Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

It may get a bit technical here, by intent.
Hasn't so far, that I've seen. I've given answers to the three questions you asked, that was about as technical as it got. Haven't seen any response, except a lot of flame warring to try to bury the fact that answers were given. Here they are again:

Unanswered Questions and Challenges
1. A challenge for AGW believers to cite a scientific atmospheric study that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2 in the atmosphere.
Cited. See this post. The link to the overall report, the link to the individual chapter most concerned with this precise matter, and page numbers were given, as well as a quote that is salient to this matter.

2. This is a link to a summary of Singer's theory of the 1,500 year climate cycle, excerpted from his book. Debunk Singer's core theory, of the 1,500 year climate cycle.
A 1500 year cycle that is claimed to be responsible for a warm period now and another 500 years ago. What more debunking is required? A 1500 year cycle claimed to be responsible for a warm period now and another 1500 years ago, now that makes sense. This doesn't.

3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?
Yes. CO2 absorbs infrared radiation, which the Earth's surface re-radiates when heated by the Sun, and re-radiates that infrared radiation in a random direction. Since half of such directions go back to the Earth, this means that approximately half of the radiation that Earth emits as a result of solar heating, that is absorbed by CO2 in the atmosphere, returns to the Earth, and is not lost to space. That means that the Earth is warmer than it would be if there were no CO2. Since an increase in the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere increases the chance that infrared photons moving through the atmosphere will be absorbed by a CO2 molecule, it also means that as the percentage of CO2 in the atmosphere rises, so does the temperature of the Earth.

Simple, easy, obvious. None of the research for any of these points took more than ten minutes.
 
No, actually, you claimed I had said it, and I didn't. Whether I said something equivalent is not the point.

I thought you were gone. Why do I always attract the nutjobs? So, now you admit you did say something equivalent. So, I didn't lie? News to me. Really, I would lie if you would just go away. Can you give me another opportunity? You can even choose the lie. Something like "Schmeibster is right." Would that do?

You didn't say I'd said something equivalent. If you're going to lie, at least make it something that's a little bit more difficult to prove you're lying about than that.

Sorry to make it so difficult for you. What exactly would it take to be rid of you? Really, at this point, selling my own grandmom into slavery would be considered, 'cept she's dead. Do you take dead offerings?

By the way, stoichiometric refers to the proportions of compounds that react with one another and the proportions of compounds that result, not to the relationship of two variables that change in step with one another. The term is restricted to chemistry, and has nothing to do with thermodynamics. See the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry's Gold Book definition of it here. So it looks like YOU don't know the definition yourself, since you were applying it to heat, which is not a chemical compound.

Heh. Stoichiometry also refers to the excitation of compounds by photons. CO2 + hv ---> CO2*. Sorry to bring your cherry picking down, bobo. How do you think photochemistry keeps track of reactions? Magic? You really are almost laughable. The almost refers to you being pitiable.

As I've told you before, you're out of your depth here. I did photochemistry research in school so I know you're just a poser when it comes to chemistry. Unfortunately for you, chemistry is the operative tool in discerning the formation and fate of excited carbon dioxide. Now, won't you please run along and tend to your quanta? You have nothing to offer here. The "deniers" here are scientists so we're not likely to succumb to your pathological efforts to browbeat us based on your knowledge of quantum mechanics. We're not buying. Go away.
 
So, now you admit you did say something equivalent.
Nope. Like I said, reading comprehension problems.

Heh. Stoichiometry also refers to the excitation of compounds by photons. CO2 + hv ---> CO2*. Sorry to bring your cherry picking down, bobo. How do you think photochemistry keeps track of reactions? Magic? You really are almost laughable. The almost refers to you being pitiable.
Reference? Mine is the IUPAC Gold Book. Do you consider that to be another of those books comparable to von Daniken, or an argument from authority?

As I've told you before, you're out of your depth here. I did photochemistry research in school so I know you're just a poser when it comes to chemistry.
Actually, I haven't brought it up before, but you seem unaware of sources and books that I have a lot of trouble understanding how someone would make it through a course in physical chemistry without being familiar with. Is this just another one of those little pieces of dishonesty you seem so comfortable with? It appears so.

Unfortunately for you, chemistry is the operative tool in discerning the formation and fate of excited carbon dioxide.
Oh, really? That's interesting. Since it involves photons being absorbed and re-emitted by electrons, I would have said QED was far more applicable. What precisely do you claim is the chemical change induced by the absorption of a photon by a CO2 molecule? And if there is no chemical change, then what precisely does it have to do with chemistry?

Now, won't you please run along and tend to your quanta? You have nothing to offer here. The "deniers" here are scientists so we're not likely to succumb to your pathological efforts to browbeat us based on your knowledge of quantum mechanics. We're not buying. Go away.
No, thanks, I think I'll stick around. It's amusing.
 
Nope. Like I said, reading comprehension problems.

Too bad Why are you bothering me with your problems?

Reference? Mine is the IUPAC Gold Book. Do you consider that to be another of those books comparable to von Daniken, or an argument from authority?

Don't mean to take you over the hedge here but the Gold Book is still in draft and is targetted for people like you. It's pablum. You would have to access specialty journals for what I'm talking about but that costs money.
Actually, I haven't brought it up before, but you seem unaware of sources and books that I have a lot of trouble understanding how someone would make it through a course in physical chemistry without being familiar with. Is this just another one of those little pieces of dishonesty you seem so comfortable with? It appears so.

Whatever makes you feel good is fine by me, bobo. Would it make you leave if I said yes? Convince yourself of anything you like. All you're doing is confirming your absolute ignorance of the topics and sciences at hand. Again, they're not physics, for which you seem to have a selective hard-on. The rest of us will continue on without you, if it's OK. Hell, even if it's not.

Oh, really? That's interesting. Since it involves photons being absorbed and re-emitted by electrons, I would have said QED was far more applicable. What precisely do you claim is the chemical change induced by the absorption of a photon by a CO2 molecule? And if there is no chemical change, then what precisely does it have to do with chemistry?

You really are clueless. When was physics ever involved in the development of the photographic process? An excited molecule can do more than re-emit, genius. It can undergo rearrangement, dissociation, and so on. Where did you get your chemistry training? Get your money back.

BTW, "QED" stands for "quid est demonstratum" or "that which is demonstrated". You seem to have a real difficult time with lexicon, chemical or otherwise.

No, thanks, I think I'll stick around. It's amusing.

So, you've neither put me on your Ignore List nor quit the thread. I have to point out to you that it qualifies as another lie. You don't seem to mnd issuing them so that's not much of a surprise to me. Nevertheless, if someone else is keeping tabs, here's a +1 for them.
 
Too bad Why are you bothering me with your problems?
This is generally accepted as a childlike tactic from the schoolyard.

Don't mean to take you over the hedge here but the Gold Book is still in draft and is targetted for people like you. It's pablum.
Really? That's interesting. It seems to have been published in two editions so far, the first in 1987 and the second in 1997. It seems to be a standard reference book. It doesn't look like pablum, and "draft" generally refers to works that have not yet been published. Seems you have only the merest nodding acquaintance with the truth, if that. You'll say anything, tell any lie, to "prove" you're "right," won't you? Tell me, how do people generally react when they find that out about you?

You would have to access specialty journals for what I'm talking about but that costs money.
So, of course, you can't provide any links to prove what you say is true. How convenient for you, considering your little problem.

You really are clueless. When was physics ever involved in the development of the photographic process? An excited molecule can do more than re-emit, genius. It can undergo rearrangement, dissociation, and so on. Where did you get your chemistry training? Get your money back.
And CO2 does all those things, right? In the atmosphere, right? I'm sure. Just like it's used in photography. I mean, really. This is like reading something off the timecube site.

BTW, "QED" stands for "quid est demonstratum" or "that which is demonstrated". You seem to have a real difficult time with lexicon, chemical or otherwise.
It also stands for Quantum ElectroDynamics, yet another subject it's not really possible to complete a physical chemistry curriculum without being exposed to. And by the way, it's "quod erat demonstrandum." I'm rapidly coming to the conclusion that you are a complete, thoroughgoing fraud. I'm thinking basement dweller here. Probably about seventeen or so. Pimples.

So, you've neither put me on your Ignore List nor quit the thread. I have to point out to you that it qualifies as another lie. You don't seem to mnd issuing them so that's not much of a surprise to me. Nevertheless, if someone else is keeping tabs, here's a +1 for them.
No, I took you off, and I never said I'd leave the thread. This is far too interesting a study in entomology to leave now.
 
This is generally accepted as a childlike tactic from the schoolyard. ...

Enough prattle from you, bobo. I've deputized all the walls in your abode such that you can argue with them personally just as if I were there.

In the meantime, do something constructive and deal with this:

Perhaps you should provide references to the first principles of physics regarding atmospheric CO2. That would go a long way in helping us understanding where you're coming from. In fact, it would be better still to provide a point A to point B type exposition to validate IPCC’s hypothesis arriving at a ~2.5C increase in temperature by a doubling of atmospheric CO2. This exposition would include first principles of physics, chemistry, fluid dynamics, thermodynamics etc. and all forcings and feedbacks such as clouds, ocean aerosols, solar, cosmic rays, UHI for example.

Cornell University published a paper in July by Gerlich and Tscheuschner entitled "Falsification Of
The Atmospheric CO2 Greenhouse Effects Within The Frame Of Physics".
The abstract reads:

The atmospheric greenhouse effect, an idea that authors trace back to the traditional works of Fourier 1824, Tyndall 1861, and Arrhenius 1896, and which is still supported in global climatology, essentially describes a fictitious mechanism, in which a planetary atmosphere acts as a heat pump driven by an environment that is radiatively interacting with but radiatively equilibrated to the atmospheric system. According to the second law of thermodynamics such a planetary machine can never exist. Nevertheless, in almost all texts of global climatology and in a widespread secondary literature it is taken for granted that such mechanism is real and stands on a firm scientific foundation. In this paper the popular conjecture is analyzed and the underlying physical principles are clarified. By showing that (a) there are no common physical laws between the warming phenomenon in glass houses and the fictitious atmospheric greenhouse effects, (b) there are no calculations to determine an average surface temperature of a planet, (c) the frequently mentioned difference of 33 degrees Celsius is a meaningless number calculated wrongly, (d) the formulas of cavity radiation are used inappropriately, (e) the assumption of a radiative balance is unphysical, (f) thermal conductivity and friction must not be set to zero, the atmospheric greenhouse conjecture is falsified.

Excerpt:

Global climatologists claim that the Earth's natural greenhouse effect keeps the Earth 33 deg C warmer than it would be without the trace gases in the atmosphere. 80 percent of this warming is attributed to water vapor and 20 percent to the 0.03 volume percent CO2. If such an extreme effect existed, it would show up even in a laboratory experiment involving concentrated CO2 as a heat conductivity anomaly. It would be manifest itself as a new kind of `superinsulation violating the conventional heat conduction equation. However, for CO2 such anomalous heat transport properties never have been observed.

Please review and correct the errors in the physics as presented in the article. It would also be beneficial if it were explained why the troposphere is not warming at a faster rate than the surface as proposed by the AGW hypothesis.

Thanks.
 
Enough prattle from you, bobo. I've deputized all the walls in your abode such that you can argue with them personally just as if I were there.

In the meantime, do something constructive and deal with this:

I think I know where this going. First of all I will solve string theory, then I will get back to you.
 
Slimething said:
Actual climate data is gathered by research teams and institutions such as NASA or the Met Office. Do you question their methods? All of them?

No. Merely the ones that seem difficult to me based on my experience with soil sampling. If I were going to sample ice for gases, I certainly wouldn't do it from the top down but from an "inspection trench" dug alongside the ice so that I could sample horizontally.

I am fairly sure that the researchers thought of this, or at least some of them did, so I'm not sure that moi really has much to offer. I was going to go down to the local university to look up the original work but I gave myself the day off. I'm also interested in this compensation mechanism of measuring comparative isotope concentrations. I have some expertise in that field myself.


Looks like a sensible position to hold.

Like you, I would also be 'fairly sure that the researchers thought of this'. For most of the problems that we can dream up with their research. Looking into the primary research could be very illuminating in finding out just how rigorous (or not) the science is.

Did you have any particular reference in mind?
 
Oh, and one piece of unfinished business:

"1. A challenge for AGW believers to cite a scientific atmospheric study that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2 in the atmosphere." From the OP, here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2993363#post2993363

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html

That's AR4, the report from Working Group 1 of the IPCC, titled "The Physical Science Basis." Significant information is available here, the chapter titled "Changes in Atmospheric Constituents and in Radiative Forcing." Page 137 begins the section containing data on CO2 increases; on page 138 is a graph comparing emissions to concentration. On page 208, which begins the section dealing with the time evolution of radiative forcings, the following unequivocal statement is made: "Increases in RF [radiative forcing] are clearly dominated by CO2."

So all three questions have been answered, clearly and concisely. Is there any further point in this thread?

Taking a look at your reference it seems pretty much non responsive.

Alternately I might offer the criticism that if in fact the answer was buried somewhere in that tome, it is your job to go find it and show it, not my job to prove it's absence.

Nonetheless, I've gone back over a section of this and found a few interesting things. Citations to "scientific atmospheric studies that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2" seem to be quite lacking - at least, from the pages I have skimmed this morning. You are most welcome to prove me wrong.

"Scientific atmospheric studies" would be studies done in the atmosphere that measured it's emission spectrum and/or temperature, likely by airplane or balloon. "Empirical evidence" would be the direct measurements of the hypothesized greenhouse effects, not via models and such. So it would be likely that such a study would look at the rates of change of temperature in the atmosphere, at the levels of the atmosphere involved, and also it might look at daytime vs. night time temperatures.

"Scientific atmospheric studies that provide empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects" thus do not include work done from ground based sensors or interpretation of satellite data. This has been previously discussed. Thus if the IPCC document contains the answer to this challenge, please point it out.
On page 208, which begins the section dealing with the time evolution of radiative forcings, the following unequivocal statement is made: "Increases in RF [radiative forcing] are clearly dominated by CO2."
​
What does this have to do with the Challenge #3? A simple question to cite a certain type of scientific study is not answered with a chart, it is answered with the peer reviewed studies on the subject of the challenge.
 
Minor correction. Last pp. should read "Challenge 1", not "Challenge 3".
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?
​
Yes. CO2 absorbs infrared radiation, which the Earth's surface re-radiates when heated by the Sun, and re-radiates that infrared radiation in a random direction. Since half of such directions go back to the Earth, this means that approximately half of the radiation that Earth emits as a result of solar heating, that is absorbed by CO2 in the atmosphere, returns to the Earth, and is not lost to space. That means that the Earth is warmer than it would be if there were no CO2. Since an increase in the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere increases the chance that infrared photons moving through the atmosphere will be absorbed by a CO2 molecule, it also means that as the percentage of CO2 in the atmosphere rises, so does the temperature of the Earth.

This qualifies as a response worth replying to, even though as I have clearly stated before, the challenge involves showing a relationship between data series for time and temperature. You would like to lead indirectly but logically to the conclusion "there must be a relationship".

You ignore clouds, albedo, the entire water cycle, absorption and re emission of infrared by H2O in your response. These may be affected by an increase or decrease in temperature, therefore it does not follow that as the percentage of CO2 in the atmosphere rises, so does the temperature. Examples of such things are easy to show.

Your response is incorrect, then. (without going farther into the physics).

Ignoring these realities, your assertion fails as follows. Suppose that the effect of CO2 in the atmosphere existed exactly as you have described, but was very small. All of what you have asserted could be true, but the resulting effects of CO2 would be too small to be measured as a temperature change.

Then the AGW hypothesis crumbles. You don't want that, so I assume you would not want to go with my second response. Thus I suggest you address the first response.

I believe you could develop a strong argument, taking into account the various factors involved, if you wished. It might be a good idea first, though, to review the paper noted in post #266.

I'll get to your attempt at Challenge #2, Singer's Theory, later. This is enough for now.
 
This is far too interesting a study in entomology to leave now.

Indeed.

Please revisit the JREF rules 10, 11, and 12. Also the very first words in the Membership agreement "Guidelines".

"Be Civil and Polite."

After reviewing this, note the subject of this thread. It's about scientific arguments and their merits, not people, whether on this forum or somewhere else. I intend to keep this thread strictly on scientific issues. If you want to ad hom people on this forum do it elsewhere, here you will be flagged. If you want to disrespect scientists and others related to GW including those who are skeptical, do it elsewhere. Here you debate their arguments.

You entered this thread at post 179, and have only recently, in the last few posts, came up with anything vaguely related to a scientific argument on the subject of the thread. Please consider this.

You have been politely warned. Thanks.
 
I think I know where this going. First of all I will solve string theory, then I will get back to you.

OK, although I don't know what string theory has to do with carbon dioxide being the driver for global warming. (Let's for the moment assume the planet is warming. I've seen enough evidence that it is despite the lack of authoritative measurement of a true or even representative planetary temperature.)

If you know where all this is going, please post our final conclusion and save us all a lot of time and me a trip to the university liberry.
 
Enough prattle from you, bobo. I've deputized all the walls in your abode such that you can argue with them personally just as if I were there.

In the meantime, do something constructive and deal with this:

Check my post 1591 in the other global warming thread for what Steve McIntyre says about that paper.

Gerlich says absorption and reemmission is not reflection, wah wah wah.

I'm surprised that paper was published.
 
Looks like a sensible position to hold.

Like you, I would also be 'fairly sure that the researchers thought of this'. For most of the problems that we can dream up with their research. Looking into the primary research could be very illuminating in finding out just how rigorous (or not) the science is.

Did you have any particular reference in mind?

Check my post 1591 in the other global warming thread for what Steve McIntyre says about that paper.

Gerlich says absorption and reemmission is not reflection, wah wah wah.

I'm surprised that paper was published.

Thanks to both of you. As far as my first visit to look up the original papers, I'm going to begin wth the citations that McIntyre as a source for his four assumptions behind the ice coring data. Those assumptions, to me, are very troubling. It's not only that they're huge assumptions but that these assumptions can be tested empirically so there's no need to make them, unless you're in a rush to publish.

Maybe those assumptions are operative for only a few studies and maybe they've been abandoned in later work. Doing that level research could take years and I don't have the time. I'm especially interested in any possible difference in sampling or analysis technique that would account for the difference between the two graphs I've seen (the one that looks like a simple decline and the one that shows definite periodicity). There's something that just doesn't pass the laugh test here. I personally believe that the work showing periodicity is much more credible than the one that shows a smooth, steady increase (that doesn't quite link up to the present day measurements).

Also, once I get to one of the studies that uses isotope ratio for self-correction, I'm going to want to see if there is isotope-enrichment in biota as there is for some other natural isotopes, such as nitrogen-13. It's a subtle point but, unless the correction was made, the bias in the measurements could be huge, especially for trapped gases captured during oceanic blooms.
 
This qualifies as a response worth replying to, even though as I have clearly stated before, the challenge involves showing a relationship between data series for time and temperature. You would like to lead indirectly but logically to the conclusion "there must be a relationship".

You ignore clouds, albedo, the entire water cycle, absorption and re emission of infrared by H2O in your response.
You're right. This is simply about the fact that if warm objects radiate in IR, and they do, and CO2 absorbs IR, and it does, and the absorbed IR is re-radiated in a random direction, and it is, then CO2 in the atmosphere will raise the equilibrium point of the Earth's energy budget, and thus the temperature, and the more CO2, the higher the equilibrium point will be.

Clouds, albedo, the water cycle, and the warming effects of water vapor are irrelevant to this point. This is about what we should expect to see when we examine temperature data series. If we don't see it, then some very basic physics is just plain flat wrong. We're not talking about leading-edge stuff here; we're talking about physics that's been known since the eighteenth century.
 
do something constructive and deal with this:
The first 40 pages of this approximately 120-page "paper" are spent proving that the greenhouse effect cannot possibly work the same way as a real greenhouse does, a conclusion no one in their right mind would argue.

The remainder falls on its face when someone naively asks, "Then why isn't the Earth's surface the same temperature as the Moon's?"

Next.
 
Taking a look at your reference it seems pretty much non responsive.

Alternately I might offer the criticism that if in fact the answer was buried somewhere in that tome, it is your job to go find it and show it, not my job to prove it's absence.
You got page numbers. It has a table of contents. You're on your own.

"Empirical evidence" would be the direct measurements of the hypothesized greenhouse effects, not via models and such.
What precisely do you think you're talking about here? What do you mean "no models and such?" Do you actually have a realistic expectation that anyone is ever going to measure the precise temperature of every cubic centimeter of the atmosphere? It seems so from this statement. I'm sorry, I thought this might have turned into a rational discussion; it appears I was wrong.

The data are provided. It was eminently predictable that you would claim that they were insufficient. Sorry, I'm not playing this game. Your "challenge" has been answered, and you haven't a prayer of coming up with a rebuttal, is what all this rhetorical BS says. Fine, we'll take it as read.

Next.
 
You got page numbers. It has a table of contents. You're on your own.

What precisely do you think you're talking about here? What do you mean "no models and such?" Do you actually have a realistic expectation that anyone is ever going to measure the precise temperature of every cubic centimeter of the atmosphere? It seems so from this statement. I'm sorry, I thought this might have turned into a rational discussion; it appears I was wrong.

The data are provided. It was eminently predictable that you would claim that they were insufficient.

Hmm.... I have (what seems to me) a realistic expectation not that every cubic centimeter of the atmosphere might be measured, but that some, at differing heights above ground and composition, might be actually measured. And that from that empirical data, it might be possible to make a statement about atmospheric warming, and the relation of the CO2 component to that.

This has been discussed from a number of points of view, and there isn't any hidden trick or gotcha.

It's just a simple challenge to locate actual empirical atmospheric research. Alternately, there has been a lot of discussion as to why this might not be possible to be done. I'm not sure I agree with that.

The table of contents of the IPCC documentation has a lot of good stuff, but isn't any more an answer to this question than one could say that the table of contents to a physics book answered a physics problem.

By the way, I like being on my own.:D
 
Please revisit the JREF rules 10, 11, and 12. Also the very first words in the Membership agreement "Guidelines".

"Be Civil and Polite."
ROFLMFAO! Can't win the science so now you want to take it political? Fine, bring it. This post right here will be the first one I report.

You entered this thread at post 179, and have only recently, in the last few posts, came up with anything vaguely related to a scientific argument on the subject of the thread.
Oh, really? Let's just have a look at post 179, shall we? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=3032324&postcount=179

Gee, looks like I made the same answer I've been making all along. Over and over again. It looks technical. It looks scientific. What a surprise.

You have been politely warned.
Your blatant threat has been noted; further threats will result in you being reported to the moderators as attempting to suppress viewpoints you disagree with.

You're welcome.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom