Schneibster
Unregistered
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2005
- Messages
- 3,966
What are you blathering about? I make an assertion, no one finds anything to argue with in it, and you tell ME to get a grip? How about YOU get a grip and start admitting that you haven't got a leg to stand on and never did?Get a grip. We don't get to judge our own work in science. Maybe you do where you work but that's not permitted, even in physics.
At room temperature? You're kidding, right? At STP, no more than one in a thousand vibrationally excited CO2 molecules is going to get quenched before it re-radiates. But here's the real kicker: quenching excites the quenching molecule. In other words, either the heat gets re-radiated, back toward Earth's surface in half the cases, or the heat stays in the atmosphere, right there where the quenching interaction occurred.quenching
Conservation of energy, remember?
Where do you get this stuff? Deconvolution is a data manipulation technique that reduces noise and increases resolution, not a method of analyzing spectroscopic data to determine the molecular composition of molecular cloud complexes. It's also relatively new, and requires a fair bit of computing power; power that was not available when the seminal spectroscopic studies of the molecular cloud complexes in Sagittarius and Orion were done in the 1980s. As it happens, I use maximum entropy deconvolution on astrophotographs I take; and adjusting the matrix size to fit the atmospheric distortion ("seeing") cell size works very nicely to clean the image up.matrix deconvolution of spectroscopic data
While deconvolution might be used in pre-processing of spectroscopic data to sharpen the spectrogram, it will not yield data that tells what molecular and atomic species created the spectrum. You have to analyze the data to do that, and deconvolution is not an analysis technique.
Basically, you're picking up terminology that you don't really understand the meaning of, and using it to try to bolster your case because it sounds good.
But if the intensity is abated, then the heat stops where it is. In the atmosphere.Umm...no one said anything about changing a spectrum. The discussion at hand has all to do with abatement of intensity, not shifting of spectra.
Speaking of thermodynamics, what happens in cases of low efficiency? Heat is dissipated. In situ. Remember that conservation of energy thing?Efficiency.
And whereby that interference heats the interfering molecule.quenching is a well known phenomena whereby one molecule interferes with the radiation of another.
Well, I know enough to know that energy is conserved, a concept you seem a little shaky on. Scattering is, of course, what I've been discussing all along; specifically, elastic scattering. In the case of quenching, the scattering becomes inelastic, but that doesn't mean the heat just goes away.No, quenching has only to do with intensity. Scattering is what you're after but that doesn't affect absorption, only emission. Are you sure you're a physicist? This is basic stuff here. Even chemists know this stuff.
Then there'd be the fact that broadening of the spectrum has nothing to do with quenching. Are you sure you actually read this post, or were you having a conversation with an imaginary friend?
I think posting ten plus pages of citations would qualify as spamming; the reader is encouraged to examine the references sections of several of the chapters in AR4 to verify the truth of my assertion. Links to AR4 are provided in the conversation above.No, no, no. Stop there. Please post some evidence for these outlandish claims. You're going over the edge here.
