Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

So far, you've refuted neither LR's post nor the basis publication. Glass is not what causes the greenhouse effect, even in greenhouses. Perhaps you've never written a technical criticism?
Ad hom noted. At least this time you're providing some evidence, however incomplete and incorrect it may be.

The warming of a real greenhouse is due to two things:
1. The glass admits energy.
2. Once the energy warms the contents of the greenhouse, the greenhouse retains the warmed air, which would otherwise escape and cool those contents.

So it appears that the glass DOES cause the greenhouse effect in greenhouses, by means of transmission of radiation, and physical entrapment of heated air. Which means that instead of failing to provide any evidence at all, this time you just provided evidence that was wrong.
 
Perhaps you've never written a technical criticism?

Somewhere I had a list of standards for critiques of engineering work. Standards do have their uses.

Gerlich is on the table, and the ice core data stitching. I think Challenges #1 and #3 are off for now (???), and I asked for a little delay in Schneib's interest in Singer and Cycles. One thing about JREF threads, because they do not handle subthreads, there can be a number of conversations at the same time. It can get confusing.

I'd like to add another issue related to IPCC AR4, but maybe it should wait until we've dug into the ice core and Holocene CO2 levels a bit?

Come to think of it, the IPCC issue could be combined with the ice core/Mauna Loa data stitching issue.
 
Strawman argument noted; I never said tens of thousands of contributors.

Here ya go.

This isn't five papers; it's literally thousands. When we talk about consensus, understand that we're not talking about twelve geophysicists in a lab someplace; we're talking about hundreds or thousands of scientists, and thousands or tens of thousands of researchers, cranking papers out regularly. The literature in this area constitutes reading for the next several years.


So basically, what we have in this entire post is an ad hominem argument in every paragraph for the ice cream, a bunch of assertions that have no support for the whipped cream, and a strawman to top it off like a cherry. A fallacy sundae. :)

I forgot that questioning you is by necessity an ad hominem attack. But, then, I foget that all you have to do to prevail in a discussion is to proclaim yourself the winner. Too bad, so sad.

I don't fall for the troller trick of making up stupidities just to have the other side do actual work to rebut it. You've made a lot of claims but haven't backed any up. Your understanding of thermodynamics is simplistic, incomplete and oftentimes just wrong. It's low testament to the education system that you have any credibility here at all.

BTW, thanks for mentioning ice cream. It's one of the tangible things we have on this planet that proves your basic premise wrong. Don't bother asking how because I'm not telling. Perhaps someone who has the training, intelligence and likes you will inform you. I only qualify in two of the three categories. You're on your own. :)
 
Ad hom noted. At least this time you're providing some evidence, however incomplete and incorrect it may be.

The warming of a real greenhouse is due to two things:
1. The glass admits energy.
2. Once the energy warms the contents of the greenhouse, the greenhouse retains the warmed air, which would otherwise escape and cool those contents.

So it appears that the glass DOES cause the greenhouse effect in greenhouses, by means of transmission of radiation, and physical entrapment of heated air. Which means that instead of failing to provide any evidence at all, this time you just provided evidence that was wrong.

More evidence still that you don't have a clue about thermodynamics. In a practical way, you're partially right. In a theoretical way, you're so, so off.

Oh, damn, another ad hom! Never ever tell sheib he's wrong!! Bad. bad slime!
 
I forgot that questioning you is by necessity an ad hominem attack. But, then, I foget that all you have to do to prevail in a discussion is to proclaim yourself the winner. Too bad, so sad.
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your claims noted. Here's your New Clue(tm): I never said anything about who wrote the papers.

I don't fall for the troller trick of making up stupidities just to have the other side do actual work to rebut it.
Ad hom noted. Attempt to justify not providing evidence noted.

You've made a lot of claims but haven't backed any up.
Lie noted. I've backed every claim I've made; this is all the response left to you, since you cannot refute any of them.

Your understanding of thermodynamics is simplistic, incomplete and oftentimes just wrong.
My understanding of thermodynamics appears superior to your own, since you don't seem to be aware that the First Law of Thermodynamics is conservation of energy. Ad hom noted.

It's low testament to the education system that you have any credibility here at all.
Ad hom noted.
 
Gerlich is on the table,
Gerlich has been answered, whether you care to admit it or not.

and the ice core data stitching.
What ice core data stitching, and what does data stitching mean?

I think Challenges #1 and #3 are off for now (???), and I asked for a little delay in Schneib's interest in Singer and Cycles. One thing about JREF threads, because they do not handle subthreads, there can be a number of conversations at the same time. It can get confusing.
That's why I combined my answers to all three in one post. I didn't see any request for delay.

I'd like to add another issue related to IPCC AR4, but maybe it should wait until we've dug into the ice core and Holocene CO2 levels a bit?

Come to think of it, the IPCC issue could be combined with the ice core/Mauna Loa data stitching issue.
Maybe if you'd tell us what data stitching is, I'd have some idea what to say in response.
 
I never said anything about who wrote the papers.

Evasion noted.

I've backed every claim I've made; this is all the response left to you, since you cannot refute any of them.

In your own mind, maybe. Your idea of backing up a claim is to completely fail to post supporting data (evidence: info on gas concentrations instead of the subject temperature) then declaring yourself the winner. And, oh, do I have so many responses waiting for you, bobo. At this point, I'm going to be your personal editor, correcting your posts for omissions, evasions and lies.

My understanding of thermodynamics appears superior to your own, since you don't seem to be aware that the First Law of Thermodynamics is conservation of energy.

Uno, dos, tres. Oy, three there are! There are three! Three to me, you see. :)
 
Evasion noted.
Lack of reading comprehension noted.

In your own mind, maybe. Your idea of backing up a claim is to completely fail to post supporting data
Ad hom noted. Lie repeated, and noted again.

(evidence: info on gas concentrations
I posted no information on gas concentrations. Lie noted.

And, oh, do I have so many responses waiting for you, bobo.
Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted.

At this point, I'm going to be your personal editor, correcting your posts for omissions, evasions and lies.
Ad hom noted. Lack of evidence to support your assertions noted.
 
snide, why did you leave out the one that shows you only obey one of three laws of energy? :)
 
snide, why did you leave out the one that shows you only obey one of three laws of energy? :)
Lack of evidence to support your assertion noted.

Not that I have the slightest idea what you're talking about; if you'd have presented some evidence, OTOH, I might have. But far be it from you to exhibit enough rationality to bother to explain elliptical comments, or support anything with actual evidence.
 
Not that I have the slightest idea what you're talking about; if you'd have presented some evidence, OTOH, I might have. But far be it from you to exhibit enough rationality to bother to explain elliptical comments, or support anything with actual evidence.

Well, now you're admitting stuff. I've bolded the admission. There are three laws of energy, snide, not only one. Your hypotheses must conform to all three to be viable. So far, your postulates are consistent with only the first but not the second or the third.

Really, don't take my word for it. Look it up.

What's your favorite flavor of ice cream?
 
That's why I combined my answers to all three in one post. I didn't see any request for delay.

Is it urgent? Why not take a while and mull about it a bit. As I am sure that you noted, these Challenges are not College 101 material.

How about a single, well thought out and documented response, with substantiating links, strong arguments, previously checked and verified.

Well, of course that's just my opinion.
 
I think we've lost him for a while. This happens every time he gets caught off guard. I really should have kept my mouth shut about the 2LOE and 3LOE but, as it is probably the gist of Gerloch's paper, I don't think I've let too much out of the bag here. It really is in everyone's best interest to read through that paper (myself included) with paper and pencil in hand.

Now, back to my world where the earth has the same atmosphere as the moon and we use carbon dioxide to fill light bulbs! Ooops, there's another hint! :)
 
Well, now you're admitting stuff. I've bolded the admission. There are three laws of energy, snide, not only one.
There is a user on this site whose handle is Snide; not usually a poster on SMM&T. I'm sure both s/he and I would appreciate your using our proper handles, whatever the voices in your head tell you to do.

It's immaterial how many laws of thermodynamics there are; and if you think there are only three, you're sadly mistaken.

Your hypotheses must conform to all three to be viable. So far, your postulates are consistent with only the first but not the second or the third.
If you don't know what you're talking about, then it's difficult for anyone else to. Here's a hint: I stated that your assertion broke conservation of energy. I don't need to show that it breaks increase of entropy to a maximum, nor the prohibition on absolute zero, for that to be true.

Really, don't take my word for it. Look it up.
You need not fear that I will take your word for anything, ever.

What's your favorite flavor of ice cream?
Why should I tell you, and why would you care? For that matter, how is that relevant to this conversation, and why are you even sure I like ice cream?
 
I think we've lost him for a while. This happens every time he gets caught off guard.
So now I'm supposed to remain properly attentive so you don't ad hom me? Ad hom noted.

I really should have kept my mouth shut about the 2LOE and 3LOE but, as it is probably the gist of Gerloch's paper, I don't think I've let too much out of the bag here.
There aren't any Laws of Energy, they're Laws of Thermodynamics. And you don't have the correct number of them. Complete lack of knowledge of standard terminology in thermodynamics noted. Conflict of this with prior claims of knowledge in this area noted.

It really is in everyone's best interest to read through that paper (myself included) with paper and pencil in hand.
If you think that reading a proof that the Earth's atmosphere is not covered with glass is worth your time, then have at it. I have better things to do.

Now, back to my world where the earth has the same atmosphere as the moon and we use carbon dioxide to fill light bulbs! Ooops, there's another hint! :)
Now, from a claim in the paper, it becomes MY claim. Lack of reading comprehension noted.
 
Is it urgent? Why not take a while and mull about it a bit. As I am sure that you noted, these Challenges are not College 101 material.
Yep. More like gradeschool material than college.

How about a single, well thought out and documented response, with substantiating links, strong arguments, previously checked and verified.
You mean like this one? Been there, done that, got the t-shirt, used it for an oil rag.
 
Yep. More like gradeschool material than college. You mean like this one? Been there, done that, got the t-shirt, used it for an oil rag.

Well then, if you've answered these Challenges to your own satisfaction, decided you don't have any interest in Gerlich, do you have any more interest in this thread? Do you have anything you'd like to contribute?
 
I read it, liked it, and went on to reading other things. Gee, if I had spent all my time debating and arguing about whether something was worth reading, I never would get to read anything.

The more Warmers deride something and say it isn't worth reading, the more people will probably go read it.

I haven't heard much in the way of a serious rebuttal to Gerlich so far.

Surely one can be formulated?

But you won't read the IPCC report? :confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom