Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

It's probably worth noting that I'm merely answering you using exactly the same rhetorical tricks and misrepresentations you are; I'm assuming you believe this is a good and proper way to communicate, and I want to make sure I follow your rules of politeness, however strange they may seem to me. If the assumption on my part that this is how you like to communicate is incorrect, you are free to demonstrate that by communicating with me in a different manner that you feel is more appropriate.

Have a nice day.
 
Interesting.

You are correct, I have not answered your question.
That's good, because I didn't ask any questions. It's nice to know that you have such excellent reading comprehension.

That is because I have no interest in helping you answer the challenge that you set out so eagerly upon. So do your best. Include references please.
I have no need of any help from you. I think I've demonstrated that you have no idea what you're talking about without it, in any case, which was my entire point.

In case it wasn't clear earlier, I have absolutely no intention of providing references that prove that physics correctly describes how CO2 behaves. I see no need; if you don't know it yourself, you've got no business talking about geophysics in the first place.
 
How about you try to get this thread back on track and eliminate the personal attacks, folks?
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Paul C. Anagnostopoulos
 
That's good, because I didn't ask any questions. It's nice to know that you have such excellent reading comprehension.

I have no need of any help from you. I think I've demonstrated that you have no idea what you're talking about without it, in any case, which was my entire point.

In case it wasn't clear earlier, I have absolutely no intention of providing references that prove that physics correctly describes how CO2 behaves. I see no need; if you don't know it yourself, you've got no business talking about geophysics in the first place.

Perhaps you should provide references to the first principles of physics regarding atmospheric CO2. That would go a long way in helping us understanding where you're coming from. In fact, it would be better still to provide a point A to point B type exposition to validate IPCC’s hypothesis arriving at a ~2.5C increase in temperature by a doubling of atmospheric CO2. This exposition would include first principles of physics, chemistry, fluid dynamics, thermodynamics etc. and all forcings and feedbacks such as clouds, ocean aerosols, solar, cosmic rays, UHI for example.

Cornell University published a paper in July by Gerlich and Tscheuschner entitled "Falsification Of
The Atmospheric CO2 Greenhouse Effects Within The Frame Of Physics".
The abstract reads:
The atmospheric greenhouse effect, an idea that authors trace back to the traditional works of Fourier 1824, Tyndall 1861, and Arrhenius 1896, and which is still supported in global climatology, essentially describes a fictitious mechanism, in which a planetary atmosphere acts as a heat pump driven by an environment that is radiatively interacting with but radiatively equilibrated to the atmospheric system. According to the second law of thermodynamics such a planetary machine can never exist. Nevertheless, in almost all texts of global climatology and in a widespread secondary literature it is taken for granted that such mechanism is real and stands on a firm scientific foundation. In this paper the popular conjecture is analyzed and the underlying physical principles are clarified. By showing that (a) there are no common physical laws between the warming phenomenon in glass houses and the fictitious atmospheric greenhouse effects, (b) there are no calculations to determine an average surface temperature of a planet, (c) the frequently mentioned difference of 33 degrees Celsius is a meaningless number calculated wrongly, (d) the formulas of cavity radiation are used inappropriately, (e) the assumption of a radiative balance is unphysical, (f) thermal conductivity and friction must not be set to zero, the atmospheric greenhouse conjecture is falsified.

Excerpt:
Global climatologists claim that the Earth's natural greenhouse effect keeps the Earth 33 deg C warmer than it would be without the trace gases in the atmosphere. 80 percent of this warming is attributed to water vapor and 20 percent to the 0.03 volume percent CO2. If such an extreme effect existed, it would show up even in a laboratory experiment involving concentrated CO2 as a heat conductivity anomaly. It would be manifest itself as a new kind of `superinsulation violating the conventional heat conduction equation. However, for CO2 such anomalous heat transport properties never have been observed.

Please review and correct the errors in the physics as presented in the article. It would also be beneficial if it were explained why the troposphere is not warming at a faster rate than the surface as proposed by the AGW hypothesis.

Thanks.
 
<snipped a large volume of ad hom to get to what I wanted>

You're on your own, sport. As I said, you confounded two separate statements, neither of which you understood, and made a claim of what I said based on that. It's not my problem if you don't have reading comprehension beyond the third grade level.

Well, you sure coulda fooled me, because I said, "CO2 absorbs energy, and re-radiates it in a random direction, and that makes the Earth warmer," and you said, "That has little to do with what does or does not cause GW or AGW." Looks like that reading comprehension thing rearing its ugly head again to me.

Yeah, whatever. We're discussing GW here, not my reading comprehension skills. As you have already admitted, I am correct in that the temperature of the earth is not linked stoichiometrically to the concentration of carbon dioxide. I may have misread but I though you claimed that the reasons were known and cataloged. Perhaps you actually meant that the discrepancies were cataloged but that's redundant and fatuous so I didn't think that's what you meant.

So there's magic CO2 that behaves differently in the atmosphere. It's not clear whether you think that's the man-made kind, or the natural kind, and I'm not especially clear on what possible difference you think there might be, so I'll choose one and say that you think the magic CO2 comes from human activity. It could as easily be the natural CO2 that you think is magic, but it would be more consistent if it were the man-made kind.

Again, you're misinterpreting. I know that carbon dioxide will behave the same in the environment as in the lab, given the same conditions exist. That's why I brought up the concept of activity, not concentration. The activity of carbon dioxide may or may not be the driver to GW as that crucial correlation has not been proven. Note that adding one molecule of cabon dioxide to the atmosphere does not necessarily mean it stays there. There are many variable in the environment that have not been included in the lab studies.

See, otherwise it doesn't matter where the CO2 comes from; that's not what the question was about. The question was, can you substantiate a relationship between CO2 concentration and temperature? And the answer is, yes, I can, CO2 absorbs infrared photons and re-radiates them in a random direction, and that means that some of them don't make it to space, and that means that there's more energy on the Earth's surface, and that means that the temperature goes up, unless you don't "believe in" physics.

You have already admitted that there is not a precise correlation between carbon dioxide concentration and the planet's temperature. So, you have demonstrated no such thing. On the issue of carbon dioxide's radiative properties, that constitutes evidence that it could, and probably does, contribute to warming but in no way seals the deal that it is the driver. Other gases are known to also contribute but the rate of warming (as defined today) is more out of step with their concentrations than with carbon dioxide so the theory is not as much about them.

As it happens, I am very familiar with stereochemistry, but that is neither here nor there.

Good. Fascinating stuff. But it's not accounted for by basic physics. I was making a point that some phenomena are not explained thusly.

First, stereochemistry is aside from the point; and second, you got in trouble with me originally because you got mad when you said something stupid about chemistry and physics and got challenged on it and didn't have an answer. Pretty much like you're doing right now.

I don't want to dredge back an old debate but I want to set the record straight here. Your claim was that Physics could explain everything. I brought up stereochemistry and you confabulated a book to prove me wrong (even if you hadn't lied, that's still argument from authority). So, if you want to revive that thread, go ahead. I'm still waiting on you for an explanation on how Physics explains this phenomenon.

But, not here. Here we're discussing humanity's role in global warming.
 
<snipped more ad hom to get where I wanted to go>

Stereochemistry is the study of the arrangement of atoms within a molecule, more precisely, the study of how many different spatial arrangements are possible for the same structural formula, and how those different spatial arrangements differ when they react with other chemicals. In most cases, because we live in a three-dimensional universe, that number is two; thus, "stereo"chemistry. This is called "chiral" stereochemistry, where chiral refers to handedness, as in left hand and right hand, which implies mirror imaging. A stereoisomer is a molecule that has the same structural formula as another, but whose atoms are arranged in a mirror image in space.

Now, this concerns atoms; and it concerns position; and it concerns spatial arrangement. And all of these things are matters of physics. Furthermore, since it studies how such isomers differ in their interactions with other chemicals, it concerns the interactions of atoms in the molecules with one another, and that also is a matter of physics. Theoretically, all such interactions could be described purely in terms of quantum mechanics; however, an enormous amount of computing power would be required due to the complexities of these interactions, and this is also true of other types of chemistry. Stereochemistry, therefore, provides a higher-level view, in which the units are molecules and their isomers rather than individual atoms; this higher-level view is more tractable, permitting the use of much more compact modeling, perhaps even without computers other than pencil and paper. Little or no detail is lost, due to the symmetries of physics, when using this approach. However, again theoretically, all of this could be worked out on the basis of individual quantum interactions, and fully described in those terms.

That is what I said, that is what I meant, and it is self-evidently true. Of course, if you don't think physics is a science, then you probably don't think so, but that's not my problem. You asked, I answered, we're done.

This discussion does not belong here. But, you're forgotten the issue anyway and the above does not address it. Revive the old thread if you want to address the issue which was, how Physics explains the rotation of light by pure stereo-isomers.

How do you do your job?

Very well. Thanks!;)
 
Yeah, whatever. We're discussing GW here, not my reading comprehension skills.
Great, then discuss it.

As you have already admitted, I am correct in that the temperature of the earth is not linked stoichiometrically to the concentration of carbon dioxide.
I do not recall using the word "stochiometric" or any of its derivatives in any post I made until this one. This is a dishonest claim, since I admitted nothing of the kind.

I may have misread
Considering that you made the claim above, I would have to agree with that. In addition you confounded two separate claims of mine and have yet to acknowledge it.

but I though you claimed that the reasons were known and cataloged.
The reasons for what, precisely? For CO2 absorbing and re-emitting photons? No, I claimed nothing of the kind- it would be superfluous. The reasons for temperature deviations from a strict adherence since the 1870s to a direct relation between CO2 and global temperature? Yes, I did claim that. AUP has provided several links to my reference. It's by the IPCC. The links to the individual papers containing the data that account for these deviations are in that reference.

Perhaps you actually meant that the discrepancies were cataloged but that's redundant and fatuous so I didn't think that's what you meant.
My reference is relatively obvious, and although it has been referred to several times, given that you didn't produce any criticism of it, I fail to see how you would know whether it was redundant or fatuous.

Again, you're misinterpreting. I know that carbon dioxide will behave the same in the environment as in the lab, given the same conditions exist. That's why I brought up the concept of activity, not concentration. The activity of carbon dioxide may or may not be the driver to GW as that crucial correlation has not been proven.
Proven? We're talking about science here. You don't "prove" anything in science. However, the current theory of GW says that the primary driving force behind GW at this time is CO2. A model based upon that hypothesis has given good predictions of global temperatures since the 1980s. Other predictions of this hypothesis, including the melting of glaciers and the ice caps among other significant events, have also been verified. It's the current best theory we have of what global temperatures are going to do.

Does that constitute proof? Not really. There is no proof in science. Does it constitute a theory that has been tested and found to give good predictions, and not make any predictions that are incorrect? Yes, it does. This theory, therefore, is accepted by the majority of experts in the field. It will continue to be so accepted until it makes a prediction that does not agree with observation, if it ever does.

Note that adding one molecule of cabon dioxide to the atmosphere does not necessarily mean it stays there. There are many variable in the environment that have not been included in the lab studies.
This can be controlled for by checking historical and current CO2 concentrations, and it has been. This is not a matter of theory, but one of fact. We have data sets that go back hundreds of thousands of years, and others that go back only decades but are more comprehensive, and all of these data sets from different sources agree with one another relatively well (that is, within error bars established using independent considerations).

You have already admitted that there is not a precise correlation between carbon dioxide concentration and the planet's temperature.
Of course there isn't; there are other driving forces that can affect the climate, obviously. The question is not, are there other such drivers, but whether when they go away, the original signal from the CO2 emerges again; and the answer is, yes, it does.

So, you have demonstrated no such thing.
Demonstrated what, precisely? That more CO2 in the atmosphere means it will get warmer? This is relatively obvious. Both the basic physics and our observations confirm it. PROVED it? Well, there isn't any proof in science. But when you get results from two completely different methods that agree with one another, then it's a good bet that you're onto something; and when you get data from fifteen or twenty data sources that agree with one another, most people would say that's pretty strong evidence. The current level of certainty among those with the most knowledge is generally agreed to be "beyond a reasonable doubt," a level of certainty at which most juries will convict someone of a crime. For the precise evidence involved, please see the IPCC report. For a statement that this is the agreed upon level of certainty, please see the IPCC report.

On the issue of carbon dioxide's radiative properties, that constitutes evidence that it could, and probably does, contribute to warming but in no way seals the deal that it is the driver. Other gases are known to also contribute but the rate of warming (as defined today) is more out of step with their concentrations than with carbon dioxide so the theory is not as much about them.
This is an oversimplification. Many other factors are capable of influencing global temperature, some positively, some negatively. What we can say is that we do not see these factors as having as good a correlation with global temperature as CO2 does at this time, and that we don't see those factors as being active at this time, either. Whether they might be in the future, we do not know, but we have no reason to expect it. The few that do seem to be active are all contributing positively.

I don't want to dredge back an old debate but I want to set the record straight here. Your claim was that Physics could explain everything.
No, it wasn't. Like here, you misunderstood what I was saying. First, I spoke of quantum mechanics, not physics in general. Second, what I said was that the specific field you brought up had an explanation in terms of the physics of quantum electrodynamics, which, since it involves the interaction of photons with electrons, is the appropriate discipline from which to derive such an explanation.

I brought up stereochemistry and you confabulated a book to prove me wrong (even if you hadn't lied, that's still argument from authority).
By this standard, any possible citation is an "argument from authority." The title of the book was provided, and it was available for review. It was a textbook, and the title alone, IIRC, was enough to show that you had no idea what you were talking about. It was shown to be written by an expert in the field, with a long history of teaching in that field, and quite a few papers in the field.

So, if you want to revive that thread, go ahead. I'm still waiting on you for an explanation on how Physics explains this phenomenon.
And I have provided one, in that thread. It is the accepted physics explanation for the phenomenon of the rotation of optical planes by optical isomers in a solution.

But, not here. Here we're discussing humanity's role in global warming.
Hey, you brought it up, four times now. If you didn't want to discuss it, why bring it up?
 
I'll point out also that neither of my two answers to questions 2 and 3 has been seriously challenged. It has been as good as admitted that my answer to #3 is correct, that given what we know about CO2 and photons, there is excellent reason to expect that if there is more CO2 in the atmosphere, then it will be warmer; and no one has even tried to answer the obvious deficiencies in a hypothesis that proposes a 1500 year cycle as an explanation for events that happened 500 years ago and are happening now.
 
The book I referenced, by the way, is available from Amazon, here: http://www.amazon.com/Electronic-St...169893-8820409?ie=UTF8&qid=1191782124&sr=11-1

It's listed in the curricula of three college courses on physical chemistry that I provided in that thread, and there were many more. It is listed in the references of three current papers published in the last year in peer-reviewed journals in the field of physical chemistry.

You claimed it was not about physical chemistry; here you've claimed that it's an "argument from authority." I think that pretty much covers things. I see no reason to resurrect the original thread, but if anyone is interested, the thread is here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=73704 and the specific reference in which ST refers to it as comparable to von Daniken is available here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2320304#post2320304

Furthermore, it was not me that you challenged to provide an explanation of optical rotation in terms of quantum mechanics; it was pgwenthold.

I think this is sufficient to put this particular conversation to bed.
 
I do not recall using the word "stochiometric" or any of its derivatives in any post I made until this one. This is a dishonest claim, since I admitted nothing of the kind.

Yes, you did. Merely because you don't know what stoichiometric means does not lessen or negate your admission. Look it up. I'm sorry I misspelled it in my original post.

AUP has provided several links to my reference. It's by the IPCC. The links to the individual papers containing the data that account for these deviations are in that reference.

Then you would have no problem stating the reasons. Please do so. Not everyone on this thread has time to reread the volume to try to tease out of it whatever it is you're talking about.

However, the current theory of GW says that the primary driving force behind GW at this time is CO2. A model based upon that hypothesis has given good predictions of global temperatures since the 1980s. Other predictions of this hypothesis, including the melting of glaciers and the ice caps among other significant events, have also been verified. It's the current best theory we have of what global temperatures are going to do.

You are incorrectly mixing the scientific terms of theory and hypothesis. Let's be clear here and agree that all models of AGW or GW are hypotheses, not theories. The ongoing furor about the mere existence or the causes of GW are proof enough of that. You have already admitted that the temperature of the planet does not track perfectly with carbon dioxide concentrations so I would surmise one of two possibilities:
  1. Carbon dioxide is not the sole driver. It might be a contributing driver but it is not alone.
  2. Carbon dioxide has nothing to do with global warming.
I would also point out that secondary predictions such as melting, flooding, storms, etc. are not evidence for any driver. They are merely signs of changing weather patterns.

This theory, therefore, is accepted by the majority of experts in the field. It will continue to be so accepted until it makes a prediction that does not agree with observation, if it ever does.

Again, hypothesis. We are at a disadvantage that confirmation of the various predictions will take many, many years.

This can be controlled for by checking historical and current CO2 concentrations, and it has been. This is not a matter of theory, but one of fact. We have data sets that go back hundreds of thousands of years, and others that go back only decades but are more comprehensive, and all of these data sets from different sources agree with one another relatively well (that is, within error bars established using independent considerations).

In this thread, we are currently discussing the topic of whether or not ice core data are reliable. I've personally observed that one publication questioning these data has posited that they are based on four assumptions that are, frankly, dubious to me. Read the thread to see if you can offer any reasoning (based on physics, of course) that these four assumptions should be accepted. Maybe you have personal knowledge that these assumptions are not accepted?

The question is not, are there other such drivers, but whether when they go away, the original signal from the CO2 emerges again; and the answer is, yes, it does.

That is a claim supported by evidence? Could we have it?

Demonstrated what, precisely? That more CO2 in the atmosphere means it will get warmer? This is relatively obvious. Both the basic physics and our observations confirm it. PROVED it? Well, there isn't any proof in science. But when you get results from two completely different methods that agree with one another, then it's a good bet that you're onto something; and when you get data from fifteen or twenty data sources that agree with one another, most people would say that's pretty strong evidence. The current level of certainty among those with the most knowledge is generally agreed to be "beyond a reasonable doubt," a level of certainty at which most juries will convict someone of a crime. For the precise evidence involved, please see the IPCC report. For a statement that this is the agreed upon level of certainty, please see the IPCC report.

I have seen the IPCC report and I have no doubt that the authors of the report stand behind what it says. I'm not questioning their interpretation but their data-gathering methods.

This is an oversimplification. Many other factors are capable of influencing global temperature, some positively, some negatively. What we can say is that we do not see these factors as having as good a correlation with global temperature as CO2 does at this time, and that we don't see those factors as being active at this time, either. Whether they might be in the future, we do not know, but we have no reason to expect it. The few that do seem to be active are all contributing positively.

The discussion here is whether or not humankind is contributing to global warming. Some posters seem to believe that the planet is not warming and some doubt that a small change in carbon dioxide will result in considerable warming. So, what we're stuck with here, is a problem of time. In most models, we can usually isolate a microcosm wherein we apply a known amount of the substance and look for the specific short-term evidence of an effect or lack thereof. We don't have such a system available to us here. Suppose the earth is warming. How do we nail down what is doing it, seeing that we can't isolate a microcosm for testing?

No, it wasn't. Like here, you misunderstood what I was saying. ...
Hey, you brought it up, four times now. If you didn't want to discuss it, why bring it up?

Wrong place. I'm not going to discuss it here. Take it to the original thread. That's the end of it here.
 
I'll point out also that neither of my two answers to questions 2 and 3 has been seriously challenged. It has been as good as admitted that my answer to #3 is correct, that given what we know about CO2 and photons, there is excellent reason to expect that if there is more CO2 in the atmosphere, then it will be warmer; and no one has even tried to answer the obvious deficiencies in a hypothesis that proposes a 1500 year cycle as an explanation for events that happened 500 years ago and are happening now.

*sigh* Your answers don't address the main point of this thread so they are of little interest to anyone. Merely because no one is listening is not proof that you are correct.

Again I will point out to you that there are many, many environmental models built on the best geophysical and environmental chemistry knowledge we have on hand. Despite the fact that we have full access to all the physical characteristics to the molecules we're trying to study, the models are not very good at all. That is why I don't take your insistance that merely because we know the physical characteristics of carbon dioxide in the lab, the effects of additional carbon dioxide in the environment will produce such effects stoichiometrically. You have already admitted that they don't. To me, additional carbon dioxide should be considered an environmental pollutant for which, I hate to admit, we can't predict which of many compartments it will occupy or spread itself into.
 
The book I referenced, by the way, ....

I have told you that I'm not discussing it here. Yes, anyone who wants to witness you lying can go to that thread. A shameful spectacle but, since you brought it up, I would urge any interested parties to go there.

In the meantime, if you have anything other than handwaving (it must be due to electrons...DUH!) to explain the optical rotation of stereoisomers in solution, add it to that thread, not here. That's the end of that discussion here.
 
That's the end. Produce a quote or admit you're lying.

Oh, now I get it. You need to be able to claim that I lie because I caught you in one? That's rich. And, now, you want to challenge me based on a word "stoichiometry" that you don't even know the definition for? (Hint: there's dictionaries on the web!)

You're way out of your league here, boy. This is not about quanta or spin or anything you know about. This discussion is about phenomena that are not underpinned by anything in your ken. The science here uses environmental modeling and that is something I know a lot about. You? Not so much. A degree in physics doesn't give one carte blanche over all fields of science. Nice attempt at browbeating again but it looks like any success you ever had at dominating discussions by pulling facts out of your alternate mouth are now at an end.

Begone, little one. Buy a dictionary.


As for the rest of us, we'll continue with the discussion.
 
Last edited:
Fine, we're done. Just wanted to be sure anytime I encounter you in the future I have a link to show that you lie. Thanks.
 
Oh, and one piece of unfinished business:

"1. A challenge for AGW believers to cite a scientific atmospheric study that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2 in the atmosphere." From the OP, here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2993363#post2993363

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html

That's AR4, the report from Working Group 1 of the IPCC, titled "The Physical Science Basis." Significant information is available here, the chapter titled "Changes in Atmospheric Constituents and in Radiative Forcing." Page 137 begins the section containing data on CO2 increases; on page 138 is a graph comparing emissions to concentration. On page 208, which begins the section dealing with the time evolution of radiative forcings, the following unequivocal statement is made: "Increases in RF [radiative forcing] are clearly dominated by CO2."

So all three questions have been answered, clearly and concisely. Is there any further point in this thread?
 
Oh, and one piece of unfinished business:

"1. A challenge for AGW believers to cite a scientific atmospheric study that provided empirical evidence of the hypothesized greenhouse effects of CO2 in the atmosphere." From the OP, here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2993363#post2993363

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html

That's AR4, the report from Working Group 1 of the IPCC, titled "The Physical Science Basis." Significant information is available here, the chapter titled "Changes in Atmospheric Constituents and in Radiative Forcing." Page 137 begins the section containing data on CO2 increases; on page 138 is a graph comparing emissions to concentration. On page 208, which begins the section dealing with the time evolution of radiative forcings, the following unequivocal statement is made: "Increases in RF [radiative forcing] are clearly dominated by CO2."

So all three questions have been answered, clearly and concisely. Is there any further point in this thread?

For some reason, the 4AR is not to be read, even though it is the authoritive source for the AGW claims.
 
I have seen the IPCC report and I have no doubt that the authors of the report stand behind what it says. I'm not questioning their interpretation but their data-gathering methods.

The IPCC reports on the current state of climate-related science, and the data it gathers comprises published science. It does not directly gather climate data, and so has no methods for doing so. It does have methods for gathering published science. It also has methods for evaluating published science. The main one being, of course, wide and open discussion within the scientific community leading to a concensus.

Actual climate data is gathered by research teams and institutions such as NASA or the Met Office. Do you question their methods? All of them?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom