Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Get a grip. We don't get to judge our own work in science. Maybe you do where you work but that's not permitted, even in physics.
What are you blathering about? I make an assertion, no one finds anything to argue with in it, and you tell ME to get a grip? How about YOU get a grip and start admitting that you haven't got a leg to stand on and never did?

quenching
At room temperature? You're kidding, right? At STP, no more than one in a thousand vibrationally excited CO2 molecules is going to get quenched before it re-radiates. But here's the real kicker: quenching excites the quenching molecule. In other words, either the heat gets re-radiated, back toward Earth's surface in half the cases, or the heat stays in the atmosphere, right there where the quenching interaction occurred.

Conservation of energy, remember?

matrix deconvolution of spectroscopic data
Where do you get this stuff? Deconvolution is a data manipulation technique that reduces noise and increases resolution, not a method of analyzing spectroscopic data to determine the molecular composition of molecular cloud complexes. It's also relatively new, and requires a fair bit of computing power; power that was not available when the seminal spectroscopic studies of the molecular cloud complexes in Sagittarius and Orion were done in the 1980s. As it happens, I use maximum entropy deconvolution on astrophotographs I take; and adjusting the matrix size to fit the atmospheric distortion ("seeing") cell size works very nicely to clean the image up.

While deconvolution might be used in pre-processing of spectroscopic data to sharpen the spectrogram, it will not yield data that tells what molecular and atomic species created the spectrum. You have to analyze the data to do that, and deconvolution is not an analysis technique.

Basically, you're picking up terminology that you don't really understand the meaning of, and using it to try to bolster your case because it sounds good.

Umm...no one said anything about changing a spectrum. The discussion at hand has all to do with abatement of intensity, not shifting of spectra.
But if the intensity is abated, then the heat stops where it is. In the atmosphere.

Efficiency.
Speaking of thermodynamics, what happens in cases of low efficiency? Heat is dissipated. In situ. Remember that conservation of energy thing?

quenching is a well known phenomena whereby one molecule interferes with the radiation of another.
And whereby that interference heats the interfering molecule.

No, quenching has only to do with intensity. Scattering is what you're after but that doesn't affect absorption, only emission. Are you sure you're a physicist? This is basic stuff here. Even chemists know this stuff.
Well, I know enough to know that energy is conserved, a concept you seem a little shaky on. Scattering is, of course, what I've been discussing all along; specifically, elastic scattering. In the case of quenching, the scattering becomes inelastic, but that doesn't mean the heat just goes away. :rolleyes:

Then there'd be the fact that broadening of the spectrum has nothing to do with quenching. Are you sure you actually read this post, or were you having a conversation with an imaginary friend?

No, no, no. Stop there. Please post some evidence for these outlandish claims. You're going over the edge here.
I think posting ten plus pages of citations would qualify as spamming; the reader is encouraged to examine the references sections of several of the chapters in AR4 to verify the truth of my assertion. Links to AR4 are provided in the conversation above.
 
the popular conjecture is analyzed and the underlying physical principles are clarified

​
I think it is clear. The popular conjecture is per Gore.
Ummm, nope. According to the abstract, the popular conjecture is the conjecture that there is a greehouse effect, and it's misnamed as a conjecture; it's a theory, yet another inaccuracy. It has nothing to do with Gore, and considerably predates him, as must be obvious from the dates in the abstract in the nineteenth century.

By the way, I catalog all links in posts, not just anti AGW links.
So?
 
Since you're repeating yourself, I'll do likewise. If you haven't read it, don't pretend to understand it let alone critique it. If you think I believe that you've even skimmed the paper, you are mistaken.
I really don't care what you believe; I showed inaccuracies in the abstract, there isn't any need for more to impeach it.
 
Belly up buddy.

I am not familiar with that expression... I suppose it means

"I'm sorry for the misunderstanding, and for inadvertedly making up positions for other people".

or maybe

"Yes, according to my logic, I can't really discuss atmospheric processes, since I'm not an expert in the adequate field of science"

or maybe something else... who's to know...
 
Is it valid to average together some temperatures from liquid, solid and gases somehow?

That is, temperatures one or two meters above land, temps from buckets scooped from the ocean, temps from ship engine intakes, and temps inferred from satellite?

Say that a gas is 1/500 the molar density of water or landmass. The measure of merit is heat contained in the things measured, right?

Where is the adjustment that gives the sea temperatures 500 times the weight as the measured air temperatures?

So did the climatologists do it right, if there is in fact any way to have done it right?​
Sophistry.

Wow!

I'm off to boil some water on the stove...Got gas, liquid, solid in that little thermo system...On that one, AUP, it's break time for me.:D
 
Wow, I reply to AUP, schneiber answers. I reply to schneiber, AUP answers.

No, like I said before, I haven't read it. I don't even have it. The post was from David Rodale and I reposted it because it was being ignored. I've noted that David is again being ignored. He's the best source of information about this article so communicate your concerns to him. I'm sorry I can't be of much help here one way or the other.
Well, the link to it is right there in my post. So get readin'. Doesn't it seem a little hypocritical to you to accuse other people of not reading it when you haven't done so yourself?
 
Obviously, I do not share your opinion that it is unnecessary, and neither do quite a few people. You are welcome to your opinion of course, and there may be quite a few people who share it with you.
Opinion is irrelevant. Your challenge has been shown to be based upon invalid underlying assumptions. You have not refuted that exposition.
 
Opinion is irrelevant. Your challenge has been shown to be based upon invalid underlying assumptions. You have not refuted that exposition.

Actually, no. I'm not obliged to give you the right answers.:D

Tell you what, perhaps on 1-1-2008 I'll wrap up these several challenges and note the very best replies.

At this time be advised, your answer is not the best. Not by far.

I think you could do a pretty good job at it, though.
 
Actually, no. I'm not obliged to give you the right answers.:D
THAT'S reassuring. I certainly hope you're not thinking that I'm waiting on you for them. :roll:

Tell you what, perhaps on 1-1-2008 I'll wrap up these several challenges and note the very best replies.
I can hardly wait. :rolleyes:

At this time be advised, your answer is not the best. Not by far.
I'm sure you don't think it is. It's rather disconcerting to have your assumptions exposed for everyone to look it, isn't it?

I think you could do a pretty good job at it, though.
Neat.
 
Actually, I read the paper. There are a set of conclussions I posted in the GW thread. No one could refute those.

Here is the link in page 15


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2898206&postcount=585

I read it, liked it, and went on to reading other things. Gee, if I had spent all my time debating and arguing about whether something was worth reading, I never would get to read anything.

The more Warmers deride something and say it isn't worth reading, the more people will probably go read it.

I haven't heard much in the way of a serious rebuttal to Gerlich so far.

Surely one can be formulated?
 
If you want to discuss the paper, read it.

If you grasp that all temperatures are averages and you are a chemist, than it makes no great leap to say that a global temperature (of the atmosphere) is possible, which Gerlich says in his paper is impossible. Not hard mind you, but impossible.

And yes the record temperature in NYC is just one data point but like I've said before, I have been concerned about global warming since before Al Gore invented the internet.
 
I make an assertion, no one finds anything to argue with in it, and you tell ME to get a grip? How about YOU get a grip and start admitting that you haven't got a leg to stand on and never did?

Ho-hum. My point was that, in a debate, you don't get to declare yourself the winner. Unless you're five years old.

At room temperature? You're kidding, right? At STP, no more than one in a thousand vibrationally excited CO2 molecules is going to get quenched before it re-radiates. But here's the real kicker: quenching excites the quenching molecule. In other words, either the heat gets re-radiated, back toward Earth's surface in half the cases, or the heat stays in the atmosphere, right there where the quenching interaction occurred.

Your training in photochemistry is lacking. You have made several mistakes and assumptions in the above paragraph. It's really not worth rebutting.

Where do you get this stuff? Deconvolution is a data manipulation technique that reduces noise and increases resolution, not a method of analyzing spectroscopic data to determine the molecular composition of molecular cloud complexes.

Again, your training and knowledge are lacking here. Matrix math is not new and certainly doesn't require computers but computers do help. There are many applications of matrix deconvolution of signals (note, they don't have to be spectroscopic signals) used in science. Again, not worth rebutting because you're arguing from ignorance.

While deconvolution might be used in pre-processing of spectroscopic data to sharpen the spectrogram, it will not yield data that tells what molecular and atomic species created the spectrum. You have to analyze the data to do that, and deconvolution is not an analysis technique.

Again, wrong. I have specific examples in mind but I won't share them with you because I believe that you're just trolling and using a jargon generator to fool people who don't know better.

Basically, you're picking up terminology that you don't really understand the meaning of, and using it to try to bolster your case because it sounds good.

Projection, dear sir, projection. I just checked on the wall and my degree is still there.

Speaking of thermodynamics, what happens in cases of low efficiency? Heat is dissipated. In situ. Remember that conservation of energy thing?

And whereby that interference heats the interfering molecule.

I was going to write something here about your obvious lack of understanding of thermodynamics but I'd rather see you dig the hole deeper and wider. :)

Well, I know enough to know that energy is conserved, a concept you seem a little shaky on. Scattering is, of course, what I've been discussing all along; specifically, elastic scattering. In the case of quenching, the scattering becomes inelastic, but that doesn't mean the heat just goes away. :rolleyes:

You are protesting too much. Seems I've caught you in something again. Yes, of course, you have been discussing scattering, only now do you think of the correct scientific terminology because I used it. There are many, many types of scattering. Assuming that only elastic scattering is occuring is a sign of ignorace. That's why we run experiments, right?

I think posting ten plus pages of citations would qualify as spamming; the reader is encouraged to examine the references sections of several of the chapters in AR4 to verify the truth of my assertion. Links to AR4 are provided in the conversation above.

Funny how you're never really precise in your claims. I really would love to see how ten pages of citations would include the names of tens of thousands of contributors. Maybe if they printed it like this or even small enough that we would all need loupes to read them. Don't bother posting it, just another specious claim.
 
Last edited:
I really don't care what you believe; I showed inaccuracies in the abstract, there isn't any need for more to impeach it.

You do care what I believe as evidenced by the fact that you're responding. I disagree that you showed any inaccuracies in the abstract. As a matter of fact, your "rebuttal" included no more information than what was in the abstract and that is why I doubt you even looked at it.

Again, you do nothing then you claim to have won. That is a very telling practice and it says more about you than you want.
 
Doesn't it seem a little hypocritical to you to accuse other people of not reading it when you haven't done so yourself?

No, that's not what I wrote. I told you that you shouldn't critique it if you handn't read it. That's kind of like writing a book report on a novel you haven't read. I would call it a lie but I know how much that word excites you.

Thanks, though. Your post is an admission that you did not read the paper.
 
Ho-hum. My point was that, in a debate, you don't get to declare yourself the winner. Unless you're five years old.
Ad hom noted.

Your training in photochemistry is lacking. You have made several mistakes and assumptions in the above paragraph. It's really not worth rebutting.
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted. Implicit assertion that energy conservation laws are not obeyed in photochemistry noted. :rolleyes:

Again, your training and knowledge are lacking here. Matrix math is not new and certainly doesn't require computers but computers do help. There are many applications of matrix deconvolution of signals (note, they don't have to be spectroscopic signals) used in science. Again, not worth rebutting because you're arguing from ignorance.
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted. Lack of knowledge of the actual complexity of deconvolution mathematics noted. Lack of knowledge of the use of deconvolutions in astrophysics noted.

Again, wrong. I have specific examples in mind but I won't share them with you because I believe that you're just trolling and using a jargon generator to fool people who don't know better.
Multiple ad homs noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted. Projection noted; "jargon generator" is precisely what you used in the first place, invoking deconvolution and quenching, apparently in the mistaken belief that I didn't know what they meant.

Projection, dear sir, projection. I just checked on the wall and my degree is still there.
Yes, and we can all see it too. :rolleyes:

I was going to write something here about your obvious lack of understanding of thermodynamics but I'd rather see you dig the hole deeper and wider. :)
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted.

You are protesting too much. Seems I've caught you in something again. Yes, of course, you have been discussing scattering, only now do you think of the correct scientific terminology because I used it. There are many, many types of scattering. Assuming that only elastic scattering is occuring is a sign of ignorace. That's why we run experiments, right?
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted.

Funny how you're never really precise in your claims. I really would love to see how ten pages of citations would include the names of tens of thousands of contributors. Maybe if they printed it like this or even small enough that we would all need loupes to read them. Don't bother posting it, just another specious claim.
Ad hom noted. Lack of research noted; that's the list for a single section. Strawman argument noted; I never said tens of thousands of contributors.

So basically, what we have in this entire post is an ad hominem argument in every paragraph for the ice cream, a bunch of assertions that have no support for the whipped cream, and a strawman to top it off like a cherry. A fallacy sundae. :)
 
You do care what I believe as evidenced by the fact that you're responding. I disagree that you showed any inaccuracies in the abstract. As a matter of fact, your "rebuttal" included no more information than what was in the abstract and that is why I doubt you even looked at it.

Again, you do nothing then you claim to have won. That is a very telling practice and it says more about you than you want.
Multiple ad homs noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted.
 
No, that's not what I wrote. I told you that you shouldn't critique it if you handn't read it. That's kind of like writing a book report on a novel you haven't read. I would call it a lie but I know how much that word excites you.

Thanks, though. Your post is an admission that you did not read the paper.
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom