Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

When he first entered this discussion, schriebest ridiculed me for not agreeing with him that a molecule of carbon dioxide, having absorbed a photon in the infrared, would necessarily relax by radiating a photon in the infrared. That is provably wrong and he knows it. I hope you do too. That's why he wouldn't commit himself to repeating that idiocy when I asked him to directly. I lost my cool but that happens when I deal with things of that ilk.

I you believe that excited CO2 must radiate heat to reach a stable ground state, you know nothing of chemistry, or even physics. The electrons in carbon dioxide have an infinite number of permissible energy states to occupy once excited. They can hop back down in one or many steps. It is not my fault that molecules are so complex. I only know that they are. If you want to believe someone who pulls quantum mechanics out of thin air anytime they can't deal with reality, that's on you not me.

According to this http://www.ucar.edu/learn/1_3_1.htm it will be re-emmitted as infrared. I don't know a lot about the physics of this, but I think it can, in theory, be reemitted at a higher frequency, but the odds of that happening shorten very quickly as the frequency gets higher.

The radiation re-emmitted can't be at a higher frequency that it was absorbed at, can it?

Also, according to the absorption bands, CO2 is transparent at higher frequencies, that is, sunlight passes pretty well right through it, but not at certain infrared bands.

Who's having a tantrum? What I am saying is that, absent a verifiable basis, I don't believe we as a society should act rashly on a hypothesis which is currently unmamagable. Whether or not it even has a basis in fact is also open to question but that has nothing to do with the fact that we don't have the tools to manage the problem right now even if it were true. Let me put it this way, AUP, if you had to start a program to ameliorate global warming today, say by reducing carbon dioxide, how would you quantify your progress?

We invaded Iraq on a lot less, and the cost of that adventure will be about the same. The cost of reducing reliance on fossil fuels will be pretty neutral, since we avoid a lot of the problems that warming will produce, and save a lot of money in the process by reducing reliance on them.

Well, no. That's not why I became a scientist. We could have much better science than what is being presented right now. Your stance befuddles me. Why are you demanding action instead of better science?

Did you read the number of references that the AR4 has? That's a lot of research, and it's ongoing.
 
According to this http://www.ucar.edu/learn/1_3_1.htm it will be re-emmitted as infrared. I don't know a lot about the physics of this, but I think it can, in theory, be reemitted at a higher frequency, but the odds of that happening shorten very quickly as the frequency gets higher.

The radiation re-emmitted can't be at a higher frequency that it was absorbed at, can it?

If all the CO2 in the atmosphere was put next to the ground, how thick do you think the layer would be?
 
According to this http://www.ucar.edu/learn/1_3_1.htm it will be re-emmitted as infrared. I don't know a lot about the physics of this, but I think it can, in theory, be reemitted at a higher frequency, but the odds of that happening shorten very quickly as the frequency gets higher.

Carbon dioxide is tranparent to the visible spectrum. It does, however, absorb and radiate in both the IR and UV sectors. Here's a pretty good site on the spectra of carbon dioxide. Note that carbon dioxide is not limited to the IR. The mode of relaxation is not dependent on time.

The radiation re-emmitted can't be at a higher frequency that it was absorbed at, can it?

The molecule would need to be in a lower energy state than when it absorbed that photon. It could happen.

Also, according to the absorption bands, CO2 is transparent at higher frequencies, that is, sunlight passes pretty well right through it, but not at certain infrared bands.
.

And UV. That's why I wouldn't agree with your friend's taunting questions about re-radiation. Also, carbon dioxide could be excited enough to react chemically with another molecule. If the excitation energy is sufficient, it can become a free radical and react with anything in its way.

We invaded Iraq on a lot less, and the cost of that adventure will be about the same. The cost of reducing reliance on fossil fuels will be pretty neutral, since we avoid a lot of the problems that warming will produce, and save a lot of money in the process by reducing reliance on them.

All true. Really, I don't object at all to some of the remedies being advocated toward relieving global warming. Planting trees, making less trash, switching to biodegradables, being mindful of the environment in general are just A-OK by me. Also, a more humane method of distributing the planet's resources is great by me, too. My objections stem from the politization of science. Even though the fight against AGW might be the right thing to do regardless, I just can't stand by and see my vocation used as an excuse.

Did you read the number of references that the AR4 has? That's a lot of research, and it's ongoing.

Like I said, AR4 is voluminous and impressive. I just wish these guys had decided to set the metrics before wading into the theory. Theory is nice but fact keeps our feet on the ground.
 
According to this http://www.ucar.edu/learn/1_3_1.htm it will be re-emmitted as infrared. I don't know a lot about the physics of this, but I think it can, in theory, be reemitted at a higher frequency, but the odds of that happening shorten very quickly as the frequency gets higher.

The radiation re-emmitted can't be at a higher frequency that it was absorbed at, can it?
Looks like it's time to do a proper science post on how CO2 interacts with photons.

The short answer is, a CO2 molecule that absorbs a photon of a particular frequency, assuming it hasn't absorbed any others, and assuming it was quiescent, can't radiate a photon of a higher frequency, because higher frequency is higher energy, and that would violate conservation of energy; the energy has to come from somewhere. Conservation of energy is a really important concept, and one that's followed in all of physics. We first found out about it in thermodynamics, but it turns out to be important everywhere. What it means is that energy never just disappears; if it appears to, it went somewhere, and finding that somewhere can lead to all sorts of interesting things. No experiment has ever been performed that violated conservation of energy, and physicists expect none ever will be. As far as we can tell, conservation of energy is an absolute principle of how our universe works. Physicists call it a Law of Nature. That's very important, so keep it in mind.

Now, there are different ways CO2 can absorb a photon. The simplest is by the carbon atom, or one of the oxygen atoms, absorbing the photon in their electron shells. This increases the energy of an electron (the one that absorbed the photon), and it jumps to a higher energy level (farther out from the nucleus). In technical terms, it changes to a different orbital. This state is unstable; the electron can jump back down to the lower state it came from, by re-emitting the photon, and it generally does so. One point to note very carefully is that an electron can only absorb a photon of precisely the right frequency to jump the electron to the next orbital; a little too much, or too little, and the photon cannot be absorbed. And, of course, the photon emitted is the same frequency as the one absorbed. Physicists refer to this phenomenon as deep elastic electron-photon scattering.

But there is a little problem; the frequencies this happens at are too high to be infrared; they're in the visible light spectrum, or in the ultraviolet. Luckily, there is another mechanism at work in molecules that permits the absorption of photons. And this mechanism works in the infrared.

Molecules aren't zero sized. What that means is that the molecule has a shape that can be bent; and what's more important, it can resonate between different shapes. In other words, it can vibrate, kind of like a tuning fork does; but there's a difference between the way a molecule vibrates and the way a tuning fork does. The tuning fork is constantly losing little bits of energy to the air, and so it eventually runs out of energy and stops vibrating; but there's no "air" around a molecule, so it doesn't lose energy that way. (That's actually an oversimplification, and there's a thing that happens that does that to molecules, but I'll come back to it.) A molecule that has absorbed a photon of the correct frequency to set it vibrating this way is said to be "excited." And just like the electron, the situation isn't stable. The molecule can return to its original unexcited state by simply emitting a photon of the same frequency, and in general, that's exactly what it does.

Now, the ways a molecule can vibrate depend on the shape of the molecule, and there's a formula for that. A molecule like CO2 is called a linear molecule, because the atoms are arranged in a straight line, like this: O-C-O. For linear molecules, the formula is 3N - 5, where N is the number of atoms; for CO2, that's three. Therefore, the CO2 molecule can vibrate in (3 x 3) - 5, or four, different ways. For a picture of this, see here, search on the string "CO2" to see a discussion of it. Each of those ways has a specific energy. There are also specific considerations having to do with deeper rules of quantum mechanics that dictate that some modes cannot be excited by photons; this has to do with how the electric charges move relative to one another, and is outside the scope of this discussion. One of the four modes cannot for CO2. So that leaves three. Of those three, two are identical, just rotated 90 degrees; so they have the same energy. Therefore, CO2 has two frequencies it can absorb in the infrared, one for the first two, and one for the single remaining one.

Now, it's important to understand that quantum phenomena like the emission and absorption of photons don't proceed like clockwork. They're random; and the chance of them happening is governed by a probability equation. The probability equation that governs the emission of photons by excited CO2 has the highest probability right after the absorption, and it lowers over time quite quickly. So most CO2 molecules that absorb a photon and start vibrating emit the photon again pretty quickly, although a few may hang onto it longer. We're talking nanoseconds to milliseconds here.

But there are another couple of variables to consider as well. The molecule can only absorb the photon if it is coming in a certain direction, and it can only emit it in that same direction (or perhaps in a plane parallel to the direction of vibration, or in a line parallel to it- the details depend on the particular vibration mode, and CO2 turns out to have more than one). In addition, the CO2 molecule isn't trapped in a solid, it's floating as a constituent of a gas, so it will be tumbling and spinning in various ways. The direction the photon emerges in is therefore random; it depends on the way the molecule is tumbling, and the vibration mode the photon engendered, and ultimately on that random timing of the quantum probability equation. It's therefore safe to say that if you divide all directions into a pair of hemispheres, about half the time the photon will come out toward one of them, and the other half, the other, and that's just what we see when we experiment with them.

Well, a photon floating in the Earth's atmosphere is going to see about half of the directions be into space, and the other half back to Earth. The Earth's atmosphere is very thin compared to its diameter. It's probably 50.00000001% space and 49.999999999% Earth; close enough.

Slimething pointed out, quite correctly, that there's something else that can happen to an excited CO2 molecule than emitting a photon. Since the molecule is floating in a gas, it might collide with another molecule, and if it does, then it might transfer some or all of its energy to that other molecule. This can result in that other molecule vibrating, but only if the energy is just the right amount; most likely, that can only happen with another CO2 molecule. Another thing that can happen is that that other molecule can be "bumped" and accelerate to a higher speed. This is called "quenching." It's important to remember, however, that this can only happen for the various vibrational modes, not for the excited electron in an electron shell; of course, we're not talking about that situation, but it is something to keep in mind.

It's important to keep that quantum probability equation in mind; because what it says is that the photon is most likely to be re-emitted almost immediately. As a result, in a fairly low-pressure gas like our atmosphere, it's fairly unlikely that the CO2 molecule will encounter another molecule before it re-emits the photon. So for every 1,000 absorptions, probably only one or so will result in a quenching event; the other 999 will be re-emissions.

But there's another thing to keep in mind. What we call "temperature," at least in a gas, is really the average kinetic energy of the molecules in the gas. (It's a bit different in a solid or a liquid, but that's off-topic.) And remember, the most likely molecule for a CO2 molecule to encounter is a nitrogen molecule (nitrogen molecules contain two nitrogen atoms, thus N2). Since it can't absorb the vibration (doesn't have a vibration mode of the proper energy), if anything happens, and it might not other than the molecules just bouncing off one another, then what happens is the nitrogen atom is accelerated; that means it speeds up. And that of course means its kinetic energy goes up; and that means that the gas (the atmosphere) gets warmer. That nitrogen molecule will be bouncing off other molecules in the atmosphere, and at each bounce it will give up some of its kinetic energy, increasing the kinetic energy of the other molecules it hits. Eventually, that tiny bit of energy will be distributed among all the molecules.

So either the CO2 molecule re-emits the photon, and half the time it returns to the Earth where it came from; or else the atmosphere gets a tiny bit warmer. Either way, some of the energy radiated from the Sun-warmed surface of the Earth doesn't escape into space; it's trapped, and makes the surface and the atmosphere warmer. And of course, since the Earth's surface can lose heat by conduction to the atmosphere, either way, the atmosphere gets warmer, too. This is the greenhouse effect, and the fact that I can just about completely describe it without much mathematics should tell you that this is a fairly simple piece of physics.

Now, not all photons leaving the Earth hit CO2 molecules. In fact, most of them don't hit any molecule at all. Otherwise, obviously, we wouldn't be able to take infrared pictures of the Earth with satellites. But the more CO2 molecules there are, the more likely photons are to hit them; and we've already discussed what happens then. So the more CO2 there is in the atmosphere, the warmer the Earth's surface and atmosphere will get. It's not a simple linear relationship; but qualitatively speaking, the more CO2, the more trapped heat, and the higher the temperature. And that's global warming.

Also, according to the absorption bands, CO2 is transparent at higher frequencies, that is, sunlight passes pretty well right through it, but not at certain infrared bands.
Yes, that's pretty much true; CO2 has a few narrow visible light absorption bands, but because sunlight is white, it has many frequencies, and we don't notice the CO2 absorbing much of the light. If the atmosphere were pure CO2, and we had a spectroscope, we could find those bands; but we would only probably notice a slight brightening if it were all taken away.

Now, doubtless Slimething will find various minor errors, mostly of omission, in that explanation; but from the viewpoint of the layman, that's about as detailed as you're going to get without engaging all sorts of math. And you can always refer to that page I linked. So I'd say anyone with an ounce of gumption can just go ahead and look over there and see whether what Slime's got to say holds water for themselves without me needing to point anything out.
 
Last edited:
Presumptions

most of them kinetic
energy goes up
about half of the directions
another couple of variables
a little too much, or too little
generally does so
Luckily, there is another mechanism
kind of like a tuning fork
tumbling and spinning in various ways
specific considerations having to do with deeper rules
a certain direction
most likely
Another thing that can happen
probably only one
it might collide
only if the energy is just the right amount
tiny bit of energy
the most likely
fairly unlikely
if anything happens
if anything happens
the more CO2 there is
the more trapped heat
more likely photons are to hit

Conclusion

atmosphere gets warmer?

From that set of
  • maybes,
  • abouts,
  • bits,
  • likelies,
  • about halfs,
  • anything happened,
  • etc.
would you like to tell us what the temperature increase is for a doubling of CO2?
 
Presumptions
None of which you actually refute, you just question them. Here, I'll help you with that:

most of them kinetic
I didn't say that.
energy goes up
It's called "conservation of energy." The kinetic energy can't go down if energy is transferred from the CO2 molecule.
about half of the directions
Oh, really? Tell me you've flown on a plane. Ever looked out the window? That's enough to tell you I'm right.
another couple of variables
I enumerated them. Do you propose that there are more, or one of mine was incorrect? If so, specify. Either you know enough to have this conversation, or you don't- and from what I've seen of you, you don't.
a little too much, or too little
Known physical law, as you'd know if you knew any physics, which you obviously don't. That's why it creates lines in the spectrum, sport. You are really out of your league here.
generally does so
And I specified all the other things it can do, and they are low probability, which I also specified. Did you have some sort of a point here? Apparently not.
Luckily, there is another mechanism
Known physical law. You really DON'T know much about physics, do you?
kind of like a tuning fork
You don't know much about metaphors either, apparently. Which is no more surprising than that you don't know much about physics.
tumbling and spinning in various ways
So, you believe all the molecules in the atmosphere are lined up the same way???!!?? :dl:
You really, REALLY, REALLY don't know any physics, do you?
specific considerations having to do with deeper rules
Fine, you want me to go into it? Here you go:
If a molecule moves in certain ways, it exhibits a net electric charge at certain points in that motion. This is technically called a dipole moment. It turns out that because photons are quanta of the electromagnetic force, they can only directly interact with things that have a dipole moment. Most such things are just charged particles, like electrons and protons. Having a charge is a sure indication that something has a dipole moment.

However, there are ways that things that don't have a net charge can still have a dipole moment, and one of those ways is by having charges distributed across them, that add up to zero globally across the object, but have net charges at various points. Since atoms are made up of electrons and protons, there must be electrons distributed across the molecule; and if the atoms move relative to one another in certain ways, those electrons can momentarily be out of balance and cause the molecule to have a dipole moment that the photon can couple to. If that's the case, then the molecule can absorb photons in its movements, and if it does, then it will vibrate in that mode until it re-radiates the photon, or is quenched.

Now, I'm absolutely certain (considering what I've seen from you so far- chuckle, sorry, I rarely meet someone who claims to be able to talk sensibly about global warming who doesn't know enough physics to know that all the little molecules in the atmosphere aren't all lined up with each other all the time) that you have not the least slightest clue what any of that means. But there you have it. Since you have not a clue what it means, I don't know how you intend to evaluate it, but there you go.
a certain direction
The direction and phase of the photon's wave function have to match up with the direction the molecule can vibrate when the photon goes by; if they don't, it won't be absorbed. Of course, you might have a little trouble visualizing that if you think they're all lined up in the same direction, chuckle, sorry.
most likely
I found several instances of this; all are either references to quantum probability, in which case "most likely" is a generalized quantification of the probability equation, or cases where I enumerated all the possibilities. Perhaps you'd care to be more specific, so I can show how much more you don't know about physics.
Another thing that can happen
Ummm, that's pretty specific. I see no presumption. That's how it works.
probably only one
I found a couple references that indicated that it's unlikely, but none of them quantified it better than that. Feel free to google it. If you even understand what I was talking about. That will be your little piece of homework for the evening. Maybe you'll even learn some physics. Chuckle. Sorry.
it might collide
Yep. That's a probability equation based statement. Quantum physics is like that. For that matter, so is the simple physics of molecules considered as particles in a gas; the perfect gas equation is based on this particular "it might." Not that you have the faintest idea what the perfect gas equation is.
only if the energy is just the right amount
Known physical law. Also a matter of conservation of energy. You can't absorb half a quantum, or any other fraction. It's called the "quantum theory," and was proposed by Max Planck at the beginning of the 20th century. You probably haven't heard of it. Chuckle. Sorry.
tiny bit of energy
Well, that's what it is. How much depends on the collision angle, and the angles of the molecules to one another, and how they're moving precisely with respect to one another. It's called "dynamics." I don't think you'd understand it; it's some more of that, you know, physics stuff. Chuckle. Sorry.
the most likely
Straight probability again. Say, you wouldn't have a problem with math, would you? That would explain a LOT about you. Certainly you seem to have no grasp of probabilities.
fairly unlikely
Yeah, you're pretty unclear on that whole "probability" thing. That must be a major handicap; I mean, physics is one thing, but how would you know whether to even buy lottery tickets, or play poker?
if anything happens
It might not. As I described. Wow, you're getting worse and worse. Now you're having reading comprehension problems. Tell me, were you drunk when you wrote this?
the more CO2 there is
the more trapped heat
more likely photons are to hit
Again, simple physical law. Nowhere to hide (unless you believe all the molecules in the atmosphere are lined up like an enormous chorus line). Not a presumption to be found. And that includes the rest of them, too.

You are so completely out of your depth, it's pitiful. All you can come up with is that weak-sister crap. You don't know physics, you don't understand probability, and you can't even read properly. Why are you here? Is there some sort of ideological reason you dimly conceive of that drives you? Or is it some sort of tropism, like a slug crawling toward a leaf? Entomology is fascinating. Disgusting, but fascinating.

Conclusion

atmosphere gets warmer?
Yep, there you have it. Been known since the eighteenth century. Simple stuff, not even any math. Plain as the nose on your face when you understand how things work. Of course, you have to be able to understand probability, and that kind of leaves you out, doesn't it?

From that set of
  • maybes,
  • abouts,
  • bits,
  • likelies,
  • about halfs,
  • anything happened,
  • etc.
would you like to tell us what the temperature increase is for a doubling of CO2?
Now, that's a far more complex subject. See, to do that, you need to do the math, like the scientists who made the prediction did. I think that kind of leaves you out in the cold, with your little problem and all. I mean, if you can't even figure out statements of probability when they're presented to you, how would you ever even dream of comprehending just how much you have to do to make an estimate like that? Not a chance.

Keep on wrigglin', it's fun to watch you squirm. You got no place to hide, and it's getting hotter, isn't it?
 
In case the thought hasn't crossed your tiny little brain yet, presuming of course that you are capable of having thoughts, and presuming for that matter that you actually have a nervous system, much less a brain, you might not quite want to cross swords with someone on physics when they know a lot and you don't. It kind of has the tendency to make you look like an idiot. Not that you hadn't accomplished that long ago; just something to think about (again, presuming of course that you're capable of that).

You are really pitiful when you try to talk about science, you know that?
 
That was uncharitable. You know, I have come to a sudden realization: you don't know ANYTHING about how science works. That totally explains why you behave this way, mhaze. You think it's like how Perry Mason does law, or something; that there's little loopholes and stuff, or magic things happening, that "science can't explain," if you'll pardon the rather obvious woo physics and homeopathy reference. You haven't got a single clue what scientists actually DO, do you? You think they just make this stuff up. It must puzzle heck out of you how they invented computers and nuclear weapons and cars and refrigerators. I can't even imagine not knowing how those things work. Even less can I imagine engaging in a debate on the reality of global warming without knowing that.

So let me ask you: if you don't know any science, why are you arguing with people who do, on any subject to do with science?
 
Of course you're not talking about tree rings because the hockey stick is a fraud.
Seems, from the above, to have worked well enough.

110,000 years? Is that right? Of course you have references to back that up, correct?
Sure. What do you need, to know how long ago the last glaciation started and ended? Or that the ice was that old?

http://nsidc.org/iceshelves/larsenb2002/ end of the second paragraph: "Based on studies of ice flow and sediment thickness beneath the ice shelf, scientists believe that it existed for at least 400 years prior to this event, and likely existed since the end of the last major glaciation 12,000 years ago." The linked research says, "...it appears from our preliminary stratigraphic studies that the Larsen-B ice shelf has not experienced a history of full recession and reformation since the Last Glacial Maximum..." from the abstract here.

As for the timeline of glaciations, a quick wikipedia will clear that up: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_glaciation See the table under "Land-based chronology."

I don't read newspapers to get scientific data,
Nor much of anything else as far as I can tell. Certainly you're not familiar with the scientific research in the area; kinda surprising in someone who claims to know anything about global warming.

but since you don't wish to read what I say, you'll never be able to respond to the following:

http://www.geo.umass.edu/climate/papers/brineretal2006.pdf
You didn't read it, and you don't know how the Milankovitch cycle affects that measurement. Note that on pages 432 and 433, it says,
Holocene climate on eastern Baffin Island has been influenced by three main forcing factors: 1) insolation (which has gradually declined since 12,000–10,000 cal yr B.P., when total insolation at 60 N was almost 10% higher than at present; (Berger and Loutre, 1991) and seasonality of insolation (which has also gradually declined through the Holocene)...
Note the reference to Berger and Loutre, 1991. If you search that up, you'll find the following page: http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/forcing.html#orbital Looking on that page, the topmost link in the section labeled "Orbital Variations" (which is, of course, the label pointed to by #orbital in the above URL) has the following entry:
Orbital Variations, 5,000,000 Years, Berger and Loutre 1991
which links to a table of orbital and axial tilt calculations for the Earth's orbit- which is the Milankovitch cycle.

See, if you actually knew how to READ a reference, rather than just cherry-pick it, you might actually understand what they were saying, which is that IN THE ARCTIC, there was a thermal maximum, CAUSED BY THE TILT OF THE EARTH'S AXIS AND ITS ORBITAL PARAMETERS, between 10,000 and 8,500 years ago. All of the temperatures they were talking about were ONLY in that specific location.

And if you read some more, there's even more information available in that paper. On page 431, the first page, it says,
Although recent progress has been made toward obtaining spatially dense records of Holocene climate change (Kaufman et al., 2004), quantitative records are relatively few and far between.
Which would be why reconstructions of paleoclimate have been limited to tree rings; they didn't have enough lake sediment cores to make a field that was spatially dense enough to say anything sensible. No doubt the lake sediment core data will come in and show the same thing as the tree ring data does, fairly shortly when enough of it has been collected.

Now, to know all that, you actually have to read the reference you cherry-picked your "proof theres no globul warmeng" from, instead of cherry picking it. And that appears to be beyond your capabilities.

That pretty much takes care of the next two references as well, which are from Arctic Russia and the Western Arctic. In case it's not clear to you, the Arctic goes all the way around the top of the Earth.

As I said, be careful what you wish for. You may get it.

http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/quikscat-20071001.html
http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2007/2007GL031138.shtml
I have the full article. Not one reference is made to "global warming", "anthropogenic" or anything else relating to AGW, CO2 levels etc. Keep circling the wagons Schneibster.
You don't know much about science, do you? That seems to be a common theme among denialists.

First of all, why does ice melt? Have you managed to figure that one out yet?

Second, they're not doing research on global warming, or human CO2 emissions, they're doing research on sea ice dynamics in the Arctic. So when someone writes a paper on, say, stellar dynamics, if they don't mention the Big Bang, is that proof there wasn't one, or even that the writer doesn't think there was?

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Nice try. But flawed by your lack of reading and comprehension skills. Too bad. Try again. I'll be happy to show you how much more you don't know that you think you do.
 
Why?

I mean, what's the back story here, why keep asking this question?

The exposition of physics is I assume intended to somehow prove that CO2-in-the-atmosphere yada-yada-yada. There is a complete lack of constants, measured values and mathematical relationships in the exposition.

Nothing whatsoever can be figured from it. As Schneibster notes in response to this question (prior to going off on a bender),
would you like to tell us what the temperature increase is for a doubling of CO2?
​
Now, that's a far more complex subject.

Yes, it is a far more complex subject. A lot of people would like to know to what extent current scientific understanding can provide a useful prediction on alleged global warming, or what extent it can not.

Schneibster shrugs this problem off, and proceeds to make assertions about the presence of AGW and its serious implications. Yet he views actual atmospheric experiments intended to get empirical data on the behavior of trace gases as a waste of time (if I understood correctly his comments on this subject).

Is the effect of higher CO2 levels negligible? Using a doubling of CO2 as the metric, suppose that the resulting temperature change was 0.3C. Schenibster's exposition does nothing to disprove this assertion or to prove that the resulting temperature change on the contrary, say might be 6C.
 
Originally Posted by David Rodale
http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/loo...-20071001.html
http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/200...GL031138.shtml
I have the full article. Not one reference is made to "global warming", "anthropogenic" or anything else relating to AGW, CO2 levels etc. Keep circling the wagons Schneibster.

​
First of all, why does ice melt? Have you managed to figure that one out yet?

Second, they're not doing research on global warming, or human CO2 emissions, they're doing research on sea ice dynamics in the Arctic. So when someone writes a paper on, say, stellar dynamics, if they don't mention the Big Bang, is that proof there wasn't one, or even that the writer doesn't think there was?

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Nice try. But flawed by your lack of reading and comprehension skills. Too bad. Try again. I'll be happy to show you how much more you don't know that you think you do.

Well, these articles do look interesting. So I'll throw a few comments in.

Scneibster: First of all, why does ice melt? Have you managed to figure that one out yet?
Nghiem said the rapid decline in winter perennial ice the past two years was caused by unusual winds. "Unusual atmospheric conditions set up wind patterns that compressed the sea ice, loaded it into the Transpolar Drift Stream and then sped its flow out of the Arctic," he said. When that sea ice reached lower latitudes, it rapidly melted in the warmer waters.

"The winds causing this trend in ice reduction were set up by an unusual pattern of atmospheric pressure that began at the beginning of this century," Nghiem said.
​
The article clearly and concisely addresses why arctic ice melts. Nghiem indicates that the patterns of winds that are responsible began around 1900 and explains the mechanism.

There is no way to sneak AGW into this one....well, actually I can think of one way, let's see if anyone comes up with it. I welcome Schneibster, or others, to expound further on the paper and how it may affect current our understanding on the recent decline in sea ice.

The link to NASA is just a summary of the work. Is the actual paper available somewhere?
 
The exposition of physics is I assume intended to somehow prove that CO2-in-the-atmosphere yada-yada-yada. There is a complete lack of constants, measured values and mathematical relationships in the exposition.

Nothing whatsoever can be figured from it. As Schneibster notes in response to this question (prior to going off on a bender),
would you like to tell us what the temperature increase is for a doubling of CO2?
​
Now, that's a far more complex subject.

Yes, it is a far more complex subject. A lot of people would like to know to what extent current scientific understanding can provide a useful prediction on alleged global warming, or what extent it can not.

Schneibster shrugs this problem off, and proceeds to make assertions about the presence of AGW and its serious implications. Yet he views actual atmospheric experiments intended to get empirical data on the behavior of trace gases as a waste of time (if I understood correctly his comments on this subject).

Is the effect of higher CO2 levels negligible? Using a doubling of CO2 as the metric, suppose that the resulting temperature change was 0.3C. Schenibster's exposition does nothing to disprove this assertion or to prove that the resulting temperature change on the contrary, say might be 6C.


Okay. I think that asking "what temperature increase could be expected from a doubling of CO2" is reasonable.

But what is a reasonable way of answering it? How would you (or anybody) go about making such an estimate?

It appears, from what I'm reading here, that only an answer from atmospheric physics would be acceptable to you. Is that correct?
 
The exposition of physics is I assume intended to somehow prove that CO2-in-the-atmosphere yada-yada-yada. There is a complete lack of constants, measured values and mathematical relationships in the exposition.

Nothing whatsoever can be figured from it.
Well, if you don't understand how science works, I guess not. I believe I heard someone questioning whether CO2 could cause the greenhouse effect, somewhere around here. But if you don't know enough math to be able to understand probabilities, I guess it's asking a bit much for you to be able to estimate effects from knowing how things work.

As Schneibster notes in response to this question (prior to going off on a bender),
would you like to tell us what the temperature increase is for a doubling of CO2?
​
Now, that's a far more complex subject.

Yes, it is a far more complex subject. A lot of people would like to know to what extent current scientific understanding can provide a useful prediction on alleged global warming, or what extent it can not.
Well, if you can't understand probability, I'm afraid that's going to be a bit beyond your capabilities. Of course, you could always go read the papers, if you think you can handle it. They describe it all in detail. With the math.

Schneibster shrugs this problem off,
No, I merely pointed out that if you can't do enough math to understand probabilities, and don't know enough physics to know that all the CO2 molecules in the atmosphere aren't all lined up pointing the same way, you're probably not going to understand the explanation even if it's given to you, and I'm not into wasting my time.

and proceeds to make assertions about the presence of AGW and its serious implications. Yet he views actual atmospheric experiments intended to get empirical data on the behavior of trace gases as a waste of time (if I understood correctly his comments on this subject).
No, you didn't understand correctly (or if you did, you're lying again). I provided proof that empirical data were available, of precisely the type you were interested in, and pointed out that they had been used. You ignored that. Your loss.

Is the effect of higher CO2 levels negligible? Using a doubling of CO2 as the metric, suppose that the resulting temperature change was 0.3C. Schenibster's exposition does nothing to disprove this assertion or to prove that the resulting temperature change on the contrary, say might be 6C.
So? It wasn't intended to. It was intended to make it clear that the mechanism of global warming is well understood and has been for over a century, and is so obvious (at least if you know how physics works) that it's basically beyond argument. This was all started by the ridiculous paper you guys dragged up that gave us the Earth-shattering information that the atmosphere isn't covered with glass.
 
Okay. I think that asking "what temperature increase could be expected from a doubling of CO2" is reasonable.
I'll point out at this juncture that this has been done.

But what is a reasonable way of answering it? How would you (or anybody) go about making such an estimate?
You have to make a geophysical model of the atmosphere. To figure it has to get warmer, in simple qualitative terms, all you need is what I made the long post on. But figuring how MUCH warmer requires a great deal more information be processed, because you have to know how the heat moves, and how the air moves, and how the air interacts with the ground, and how the air interacts with the sea, and with ice, and how heat moves in the sea, and a very large number of other details. The only way to do that is to make a model, and these guys don't believe in models (which is why I keep saying they don't know much about science, which is almost completely composed of models of greater or lesser complexity).

It appears, from what I'm reading here, that only an answer from atmospheric physics would be acceptable to you. Is that correct?
While that's probably true, I seriously doubt that it can be done without a very complex model, and since we don't have a computer to run it on, about all we can do is check whether all the variables we can think of have been mentioned in the paper where the results of such a model have been documented. And even if we did it, I don't think it would help much with people who don't understand science. But you're welcome to try. And perhaps I'm wrong; maybe we can come up with a good way to estimate it. It's not gonna be quick, though.
 
I'll point out at this juncture that this has been done.


Yes, of course one would certainly hope so. It's a blindingly obvious question to ask, really. I'm just trying to pin down what the point of all this rhetoric is, McIntyre's challenge, mhaze repeating it over here. I can't help thinking there's going to be a 'gotcha!' at the end of it all...

What I'm not sure is so reasonable is demanding an explanation / exposition that 2x CO2 results in a 2.5C temperature rise. Why that specific value, and why does the answer have to (seemingly) come from atmospheric physics?

What am I missing here?
 
{snip}

While that's probably true, I seriously doubt that it can be done without a very complex model, and since we don't have a computer to run it on, about all we can do is check whether all the variables we can think of have been mentioned in the paper where the results of such a model have been documented. And even if we did it, I don't think it would help much with people who don't understand science. But you're welcome to try. And perhaps I'm wrong; maybe we can come up with a good way to estimate it. It's not gonna be quick, though.


No, I know my limitations... ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom