Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

I'm asking for science because I haven't seen enough of it yet. I have been very specific about my misgivings of the science so far and, while it's not rubbish, there are loose ends.

Getting back to the purpose of this thread. Can you establish without a doubt that humankind is causing the earth to warm? If so, to what degree? (excuse the pun)

ETA: If you believe that your buddy's post is Wiki-ready, I'd love to see him contribute it so he can further his education in physics, and fairly quickly, I should think. I stopped reading after the first major gaffe.

Recently a guy emailed me with a technical problem which I had discussed with him several months ago. He included a wikipedia article on the subject.

I responded to his questions and was genuinely surprised at the wiki article and how good it was.

Told him "that article is dead on accurate. It is exactly correct in all respects."

His response.

"That was your previous email-I put it in wikipedia.":D

Personal bias is a strange thing...
 
It's just your imagination. The last two links to papers, and they're on this page (unless this post goes to page 14), were presented by me and varwoche.
 
It's about the science of AGW. Schneibster has responded to demands about how CO2 absorbs and re-emits radiation, and the understanding of the physics behind it.

What of it is wrong?

AUP, no, this thread is not about the science of AGW. It's about any scientific evidence that AGW exists apart from either stasis or natural GW. If you want to start a thread about the science of AGW, go ahead. It would be useless because, from what I've seen, all science has something to contribute to either the pro or con camp. If you want lessons in science, you need to go to courses and study so that you don't become the context-free banality that your buddy has become.

For me to correct what shcleoster has posted, it would be like me removing a splinter form my foot, sharpening it and then reinserting it. Let's just leave it at the fact that his error (fairly major, really) will not impede the topic discussion. You will allow an old man a little schadenfreude, won't you? The error will make shleiber that more vulnerable next time we tangle.

Like I told you before, if you want to believe this person, you're on your own. Let me point out that he has dropped his silly argument "we know how carbon dioxide acts in the lab" since I posted about how ice cream is made. He only began backpeddaling on his "IR begets IR" fallacy once I posted about the other relaxation routes carbon dioxide (actually, any molecule) has avialable to it. He only began admitting that scattering and quenching were inefficiencies in said fallacy once I introduced them into the discussion. And, he started using "fatuous" after I used it.

So, again, considering a hypothesis that touts the possible decimation of humanity, what standard of evidence should we expect?
 
Recently a guy emailed me with a technical problem which I had discussed with him several months ago. He included a wikipedia article on the subject.

I responded to his questions and was genuinely surprised at the wiki article and how good it was.

Told him "that article is dead on accurate. It is exactly correct in all respects."

His response.

"That was your previous email-I put it in wikipedia.":D

Personal bias is a strange thing...

Kudos. Wiki is where the big boys play.

Funny, for one who has "stones" and posts scientific diatribes, I don't expect to see any of it in Wiki. Such a loss for science! ;)
 
Originally Posted by casebro
Yes but warming or cooling this instant is meaningless without comparing to ancient ranges. One thing is constant in climate, that is variability. Yes, Capeldoger, I know you think that is taking refuse in the past. But without past records to compare to, we just don't know whether this warm period is abnormal or not.
​
Schneibster
Let's put it this way: Ice that hasn't melted since the end of the last glaciation is melting now. A LOT of it. Most of the ice in the Arctic melted this summer and fall, which hasn't happened in at least a hundred and ten thousand years. Is that abnormal enough for you
​
Originally Posted by David Rodale
110,000 years? Is that right? Of course you have references to back that up, correct?

Schneibster
http://nsidc.org/iceshelves/larsenb2002/ end of the second paragraph: "Based on studies of ice flow and sediment thickness beneath the ice shelf, scientists believe that it existed for at least 400 years prior to this event, and likely existed since the end of the last major glaciation 12,000 years ago." The linked research says, "...it appears from our preliminary stratigraphic studies that the Larsen-B ice shelf has not experienced a history of full recession and reformation since the Last Glacial Maximum..." from the abstract here.

So where are you at on this now, 400, 12,000, or 110,000 years?
 
Which, basically, is that you haven't got anything, Slime, and you never did. You made it up. There's nothing wrong with it, and you've just confirmed it; if there were, you'd have already said what it was.

Poser.
 
I have no idea what you are talking about.

Do I have to 'splain everything? If you add 400, 12,000, and 110,000 years, you'll get yet another made-up number (122,400 years) that schleibo still won't be ablt to prove. That makes a perfect set of four so that means, yes, that's right:

schneibster can declare himself the weiner winner!!!
 
AUP, no, this thread is not about the science of AGW. It's about any scientific evidence that AGW exists apart from either stasis or natural GW. If you want to start a thread about the science of AGW, go ahead. It would be useless because, from what I've seen, all science has something to contribute to either the pro or con camp. If you want lessons in science, you need to go to courses and study so that you don't become the context-free banality that your buddy has become.

For me to correct what shcleoster has posted, it would be like me removing a splinter form my foot, sharpening it and then reinserting it. Let's just leave it at the fact that his error (fairly major, really) will not impede the topic discussion. You will allow an old man a little schadenfreude, won't you? The error will make shleiber that more vulnerable next time we tangle.

Like I told you before, if you want to believe this person, you're on your own. Let me point out that he has dropped his silly argument "we know how carbon dioxide acts in the lab" since I posted about how ice cream is made. He only began backpeddaling on his "IR begets IR" fallacy once I posted about the other relaxation routes carbon dioxide (actually, any molecule) has avialable to it. He only began admitting that scattering and quenching were inefficiencies in said fallacy once I introduced them into the discussion. And, he started using "fatuous" after I used it.

So, again, considering a hypothesis that touts the possible decimation of humanity, what standard of evidence should we expect?

I think his point was that they are aren't important to how the 'greenhouse' effect works. Links I refer to also only refer to the absorption and re-radiation of infra red. Statistically, it appears, they don't add much to the overall effect.
 
What's the best recent pro-AGW paper?
Recent you want recent you get.

A team of American and Canadian scientists has devised a new way to study Earth's past climate by analyzing the chemical composition of ancient marine fossils. The first published tests with the method further support the view that atmospheric CO2 has contributed to dramatic climate variations in the past, and strengthen projections that human CO2 emissions could cause global warming.
 
I think his point was that they are aren't important to how the 'greenhouse' effect works.

Really? His statements that "we" know how CO2 behaves in the lab and that must be the way it behaves in the atmosphere without mentioning the mechanisms that would interfere with that activity are disingenuous at best. Primary inefficiencies in reradiation from carbon dioxide, his avowed AGW engine, are of no consequence? Did you follow Alice down the rabbit-hole?

Links I refer to also only refer to the absorption and re-radiation of infra red. Statistically, it appears, they don't add much to the overall effect.

I'm baffled. You base the relaxation mode of carbon dioxide on the number of hits you get on Google? Are you serious? See, this is where you lose the scientifically-minded. These just-so statements are less than worthless. They actually make you look silly and hurt your argument.

Again, I ask you, what level of evidence should we demand of a hypothesis that portends calamitous consequences for mankind?
 
Thanks for confirming it, Slime. Thanks for also confessing you just lied.

This is too funny. Mr. "stones" doesn't have the guts to submit something to Wiki which his fan has declared "more than Wiki has for either subject already" and he himself has declared perfect. We know who the know-nothing is, schneib.

Prove me a liar and post it on Wiki. Make my day. If I am a liar and an incompetent scientist and poser, you have nothing to worry about. Show us your "stones".

:lol2:
 
This is too funny. Mr. "stones" doesn't have the guts to submit something to Wiki which his fan has declared "more than Wiki has for either subject already" and he himself has declared perfect. We know who the know-nothing is, schneib.

Prove me a liar and post it on Wiki. Make my day. If I am a liar and an incompetent scientist and poser, you have nothing to worry about. Show us your "stones".

:lol2:

For a thread about science there seems to be way more playground taunts than I would expect if people were actually talking about science.

If you think something is wrong with his post, then please share with the rest of the class. That way we all get to actually learn something. If all you are actually here for is to trade insults then thanks for helping to derail this thread so as to make it useless for anyone trying to learn something. There is an E in JREF afterall.
 
Really? His statements that "we" know how CO2 behaves in the lab and that must be the way it behaves in the atmosphere without mentioning the mechanisms that would interfere with that activity are disingenuous at best. Primary inefficiencies in reradiation from carbon dioxide, his avowed AGW engine, are of no consequence? Did you follow Alice down the rabbit-hole?

According to the rest of the research, those effects are not stopping the warming that is happening. I'll go with Schneibster on this. Why would a lab experiment indicate anything different to the atmosphere? It appears to me that the inefficiencies you state would also be present in a lab experiment.

I'm baffled. You base the relaxation mode of carbon dioxide on the number of hits you get on Google? Are you serious? See, this is where you lose the scientifically-minded. These just-so statements are less than worthless. They actually make you look silly and hurt your argument.

Again, I ask you, what level of evidence should we demand of a hypothesis that portends calamitous consequences for mankind?
Just indicating that we are getting to the more arcane levels of knowledge at this level. I have never heard of it before. Nothing more significant in my statement than that.

It's a matter or risk management. 9/11 was a good example of what can happen, and that was extremely unlikely. The USA has had a booming economy, while bleeding a trillion dollars down the sink. A trillion on reducing reliance on fossil fuels will have enormous benefits for the USA even if AGW isn't true.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom