Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Well, these articles do look interesting. So I'll throw a few comments in.

Scneibster: First of all, why does ice melt? Have you managed to figure that one out yet?
Nghiem said the rapid decline in winter perennial ice the past two years was caused by unusual winds. "Unusual atmospheric conditions set up wind patterns that compressed the sea ice, loaded it into the Transpolar Drift Stream and then sped its flow out of the Arctic," he said. When that sea ice reached lower latitudes, it rapidly melted in the warmer waters.

"The winds causing this trend in ice reduction were set up by an unusual pattern of atmospheric pressure that began at the beginning of this century," Nghiem said.
​
The article clearly and concisely addresses why arctic ice melts. Nghiem indicates that the patterns of winds that are responsible began around 1900 and explains the mechanism.
Ummmm, that would be around 2000 in the real world. We've started a new century; you might want to keep that in mind for later.

There is no way to sneak AGW into this one....well, actually I can think of one way, let's see if anyone comes up with it. I welcome Schneibster, or others, to expound further on the paper and how it may affect current our understanding on the recent decline in sea ice.
Well, now, tell me more about this unusual weather pattern that hasn't happened since the beginning of the last glaciation, 100,000 years or more. All of a sudden, there's a new weather pattern in the Arctic, something we haven't seen in the last 100,000 years. Isn't that a surprise? And just when all those scientists are yadda-yaddaing about all that global warming BS. Now, ain't that just a co-inky-dink?

The link to NASA is just a summary of the work. Is the actual paper available somewhere?
Yep. http://uwnews.org/relatedcontent/2007/September/rc_parentID36894_thisID36984.pdf

If that's not it, it's a precursor to it. Have fun.

You probably ought to actually read my response to DR. You might learn something, if that doesn't burn too much.
 
Nghiem said the rapid decline in winter perennial ice the past two years was caused by unusual winds. "Unusual atmospheric conditions set up wind patterns that compressed the sea ice, loaded it into the Transpolar Drift Stream and then sped its flow out of the Arctic," he said. When that sea ice reached lower latitudes, it rapidly melted in the warmer waters.
This fails to explain melting permafrost.
 
Last edited:
... intended to make it clear that the mechanism of global warming is well understood and has been for over a century, and is so obvious (at least if you know how physics works) that it's basically beyond argument. This was all started by the ridiculous paper you guys dragged up that gave us the Earth-shattering information that the atmosphere isn't covered with glass.

No, you are quite incorrect. Here is why.

You conveniently slide over the quantification of the effects that you have described relative to CO2's presumed activity relative to global warming.

Therefore, one could as easily assert that CO2 had an effect on warming the globe of 0.00000000001C as one could say that it had an effect of 2.5C.

If you can't show a numerical result you've proved nothing. But then the upturning of your Titanic arguments and their slow slide into the depths is no more than I expected. Show that I am wrong in some fashion superior than a mindless detour into ad homs, such tactics lose the argument to your side.

Alternately, continue the ad homs, demonstrating thereon your lack of a sound scientific basis for any serious rebuttal whatsoever.

Surely Warmers can do better. Surely?
 
Okay. I think that asking "what temperature increase could be expected from a doubling of CO2" is reasonable.

But what is a reasonable way of answering it? How would you (or anybody) go about making such an estimate?

It appears, from what I'm reading here, that only an answer from atmospheric physics would be acceptable to you. Is that correct?

There may be a way to figure it other than from actual atmospheric experiments. No one has adequately explained how that might be done, to my knowledge.

The reason that the question about the effects of doubling CO2 is asked as opposed to a 10% increase, or a 300% increase, is that this is a traditional metric used in climate science. That doesn't mean it is even a good or great metric, just that it is the traditional one.
 
Yes, of course one would certainly hope so. It's a blindingly obvious question to ask, really. I'm just trying to pin down what the point of all this rhetoric is, McIntyre's challenge, mhaze repeating it over here. I can't help thinking there's going to be a 'gotcha!' at the end of it all...

What I'm not sure is so reasonable is demanding an explanation / exposition that 2x CO2 results in a 2.5C temperature rise. Why that specific value, and why does the answer have to (seemingly) come from atmospheric physics?

What am I missing here?

I agree with you. Theory is nice but relevant experimentation would be better. Of course, we can't isolate a complete atmospheric column and enrich it with carbon dioxide but, pondering this, my so-called mind shot back a few decades to the ill-fated Biosphere 1 and 2 experiments.

In those experiments, people tried to create a fully-enclosed environment that would, theoretically, be sustainable forever, or a very long time, whichever came first. Predictably, lots of things went wrong but one of the factors cited for failure may have been the enclosed environment's inability to maintain the equilibrium level of carbon dioxide that we're used to. I think the data has long been burried somewhere and all that remains is the deep animus that the inhabitants have against one another but I don't recall any complaints about the biodome being too warm as a result of the excess carbon dioxide.

I think it would be a worthwhile experiment for the IPCC to undertake as the structure still exists. Track the temperature in the dome for several weeks then artificially enrich the atmosphere with carbon dioxide to 1.2, 1.6, 1.8 and 2.0 x the average original value and track the temperature. I'd be interested in those results. Beats handwaving any day.
 
Last edited:
No, you are quite incorrect. Here is why.

You conveniently slide over the quantification of the effects that you have described relative to CO2's presumed activity relative to global warming.

Therefore, one could as easily assert that CO2 had an effect on warming the globe of 0.00000000001C as one could say that it had an effect of 2.5C.

If you can't show a numerical result you've proved nothing.
Wrong, I've proved it has to have SOME positive effect. Which you've been denying. You've now clearly admitted it: "Therefore, one could as easily assert that CO2 had an effect on warming the globe of 0.00000000001C as one could say that it had an effect of 2.5C."

Little baby steps with you. You're not all that bright.

But then the upturning of your Titanic arguments and their slow slide into the depths is no more than I expected. Show that I am wrong in some fashion superior than a mindless detour into ad homs, such tactics lose the argument to your side.
Didn't I hear some idiot on your side crowing that one does not announce oneself as the winner in a debate? Seems to me the term "childish" was bandied about.

Just sayin'.

Alternately, continue the ad homs, demonstrating thereon your lack of a sound scientific basis for any serious rebuttal whatsoever.

Surely Warmers can do better. Surely?
Like I said, little baby steps for the dumb ones.
 
There may be a way to figure it other than from actual atmospheric experiments.
Atmospheric experiments??!!? :dl:

I thought you were sure the atmosphere wasn't covered with glass!! You even provided a paper that proved it!

I'll get free beers for a year telling this one. "Atmospheric experiments."

No one has adequately explained how that might be done, to my knowledge.
Unreal. Yeah, I'd say no one is going to do any "atmospheric experiments" any time soon. We get around to terraforming Mars or Venus we might do some "atmospheric experiments." If we can survive long enough. What with AGW and all.

The reason that the question about the effects of doubling CO2 is asked as opposed to a 10% increase, or a 300% increase, is that this is a traditional metric used in climate science. That doesn't mean it is even a good or great metric, just that it is the traditional one.
Yeah, I was right- you don't know ANYTHING about science.
 
Atmospheric experiments??!!?
Yeah, I was right- you don't know ANYTHING about science.

Yes, Indeed. Those are very enlightening comments. Thank you for helping us to understand these difficult problems. Oh. By the way. Care to elaborate on some of your other scientific opinions?

Here are a few.
  • You lied
  • You'll say anything, tell any lie, to "prove" you're "right," won't you?
  • this is just another tissue of lies and I'll not waste my time on it.
  • you are perfectly capable of constructing fake "evidence,"
  • If you're going to lie, at least make it something that's a little bit more difficult to prove you're lying about than that.
  • Lie noted.
  • Lie repeated, and noted again.
  • presuming of course that you are capable of having thoughts
  • presuming for that matter that you actually have a nervous system, much less a brain
  • Is this just another one of those little pieces of dishonesty you seem so comfortable with?
  • This is far too interesting a study in entomology to leave now.
  • This is generally accepted as a childlike tactic from the schoolyard.
  • Your blatant threat has been noted
  • you think accusing people of fabricating evidence is a repulsive low-life tactic.
  • If we can survive long enough. What with AGW and all.
  • yes, that's the script.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
If all the CO2 in the atmosphere was put next to the ground, how thick do you think the layer would be?
​
How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

Answer.

1 cubic foot of air weighs 0.0807 lb.
Total weight of 1 square foot column of air is 14.7 lb.
CO2 is 0.000380 of the air.
A column of CO2 some 99.67 feet high then would contain all of the CO2 in the atmosphere.
​
Shall we try this with another greenhouse gas called water vapor which may be 3% of the atmosphere?
That column would be 787 feet high.
​
How important is the CO2?
 
If you didn't want to have a mud fight, I guess you shoulda thought before you threw the first handful. As far as I'm concerned, you've given as good as you've got; the difference between us is, you're whining about it, and I'm not. If you lie, expect me to throw it in your face, and you are lying on a regular basis. It's not an accusation or insult, it's a matter of documented fact on this forum, in this thread.

If you'd like to stop now, and discuss actual science and find out as much as you're going to (c'mon, nobody's learning enough calculus to be writing programs to do Navier-Stokes equations here), then feel free to suggest it at any time; but you're going to have to accept that people who have information you don't like aren't lying, and more importantly, people who bring data to the table that you don't like aren't either. I seriously doubt, like Slimething, that you have the stones for this, but if you do, then go for it.

One warning: you get to do that ONCE. If you lie about it, or renege, then you'll never hear anything from me but what you've heard so far. I'll just continue showing what a fool you are, until you go away.
 
Answer.

1 cubic foot of air weighs 0.0807 lb.
Total weight of 1 square foot column of air is 14.7 lb.
CO2 is 0.000380 of the air.
A column of CO2 some 99.67 feet high then would contain all of the CO2 in the atmosphere.
​
Shall we try this with another greenhouse gas called water vapor which may be 3% of the atmosphere?
That column would be 787 feet high.
​
How important is the CO2?
A good hiking boot weighs two or three pounds; the gore-tex lining only an ounce or two. How important is the gore-tex?

ETA: just thought of this: the column of air is 100 miles high. How important is the water vapor?
 
Last edited:
Presumptions

most of them kinetic
energy goes up
about half of the directions
another couple of variables
a little too much, or too little
generally does so
Luckily, there is another mechanism
kind of like a tuning fork
tumbling and spinning in various ways
specific considerations having to do with deeper rules
a certain direction
most likely
Another thing that can happen
probably only one
it might collide
only if the energy is just the right amount
tiny bit of energy
the most likely
fairly unlikely
if anything happens
if anything happens
the more CO2 there is
the more trapped heat
more likely photons are to hit

Conclusion

atmosphere gets warmer?

From that set of
  • maybes,
  • abouts,
  • bits,
  • likelies,
  • about halfs,
  • anything happened,
  • etc.
would you like to tell us what the temperature increase is for a doubling of CO2?

You ask for science, you get science, yet all you can do is ridicule it. The measurements have been done on this over a century ago, it's only relatively recently that the reasons for the measurements have been understood.
 
You ask for science, you get science, yet all you can do is ridicule it.

I'm asking for science because I haven't seen enough of it yet. I have been very specific about my misgivings of the science so far and, while it's not rubbish, there are loose ends.

Getting back to the purpose of this thread. Can you establish without a doubt that humankind is causing the earth to warm? If so, to what degree? (excuse the pun)

ETA: If you believe that your buddy's post is Wiki-ready, I'd love to see him contribute it so he can further his education in physics, and fairly quickly, I should think. I stopped reading after the first major gaffe.
 
Last edited:
Answer.

1 cubic foot of air weighs 0.0807 lb.
Total weight of 1 square foot column of air is 14.7 lb.
CO2 is 0.000380 of the air.
A column of CO2 some 99.67 feet high then would contain all of the CO2 in the atmosphere.
​
Shall we try this with another greenhouse gas called water vapor which may be 3% of the atmosphere?
That column would be 787 feet high.
​
How important is the CO2?

You know that argument is absurd, but you persist in it. It's important because it has been found to be important. What percentage of the human body is vitamin C? What percentage H2O? How important are both to life?
 
I'm asking for science because I haven't seen enough of it yet. I have been very specific about my misgivings of the science so far and, while it's not rubbish, there are loose ends.

Getting back to the purpose of this thread. Can you establish without a doubt that humankind is causing the earth to warm? If so, to what degree? (excuse the pun)

ETA: If you believe that your buddy's post is Wiki-ready, I'd love to see him contribute it so he can further his education in physics, and fairly quickly, I should think. I stopped reading after the first major gaffe.

If you want to correct any mistakes you see, please do. I thought this was about determining the science.

There is no 'without a doubt'. That's the nature of science.
 
Hey, Slime, if you got a criticism, let's see it. If it's a factual error, maybe you're right. If it's another of your nit-picking objections to an "oversimplification" made for pedantic reasons, don't bother.

And if you don't reply, well, that's just another assertion you made that you can't support. No skin offa my nose.
 
If you want to correct any mistakes you see, please do. I thought this was about determining the science.

There is no 'without a doubt'. That's the nature of science.

This thread is about determining whether or not anyone can establish AGW as fact, not about the ignorance of a phony scientist with an ugly avatar. I would correct it if I liked the individual but I don't.

So, I think your idea of contributing that write-up to Wiki would be a true test. Let's see about his stones. He seems to have a real obsession with them.

You're right about no "without a doubt" in science. What level of confidence would you be happy with?
 
This thread is about determining whether or not anyone can establish AGW as fact, not about the ignorance of a phony scientist with an ugly avatar. I would correct it if I liked the individual but I don't.

So, I think your idea of contributing that write-up to Wiki would be a true test. Let's see about his stones. He seems to have a real obsession with them.

You're right about no "without a doubt" in science. What level of confidence would you be happy with?

It's about the science of AGW. Schneibster has responded to demands about how CO2 absorbs and re-emits radiation, and the understanding of the physics behind it.

What of it is wrong?
 
Is it my imagination or is it just the skeptics who always are presenting new papers here for discussion?

What's the best recent pro-AGW paper?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom