Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

For some reason, the 4AR is not to be read, even though it is the authoritive source for the AGW claims.

It's the authoritative reference-point from which the published science can be located.

There is, of course, no universal desire to understand science because the more you know the more constrained you are in speculation. And in speculation lies hope. Hope that CO2 has different properties inside and outside the lab. Hope that CO2 and H2O, deep in the cold and dark, can form a bond in mutual adversity and become a hydrocarbon. Hope that it might all go away because this guy down the pub says there's a cycle.

Where hope is potentially undermined, personal abuse often follows to fend off the threat. It's just human nature.
 
It is absurd to believe that the intelliegence of humans can save us all from the universe when someday, all we will have left is the earths troposphere to seperate of from deadly cosmic rays and radiation.

That suggests a lack of respect for that stalwart ally, the stratosphere. I reckon they'll go down fighting shoulder-to-shoulder when the Sun finally brings it on. At which point cosmic rays will be the least of our worries, unless we're living off-world - in which situation they'll always be one of the most of our worries anyway :).
 
The IPCC reports on the current state of climate-related science, and the data it gathers comprises published science. It does not directly gather climate data, and so has no methods for doing so. It does have methods for gathering published science. It also has methods for evaluating published science. The main one being, of course, wide and open discussion within the scientific community leading to a concensus.

Actual climate data is gathered by research teams and institutions such as NASA or the Met Office. Do you question their methods? All of them?

So we understand, it is your belief IPCC contains no errors, bias, conflicts of interest or influence from government bureaucracies?

Where was all this "wide and open discussion" and "evaluation" for the hockey stick? Mann was the author of the hockey stick and also the lead author for IPCC in the section covering it. That's not a problem with you? It was ramrodded through with no scrutiny whatsoever, quite obviously to promote an agenda, not the science.

You don't find it odd the Summary for Policymakers was released before the science? It's not an issue when the science panels are instructed to agree with the SPM?

IPCC is rife with this type of chicanery throughout it's reports, and it is well documented. Apparently you and others worshiping IPCC turn a blind eye to it.

Also, UAP, it's AR4, not 4AR.
 
Practical Solutions?

Hello, I'm not an expert, or scientist, but I have an interest in AGW.
My knowledge is only non-scientific, but I can follow basic principles.
That said, this thread mentioned 'tipping point' associated with AGW. And also, carbon buildup in the atmosphere.
globalwarminglife.com has recent posted articles quoting Hansen dealing with Arctic Ice Thaw and it's tipping point.
It also has two recent articles quoting Tedesco dealing with the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets both experiencing progressive melting and its association with greenhouse gas. I found this issue very pressing and I have found globalwarminglife to be the most up to date and 'readable' site dealing with this issue.
 
Ummm, well, it's like this, to put it bluntly.

Both of your "answers" have been brought up before here in reference to these questions and discussed at length.

Not discussed at length. Hardly discussed at all. Mostly ignored.

In fact, some others did a much better job at bringing those arguments up was done than what you have done. And both of them fell considerably short of anything that could be considered success, although some of the ideas were quite interesting. And it could well be that if some of them were carried a bit farther, they might address the questions.

OK, taking it further - we're on 3 here, yeah? The direct correlation between CO2 levels and temperature, year-by-year, month-month-by-month, day-by-day? That challenge?

I addressed it, probably in another place, by pointing out that increasing CO2-load is not equivalent to turning on another bar on an electric fire. CO2-load influences the energy-budget, just as wrapping a blanket around yourself changes your body's energy-budget. The blanket itself does not warm you, it's the accumulation of heat within the blanket that gradually does that. Two blankets won't initially warm you any faster than one - but they will leave you warmer in the end. Eventually your body-heat will seep out as fast as you generate it and an equilibrium is arrived at.

Given this reality, along with the natural variability of eruptions, ENSO, yadda-yadda, you'd be asking the wrong question if you were actually asking one. But you aren't. You're issuing a challenge. An unanswerable one.

I'd welcome a discussion with you of this here post of mine. On the science, my implicit accusation of intellectual dishonesty, or both.

I'd also like to see what lie Slimething is accusing Schneibster of. Yet more evidence that I live in hope.

Sorry, but that's reality.

No, that's your interpretation of reality. Actual reality is not your friend.
 
Hello, I'm not an expert, or scientist, but I have an interest in AGW.
My knowledge is only non-scientific, but I can follow basic principles.
That said, this thread mentioned 'tipping point' associated with AGW. And also, carbon buildup in the atmosphere.
globalwarminglife.com has recent posted articles quoting Hansen dealing with Arctic Ice Thaw and it's tipping point.
It also has two recent articles quoting Tedesco dealing with the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets both experiencing progressive melting and its association with greenhouse gas. I found this issue very pressing and I have found globalwarminglife to be the most up to date and 'readable' site dealing with this issue.

There's another Science thread at http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=92110 which is far more ice-oriented than this one, and a lot less frenetic. I'd be happy to discuss ice-related tipping-points if you post this over there. (Don't feel you have to plough through the rest of it beforehand :).) On this thread the very existence of tipping-points of any variety is a contentious issue and liable to provoke a welter of weirdness and accusations of alarmism. If you're looking for a considered response - which I think you are - you won't find it here.
 
Actual climate data is gathered by research teams and institutions such as NASA or the Met Office. Do you question their methods? All of them?

No. Merely the ones that seem difficult to me based on my experience with soil sampling. If I were going to sample ice for gases, I certainly wouldn't do it from the top down but from an "inspection trench" dug alongside the ice so that I could sample horizontally.

I am fairly sure that the researchers thought of this, or at least some of them did, so I'm not sure that moi really has much to offer. I was going to go down to the local university to look up the original work but I gave myself the day off. I'm also interested in this compensation mechanism of measuring comparative isotope concentrations. I have some expertise in that field myself.
 
Fine, we're done. Just wanted to be sure anytime I encounter you in the future I have a link to show that you lie. Thanks.

Oh, we were done a long time ago, Schneibster. You can go off an tell everyone I lie. I really don't care much about the opinion of anyone who would listen to you. You're hiding behind you lack of understanding of the word stoichiometry which means, in proportion. It was your position stated in scientific terms but you don't like that because it's another nail in the coffin of your aberrant reasoning.

So, let's look at the bottom line. What have you contributed since you entered the discussion? Merely an argument that carbon dioxide is the driver of global warming. And you couldn't back it up. So, you have to escape somehow, right? May as well pretend that I lied. Funny how that doesn't seem to me to be a logical excuse to quit a topic but one that most people would use as motivation to presist.

You really are one of the most disingenuous and pathetic people I've met here. I have no regrets populating your Ignore List, a place you had already claimed I inhabited. I respect you not at all either as a human being nor as a scientist. Take that to the bank.
 
It's the authoritative reference-point from which the published science can be located.

There is, of course, no universal desire to understand science because the more you know the more constrained you are in speculation. And in speculation lies hope. Hope that CO2 has different properties inside and outside the lab. Hope that CO2 and H2O, deep in the cold and dark, can form a bond in mutual adversity and become a hydrocarbon. Hope that it might all go away because this guy down the pub says there's a cycle.

Where hope is potentially undermined, personal abuse often follows to fend off the threat. It's just human nature.

I agree with you. Ambiguity breeds speculation and, perhaps, false hope. Yes, there will always be people who deny reality for their convenience. So, I see that the science has to be nailed down in the case of GW. As I've written previously, there must be an aritight case (no pun intended) from which to not only get governments to commit to action but to also measure progress. I just don't see the practicality of embarking on an effort to ameliorate an effect if you can't even tell whether or not your efforts are successful, of no use or even mistaken.
 
So we understand, it is your belief IPCC contains no errors, bias, conflicts of interest or influence from government bureaucracies?

OK, before we start, I'll just point out that your entire post bears no relation to the post of mine that it claims to respond to.

My post, recent enough to recall, was about the IPCC and data-gathering. To reiterate my point, lest it be lost in obfuscation, the IPCC does not gather climate-data. What it does, and is mandated to do, is report on the current state of climate-related science.

The IPCC was given this mandate by the governing bodies of most nation-states, under UN auspices. Any such panel is bound to find its mandate subject to political influence by said nation-states because nation-states do not surrender sovereignty glady.


Where was all this "wide and open discussion" and "evaluation" for the hockey stick? Mann was the author of the hockey stick and also the lead author for IPCC in the section covering it.

Lead author. Of the Mann et al climate reconstruction. Which was about all that was available at the time - this being the first IPCC report. There have been four reports, and many other independent climate reconstructions since have confirmed Mann et al. Meanwhile the blade of the hockey-stick has got longer. Mann et al was open for discussion at the time, the data was from other researchers, further research and (of course) observations over the intervening years providing confirmation ... I'm happy with that. The system seems to have worked.

That's not a problem with you? It was ramrodded through with no scrutiny whatsoever, quite obviously to promote an agenda, not the science.

There was lots of scrutiny. There was lots of data. There's even more now.

What's this agenda that's so obvious from back then? Has it been mere coincidence - luck - that agenda-led mendacity and manipulation has been confirmed by further research and subsequent events?

Hardly likely. Mann et al was honest back then, was honestly reported, and has been honestly confirmed since. Your imputations - which date from the same period, the past being a comfortable refuge - of totalitarian dishonesty do not stand up to scrutiny.

You don't find it odd the Summary for Policymakers was released before the science?

It's the policymakers that call the shots, and that's what they wanted. The science was out there beforehand because all the IPCC does is report on the existing published science. In practice it generally lags the science and remains on the conservative side. That's the political influence, real and perceived, in action.

It's not an issue when the science panels are instructed to agree with the SPM?

Bollocks. Whatever that means, I'm confident that it's bollocks.

IPCC is rife with this type of chicanery throughout it's reports, and it is well documented. Apparently you and others worshiping IPCC turn a blind eye to it.

A lot of us follow the science, which is what the IPCC reports on. We also follow the real world events. Such as melting permafrost, glacial retreat, changing seasons, phenological anomalies, stuff like that. The big bad analogue model. Is that all down to chicanery?

Also, UAP, it's AR4, not 4AR.

That's just sad.
 
Last edited:
Hello, I'm not an expert, or scientist, but I have an interest in AGW.
My knowledge is only non-scientific, but I can follow basic principles.
That said, this thread mentioned 'tipping point' associated with AGW. And also, carbon buildup in the atmosphere.
globalwarminglife.com has recent posted articles quoting Hansen dealing with Arctic Ice Thaw and it's tipping point.
It also has two recent articles quoting Tedesco dealing with the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets both experiencing progressive melting and its association with greenhouse gas. I found this issue very pressing and I have found globalwarminglife to be the most up to date and 'readable' site dealing with this issue.

Hi, manofthesea.

I looked at the site you mentioned, and it could be categorized as a rather biased "warmer alarmist" site. Most of the stories that are discussed there are also discussed here, although in more depth. Many disagree with the "alarmist," others disagree with the idea that man is primarily responsible for the 20th century slight temperature increase.
 
Hello, I'm not an expert, or scientist, but I have an interest in AGW.
My knowledge is only non-scientific, but I can follow basic principles.
That said, this thread mentioned 'tipping point' associated with AGW. And also, carbon buildup in the atmosphere.
globalwarminglife.com has recent posted articles quoting Hansen dealing with Arctic Ice Thaw and it's tipping point.
It also has two recent articles quoting Tedesco dealing with the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets both experiencing progressive melting and its association with greenhouse gas. I found this issue very pressing and I have found globalwarminglife to be the most up to date and 'readable' site dealing with this issue.

On this thread the very existence of tipping-points of any variety is a contentious issue and liable to provoke a welter of weirdness and accusations of alarmism. If you're looking for a considered response - which I think you are - you won't find it here.

This thread is currently the home of scientists and others who are arguing about the methods of knowing whether or not global warming is caused by humans. Tipping points and the like are way down the road of this discussion and presuppose that there's anything humans can do about them. So, stay if you want to learn about science. Go to the other thread if you want to catch up on the popular assumptions.
 
This thread is currently the home of scientists and others who are arguing about the methods of knowing whether or not global warming is caused by humans. Tipping points and the like are way down the road of this discussion and presuppose that there's anything humans can do about them. So, stay if you want to learn about science. Go to the other thread if you want to catch up on the popular assumptions.

It may get a bit technical here, by intent.

Are we back to our regularly scheduled programs now?:)
 
IPCC is rife with this type of chicanery throughout it's reports, and it is well documented. Apparently you and others worshiping IPCC turn a blind eye to it.
Also, UAP, it's AR4, not 4AR.

Yes, but let's stick to the scientific issues, when possible. Note there is a pretty good argument for validity of IPCC sections as, say, historical reviews of areas of science. AUP makes this case. Whether IPCC is peer reviewed, is another question. ;)

Can a reference to a IPCC page or section be considered other than an Argument from Authority? Certainly it should be considered, if the page and chapter is provided. But as noted by the many dissenting reviewers, sometimes the summary paragraphs do not adequately reflect the original research. I feel personally much more comfortable with regular articles from scientists.

Further, how do we consider the more recent science? Wentz 2007 alone has a huge impact on the radiative forcing table of IPCC. Obviously, that table is no good after Wentz. Similar for Tsonis 2007 and Schwartz.

I do not feel that it is slighting or disparaging the good work of many scientists) who participated in the IPCC process (leaving the politics out) to place a higher emphasis on more recent work.

At the same time, all the basic presumptions should be open to examination.
 
I agree with you. Ambiguity breeds speculation and, perhaps, false hope. Yes, there will always be people who deny reality for their convenience. So, I see that the science has to be nailed down in the case of GW. As I've written previously, there must be an aritight case (no pun intended) from which to not only get governments to commit to action but to also measure progress. I just don't see the practicality of embarking on an effort to ameliorate an effect if you can't even tell whether or not your efforts are successful, of no use or even mistaken.

The curious thing, to me, is how many people are prepared to act, to the tune of a trillion dollars, on the mere possibility of terrorism. Yet on the matter of global warming, which is never going to be 100% proven, but appears to be reasonbly well documented and studied, nothing is to be done.
 
Moved from "GW Thread", more suited here.

Originally Posted by stevea
My point remains that despite niggling about the precise amount it is almost universally admitted that humans have significantly increase atmospheric CO2 levels. The CO2 increase should, due to many separate reasons, have an impact on the biosphere beyond climate, and that we should have some agreement that reducing atmospheric CO2 is a good idea, despite disagreement about the extent of climatic impact.
​
One minor point about your first comment here. There has been an assertion that over the 8000 years of the Holocene erase, approximately 40 ppm of CO2 was introduced into the atmosphere gradually - thus in the absence of human activity, the level in about year 1800 would have been 240 ppm.

Research has shown this to be false, and has also shown that during the Holocene there was considerable rapid fluctuations in CO2 level. This is not to say that we are not now contributing approximately 100 ppm, just that the climate is dynamic and the natural level of CO2 does vary, roughly say between 2xx and 3xx. There is no baseline, static level which is "right".

The second point you make can be vigorously debated on several levels as I am sure you are aware. You can't have an international agreement to control CO2 when the Asian countries producing the huge brown clouds are excluded and when those clouds are known to constitute more than 50% of the problem in those areas. That makes no sense. You are then attacking one thing, a possible non problem and ignoring a known problem.

We could wind up as successful at understanding and controlling "the CO2 problem" as we have with controlling those dangerous freons, proven scientifically to be responsible for the ozone hole.:)
 
The curious thing, to me, is how many people are prepared to act, to the tune of a trillion dollars, on the mere possibility of terrorism. Yet on the matter of global warming, which is never going to be 100% proven, but appears to be reasonbly well documented and studied, nothing is to be done.

That's a great point, AUP. All I can offer is that politicians have a way of selling fear about immediate threats. That's primarily because of their four to six years terms. They really have not use for bringing up any longer-term threats.

I live in the USA and you don't but all I can do is offer US examples. You'll probably think of instances closer to you. Anyway, financial experts in the US have long been after the electorate to save more and stop the deficit spending thing but to no avail because the threat is to future generations via the national debt. A related theme is the state of the social security system (not good) but no one cares because it's not about them.

I have my own thoughts about AGW (if it's true, then the politicians should allow the scientist's credibility to carry the message). Anyway, the politicos have decided to take the message to the populace themselves and people don't trust them. Quite sad.
 
You're hiding behind you lack of understanding of the word stoichiometry which means, in proportion.
No, actually, you claimed I had said it, and I didn't. Whether I said something equivalent is not the point. You didn't say I'd said something equivalent. If you're going to lie, at least make it something that's a little bit more difficult to prove you're lying about than that.

By the way, stoichiometric refers to the proportions of compounds that react with one another and the proportions of compounds that result, not to the relationship of two variables that change in step with one another. The term is restricted to chemistry, and has nothing to do with thermodynamics. See the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry's Gold Book definition of it here. So it looks like YOU don't know the definition yourself, since you were applying it to heat, which is not a chemical compound.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom