Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Those are interesting studies, they obviously have a lot of use in atmospheric studies. No relation to sampling temperature from air as it heats up or cools down, though.
What does "sampling temperature from air as it heats up or cools down" mean? How precisely do you propose to gather enough temperature samples, other than using a satellite, which has been done, to give a reasonable idea of the temperature of the air? Do you have any reason to believe that the infrared spectroscopy done from satellites (which has been checked using balloon data) is incorrect?

Did I miss something?
Clearly.
 
A hundred and ten pages, the first sixty of which show the blindingly obvious? No, I'm not particularly interested in reading a paper written by a master of the obvious.

So my suspicion was correct. You haven't read the paper. Yet you call it a crock. Now, that's not very scientific.

Really, if you haven't read it and you don't want to or can't because you're too busy, just say so. No one will think worse of you for a little honesty. It leaves a matter unresolved but we can revisit it once someone has a specific point from it that we can debate. But, please, don't dismiss a paper you haven't read. That's a very, very bad habit to get into. Misleading as hell, too.
 
So my suspicion was correct. You haven't read the paper. Yet you call it a crock. Now, that's not very scientific.

Really, if you haven't read it and you don't want to or can't because you're too busy, just say so. No one will think worse of you for a little honesty. It leaves a matter unresolved but we can revisit it once someone has a specific point from it that we can debate. But, please, don't dismiss a paper you haven't read. That's a very, very bad habit to get into. Misleading as hell, too.
To repeat, the first sentence of the abstract is full of misstatements; and a skim over the first sixty pages (over half the document) shows that all that is proven is that the Earth's atmosphere isn't a glass-covered enclosure, after sixty pages. There's no point in reading that; it's a waste of electrons.
 
I chose to show that the assumptions on which your challenge is based are invalid instead, and did so successfully.

Get a grip. We don't get to judge our own work in science. Maybe you do where you work but that's not permitted, even in physics.

By what means will this mixture affect the absorption and re-emission of photons by one component of the mixture?

quenching

If they could, how would spectroscopy be capable of determining the composition of such mixtures?

matrix deconvolution of spectroscopic data

Consider the wealth of data available on the composition of molecular cloud complexes, thousands of light years away, using starlight that traverses them. These are mixtures of dust and gas. How is it that we know what they are made of if the mixture changes the spectrum?

Umm...no one said anything about changing a spectrum. The discussion at hand has all to do with abatement of intensity, not shifting of spectra.

And if the spectrum isn't changed, then precisely what is it you think is different?

Efficiency.

Well, emission and re-emission are involved; but how do you propose that emission and re-emission will interfere with emission and re-emission?

quenching is a well known phenomena whereby one molecule interferes with the radiation of another.

Broadening of the spectrum is a statistical effect, and furthermore one that makes CO2 MORE effective as a greenhouse gas, since it means that a wider range of frequencies can be absorbed and re-emitted. How does this interfere with that absorption and re-emission?

No, quenching has only to do with intensity. Scattering is what you're after but that doesn't affect absorption, only emission. Are you sure you're a physicist? This is basic stuff here. Even chemists know this stuff.

This isn't five papers; it's literally thousands. When we talk about consensus, understand that we're not talking about twelve geophysicists in a lab someplace; we're talking about hundreds or thousands of scientists, and thousands or tens of thousands of researchers, cranking papers out regularly. The literature in this area constitutes reading for the next several years.

No, no, no. Stop there. Please post some evidence for these outlandish claims. You're going over the edge here.
 
So my suspicion was correct. You haven't read the paper. Yet you call it a crock. Now, that's not very scientific.

Really, if you haven't read it and you don't want to or can't because you're too busy, just say so. No one will think worse of you for a little honesty. It leaves a matter unresolved but we can revisit it once someone has a specific point from it that we can debate. But, please, don't dismiss a paper you haven't read. That's a very, very bad habit to get into. Misleading as hell, too.

Have you read the first few pages? I have, it takes a while to click, because it seems such an absurd argument to make you wonder why he is making it. He's talking to himself, no-one claims what he is arguing. When you realise in the first few pages what a nutter he his, you then wonder why bother with the rest of it. The IPCC report and science it is based on has never claimed something as crazy as saying that a greenhouse and the greenhouse effect work on the same physical basis, it's just a useful model, like saying plastic balls are like atoms in science class at high school.
 
To repeat, the first sentence of the abstract is full of misstatements; and a skim over the first sixty pages (over half the document) shows that all that is proven is that the Earth's atmosphere isn't a glass-covered enclosure, after sixty pages. There's no point in reading that; it's a waste of electrons.

Since you're repeating yourself, I'll do likewise. If you haven't read it, don't pretend to understand it let alone critique it. If you think I believe that you've even skimmed the paper, you are mistaken.
 
Have you read the first few pages? I have, it takes a while to click, because it seems such an absurd argument to make you wonder why he is making it. He's talking to himself, no-one claims what he is arguing. When you realise in the first few pages what a nutter he his, you then wonder why bother with the rest of it. The IPCC report and science it is based on has never claimed something as crazy as saying that a greenhouse and the greenhouse effect work on the same physical basis, it's just a useful model, like saying plastic balls are like atoms in science class at high school.

Wow, I reply to AUP, schneiber answers. I reply to schneiber, AUP answers.

No, like I said before, I haven't read it. I don't even have it. The post was from David Rodale and I reposted it because it was being ignored. I've noted that David is again being ignored. He's the best source of information about this article so communicate your concerns to him. I'm sorry I can't be of much help here one way or the other.
 
Since I have read the Gerlich paper, here is one criticism.

Gerlich posits that there is no global average temperature, no way to calculate a global average temperature ect.

I've got news for him, all temperatures are averages, and it makes just as much sense to measure the temperature in a room as it does to measure the temperature of a mixture of gases bounded by 2 spheres, even if they are quite large.

I'll let the climatologists figure out how to do that and if they do it consistently, they can come to the conclusion that the earth is warming.

by the way they have done that.

News flash: New York city set a record high temperature yesterday by 15 degrees F.

15 degrees F or 8 degrees C for you modern types.

Something's goin on.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
Not that simple to go from the lab to the real world.
​
As it turns out, it looks like it is. You certainly haven't shown it's not here.
Originally Posted by mhaze
Just some actual relation between some sets of data is what is requested.
​
It's unnecessary.

Obviously, I do not share your opinion that it is unnecessary, and neither do quite a few people. You are welcome to your opinion of course, and there may be quite a few people who share it with you.

The Challenge remains.
 
Since I have read the Gerlich paper, here is one criticism.

Gerlich posits that there is no global average temperature, no way to calculate a global average temperature ect.

I've got news for him, all temperatures are averages, and it makes just as much sense to measure the temperature in a room as it does to measure the temperature of a mixture of gases bounded by 2 spheres, even if they are quite large.

I'll let the climatologists figure out how to do that and if they do it consistently, they can come to the conclusion that the earth is warming.

by the way they have done that.

Is it valid to average together some temperatures from liquid, solid and gases somehow?

That is, temperatures one or two meters above land, temps from buckets scooped from the ocean, temps from ship engine intakes, and temps inferred from satellite?

Say that a gas is 1/500 the molar density of water or landmass. The measure of merit is heat contained in the things measured, right?

Where is the adjustment that gives the sea temperatures 500 times the weight as the measured air temperatures?

So did the climatologists do it right, if there is in fact any way to have done it right?
 
Is it valid to average together some temperatures from liquid, solid and gases somehow?

That is, temperatures one or two meters above land, temps from buckets scooped from the ocean, temps from ship engine intakes, and temps inferred from satellite?

Say that a gas is 1/500 the molar density of water or landmass. The measure of merit is heat contained in the things measured, right?

Where is the adjustment that gives the sea temperatures 500 times the weight as the measured air temperatures?

So did the climatologists do it right, if there is in fact any way to have done it right?

Sophistry.
 
You provide a paper, with no knowledge at all as to it's authority or correctness, and just ask people to disprove it. Can you see the problem with that approach?

Are you saying anyone here is qualified to challenge Gerlich "within the realm of physics"? Are you? Is Schneibster?

Schneibster said this verbatim:
The first 40 pages of this approximately 120-page "paper" are spent proving that the greenhouse effect cannot possibly work the same way as a real greenhouse does, a conclusion no one in their right mind would argue.

He is claiming the greenhouse effect is modulating convection, just as a "real" greenhouse does.

Then you say, with the usual ad hom attack and an added script at the end:
When you realise in the first few pages what a nutter he his, you then wonder why bother with the rest of it. The IPCC report and science it is based on has never claimed something as crazy as saying that a greenhouse and the greenhouse effect work on the same physical basis, it's just a useful model, like saying plastic balls are like atoms in science class at high school.

So it appears you and Schneibster are at odds.

Long winded responses with the intent to look impressive may puff ones ego, but thus far nothing has refuted Gerlich's paper "within the realm of physics".

Scneibster says Gerlich's article is not peer reviewed. Fair enough. Well then, belly up to the bar and provide one that is "within the realm of physics".

Again, here is the excerpt from Gerlich's paper, in which he criticized skeptics for the same thing:
Depending on the particular school and the degree of popularization, the assumption that the atmosphere is transparent for visible light but opaque for infrared radiation is supposed to lead to
* a warming of the Earth's surface and/or
* a warming of the lower atmosphere and/or
* a warming of a certain layer of the atmosphere and/or
* a slow-down of the natural cooling of the Earth's surface
and so forth.
Unfortunately, there is no source in the literature, where the greenhouse effect is introduced in harmony with the scientic standards of theoretical physics. As already emphasized, the "supplement" to Kittel's book on thermal physics [92] only refers to the IPCC assessments [23, 25]. Prominent global climatologists (as well as "climate sceptics") often present their ideas in handbooks, encyclopedias, and in secondary and tertiary literature.
 
Last edited:
Since I have read the Gerlich paper, here is one criticism.

Gerlich posits that there is no global average temperature, no way to calculate a global average temperature ect.

I've got news for him, all temperatures are averages, and it makes just as much sense to measure the temperature in a room as it does to measure the temperature of a mixture of gases bounded by 2 spheres, even if they are quite large.

I haven't read or even seen Gerlich's paper so I can't put your comment in context. What claim does he make regarding global temperature measurements that you have successfully rebutted?

I'll let the climatologists figure out how to do that and if they do it consistently, they can come to the conclusion that the earth is warming.

Agreed that, in such a varied sample as a planet, the key to determining whether or not its temperature is rising is based on consistency of measurement and the selection of sampling points.

News flash: New York city set a record high temperature yesterday by 15 degrees F.

15 degrees F or 8 degrees C for you modern types.

Beware forming an opinion on "one of" observations. There are many places in the world who have had cooler-than-normal temperatures lately. Also, keep in mind that weather records extend back only a few hundred years, at the most.

Something's goin on.

Maybe, maybe not. The point of this thread is whether or not humanity has anything to do with it.
 
Are you saying anyone here is qualified to challenge Gerlich "within the realm of physics"? Are you? Is Schneibster?

Using this logic, none of the AGW deniers here is qualified to challenge climatologists...

He is claiming the greenhouse effect is modulating convection, just as a "real" greenhouse does.

Is english your first language? That might be the source of confusion. He's saying that no one in their right minds would argue with the conclusion that the atmosphere cannot work in the same way as a glasshouse. This is a statment of the obvious, and spending 40 pages on it is at the least superfluous. If the author implies that scientists hold the view that the atmosphere works in the same way as a glasshouse, then it's one of the longest strawmen i've heard of.

So it appears you and Schneibster are at odds.

Doesn't seem like it to me...
 
Using this logic, none of the AGW deniers here is qualified to challenge climatologists...



Is english your first language? That might be the source of confusion. He's saying that no one in their right minds would argue with the conclusion that the atmosphere cannot work in the same way as a glasshouse. This is a statment of the obvious, and spending 40 pages on it is at the least superfluous. If the author implies that scientists hold the view that the atmosphere works in the same way as a glasshouse, then it's one of the longest strawmen i've heard of.



Doesn't seem like it to me...
Belly up buddy.

Does earth's atmosphere modulate convection?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom