Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

OK, I screwed up in my first reply to you. The claims I'm investigating are the "found assumptions" about ice coring data as listed on p. 5 in Jaworowski's paper "CO2: the greatest scientific scandal of our time". He gives references for these assumptions, which I hope to find. I probably won't find some of them but I'm optimistic.

Jaworowski also gives references for publications which he maintains disprove these assumptions which I also hope to review.

Relevant comment from ClimateAudit -
Gunnar says: August 3rd, 2007 at 4:03 pm
I consider Jaworowski an expert in ice cores. Another point about ice core data that is quite subtle, yet profound. The average spacing of vostok samples is like 1400 years. This is latched onto a sample per minute dataset, ignoring known accurate measurements over the last 100 years, without a second thought about integrity. And then claims are made about historical C02 maximums. This means that there is only like a 3.4% confidence level for the statement that the present CO2 trend is unprecedented in the last 420,000 years.
​
Looks like his calculation of confidence level is reasonable. Do you see any premises that would invalidate this? (Leaving aside the physical evidence that we've discussed and the problem with ice cores and just looking at confidence).
 
You mean like this one? Been there, done that, got the t-shirt, used it for an oil rag.

Ah, the IPCC report again. You've already acknowledged that that report is purely interpretive using other's data. No corroboration. We're after evidence here or did you miss that part, Mr. Comprehension?
 
Ah, the IPCC report again. You've already acknowledged that that report is purely interpretive using other's data. No corroboration. We're after evidence here or did you miss that part, Mr. Comprehension?
There were three points addressed in that post. Lack of reading comprehension noted.

The IPCC report is a good starting point because the papers that have the science in them can be found from its references sections; once those papers are available, further references can be searched for using keywords from those papers. That's called research, a pursuit you seem unfamiliar with. That's pretty surprising in someone who claims to be a working scientist.
 
Last edited:
There is a user on this site whose handle is Snide; not usually a poster on SMM&T. I'm sure both s/he and I would appreciate your using our proper handles, whatever the voices in your head tell you to do.

You failed to notice that the other one is capitalized. You don't rate that.

It's immaterial how many laws of thermodynamics there are

A stundie, if I ever saw one. But, but, but only the first one applies!! :boggled:
and if you think there are only three, you're sadly mistaken.

Did a search. Found some sites that had only two, combining the second and third. Others had the three. Can you produce a site with more than three Laws of Energy or Thermodynamics? Call them whatever you want.

Here's a hint: I stated that your assertion broke conservation of energy. I don't need to show that it breaks increase of entropy to a maximum, nor the prohibition on absolute zero, for that to be true.

You are very sloppy with your terminology. A statement of X does not make X true. You showed nothing but, per usual, that does not stop you from declaring yourself the winner.

Why should I tell you, and why would you care? For that matter, how is that relevant to this conversation, and why are you even sure I like ice cream?

It's more relevant than you think. You're not a deep thinker so I'm sure you won't get it until I spell it out in detail at a later time. Remember Newton? Apples and gravity have nothing to do with each other, right?
 
There were three points addressed in that post. Lack of reading comprehension noted.

I'm not addressing all three point, Mr. Comprehension, just the one. So, you are now arguing that the IPCC report is a complete and comprehensive scientific work that rigorously establishes that global warming exists, that it can be measured and that it can be traced directly back to human activity. Is that whay you're saying? A yes or no answer will suffice. Please, no more BS.

Ah, you added an afterthought (what that was that came before, I have no idea). Selective citation is an awful way of finding the truth, don't you think? Have you looked at the raw data? Were the methods reasonable? Was bias controlled? Is the interpretation solid or does the summary point out that NONE OF THE MODELS HAVE BEEN VALIDATED? See, that's research. Trying to bully people into believing something that you do but is baseless is called religion.
 
Last edited:
Ah, the IPCC report again. You've already acknowledged that that report is purely interpretive using other's data. No corroboration. We're after evidence here or did you miss that part, Mr. Comprehension?

If you really wanted to, you could just read it, then go to the references it uses to make it's claims, rather than just demanding people here serve everything up to you on a plate.

As demanded, scientists have put a lot of time and effort into researching the basic science behind AGW. For your convenience, and their own, they have collated references to all that science, and summarised it for you. If you don't want to read their summary, please, go and read all the references.
 
A stundie, if I ever saw one. But, but, but only the first one applies!! :boggled:
So you're claiming that the limitation on achieving absolute zero applies to this conversation? How would that be, precisely? Lack of evidence to support your assertion noted.

Did a search. Found some sites that had only two, combining the second and third. Others had the three. Can you produce a site with more than three Laws of Energy or Thermodynamics? Call them whatever you want.
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/thermo/thereq.html

Note that the source is the Department of Physics and Astronomy of the College of Arts and Sciences at Georgia State University.

For someone who claims to have training in thermodynamics, you are remarkably ill-informed.

You are very sloppy with your terminology. A statement of X does not make X true. You showed nothing but, per usual, that does not stop you from declaring yourself the winner.
Let's reiterate that conversation:
quenching
quenching excites the quenching molecule. In other words, either the heat gets re-radiated, back toward Earth's surface in half the cases, or the heat stays in the atmosphere, right there where the quenching interaction occurred.

Conservation of energy, remember?
Your training in photochemistry is lacking.
Implicit assertion that energy conservation laws are not obeyed in photochemistry noted. :rolleyes:
You never responded. It doesn't look like a statement to me; it looks more like a series of eminently supportable statements of well-known physical law. Would you like me to present proof that photochemistry obeys conservation of energy?

It's more relevant than you think. You're not a deep thinker so I'm sure you won't get it until I spell it out in detail at a later time. Remember Newton? Apples and gravity have nothing to do with each other, right?
So basically you haven't got anything that has anything to do with any branch of science, so you're Laying the Big Trap for me. Oh oh, I'm all a-tremble. Do try to stick to the subject, won't you?
 
So you're claiming that the limitation on achieving absolute zero applies to this conversation? How would that be, precisely? Lack of evidence to support your assertion noted.

http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/thermo/thereq.html

Note that the source is the Department of Physics and Astronomy of the College of Arts and Sciences at Georgia State University.

For someone who claims to have training in thermodynamics, you are remarkably ill-informed.

Interesting. Like much of science, the laws of thermodynamics are a work in progress.

  • Zeroth law of thermodynamics
    be6d8f9aa9f6c130460804182c283287.png
  • First law of thermodynamics
    b575e07b92b3f4eeb118097cbdb9b2d7.png
  • Second law of thermodynamics
    ba00413207a92ef911f232953fa2ff57.png
  • Third law of thermodynamics
    ad3748ff72938a80f20c5d01c26d6de9.png
  • Onsager reciprocal relations - sometimes called the Fourth Law of Thermodynamics
  • a8575739632e5c96d8299f727d86c586.png
    ;
  • 561c885b1cd4e5e0497fe62a93427d02.png
    .
From wikipedia

That makes five.
 
If you really wanted to, you could just read it, then go to the references it uses to make it's claims, rather than just demanding people here serve everything up to you on a plate.

As demanded, scientists have put a lot of time and effort into researching the basic science behind AGW. For your convenience, and their own, they have collated references to all that science, and summarised it for you. If you don't want to read their summary, please, go and read all the references.

Yes, I know, AUP. I plan to do just that. I'm going to start with the ice core data to see what's up there. I'll report what I find.

A lot of work has gone into GW and AGW. I must confess that, if I find that the science just isn't all that good, that still would not disprove AGW, right? It just disproves the current hypothesis. But that's a discussion for later, after I've done the research.

Thanks for your thoughts.
 
Interestingly, even in the area of the notorious 2LOT. Not long ago, someone came up with the fluctuation theorem, a mathematical theorem (which, unlike a scientific theory, is subject to a rigorous proof) that reduces to the 2LOT in the limit of large systems. This has interesting implications, such as the fact that it is possible to construct experiments that use small systems that can temporarily violate the 2LOT; and the smaller the system is, the longer it can do it.
 
Interesting. Like much of science, the laws of thermodynamics are a work in progress.

From wikipedia

That makes five.

Thanks for posting that because the link that I clicked in bleibster's message did not take me there.

He's being disingenuous. The zeroth law is trivial and that's why it's called the zeroth law. It was coined for people like bleibster by St. Franis of the Bleeding Obvious (IIRC). The last one is called the combined law and is derived from dH = -Tds. It's only considered a law of thermodynamics when one is losing an argument.

Don't go into any bars and start telling people there are five laws of thermodynamics.
 
And yet another post goes by, and yet another set of assertions goes unsupported. In addition, it appears you have trouble operating a browser. You have all sorts of trouble with technical things, don't you?
 
You never responded. It doesn't look like a statement to me; it looks more like a series of eminently supportable statements of well-known physical law. Would you like me to present proof that photochemistry obeys conservation of energy?

bobo, I did tell you that you were making unwarranted assumptions, right? Do you believe that excited carbon dioxide must emit a photon in the infrared? That's another yes/no answer that I'm asking from you but have noted that you haven't given any.

So basically you haven't got anything that has anything to do with any branch of science, so you're Laying the Big Trap for me. Oh oh, I'm all a-tremble. Do try to stick to the subject, won't you?

The only big trap is the one you yourself have already written. I'm tired of you. Go away.
 
And yet another post goes by, and yet another set of assertions goes unsupported. In addition, it appears you have trouble operating a browser. You have all sorts of trouble with technical things, don't you?

Hehe. I just love it when you're angry. I bet you look as ugly as your avatar right now!
 
bobo, I did tell you that you were making unwarranted assumptions, right? Do you believe that excited carbon dioxide must emit a photon in the infrared? That's another yes/no answer that I'm asking from you but have noted that you haven't given any.
Heh, honestly, you're more fun than a sack of puppies.

Excited how? CO2 has several different modes in its spectrum, some of which are in the UV. What's important isn't what CO2 can do; what's important is what the energy of the photons it's exposed to are.

You're having another one of those conversations in your head.

The only big trap is the one you yourself have already written. I'm tired of you. Go away.
I think the most amusing thing about all of this is your accusation that I am a bully.

Entomology is fascinating. Disgusting sometimes, but fascinating nevertheless.
 
Relevant comment from ClimateAudit -
Gunnar says: August 3rd, 2007 at 4:03 pm​

I consider Jaworowski an expert in ice cores. Another point about ice core data that is quite subtle, yet profound. The average spacing of vostok samples is like 1400 years. This is latched onto a sample per minute dataset, ignoring known accurate measurements over the last 100 years, without a second thought about integrity. And then claims are made about historical C02 maximums. This means that there is only like a 3.4% confidence level for the statement that the present CO2 trend is unprecedented in the last 420,000 years.​
Looks like his calculation of confidence level is reasonable. Do you see any premises that would invalidate this? (Leaving aside the physical evidence that we've discussed and the problem with ice cores and just looking at confidence).

Sorry to keep you waiting. I was ahem otherwise occupied.

I must preface that I've only seen a few graphs but I have to say that the practice of combining data sets generated by different methods is fraught with danger. In my experience, I have not seen it successfully done. I would have to agree with Gunnar that one can't just glue one data set onto another without fully investigating the ruggedness and the variability of each method against the other. That's an enormous task and, most often, we wind up analyzing all samples with the better method.

I ran into this last week on one of my studies. A contract researcher sent me a report. I looked at the analytical portion and noticed that some recoveries were in the low 60% range but the rest were much improved (85-102%). I dug and dug through the report and found what I was looking for in the raw data. The analyst had changed the analytical subsample from 25g to 10g and figured that 15g is not such a big difference. So, I lectured. They redid the sets that were low. I told them that anything that improves the efficiency of a method by 20% is, by definition, a large enough difference to make the two sets of data incompatible.

The rule of thumb is that any change worth making gives you a new method. No, cant' do that. Not allowed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom