So we understand, it is your belief IPCC contains no errors, bias, conflicts of interest or influence from government bureaucracies?
OK, before we start, I'll just point out that your entire post bears no relation to the post of mine that it claims to respond to.
My post, recent enough to recall, was about the IPCC and data-gathering. To reiterate my point, lest it be lost in obfuscation, the IPCC does not gather climate-data. What it does, and is mandated to do, is report on the current state of climate-related science.
The IPCC was given this mandate by the governing bodies of most nation-states, under UN auspices. Any such panel is bound to find its mandate subject to political influence by said nation-states because nation-states do not surrender sovereignty glady.
Where was all this "wide and open discussion" and "evaluation" for the hockey stick? Mann was the author of the hockey stick and also the lead author for IPCC in the section covering it.
Lead author. Of the Mann
et al climate reconstruction. Which was about all that was available at the time - this being the
first IPCC report. There have been four reports, and many other independent climate reconstructions since have confirmed Mann
et al. Meanwhile the blade of the hockey-stick has got longer. Mann
et al was open for discussion at the time, the data was from other researchers, further research and (of course) observations over the intervening years providing confirmation ... I'm happy with that. The system seems to have worked.
That's not a problem with you? It was ramrodded through with no scrutiny whatsoever, quite obviously to promote an agenda, not the science.
There was lots of scrutiny. There was lots of data. There's even more now.
What's this agenda that's so obvious from back then? Has it been mere coincidence - luck - that agenda-led mendacity and manipulation has been confirmed by further research and subsequent events?
Hardly likely. Mann
et al was honest back then, was honestly reported, and has been honestly confirmed since. Your imputations - which date from the same period, the past being a comfortable refuge - of totalitarian dishonesty do not stand up to scrutiny.
You don't find it odd the Summary for Policymakers was released before the science?
It's the policymakers that call the shots, and that's what they wanted. The science was out there beforehand because all the IPCC does is report on the existing published science. In practice it generally lags the science and remains on the conservative side. That's the political influence, real and perceived, in action.
It's not an issue when the science panels are instructed to agree with the SPM?
Bollocks. Whatever that means, I'm confident that it's bollocks.
IPCC is rife with this type of chicanery throughout it's reports, and it is well documented. Apparently you and others worshiping IPCC turn a blind eye to it.
A lot of us follow the science, which is what the IPCC reports on. We also follow the real world events. Such as melting permafrost, glacial retreat, changing seasons, phenological anomalies, stuff like that. The big bad analogue model. Is that all down to chicanery?
Also, UAP, it's AR4, not 4AR.
That's just sad.