Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

One must measure the rates of temp increases and decreases.
Increases = daytime
Decreases (emissions) = both day and night time.
Or if you wish, albedo, including the subtle changes, over a 24 hour period.

You've obviously put more thought into this than I have. Our imaginary satellite readings would be susceptible to whatever weather overlaid the area you're trying to measure. A cold snap or heat wave could throw off the measurement significantly. Unless the target area was right on the Equator, you'd get the seasonal interferences as well. Yikes!

I'm surprised there is nothing in the sky that could be put to this task.

Yeah, I figured with all the spy satellites and weather equipment hovering up there that getting these data wouldn't be all that difficult. I blame Lisa.
 
I thought they do use satellite readings. The satellite data doesn't show a current warming trend. I.E., we've already peaked, ca. 1997?

I think it may be more data that is disregarded as "not fitting the preconceived notion".

Whatever, I think one of those satellites that orbits in 90 minutes would be excellent at 'averaging' the whole globe. A recording infra-red sensor, and software to figure the 'area under the curve'. And another sensor pointed outward, to see how much the sun's radiation varies. Of course, that introduces yet another 'proxy' that we have no history to compare it to.
 
Last edited:
One must measure the rates of temp increases and decreases.
Increases = daytime
Decreases (emissions) = both day and night time.
Or if you wish, albedo, including the subtle changes, over a 24 hour period.

I'm surprised there is nothing in the sky that could be put to this task.
You might want to check out the AIRS program. It's the Atmospheric Infrared Sounder satellite, which takes about 325,000 images a day and circles the Earth twice in that time. It was launched in 2002. Its IR spectrometer separates the IR spectrum into about 2,400 channels; the resolution is 1-2km and it can detect temperature, water vapor content, most GWG concentrations, and so forth with an accuracy very close to that of a weather balloon and far greater coverage (as is obvious from the number of images it takes in a day).

I don't think you have a clear idea just how much data there is available. Check it out: http://www-airs.jpl.nasa.gov/Technology/Overview/
 
Or if you wish, albedo, including the subtle changes, over a 24 hour period.

I'm surprised there is nothing in the sky that could be put to this task.

There is one sitting on the ground, doing nothing, designed to measure Albedo. IIRC, Al Gore was a sponsor that project in Congress, so bloody minded politics put an end to that project.
 
That's a heck of a lot of reading. Could you summarize what Dr. Tsonis' operative theory is? From reading one of his papers, he seems to be going in the direction that global warming will evidence itself in a broadening of the standard deviation of maxima and minima, not the shifting of the probability curve toward the maximum, which is what most people fear. Is that correct?
 
Tsonis says climate is "Synchronized Chaos"...

That's a heck of a lot of reading. Could you summarize what Dr. Tsonis' operative theory is? From reading one of his papers, he seems to be going in the direction that global warming will evidence itself in a broadening of the standard deviation of maxima and minima, not the shifting of the probability curve toward the maximum, which is what most people fear. Is that correct?

In the paper you reference, he does go into the issue generally referred to as "GW will bring fewer but stronger hurricanes", from a mathematical perspective.

The paper about "Synchronized chaos" is perhaps more interesting. A primary issue for AGW is that (allegedly) solar and temperature diverge around 1970, and there may be "no other explanation" for the warming in recent decades other than co2 increases. Bad logic, but often heard.

For the first time, Tsonis has succeeded in putting together the major oceanic climate indices, including the 1970 climate shift, into a coherent theory. For a 100 year period, he uses the theory of "synchronized chaos" to predict the 1970 climate shift and other key events.

Tsonis simply tries to develop mathematical explanations of how natural phenomena behave. It would be incorrect to consider him as either pro or anti AGW.

http://www.worldclimatereport.com/index.php/2007/08/17/climate-change-chaos/
Tsonis et al. examined the statistical behavior of four major climate indices over the period 1910-2000 including the Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO), the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), the El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO), and the North Pacific Oscillation (NPO). They write “These indices represent regional but dominant modes of climate variability, with time scales ranging from months to decades. NAO and NPO are the leading modes of surface pressure variability in northern Atlantic and Pacific Oceans, respectively, the PDO is the leading mode of SST variability in the northern Pacific and ENSO is a major signal in the tropics. Together these four modes capture the essence of climate variability in the northern hemisphere.”

Tsonis et al. end their article noting that while “The standard explanation for the post 1970s warming is that the radiative effect of greenhouse gases overcame shortwave reflection effects due to aerosols,” their result “suggests an alternative hypothesis, namely that the climate shifted after the 1970s event to a different state of a warmer climate, which may be superimposed on an anthropogenic warming trend.”

The Tsonis et al. conclusions allow us all to speculate that some degree of post-1970s warming may have been in the cards with no greenhouse forcing whatsoever.​
 
Tsonas proposes teleconnections without a physical effect to support them. The teleconnections may turn out to be common causes- and if the cause is CO2, then we're back where we started: AGW. Remember that correlation need not imply causation; it may be a coincidence, or it may be common causes. Without a clear means for events in one place to affect events in another, this is nothing but speculation.
 
You might want to check out the AIRS program. It's the Atmospheric Infrared Sounder satellite, which takes about 325,000 images a day and circles the Earth twice in that time. It was launched in 2002. Its IR spectrometer separates the IR spectrum into about 2,400 channels; the resolution is 1-2km and it can detect temperature, water vapor content, most GWG concentrations, and so forth with an accuracy very close to that of a weather balloon and far greater coverage (as is obvious from the number of images it takes in a day).

Which, to a child of the 50's, is frickin' cool. I can actually remember the fuss made over Telstar. Damn, but I've lived in interesting times - and there's no sign of boring times ahead. Reality TV notwithstanding.
 
He would set up a recording system that he was very confident was free of local contamination, and see what results came up. Fortunately, someone has already done that.

Well, that's what scientists do. The Holy Grail of Science is to be right. In that pursuit they won't claim absolute confidence - unlike religion or ideology - because to do so would open them up to being wrong.

The elimination of extraneous and uncertain parameters in any observation or experiment lies at the heart of Science. Self-examination is the standing order of the day. The introduction of uncertain parameters - however fantastical - lies at the heart of anti-Science. As, of course, do religion and/or ideology.
 
There is one sitting on the ground, doing nothing, designed to measure Albedo. IIRC, Al Gore was a sponsor that project in Congress, so bloody minded politics put an end to that project.

I doubt that can be held entirely to Al Gore's account. IMO it's more to do with politicians trying to take on the mantle of JFK, and NASA swinging with the political wind - as ever. American International Space Station, American Moon-Base, American Mars-Landing - big words from small people, but NASA always reacts.
 
Tsonas proposes teleconnections without a physical effect to support them. The teleconnections may turn out to be common causes- and if the cause is CO2, then we're back where we started: AGW. Remember that correlation need not imply causation; it may be a coincidence, or it may be common causes. Without a clear means for events in one place to affect events in another, this is nothing but speculation.

Schneibster, this is one comment that I can fully support and it's the very message that I've been touting, derails aside. I haven't read Tsonas in depth but your statement fully supports my view that there are too many assumptions in the AGW hypothesis for it to be considered a closed case at this point in time. Is it fair to say that Tsonas has alit on an acceptable hypothesis but the mechanism is still in question?

Above, you have laid out exactly what has been bothering me about the entire issue of AGW and that is a wholesale assumption that, because carbon dioxide is the only viable candidate in the gas phase to make the hypothesis correct, that gas is chosen as the most probable cause despite its rarity in the atmosphere (at 300 - 600 ppmv, it's a difficult cause ot make for any single gas that its blanketing effect is efficient enough to heat up a massive system like the surface of the planet even one inch deep).

So, are we finally on the same page?
 
I thought they do use satellite readings. The satellite data doesn't show a current warming trend. I.E., we've already peaked, ca. 1997?

Is this an embellishment of the "cooling trend since 1998" thing? There's a distinct warming trend since 1997.

I think it may be more data that is disregarded as "not fitting the preconceived notion".

I think this is more to do with your preconceived notions than the satellite data.

Whatever, I think one of those satellites that orbits in 90 minutes would be excellent at 'averaging' the whole globe. A recording infra-red sensor, and software to figure the 'area under the curve'. And another sensor pointed outward, to see how much the sun's radiation varies.

It would be more sensible to have satellites dedicated to observing solar output and other satellites dedicated to observing global temperature. The former would best be non-orbiting (and so able to observe the Sun full-time) while the latter would best be orbiting(to get the big picture).

Of course, that introduces yet another 'proxy' that we have no history to compare it to.

Direct observation is not a proxy. Proxies are resorted to when direct observation is unavailable. Or when direct observations challenge preconceived beliefs that take precedence over reality - but that's not Science.
 
Above, you have laid out exactly what has been bothering me about the entire issue of AGW and that is a wholesale assumption that, because carbon dioxide is the only viable candidate in the gas phase to make the hypothesis correct, that gas is chosen as the most probable cause despite its rarity in the atmosphere (at 300 - 600 ppmv, it's a difficult cause ot make for any single gas that its blanketing effect is efficient enough to heat up a massive system like the surface of the planet even one inch deep).

So, are we finally on the same page?

Hang on, the rarity of a substance does not imply it's effect on a system. Don't forget, all those plants and trees around the world, they all get their carbon direct from CO2, even though it's only 300ppmv. Those trees are pretty damn solid.

The temperature rise we are talking about in Kelvin is only about 2%, and that's including feedback effects. So it's not actually changing the absolute temperature all that much. However, in biological terms, where systems become optimised to their environments due to evolution, it can be a significant change, especially when it happens relatively rapidly. It also has a significant effect on such physical elements as glaciers, permafrost and sea ice.
 
Tsonas proposes teleconnections without a physical effect to support them. The teleconnections may turn out to be common causes- and if the cause is CO2, then we're back where we started: AGW. Remember that correlation need not imply causation; it may be a coincidence, or it may be common causes. Without a clear means for events in one place to affect events in another, this is nothing but speculation.

True, if you are thinking of physical effect as a "nearly in time cause."

Large scale shifts such as he discusses would seem in the 20th century to not have CO2 as a cause although he notes there may have been some coincident CO2 effect.

If I am getting the general message.
 
Agreed. Although it is worth noting that CO2 research was very obscure in the 1950s, not exactly something that many people would have cared about.

That is indeed worth noting. The groundwork in CO2 research and the Greenhouse Effect was done long before it became a political issue.
 
Schneibster, this is one comment that I can fully support and it's the very message that I've been touting, derails aside. I haven't read Tsonas in depth but your statement fully supports my view that there are too many assumptions in the AGW hypothesis for it to be considered a closed case at this point in time. Is it fair to say that Tsonas has alit on an acceptable hypothesis but the mechanism is still in question?

What assumptions behind AGW bother you?

Tsonas doesn't only lack a mechanism to explain why the current warming is occurring, it also lacks an explanation for why increased CO2-load wouldn't cause warming despite the well-supported mechanism that AGW posits.

Above, you have laid out exactly what has been bothering me about the entire issue of AGW and that is a wholesale assumption that, because carbon dioxide is the only viable candidate in the gas phase to make the hypothesis correct, that gas is chosen as the most probable cause despite its rarity in the atmosphere (at 300 - 600 ppmv, it's a difficult cause ot make for any single gas that its blanketing effect is efficient enough to heat up a massive system like the surface of the planet even one inch deep).

a_unique_person nailed that point. If 280ppm of CO2 can drive the entire biosphere it's not easily dismissed as a "very small number". Despite its smallness, it is the only viable candidate to explain the current - and continuing - warming.
 
Hang on, the rarity of a substance does not imply it's effect on a system. Don't forget, all those plants and trees around the world, they all get their carbon direct from CO2, even though it's only 300ppmv. Those trees are pretty damn solid.

We are not discussing the quantity of total carbon on the planet. We're discussing how much is actually in gaseous form. Let's leave the biota out of it unless you have a point to make that the carbon in biota will also warm the planet.

The temperature rise we are talking about in Kelvin is only about 2%, and that's including feedback effects. So it's not actually changing the absolute temperature all that much. However, in biological terms, where systems become optimised to their environments due to evolution, it can be a significant change, especially when it happens relatively rapidly. It also has a significant effect on such physical elements as glaciers, permafrost and sea ice.

Actually, no you're not talking about a few percent here. I know a few people have already posted the theoretical temperature of the Earth's surface without an atmosphere. I don't know where that came from but I suppose it would be the steady-state temperature due to only the average solar flux. Anyway, that's your starting point, not 0 K. I don't believe that the difference between what was stated (- 19 C or somewhere around there) and today's "average" temperature is more than 36 K. I've heard from some sources that the planet is going to warm by +10 C and that's a heck of a lot more than 2%. Given the mass of the atmosphere and the top, say, six inches of the Earth, the blanketing efficiency of all greenhouse gases combined would have to be astronomical to cause that effect.
 
What assumptions behind AGW bother you?

1. The assertion that the planet is warming without a mechanism to define a value for the temperature of the planet.
2. The assumption that the causative agent is carbon dioxide, given that it's the only IR-active gas in sufficient concentrations to cause the effect. That's a circular argument.

Those are the two biggies. Others have more to do with the seemingly haphazard conduct of the science.

Tsonas doesn't only lack a mechanism to explain why the current warming is occurring, it also lacks an explanation for why increased CO2-load wouldn't cause warming despite the well-supported mechanism that AGW posits.

That statement cuts both ways. When a theoretician lacks a mechanism that does not make the theory wrong. Most hypotheses begin without establishing a mechamism of cause. For example, Darwin had absolutely no explanation as to how an organism evolved, only that it did. I would argue that, without clear evidence that a certain factor is behind the broadening of the probability curve, it should be left unstated. I am not completely sure, but I have seen no reason to assume that carbon dioxide is the driver behind GW. The assumption that carbon dioxide is the driver is necessary only if you want to turn GW into AGW. And, frankly, its unsupported.

a_unique_person nailed that point. If 280ppm of CO2 can drive the entire biosphere it's not easily dismissed as a "very small number". Despite its smallness, it is the only viable candidate to explain the current - and continuing - warming.

No, sorry. Again the circularity rears its ugly head. In your statement, you are assuming that the biological uses of carbon dioxide have anything to do with raising the temperature of the planet. And, you have stated the assumption very well in your last sentence. Except that it may not be the only viable candidate. It is the only obvious candidate if you want to assume AGW.
 
We are not discussing the quantity of total carbon on the planet. We're discussing how much is actually in gaseous form. Let's leave the biota out of it unless you have a point to make that the carbon in biota will also warm the planet.



Actually, no you're not talking about a few percent here. I know a few people have already posted the theoretical temperature of the Earth's surface without an atmosphere. I don't know where that came from but I suppose it would be the steady-state temperature due to only the average solar flux. Anyway, that's your starting point, not 0 K. I don't believe that the difference between what was stated (- 19 C or somewhere around there) and today's "average" temperature is more than 36 K. I've heard from some sources that the planet is going to warm by +10 C and that's a heck of a lot more than 2%. Given the mass of the atmosphere and the top, say, six inches of the Earth, the blanketing efficiency of all greenhouse gases combined would have to be astronomical to cause that effect.

That is why the positive feedback mechanisms are important. Without them, the climate sensitivity would be low. Albedo is one, water vapour another.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom