Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Schneibster
Let's put it this way: Ice that hasn't melted since the end of the last glaciation is melting now. A LOT of it. Most of the ice in the Arctic melted this summer and fall, which hasn't happened in at least a hundred and ten thousand years. Is that abnormal enough for you
Originally Posted by David Rodale
​
110,000 years? Is that right? Of course you have references to back that up, correct?
​
Schneibster
http://nsidc.org/iceshelves/larsenb2002/ end of the second paragraph: "Based on studies of ice flow and sediment thickness beneath the ice shelf, scientists believe that it existed for at least 400 years prior to this event, and likely existed since the end of the last major glaciation 12,000 years ago." The linked research says, "...it appears from our preliminary stratigraphic studies that the Larsen-B ice shelf has not experienced a history of full recession and reformation since the Last Glacial Maximum..." from the abstract here.

You can't add, either.

Thank you for your prompt reply.

However, I still do not get it. You assert that ice of 110,000 years is melting for the first time in the Arctic. You are asked to prove that, and provide a reference that indicates the Larsen B ice may have been 400 years old or it may have been 12,000 years old.

Larsen B is Antarctic. Wrong end of the planet.

I would shrug this off just a mistake, no big deal.

Next subject.
 
Really? His statements that "we" know how CO2 behaves in the lab and that must be the way it behaves in the atmosphere without mentioning the mechanisms that would interfere with that activity are disingenuous at best.
Now I've caught you in the same idiocy as mhaze. You've just claimed that there is a behavior that CO2 can have in the atmosphere that it will not have in an atmosphere sample in the lab. What precisely is that behavior, Mr. Person-who-claims-to-be-a-chemist? Go ahead, we're all waiting for you to prove your perspicacity and depth of knowledge.

Primary inefficiencies in reradiation from carbon dioxide, his avowed AGW engine, are of no consequence? Did you follow Alice down the rabbit-hole?
There are no "primary inefficiencies." There are no "inefficiencies" of any kind from the point of view of what happens to the energy emitted by the Earth; energy is conserved, and the energy either returns to Earth, remains in the atmosphere, or escapes to space, period. Energy that returns to Earth or remains in the atmosphere contributes to the greenhouse effect; energy that escapes to space cools the Earth. The more energy is retained or returned, the warmer the Earth will be; the more energy escapes to space, the cooler it will be. Anything, therefore, that contributes to increasing the retained or returned energy, will cause global warming. And increasing the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere will increase the retained and returned energy (and primarily the returned, since at STP re-radiation will be the primary relaxation mechanism).

If you'd like to discuss the rotational mode fine structure of the energy levels of the vibrational modes of CO2, I'm prepared to do so, but I don't think that you are. If you'd like to discuss Lorentz line broadening, particularly as interpreted as the Heisenberg uncertainty of the time and energy of the emission, or pressure line broadening driven by inter-molecular collisions, or Doppler broadening caused by the relative motion of the molecules, I'm prepared to discuss that as well; but again, I don't think you are.

None of these terms in the radiative transfer function particularly struck me as suitable to a short popular exposition; if you disagreed, you were perfectly welcome to say so, without all the schoolyard BS.

If you're familiar with any other terms in the radiative transfer function, then you have invented some new science and should be publishing papers in the peer-reviewed literature, but somehow I kind of doubt it. As a matter of fact, I seriously doubt you're familiar with the RTE in the first place, considering what I've seen you say here so far. If you'd like to learn more about it, you should probably have a look at this, a fairly comprehensive treatment. Anyone else who'd like to learn more details than I have presented above is also welcome to have a look at it. I don't really think it's necessary unless you are actually writing a simulation of greenhouse forcing, but by all means, feel free.

Observers please note that the radiative transfer function presented there is essentially the function used in atmospheric radiative transfer models used by geophysicists doing climate simulations (I say essentially because the equation is generally simplified to the most important terms to speed computer calculation, and numerical simulation is used). There are no other effects involved, and comparisons of the infrared radiation measured by satellites, on the ground, and in the atmosphere using balloons and towers agree with the RTE; that's why it's used. This equation is also used in the weather models that meteorologists use to produce weather forecasts, so it is well tested.

Slime, have you a single other thing to say on this subject? Comprehensive reference material from current college classes on the subject have been presented here, validating my treatment above. Your assertion that there is some other factor to be considered has been rejected, and proven not only false but maliciously so. I see no reason to speak further on this subject. And I'll point out that this is the second time that you have done this in an interaction with me; the last time, you claimed that a standard college course textbook on physical chemistry was comparable to von Daniken. You are a woo.

I'm baffled. You base the relaxation mode of carbon dioxide on the number of hits you get on Google? Are you serious? See, this is where you lose the scientifically-minded. These just-so statements are less than worthless. They actually make you look silly and hurt your argument.
It's not a just-so statement; it's an empirically tested, theoretically determined equation that describes the transfer of energy from the warm Earth to cold space through the atmosphere. This is science, and there's nowhere for you to hide.

Again, I ask you, what level of evidence should we demand of a hypothesis that portends calamitous consequences for mankind?
It's not a hypothesis, it's a theory. Theories have made predictions that are substantiated, and have been tested against the real world to ensure that they do not make predictions that disagree with reality. I repeat, you are a woo.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your prompt reply.

However, I still do not get it. You assert that ice of 110,000 years is melting for the first time in the Arctic. You are asked to prove that, and provide a reference that indicates the Larsen B ice may have been 400 years old or it may have been 12,000 years old.

Larsen B is Antarctic. Wrong end of the planet.

I would shrug this off just a mistake, no big deal.

Next subject.
Anyone who thinks this is an actual representation of the conversation that occurred is encouraged to follow the links back and note that the link provided to my post does not contain the quote that mhaze has placed in his presentation of it. This is frank dishonesty and misrepresentation, an out-and-out lie, period. As such I will not grace this post with any further response.
 
Back to ice core + Mauna Loa Data Quilting

This is just one of a number of "divergence problems". Historical proxy data from tree rings for example do not line up with 20th century temperature series. More data splicing is required or the series are truncated....

Here is the list for four assumptions that you referenced in Z. Jawowowrski's 2007 paper.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_142244704dbaab9510.png

Double click to enlarge.

Analysis of ice cores has came a long way. I believe When Gore's movie was made ice core data analyzed at 1000 year intervals, seemed to indicate that today we have "unprecedented warming". Later, the techniques improved and the ice cores showed the various historical warm periods such as the Medievel Warming Period. Gore's "documentary" was not updated and corrected for this or any other more recent findings.

The analysis of CO2 in the shallow ice cores was very early work.

Slimething asks an interesting question -

Is there a different carbon dioxice reservoir avialable for cross-checking the ice core data? Stalagtites/stalagmites? Mineral formations? Any such thing?

And that leads us back to Beck's review article, 180 Years of Gas CO2 Analysis by Chemical Means.



The above summaries a question that was discussed up to about page 5 of this thread, namely, how well do we know CO2 concentrations prior to the Mauna Loa data? Can all chemical CO2 analysis be thrown out as inaccurate (or some).

Chemical analysis was 3% accurate. Recently I got the two papers in that were the basis for Jawororski's graph above in which he said that data quilting was done without a scientific reason.

Neftal is the one that directly addresses the 83 year offset in the data. As usual, more questions are raised than answers. However, one thing becomes clear. Neftal says point blank that the best age resolution is 22 years in a shallow ice core. Friedl indicates the measurement of CO2 from ices to be in the neighborhood of plus or minus 2 percent. Taking the approach that this work is completely right, and noting that this is just a very brief look at the whole subject, the following conclusion is hard to get around.

Combining the age resolution of 22 years and the accuracy of the measurement indicates that measuring CO2 from shallow ice cores is less accurate than the chemical analysis done historically, when applied to CO2 measurements in the last 200 years.


References
Friedl et al 1986. Ice core record of the C13/C12 ratio of atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature Vol 325 Nov 1986.

Neftel et al 1985. Evidence form polar ice cores for the increase in atmospheric CO2 in the past two centuries. Nature Vol 315 May 1985.
 

Varoche, is the actual pdf available anywhere other than by JREF readers paying for a copy from Nature? We need source documents.

The title of the Nature paper is "Coupling of surface temperatures and atmospheric CO2 concentrations during the Paleozoic era."
The study contrasts the growth temperatures of fossils from two times in the distant geological past. The Silurian period, approximately 400 million years ago, is thought to have been a time of highly elevated atmospheric CO2 (more than 10 times the modern concentration), and was found by the researchers to be a time of exceptionally warm shallow-ocean temperatures--nearly 35 degrees C.

In contrast, the Carboniferous period, roughly 300 million years ago, appears to have been characterized by far lower levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide (similar to modern values) and had shallow marine temperatures similar to or slightly cooler than today-about 25 degrees C. Thus, the draw-down of atmospheric CO2 coincided with strong global cooling.

"This is a huge change in temperature," says John Eiler, a professor of geochemistry at Caltech and a coauthor of the study. "It shows that carbon dioxide really has been a powerful driver of climate change in Earth's past."
​
 
Combining the age resolution of 22 years and the accuracy of the measurement indicates that measuring CO2 from shallow ice cores is less accurate than the chemical analysis done historically, when applied to CO2 measurements in the last 200 years.

It's actually pretty simple to get around when you realise that because of the locations of the CO2 sampling stations in Becks review article, whatever the accuracy of the results, the data is not that useful in determining past global CO2 concentrations. This has been mentioned before.
 
It's actually pretty simple to get around when you realise that because of the locations of the CO2 sampling stations in Becks review article, whatever the accuracy of the results, the data is not that useful in determining past global CO2 concentrations. This has been mentioned before.

Not going to disagree with this at all - although it would be of interest to see if some of the data sets were from locations that we could all agree were unbiased. Beck's data is from ground level, not .... seems I recall Mauna Loa was about 5000 feet altitude.

But then, the Siple ice core data is also ground level...

If then one preferred Siple, it would be only on the basis of location, not accuracy of measurement, because it is worse on that count.
 
I can't believe that someone would still claim that the CO2 levels where jumping wildly just until we were measuring them accurately and consistently...

The cognitive dissonance is amazing.
 
Not going to disagree with this at all - although it would be of interest to see if some of the data sets were from locations that we could all agree were unbiased.

I find it unlikely. Anyway, is this not what Callendar did about 50 years ago?

Beck's data is from ground level, not .... seems I recall Mauna Loa was about 5000 feet altitude.

But then, the Siple ice core data is also ground level...

If then one preferred Siple, it would be only on the basis of location, not accuracy of measurement, because it is worse on that count.

If one preferred Siple it would be because one thought that the samples were likely freer of outside contamination than those that Beck favours. If you measure contaminated samples your measurement technique can be as accurate as you like, your results are still not going to be very much good. Your insistance then that the Siple data is less accurate than Becks preferred data falls apart when looked at in that way.

Sure the results might be fine for telling us what the CO2 concentration in Giessen was then, but making the leap that global CO2 levels were the same doesn't make much sense at all because we know from Beck himself that location is all important when trying to sample CO2 levels.
 
I find it unlikely. Anyway, is this not what Callendar did about 50 years ago?

If one preferred Siple it would be because one thought that the samples were likely freer of outside contamination than those that Beck favours. If you measure contaminated samples your measurement technique can be as accurate as you like, your results are still not going to be very much good. Your insistance then that the Siple data is less accurate than Becks preferred data falls apart when looked at in that way.

Sure the results might be fine for telling us what the CO2 concentration in Giessen was then, but making the leap that global CO2 levels were the same doesn't make much sense at all because we know from Beck himself that location is all important when trying to sample CO2 levels.

Thank you for your reply. There has been some concern from the point of view of skeptically minded people that Callender may have been less than 100% objective in his comparative analysis of chemical CO2 analysis.

Regarding the siting of the chemical work, I'll email Beck and perhaps we can reopen this with more raw data, or conclude it as the case may be.
 
Thank you for your reply. There has been some concern from the point of view of skeptically minded people that Callender may have been less than 100% objective in his comparative analysis of chemical CO2 analysis.

If they are written up and published in peer reviewed journals then that will be interesting. If their concerns are laid out in editorial style pieces I will be less than impressed.
 
If you think something is wrong with his post, then please share with the rest of the class. That way we all get to actually learn something.

Jeez, fsol, I thought we were all alone in here. Thanks for chiming in. OK. Let's take a look at what Mr. Science wrote, shall we:

Now, there are different ways CO2 can absorb a photon. The simplest is by the carbon atom, or one of the oxygen atoms, absorbing the photon in their electron shells.

As I've indicated before, I've caught schniebster lying previously and this is basically the continuation thereof. He lacks a well-rounded education in even quantum physics. Here he again reveals his complete ignorance of molecular orbital theory. What should be fairly obvious to anyone is that, in any molecule, the consituent atoms don't behave like they did when they were all alone. There is no such thing as the carbon or the oxygen in carbon dioxide absorbing a photon. The molecule absorbs a photon, not the atoms. Maybe he can be excused this faux-pas as he's made it quite clear that he only believes in the First Law of Thermodynamics whereas this phenomenon has more to do with the Second Law. (I have hammered him on this before, to no avail.)

This is the reason that carbon dioxide is different than carbon monoxide. (Per schniebster, they should both be the same as they both have carbon and oxygen, no? NO!) This is also the reason that table salt is not poisonous. Carbon dioxide is carbon dioxide is carbon dioxide. It is not carbon and oxygen any more than sugar is carbon and water.

So, I wanted schneibster to put his illucid description of how molecules act in schneib-world on Wiki so I could sit back and have some fun.

One point to note very carefully is that an electron can only absorb a photon of precisely the right frequency to jump the electron to the next orbital; a little too much, or too little, and the photon cannot be absorbed.

This point is more pedantic but this is yet another sentence written in crayon. I don't think it's accidental in that schneib seems to like to tell only half-truths. An electron does not need to jump to the next orbital. An electron can jump several orbitals or just plain leave the molecule altogether as long as the jump is not prohibited. Including that, of course, would weaken his IR begets IR fallacy.

Other things he has posted that are fallacious are that quenching does not occur at room temperature (look up Liquid Scintillation Counting for one example) and that the activity of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere can be predicted from laboratory testing which is done with primary reference standard materials (really, really pure stuff). Also, scattering does not have to be elastic.

They guy's a gem of scientific illiteracy and it grates on me. For people who want to blindly follow the incomplete data set that currently comprises AGW "science", a fake scientist is better than no scientist at all.
 
I'm not sure why you scare-quoted science. Is this meant to imply that the science behind AGW isn't real science?

The science is OK but there are too many people misrepresenting it. At the moment, I find the accumulated knowledge to be equivocal such that more work has to be done. I've also written that more empiricism is required here and less theorizing.

To understand the science behind anything, you have to read the publication and consider the facts derived for what they are. Scientists hardly ever say that something is this or that without couching the statement within the assumptions made by the experimenter(s) and the parameters of the measurement. For example, you can't state that carbon dioxide will reradiate n% of IR without stating that the finding was based on measurements performed at a certain purity using a certain light source and monochromator. You would also have to specify temperature, pressure and the material the light cell was made from.

Real science is only simple to simple people. I cannot predict you from your DNA.
 
According to the rest of the research, those effects are not stopping the warming that is happening.

Sheesh! Nobody said anything about stopping the warming. The factors were offered as a consideration that carbon dioxide may not be the driver of GW.

I'll go with Schneibster on this. Why would a lab experiment indicate anything different to the atmosphere? It appears to me that the inefficiencies you state would also be present in a lab experiment.

Well, whatever. You've made your choice. If you believe that someone accurately reproduced all the variables found in different atmospheric horizons in the lab, you're more than welcome to post it. So, what is the radiative efficiency of carbon dioxide at 320 ppmv?

Just indicating that we are getting to the more arcane levels of knowledge at this level. I have never heard of it before. Nothing more significant in my statement than that.

No arcane knowledge. You're falling for the smoke screen being laid down by someone who pulls quantum physics out of their posterior whenever they're cornered. I told you that the flaw in his write-up was not germane to the subject but it was germane to his argument. Regardless what anyone else posts, we are not dealing with mystery here. The only mystery to me is why nobody is looking for the temperature of the orb.

It's a matter or risk management. 9/11 was a good example of what can happen, and that was extremely unlikely. The USA has had a booming economy, while bleeding a trillion dollars down the sink. A trillion on reducing reliance on fossil fuels will have enormous benefits for the USA even if AGW isn't true.

Exactly. It would be a matter of risk management if you could define the risk. Risk management is not the management of unforseen events. You can't manage a risk without knowing its specific quantitative triggers. That's what I've been trying to tell you: you don't know the triggers and you can't quantify the adverse effect..yet.
 
Sheesh! Nobody said anything about stopping the warming. The factors were offered as a consideration that carbon dioxide may not be the driver of GW.



Well, whatever. You've made your choice. If you believe that someone accurately reproduced all the variables found in different atmospheric horizons in the lab, you're more than welcome to post it. So, what is the radiative efficiency of carbon dioxide at 320 ppmv?

No, I don't. I do believe that the lab model is significantly accurate to model the atmospheric response. That is the nature of modelling, not getting it exactly right, but close enough to be useful. The A380 flew, and I am surprised that a project so ambitious doens't seem to have needed any major re-engineering from the first prototypes. That's all due to modeling.

No arcane knowledge. You're falling for the smoke screen being laid down by someone who pulls quantum physics out of their posterior whenever they're cornered. I told you that the flaw in his write-up was not germane to the subject but it was germane to his argument. Regardless what anyone else posts, we are not dealing with mystery here. The only mystery to me is why nobody is looking for the temperature of the orb.

I don't know much about Quantum physics, and when I said so, Schneibster helped me out. If there is anything he is specifically wrong about, what is it?

Exactly. It would be a matter of risk management if you could define the risk. Risk management is not the management of unforseen events. You can't manage a risk without knowing its specific quantitative triggers. That's what I've been trying to tell you: you don't know the triggers and you can't quantify the adverse effect..yet.

A full report from the IPCC on the projected risks. http://www.ipcc-wg2.org/

I have no idea what the actual risk is to our datacentre of it being burned down, but it's pretty damn small. But we back up all our data and ship it off site every day. What are the odds of the IPCC being totally wrong, I would guess, at 1 in 5, 1 in 10? That's a significant risk, still.

As to the triggers and quantifying.... we aren't just talking about a single, specific system. The interactions and breadth of the scope (That is, the globe), make that impossible to nail down.

http://www.theage.com.au/news/clima...ier-reef-acidic/2007/10/17/1192300858496.html

WATERS around the Great Barrier Reef are becoming acidic at a higher-than-expected rate.
Ocean acidification, a side-effect of global warming, occurs when excess carbon dioxide dissolves into the ocean and becomes carbonic acid.
It is potentially devastating for the marine environment, affecting corals, crustaceans and plankton in particular.
Professor Malcolm McCulloch of the Australian National University said the findings were worrying.
"It appears this acidification is now taking place over decades rather than centuries as originally predicted." he said.
Researchers studied a type of reef coral called porites off Cairns and found pH levels were falling faster than previously thought, meaning acidity levels were increasing.
"This new data on the Great Barrier Reef suggests the effects are even greater than forecast," Professor McCulloch said.


What do you want to quantify? There are, for practical purposes, an endless number of things to quantify. This is just one more piece of the jigsaw puzzle.
 
The science is OK but there are too many people misrepresenting it. At the moment, I find the accumulated knowledge to be equivocal such that more work has to be done. I've also written that more empiricism is required here and less theorizing.

To understand the science behind anything, you have to read the publication and consider the facts derived for what they are. Scientists hardly ever say that something is this or that without couching the statement within the assumptions made by the experimenter(s) and the parameters of the measurement. For example, you can't state that carbon dioxide will reradiate n% of IR without stating that the finding was based on measurements performed at a certain purity using a certain light source and monochromator. You would also have to specify temperature, pressure and the material the light cell was made from.

Real science is only simple to simple people. I cannot predict you from your DNA.

From what I can tell, no one has said it is simple. What the IPCC does have to do is make it simple for people to understand what they are getting at. There is a difference. Even so, they are criticised for making the reports too big and difficult to understand, but the summaries are not science. It's a lose/lose situation, for them and us.
 
I can't believe that someone would still claim that the CO2 levels where jumping wildly just until we were measuring them accurately and consistently...

The cognitive dissonance is amazing.

I agree that the measurements are highly unlikely but throwing data out because they don't fit a hypothesis is considered bad form in science. To do that, you have to do a careful debunking or at least explain why the methodology was inadequate. That undertaking would take a lot of time and effort but it's the only scientific way to do it.

That's why there's an old warning in science to beware of new measurments. Until you've built up enough experience, history and confidence that there's no quirk in your methodology, you really shouldn't use it to make prognostications. I posted a story in a thread about the local uptick in cancer anywhere a new MRI machine was installed. It wasn't cancer. It was because the people running the MRI machine thought any dark shape had to be cancer. After a few months, the cancer rate went back to baseline.
 
I agree that the measurements are highly unlikely but throwing data out because they don't fit a hypothesis is considered bad form in science. To do that, you have to do a careful debunking or at least explain why the methodology was inadequate. That undertaking would take a lot of time and effort but it's the only scientific way to do it.

I think they have been disregarded because even I can see that they can't be valid, when you compare them to Cape Grim and Mauna Loa. CO2 levels just don't behave like that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom