transfer from measurements and quantum mechanical calculations, not deriving it from their models by looking at the weather (or the climate).

As AUP has pointed out, the IPCC report is greatly simplified. I haven't been able to find some info there that I consider critical. I already looked for this stuff.
You didn't find it because it's considered part of the modeling software. The IPCC report is showing forcing numbers averaged across the whole atmosphere for the GHGs we're making; deriving that data from the HITRAN database is the job of the radiative codes.

The I and I(0) terms are reversed, ostensibly to yield an equation for emissivity, based on 100% efficiency. Beer's Law is for absorbance. No objections from me.
Cool.
 
Basically I agree, although in a larger sense, explaining the so called great climate shift of the 1970s is indeed pertinent to both pro and anti AGW advocates of various stripes. In that sense Tsonis is similar to Schwartz, where there are both superficial conclusions that can be reached (which may indeed seem to have some relevance to pro/anti AGW)

and then....there is what he's actually trying to get at.

Which would be what, in your opinion? What is it you're getting at here?

What I've been getting at regards the exploitation of Tsonas to muddy the waters enough to take refuge in. The "What about this, eh?" ploy. What, really, about it? Schneibster's taken a fair amount of trouble to read Tsonas's work and report on it. Are you doing any more than relaying what you heard about it? Filtered through a trusted source, obviously.
 
Which would be what, in your opinion? What is it you're getting at here?

What I've been getting at regards the exploitation of Tsonas to muddy the waters enough to take refuge in. The "What about this, eh?" ploy. What, really, about it? Schneibster's taken a fair amount of trouble to read Tsonas's work and report on it. Are you doing any more than relaying what you heard about it? Filtered through a trusted source, obviously.

Go back and look at my posts on Tsonas, you will find quite a bit.
 
This thread needs a climatologist... If only to can defend their science from the likes of us interested amateurs.




(For any climatologists that may be reading, this is your cue. The bat sign has been lit. Gotham needs you!... At least drop by and explain alpha.)
 
I'm SURE we're going to get into how radiative codes work, so here's the deal:

First, you've got spectroscopic characteristics measured at various temperatures and pressures and concentrations and so forth. Then, you've got to figure equations to describe how those characteristics vary in between the measured or first-principle calculated values. Then you have to make a model of how the parameters will change through the atmosphere, as the pressure and temperature and concentration change with altitude, so you're going to be using PDEs to describe that. Then you have to make a model of how the atmosphere looks from that, probably by defining homogenous layers rather than attempting to make a continuous function vary over another continuous function, so you can use numerical simulation to do it. Then you have to account for the fact that the Sun doesn't just sit up there in the middle of the sky, it moves, and as it does, various refractive indices change, and the path length through the various layers changes too. And finally, you have to put some feedback paths in there, so that the larger climate model can feed whatever variations in temperature and pressure and concentration back in, to get more accurate radiative calculations.

I've probably left a couple important things out; it would be interesting to see a flowchart of the architecture of the radiative codes to find out what I missed. But you certainly get the idea.

I think there's a vision of some geophysicist sitting in his lab somewhere crunching numbers on his PC. That's not what's going on here. What you've basically got is the scientific equivalent of a small software company generating this gigantic program. You've got little groups that get together and design and implement some part of it; the radiative codes, there's probably a fluid dynamics group doing the air movement modeling, another group doing clouds, another one doing ocean currents, another one for ocean heat transfer, and land heat transfer, and on and on like that. And the community is like a bunch of these small software companies, and the groups that do the various parts get together and discuss various pieces of how they model their little piece of the thing. Every so often, they get some time on the big computers to test their little piece; and every so ofteh, less often, the principal investigator, whoever's running the whole thing (like Hansen, or Mann, or someone like that), gets all of the software from all the groups together, and they all come sit around and get everything ready, and they run a simulation. Then the principal investigator takes the data output and goes off and analyzes it, probably with yet another group that specializes in the analysis, and then comes back and they have a big meeting and decide what new bells and whistles they're going to put in to make it a little bit more accurate the next time they run it, and they all go off and work on their piece of it some more, while the PI writes up the latest results and publishes a paper on it.

And they've been doing that now for about twenty or thirty years. So they've got a whole library of software they've written, and a bunch of specialists that know everything there is to know about their little section, and they're all reading papers all the time looking for some cool new thing someone found out about how things work so they can tell everybody about it at the next meeting and look good in front of their coworkers, and maybe their cool new thing will wind up in the next simulation or the one after that.

So when I see someone say something like, "Hey, Hansen is just lying about this," I kind of get the idea that they're not quite clear on the fact that there's like fifty or a hundred people all doing all this different stuff to make the model, and they know so much that there's no way Hansen could like, sneak something in there or anything, so they'd ALL have to be lying together and never make a mistake or someone would find out. Not only that, but there's a bunch of other groups out there doing the same thing, and if the results are way different, you're going to have a big controversy and whoever's right is gonna get the gravy and whoever's wrong is gonna get hosed. That's how science works.
 
This thread needs a climatologist... If only to can defend their science from the likes of us interested amateurs.
LOL, no doubt, I'm probably butchering their carefully crafted million-line simulation mercilessly.
 
This thread needs a climatologist... If only to can defend their science from the likes of us interested amateurs.




(For any climatologists that may be reading, this is your cue. The bat sign has been lit. Gotham needs you!... At least drop by and explain alpha.)

I know one, but he thinks debating such things as this on the internet is a waste of time. I might ask him again, since people seem to be genuinely interested in how things actually work, rather than just beating up on him for being a commie who wants to kill their babies and steal their money.
 
For anyone who is interested in the arcane science of climate models.

http://www.bom.gov.au/bmrc/basic/wksp18/papers/papers.shtml

[table="head"]Title of Paper :| Speaker| Filename| Size
Overview of ACCESS :| Kamal Puri | Puri.pdf| 246 K
The Hadley Centre climate model HadGEM1 :| V. Pope| Pope_HadGEM1.pdf| 1100 K
Towards Earth System Modeling: Bringing GFDL to life :| John Dunne| Dunne_ESM.pdf| 208 K
Overview of NWP in the Bureau, Nov 2006 :| William Bourke | Bourke.pdf| 613 K |
Parametrization of atmospheric processes in the Unified Model :| Roy Kershaw| Kershaw_Unified.pdf| 192 K
Challenges in parametrisation development and lessons for ACCESS :| Christian Jakob| Jakob.pdf | 171 K
Experience with UM/VAR at the South African Weather Service :| Warren Tennant | Tennant.pdf| 331 K
Progress in data assimilation including overview of Met Office 4D-Var :| Andrew Lorenc| Lorenc_DA.pdf| 213 K
Challenges in data assimilation and ACCESS plans :| Peter Steinle| Steinle.pdf| 151 K
The Bluelink Ocean Data Assimilation System :| Peter R. Oke and Gary B. Brassington| Oke.pdf| 338 K
Atmospheric data assimilation using the Ensemble Kalman Filter at BMRC :| Jeffrey D. Kepert, Xudong Sun and Peter J. Steinle| Kepert.pdf| 270 K
Mesoscale modelling at the Met Office :| Peter Clark and Roy Kershaw |Kershaw_Mesoscale.pdf| 886 K
Mesoscale modelling at the Bureau :| Gary Dietachmayer | Dietachmayer.pdf| 85 K
Tropical cyclone track and intensity prediction :| Noel Davidson, Harry Weber, Kevin Tory, Kamal Puri, Peter Steinle, Lawrie Rikus, Richard Dare, Chris Tingwell and Chi Mai Nguyen | Davidson.pdf| 552 K
Chemical transport modeling for air quality forecasting and policy development: linking to ACCESS :| Martin Cope, Sunhee Lee, Dale Hess and Peter Hurley | Cope.pdf| 144 K
Overview of terrestrial modelling :| A.J. Pitman| Pitman.pdf | 202 K
The CSIRO Atmosphere Biosphere Land Exchange Model and future development for ACCESS : |Yingping Wang, Eva Kowalczyk, Rachel Law and Gab Abramowitz | Wang.pdf| 205 K
POAMA – Seasonal prediction including ACCESS plans :| Oscar Alves and Harry Hendon|Alves.pdf | 304 K
Australian Community Ocean Model (AusCOM) : | Andreas Schiller, Oscar Alves, Gary Brassington, Nathan Bindoff, Jason Roberts and Petra Heil |Schiller.pdf| 30 K
The BLUElink> Project – towards marine forecasting :| Gary B. Brassington, Peter R. Oke, Tim Pugh and Graham Warren | Brassington.pdf| 439 K
Ensemble prediction at the Met Office :| Andrew Lorenc |Lorenc_Ensemble.pdf | 228 K
Proposed strategy for ensemble prediction in the Bureau of Meteorology. :| Beth Ebert, Christian Jakob, Peter Steinle and Kamal Puri |Ebert.pdf| 233 K
Coupled modelling within ACCESS: status and plans :| Anthony C. Hirst| Hirst.pdf| 20 K
A new approach to assessing climate model results for use in regional climate change projections :| P.H. Whetton, I. Macadam, J. Bathols and J. O’Grady| Whetton.pdf| 610 K
Regional climate modelling using CCAM :| John L. McGregor| McGregor.pdf | 1833 K
Statistical downscaling – an important part of ACCESS :| Bertrand Timbal | Timbal.pdf| 240 K
Earth Systems Modelling in the University sector, contributions to ACCESS :| N.L. Bindoff, Matthew England, Andy Pitman and Jason Roberts | Bindoff.pdf | 127 K
University expectations and contributions to ACCESS :| Michael Reeder and Amanda Lynch | Reeder_Lynch.pdf| 121 K
The PRISM software framework and the OASIS coupler :| Sophie Valcke, Reinhard Budich, Mick Carter, Eric Guilyardi, Marie-Alice Foujols, Michael Lautenschlager, René Redler, Lois Steenman-Clark and Nils Wedi | Valcke.pdf| 240 K
Overview of CCSM infrastructure – implications for ACCESS :| Anthony Craig| Craig.pdf| 105 K
Infrastructure development at GFDL: the Flexible Modeling System :| John Dunne | Dunne_FMS.pdf| 231 K
The Earth Simulator Project and beyond :| Wataru Ohfuchi| Ohfuchi.pdf| 819 K
The development of HadGEM2 :| V. Pope | Pope_HadGEM2.pdf | 297 K
HPCCC – Future plans in supercomputing :| Philip Tannenbaum| Tannenbaum.pdf| 103 K
The value of an integrated approach to climate applications modelling :| Roger C. Stone and Holger Meinke| Stone.pdf| 160 K
The BMRC-CSIRO Joint Research Centre :| Neville Smith and Chris Mitchell| Smith.pdf| 6622 K
[/table]
And I hope you all appreciate the time it took me to format this :cool:
 
Last edited:
Just to have something up here, here's the reference manual and program description for a pretty current version of the GISS GCM software. The name of the software is "ModelE." It contains six major modules:
  • the main module, which coordinates the data from the rest of the modules, controls their execution, and passes inputs out to them for analysis;
  • the atmospheric module, which takes care of cloud modeling, and contains the radiative transfer modules we've been talking about here, and the convection and dynamics modules, and some other important submodules;
  • the sea ice module;
  • the land surface module;
  • the ocean model;
  • tracers, which are almost certainly for following various parameters to see how they vary over time as the model evolves through a simulation;
  • diagnostics.
The majority, perhaps the entirety, of the program is written in FORTRAN. There are old modules written in FORTRAN66, and some new stuff in FORTRAN90 and FORTRAN95. You can find the reference manual here.
 
I know one, but he thinks debating such things as this on the internet is a waste of time. I might ask him again, since people seem to be genuinely interested in how things actually work, rather than just beating up on him for being a commie who wants to kill their babies and steal their money.


Please do ask. I'd be happy if just you report the answers as "personal communications", if he really doesn't want to bother with the moods and manners of internet forums.
 
Quote:
Didn't think of it as any big deal, just the way some of these climate scientists operate - slug a value, make it fit.

Isn't it a bitch when the people you rely on turn out to be inveterate liars? Thoroughly unreliable? Not a teat to turn to? I wouldn't want to face up to such a thing anymore than you do. Fortunately, I'll never have to.

So these climate scientists that have been doing that for a while now in this warming world - who are they? Just how lucky do you think they've been these last few decades, with their fabricated predictions before the event? Give us names, and stuff they made up. It's an issue that needs to be aired.

You may be over reacting. Certainly "people you rely on turn out to be inveterate liars" has no relation to my comments that I can make out. In fact, I am not even sure I know what you are talking about. There are differing standards in different fields of say, science, engineering and accounting.

Perhaps you may feel that my phraseology is a bit too blunt.
I'm not the one running around calling everyone liars, though.

And no, we are not going to derail the thread which has gotten quite interesting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom