Really? His statements that "we" know how CO2 behaves in the lab and that must be the way it behaves in the atmosphere without mentioning the mechanisms that would interfere with that activity are disingenuous at best.
Now I've caught you in the same idiocy as mhaze. You've just claimed that there is a behavior that CO2 can have in the atmosphere that it will not have in an atmosphere sample in the lab. What precisely is that behavior, Mr. Person-who-claims-to-be-a-chemist? Go ahead, we're all waiting for you to prove your perspicacity and depth of knowledge.
Primary inefficiencies in reradiation from carbon dioxide, his avowed AGW engine, are of no consequence? Did you follow Alice down the rabbit-hole?
There are no "primary inefficiencies." There are no "inefficiencies" of any kind from the point of view of what happens to the energy emitted by the Earth; energy is conserved, and the energy either returns to Earth, remains in the atmosphere, or escapes to space, period. Energy that returns to Earth or remains in the atmosphere contributes to the greenhouse effect; energy that escapes to space cools the Earth. The more energy is retained or returned, the warmer the Earth will be; the more energy escapes to space, the cooler it will be. Anything, therefore, that contributes to increasing the retained or returned energy, will cause global warming. And increasing the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere will increase the retained and returned energy (and primarily the returned, since at STP re-radiation will be the primary relaxation mechanism).
If you'd like to discuss the rotational mode fine structure of the energy levels of the vibrational modes of CO2, I'm prepared to do so, but I don't think that you are. If you'd like to discuss Lorentz line broadening, particularly as interpreted as the Heisenberg uncertainty of the time and energy of the emission, or pressure line broadening driven by inter-molecular collisions, or Doppler broadening caused by the relative motion of the molecules, I'm prepared to discuss that as well; but again, I don't think you are.
None of these terms in the radiative transfer function particularly struck me as suitable to a short popular exposition; if you disagreed, you were perfectly welcome to say so, without all the schoolyard BS.
If you're familiar with any other terms in the radiative transfer function, then you have invented some new science and should be publishing papers in the peer-reviewed literature, but somehow I kind of doubt it. As a matter of fact, I seriously doubt you're familiar with the RTE in the first place, considering what I've seen you say here so far. If you'd like to learn more about it, you should probably have a look at
this, a fairly comprehensive treatment. Anyone else who'd like to learn more details than I have presented above is also welcome to have a look at it. I don't really think it's necessary unless you are actually writing a simulation of greenhouse forcing, but by all means, feel free.
Observers please note that the radiative transfer function presented there is essentially the function used in atmospheric radiative transfer models used by geophysicists doing climate simulations (I say essentially because the equation is generally simplified to the most important terms to speed computer calculation, and numerical simulation is used). There are no other effects involved, and comparisons of the infrared radiation measured by satellites, on the ground, and in the atmosphere using balloons and towers agree with the RTE; that's why it's used. This equation is also used in the weather models that meteorologists use to produce weather forecasts, so it is well tested.
Slime, have you a single other thing to say on this subject? Comprehensive reference material from current college classes on the subject have been presented here, validating my treatment above. Your assertion that there is some other factor to be considered has been rejected, and proven not only false but maliciously so. I see no reason to speak further on this subject. And I'll point out that this is the second time that you have done this in an interaction with me; the last time, you claimed that a standard college course textbook on physical chemistry was comparable to von Daniken. You are a woo.
I'm baffled. You base the relaxation mode of carbon dioxide on the number of hits you get on Google? Are you serious? See, this is where you lose the scientifically-minded. These just-so statements are less than worthless. They actually make you look silly and hurt your argument.
It's not a just-so statement; it's an empirically tested, theoretically determined equation that describes the transfer of energy from the warm Earth to cold space through the atmosphere. This is science, and there's nowhere for you to hide.
Again, I ask you, what level of evidence should we demand of a hypothesis that portends calamitous consequences for mankind?
It's not a hypothesis, it's a theory. Theories have made predictions that are substantiated, and have been tested against the real world to ensure that they do not make predictions that disagree with reality. I repeat, you are a woo.