Yeah, whatever. We're discussing GW here, not my reading comprehension skills.
Great, then discuss it.
As you have already admitted, I am correct in that the temperature of the earth is not linked stoichiometrically to the concentration of carbon dioxide.
I do not recall using the word "stochiometric" or any of its derivatives in any post I made until this one. This is a dishonest claim, since I admitted nothing of the kind.
Considering that you made the claim above, I would have to agree with that. In addition you confounded two separate claims of mine and have yet to acknowledge it.
but I though you claimed that the reasons were known and cataloged.
The reasons for what, precisely? For CO2 absorbing and re-emitting photons? No, I claimed nothing of the kind- it would be superfluous. The reasons for temperature deviations from a strict adherence since the 1870s to a direct relation between CO2 and global temperature? Yes, I did claim that. AUP has provided several links to my reference. It's by the IPCC. The links to the individual papers containing the data that account for these deviations are in that reference.
Perhaps you actually meant that the discrepancies were cataloged but that's redundant and fatuous so I didn't think that's what you meant.
My reference is relatively obvious, and although it has been referred to several times, given that you didn't produce any criticism of it, I fail to see how you would know whether it was redundant or fatuous.
Again, you're misinterpreting. I know that carbon dioxide will behave the same in the environment as in the lab, given the same conditions exist. That's why I brought up the concept of activity, not concentration. The activity of carbon dioxide may or may not be the driver to GW as that crucial correlation has not been proven.
Proven? We're talking about science here. You don't "prove" anything in science. However, the current theory of GW says that the primary driving force behind GW at this time is CO2. A model based upon that hypothesis has given good predictions of global temperatures since the 1980s. Other predictions of this hypothesis, including the melting of glaciers and the ice caps among other significant events, have also been verified. It's the current best theory we have of what global temperatures are going to do.
Does that constitute proof? Not really. There is no proof in science. Does it constitute a theory that has been tested and found to give good predictions, and not make any predictions that are incorrect? Yes, it does. This theory, therefore, is accepted by the majority of experts in the field. It will continue to be so accepted until it makes a prediction that does not agree with observation, if it ever does.
Note that adding one molecule of cabon dioxide to the atmosphere does not necessarily mean it stays there. There are many variable in the environment that have not been included in the lab studies.
This can be controlled for by checking historical and current CO2 concentrations, and it has been. This is not a matter of theory, but one of fact. We have data sets that go back hundreds of thousands of years, and others that go back only decades but are more comprehensive, and all of these data sets from different sources agree with one another relatively well (that is, within error bars established using independent considerations).
You have already admitted that there is not a precise correlation between carbon dioxide concentration and the planet's temperature.
Of course there isn't; there are other driving forces that can affect the climate, obviously. The question is not, are there other such drivers, but whether when they go away, the original signal from the CO2 emerges again; and the answer is, yes, it does.
So, you have demonstrated no such thing.
Demonstrated what, precisely? That more CO2 in the atmosphere means it will get warmer? This is relatively obvious. Both the basic physics and our observations confirm it. PROVED it? Well, there isn't any proof in science. But when you get results from two completely different methods that agree with one another, then it's a good bet that you're onto something; and when you get data from fifteen or twenty data sources that agree with one another, most people would say that's pretty strong evidence. The current level of certainty among those with the most knowledge is generally agreed to be "beyond a reasonable doubt," a level of certainty at which most juries will convict someone of a crime. For the precise evidence involved, please see the IPCC report. For a statement that this is the agreed upon level of certainty, please see the IPCC report.
On the issue of carbon dioxide's radiative properties, that constitutes evidence that it could, and probably does, contribute to warming but in no way seals the deal that it is the driver. Other gases are known to also contribute but the rate of warming (as defined today) is more out of step with their concentrations than with carbon dioxide so the theory is not as much about them.
This is an oversimplification. Many other factors are capable of influencing global temperature, some positively, some negatively. What we can say is that we do not see these factors as having as good a correlation with global temperature as CO2 does at this time, and that we don't see those factors as being active at this time, either. Whether they might be in the future, we do not know, but we have no reason to expect it. The few that do seem to be active are all contributing positively.
I don't want to dredge back an old debate but I want to set the record straight here. Your claim was that Physics could explain everything.
No, it wasn't. Like here, you misunderstood what I was saying. First, I spoke of quantum mechanics, not physics in general. Second, what I said was that the specific field you brought up had an explanation in terms of the physics of quantum electrodynamics, which, since it involves the interaction of photons with electrons, is the appropriate discipline from which to derive such an explanation.
I brought up stereochemistry and you confabulated a book to prove me wrong (even if you hadn't lied, that's still argument from authority).
By this standard, any possible citation is an "argument from authority." The title of the book was provided, and it was available for review. It was a textbook, and the title alone, IIRC, was enough to show that you had no idea what you were talking about. It was shown to be written by an expert in the field, with a long history of teaching in that field, and quite a few papers in the field.
So, if you want to revive that thread, go ahead. I'm still waiting on you for an explanation on how Physics explains this phenomenon.
And I have provided one, in that thread. It is the accepted physics explanation for the phenomenon of the rotation of optical planes by optical isomers in a solution.
But, not here. Here we're discussing humanity's role in global warming.
Hey, you brought it up, four times now. If you didn't want to discuss it, why bring it up?