Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Looks like a sensible position to hold.

Like you, I would also be 'fairly sure that the researchers thought of this'. For most of the problems that we can dream up with their research. Looking into the primary research could be very illuminating in finding out just how rigorous (or not) the science is.

Did you have any particular reference in mind?

OK, I screwed up in my first reply to you. The claims I'm investigating are the "found assumptions" about ice coring data as listed on p. 5 in Jaworowski's paper "CO2: the greatest scientific scandal of our time". He gives references for these assumptions, which I hope to find. I probably won't find some of them but I'm optimistic.

Jaworowski also gives references for publications which he maintains disprove these assumptions which I also hope to review.
​

 
BTW, if civility is actually enforced on this thread and all like it, no one would be happier than I. But if you bring that down, be aware that I will report every slightest subtlest dig, every accusation of dishonesty, every imputation of motive other than getting at the truth, and any other deviation from strictest discussion of the exact scientific facts, as presented in reliable peer-reviewed literature, whether those digs, accusations, or imputations are about me or anyone else whatsoever. If you believe you can survive in that environment, then feel free to open the box. Otherwise, I strongly recommend you keep it shut. I have no doubt that I can deal with it. I'd prefer it, in fact. It's a lot of work for the mods, though, so I've settled on handling it my own way. I'd prefer not to have to. Be careful what you wish for, you may get it.
 
You're right. This is simply about the fact that if warm objects radiate in IR, and they do, and CO2 absorbs IR, and it does, and the absorbed IR is re-radiated in a random direction, and it is, then CO2 in the atmosphere will raise the equilibrium point of the Earth's energy budget, and thus the temperature, and the more CO2, the higher the equilibrium point will be.

Clouds, albedo, the water cycle, and the warming effects of water vapor are irrelevant to this point. This is about what we should expect to see when we examine temperature data series. If we don't see it, then some very basic physics is just plain flat wrong. We're not talking about leading-edge stuff here; we're talking about physics that's been known since the eighteenth century.

Just to be sure we are talking about the same thing here.

The challenge was no more or less than what was stated, to show and actual correlation or relation between actual temperatures (tropospheric, sea surface, giss, pretty much you pick it) and atmospheric CO2 concentration (again, this is pretty open - Mauna Loa, Antartica, historical CO2 series from chemical analysis in the 19th and early 20th century, ice core data, etc).

I'm not in disagreement with you about the measured properties of CO2 as a gas in the laboratory. But you wished to use that to logically infer the behavior of CO2 in the atmosphere. Obviously, in the atmosphere, these other factors do enter in. Also, even in the absence of these various water cycle components, there is the mixture of gases present, emission and re emission, broadening of the spectrum, path length, and so forth. Not that simple to go from the lab to the real world.

Just some actual relation between some sets of data is what is requested.
Alternately, a proof that that was impossible might be interesting, but then we would be going down the road of discussing "the major driver in radiative forcing" according to the IPCC as being impossible to prove. That's very, very anti-IPCC. That sure sounds like more of a skeptic's argument, but it won't bother me.

By the way, these several "challenges" that I posted on starting this thread are not the limit of the thread. It's just intended to be about the scientific theories and hypothesis related to GW/AGW, anything from consensus to skeptical to hairbrained. Theories that are believed 100% proven might be re examined from the initial premises back on up. (like the issue of CO2 in ice cores now being discussed)

Just added those Challenges in on the first post to get it started.
 
BTW, if civility is actually enforced on this thread and all like it, no one would be happier than I. But if you bring that down, be aware that I will report every slightest subtlest dig, every accusation of dishonesty, every imputation of motive other than getting at the truth, and any other deviation from strictest discussion of the exact scientific facts, as presented in reliable peer-reviewed literature, whether those digs, accusations, or imputations are about me or anyone else whatsoever. If you believe you can survive in that environment, then feel free to open the box. Otherwise, I strongly recommend you keep it shut. I have no doubt that I can deal with it. I'd prefer it, in fact. It's a lot of work for the mods, though, so I've settled on handling it my own way. I'd prefer not to have to. Be careful what you wish for, you may get it.

It seemed like it might be an interesting foray, into the actual science and discussion of it for a change. Time will tell.
 
The first 40 pages of this approximately 120-page "paper" are spent proving that the greenhouse effect cannot possibly work the same way as a real greenhouse does, a conclusion no one in their right mind would argue.

You noticed that too. If they put all the hand waving going on to create papers like this, we'd have enough cooling happening to stop AGW.
 
It seemed like it might be an interesting foray, into the actual science and discussion of it for a change. Time will tell.

By which time it will all be moot anyway. Mission accomplished. The free enterprise system that could not do anything to prevent AGW, will magically spring to life and solve any problems that result.
 
By which time it will all be moot anyway. Mission accomplished. The free enterprise system that could not do anything to prevent AGW, will magically spring to life and solve any problems that result.

AUP, if you don't have the background to continue in this discussion, you may be excused. Just-so statements won't do here. The connection between the free enterprise system, or any economic/political system and planetary warming is what we're discussing here.

You've just taken a handful of leaps of faith here.
 
:confused: Have you read this paper? What hand-waving?

As Schneibster said, the first part of the paper goes on about how an actual greenhouse is not like the greenhouse effect. The scientists all know that, the paper is just carrying on and wasting time about something that there is no argument about. Hand waving.

It's just their way of trying to put the concept into terms that people will understand, since the end effect is the same, that of trapping heat.
 
Hmm.... I have (what seems to me) a realistic expectation not that every cubic centimeter of the atmosphere might be measured, but that some, at differing heights above ground and composition, might be actually measured. And that from that empirical data, it might be possible to make a statement about atmospheric warming, and the relation of the CO2 component to that.
Given that precisely this has been done, and quite a lot more, I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. Ever heard of CARIBIC or AMATRAS? Here is a relevant quote from the AMATRAS site:
http://www.jal-foundation.or.jp/html/shintaikikansokue/kyukansoku(E).htm
"Between April 1993 and December 2005, the JAL Foundation and Japan Airlines have observed the concentration of greenhouse gases in the upper atmosphere from Australia to Japan. Air samples were collected approximately two times per month and the data was analyzed by the Meteorological Research Institute. Many insights were gained into the fluctuating concentration and atmospheric circulation of CO2, methane (CH4) and carbon monoxide (CO) in the upper atmosphere (approximate altitude 10,000 meters) of the southern and northern hemispheres.
These observations were the first to be conducted over a large area and at a high frequency using scheduled commercial airliners. Similar observations using commercial airliners (airbus) began in Europe, with France and Germany at the core. (For detailed information, see Previous Observations)."

Here.

The CARIBIC project is similar; more information is available here. Evaluations of the accuracy of satellite spectrometry measurements are being made using this data.

CARIBIC has been in continuous operation since 1997. AMATRAS operated from 1993 to 2005, when the aircraft equipped with the instrument packages reached their end of useful life; they have been replaced and a new program is underway. There is another program called MOZAIC, being run from France, but they are concentrating on O3 (ozone) and halocarbons.

Do you really imagine that balloon and aircraft data have not been taken, not to mention satellite data in three or four different ways, ground data, and other sources (towers, mountain peaks, ...)? Remember, AR4 is compiled from other reports; it does not gather original data on its own, nor does it draw conclusions that were not already drawn in the papers it was compiled from. A cross reference of papers spawned from AMATRAS and CARIBIC data and papers listed in the references sections of AR4 shows that this data is being used by the IPCC; this is to be expected.

So what you're asking for, has been done, and the results are summarized in AR4, which you've not read enough of to find that out.

This has been discussed from a number of points of view, and there isn't any hidden trick or gotcha.
Other than the fact that what you claim hasn't been done, actually has been done, and you've ignored it because you don't like the results.

It's just a simple challenge to locate actual empirical atmospheric research.
There it is.

Alternately, there has been a lot of discussion as to why this might not be possible to be done. I'm not sure I agree with that.
I certainly don't, considering as how it appears it actually has been done. Not cc by cc; but this is some pretty good data, and more importantly, it allows verification of satellite methods which are much more comprehensive; and that, too, has been done.

The table of contents of the IPCC documentation has a lot of good stuff, but isn't any more an answer to this question than one could say that the table of contents to a physics book answered a physics problem.
See, what you want, it's been done. It's just your ideological blinders that are keeping you from seeing it. Now, I've done your research for you. Go do some of your own. It's all there.

A great deal of the trouble I have with all this is that because you seem to believe that there's some giant conspiracy to suppress the truth, you don't go looking for actual science being done, because your expectation is that you won't find it. You're wrong.

By the way, I like being on my own.:D
Fine, then do something other than sit around in a basement dreaming up conspiracy theories. Do a little research outside your comfort zone, and take a look at the really obvious data that's out there. There's a reason the scientific consensus is AGW; it's not a plot, it's not a lie, and it's not someone trying to bolster their career with scare tactics. It's real, it's happening, and it's time to do something about it.
 
As Schneibster said, the first part of the paper goes on about how an actual greenhouse is not like the greenhouse effect. The scientists all know that, the paper is just carrying on and wasting time about something that there is no argument about. Hand waving.

So, the answer is that you have not read it. I seriously doubt that schneibster has read it either as his "rebuttal" is too perfunctory. For the record, neither have I. I'm just confirming in my own mind who here is really after fact and who is merely posing.

I must almost remind you that the paper was written by a scientist so falling back on a false belief that "the scientist knows" is ignoring the facts. To date, I have seen no rigorous treatment of the subject of AGW, in or outside the IPCC report. You have the index, you find it for me.

It's just their way of trying to put the concept into terms that people will understand, since the end effect is the same, that of trapping heat.

So, you accept dumbed-down stuff? Do you know what that makes you?
 
The first 40 pages of this approximately 120-page "paper" are spent proving that the greenhouse effect cannot possibly work the same way as a real greenhouse does, a conclusion no one in their right mind would argue.

The remainder falls on its face when someone naively asks, "Then why isn't the Earth's surface the same temperature as the Moon's?"

Next.

I'm not even saying Gerlich is correct as much is admittingly out of my domain not being a physicist and all, but you provided absolutely nothing substantive to refute his paper. If he's wrong, then specify exactly what it is. Pick a few excerpts, for example this:
Depending on the particular school and the degree of popularization, the assumption that the atmosphere is transparent for visible light but opaque for infrared radiation is supposed to lead to
* a warming of the Earth's surface and/or
* a warming of the lower atmosphere and/or
* a warming of a certain layer of the atmosphere and/or
* a slow-down of the natural cooling of the Earth's surface
and so forth.
Unfortunately, there is no source in the literature, where the greenhouse effect is introduced in harmony with the scientic standards of theoretical physics. As already emphasized, the "supplement" to Kittel's book on thermal physics [92] only refers to the IPCC assessments [23, 25]. Prominent global climatologists (as well as "climate sceptics") often present their ideas in handbooks, encyclopedias, and in secondary and tertiary literature.

Ok folks, you read here first. Schneibster thinks the earth's atmosphere works the same way as a real glass greenhouse; remember that when he comes back trying to explain how. Of course he's expected to provide the basic university physics to support his argument.

He must show earth's greenhouse effect modulates convection since that his claim:
greenhouse effect cannot possibly work the same way as a real greenhouse does, a conclusion no one in their right mind would argue.

I think most could figure out why the temperature of earth's surface is not the same as the moon.
 
Last edited:
Given that precisely this has been done, and quite a lot more, I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. Ever heard of CARIBIC or AMATRAS? Here is a relevant quote from the AMATRAS site:
http://www.jal-foundation.or.jp/html/shintaikikansokue/kyukansoku(E).htm
"Between April 1993 and December 2005, the JAL Foundation and Japan Airlines have observed the concentration of greenhouse gases in the upper atmosphere from Australia to Japan. Air samples were collected approximately two times per month and the data was analyzed by the Meteorological Research Institute.

mhaze's question was about temperature, not gas concentrations.

Next.
 
Given that precisely this has been done, and quite a lot more, I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.

Those are interesting studies, they obviously have a lot of use in atmospheric studies. No relation to sampling temperature from air as it heats up or cools down, though.

Did I miss something?
 
I'm not even saying Gerlich is correct as much is admittingly out of my domain not being a physicist and all, but you provided absolutely nothing substantive to refute his paper. If he's wrong, then specify exactly what it is. Pick a few excerpts, for example this:

I think I understand what you are getting at here. Are you suggesting using Gerlich's paper as the basis for discussion? Not as a right or wrong or pro AGW or anti AGW? Just as a document that could be gone through, argument by argument, and the reasonableness of each examined?

I've read it and think it would be excellent from that point of view - there are things everyone could agree with, some would disagree, some would agree all over the place. And it's somewhat quantitative in its approach.

Is that the method, more or less? If so, one interesting question would be could one find quantitative errors in the paper. Finding "strawmen" would indeed be easy.
 
I'm not even saying Gerlich is correct as much is admittingly out of my domain not being a physicist and all, but you provided absolutely nothing substantive to refute his paper. If he's wrong, then specify exactly what it is.

You provide a paper, with no knowledge at all as to it's authority or correctness, and just ask people to disprove it. Can you see the problem with that approach?
 
So, the answer is that you have not read it.
A hundred and ten pages, the first sixty of which show the blindingly obvious? No, I'm not particularly interested in reading a paper written by a master of the obvious. I prefer papers that are a bit more, shall we say, to the point. Particularly when I find this in the first sentence of the abstract:

"The atmospheric greenhouse effect, an idea that authors trace back to the traditional works of Fourier 1824, Tyndall 1861, and Arrhenius 1896, and which is still supported in global climatology, essentially describes a fictitious mechanism, in which a planetary atmosphere acts as a heat pump driven by an environment that is radiatively interacting with but radiatively equilibrated to the atmospheric system."

First, "fictitious" is unscientific; this abstract isn't being published in any peer-reviewed journal with that in there. Second, the proposed mechanism is not a heat pump; nothing like it. Third, have you parsed "a planetary atmosphere acts as a heat pump driven by an environment that is... radiatively equilibrated to the atmospheric system" when that environment is OPEN SPACE, that is, PURE VACUUM? Excuse me, what temperature is a vacuum? Hello? It's ABSOLUTE ZERO. If the atmosphere were in equilibrium with a vacuum, it would be snowing oxygen.

Complete kak.
 
Second, the proposed mechanism is not a heat pump; nothing like it. Third, have you parsed "a planetary atmosphere acts as a heat pump driven by an environment that is... radiatively equilibrated to the atmospheric system" when that environment is OPEN SPACE, that is, PURE VACUUM? Excuse me, what temperature is a vacuum? Hello? It's ABSOLUTE ZERO. If the atmosphere were in equilibrium with a vacuum, it would be snowing oxygen.

Complete kak.

Debunking Gore science yes, its an unpleasant task, but one that's got to be done.
 
OK, I screwed up in my first reply to you. The claims I'm investigating are the "found assumptions" about ice coring data as listed on p. 5 in Jaworowski's paper "CO2: the greatest scientific scandal of our time". He gives references for these assumptions, which I hope to find. I probably won't find some of them but I'm optimistic.

Jaworowski also gives references for publications which he maintains disprove these assumptions which I also hope to review.

An email address would solve this nicely.
 
Just to be sure we are talking about the same thing here.

The challenge was no more or less than what was stated, to show and actual correlation or relation between actual temperatures (tropospheric, sea surface, giss, pretty much you pick it) and atmospheric CO2 concentration (again, this is pretty open - Mauna Loa, Antartica, historical CO2 series from chemical analysis in the 19th and early 20th century, ice core data, etc).
I chose to show that the assumptions on which your challenge is based are invalid instead, and did so successfully.

I'm not in disagreement with you about the measured properties of CO2 as a gas in the laboratory. But you wished to use that to logically infer the behavior of CO2 in the atmosphere. Obviously, in the atmosphere, these other factors do enter in
Obviously, they do not. You have not shown any means by which any of these factors can influence the absorption and re-emission of photons by CO2 molecules. You have mentioned a bunch of factors that you claim, without any basis in known physical law, can do this; but if they could, then we would have to rewrite all the physics textbooks. I will demonstrate.

the mixture of gases present
By what means will this mixture affect the absorption and re-emission of photons by one component of the mixture? If they could, how would spectroscopy be capable of determining the composition of such mixtures? Consider the wealth of data available on the composition of molecular cloud complexes, thousands of light years away, using starlight that traverses them. These are mixtures of dust and gas. How is it that we know what they are made of if the mixture changes the spectrum? And if the spectrum isn't changed, then precisely what is it you think is different?

emission and re emission
Well, emission and re-emission are involved; but how do you propose that emission and re-emission will interfere with emission and re-emission? :confused:

broadening of the spectrum
Broadening of the spectrum is a statistical effect, and furthermore one that makes CO2 MORE effective as a greenhouse gas, since it means that a wider range of frequencies can be absorbed and re-emitted. How does this interfere with that absorption and re-emission?

path length
How does path length have anything to do with this? In scale, on a 20-foot globe, the atmosphere is thinner than a coat of paint. From any point in the atmosphere, about half of the directions are Earth, and half are space. Did you have a point? Not to mention, how precisely would path length influence the absorption and re-emission of photons by CO2 molecules?

and so forth.
What "and so forth?" None of these held water; why should anyone believe that any others you might come up with would? Presumably you chose the ones you thought were the most likely to be applicable already.

Not that simple to go from the lab to the real world.
As it turns out, it looks like it is. You certainly haven't shown it's not here.

Just some actual relation between some sets of data is what is requested.
It's unnecessary.

Alternately, a proof that that was impossible might be interesting, but then we would be going down the road of discussing "the major driver in radiative forcing" according to the IPCC as being impossible to prove. That's very, very anti-IPCC. That sure sounds like more of a skeptic's argument, but it won't bother me.
See, you're doing it again. This information is what the AR4 IS. The evidence is detailed and comprehensive. If you really want to talk about the science, AR4 is a good overview, and all the papers that make it up are referenced at the end of each chapter; chapter 2, the one I referenced, has twelve pages of references, at about three lines each, in double-column format. This isn't five papers; it's literally thousands. When we talk about consensus, understand that we're not talking about twelve geophysicists in a lab someplace; we're talking about hundreds or thousands of scientists, and thousands or tens of thousands of researchers, cranking papers out regularly. The literature in this area constitutes reading for the next several years.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom