Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

By who, by you? Oh, I never expected YOU to take me seriously. You must have me confused with someone who gives a **** what you think. It is, however, now abundantly clear that you have no way to refute either of my answers, and that you're trying desperately to cover that up. I just wanted anyone else who stops by the thread to be able to see it, too.
 
By who, by you? Oh, I never expected YOU to take me seriously. You must have me confused with someone who gives a **** what you think. It is, however, now abundantly clear that you have no way to refute either of my answers, and that you're trying desperately to cover that up. I just wanted anyone else who stops by the thread to be able to see it, too.

Ummm, well, it's like this, to put it bluntly.

Both of your "answers" have been brought up before here in reference to these questions and discussed at length. In fact, some others did a much better job at bringing those arguments up was done than what you have done. And both of them fell considerably short of anything that could be considered success, although some of the ideas were quite interesting. And it could well be that if some of them were carried a bit farther, they might address the questions.

Sorry, but that's reality.
 
Your non answer to #1 does not require any more discussion.

You are welcome to provide a coherent paragraph or two in response to #2. Please provide references from peer reviewed literature if you do, and indicate that you have some comprehension of the subject.

Otherwise, don't expect to be taken seriously.

Unintended irony par excellence.

You probably expect to be taken seriously. (You may even expect to define what is taken seriously.) But you're mistaken. Just look at the above quote for confirmation. If you don't find it embarrassing you're beyond help.
 
Ummm, well, it's like this, to put it bluntly.

Both of your "answers" have been brought up before here in reference to these questions and discussed at length.
Oh, really? Apparently, the answer to the first one was brought up early in the thread and never discussed again; one post from someone who knew some physics, one post from you, and that's it. I believe I even mentioned as much in my first post on this topic. I don't see any "at length." I see you trying to cover up poo on the carpet. Apparently, currently by making statements that are dishonest, by the evidence immediately available to anyone who cares enough to review this thread.

In fact, some others did a much better job at bringing those arguments up was done than what you have done.
In one post? Well, perhaps better- but then again, I stuck around and defended it. You know, this reminds me of watching folks duel with kleinman. I'll also remind you that this is not the first time I have brought this point up in answer to you, and also neither the first time you have tried every rhetorical book to escape from that point, nor the first time you have resorted to insults when it wouldn't go away, nor the first time you have been dishonest when nothing else would serve, and obviously so, without the slightest attempt at subtlety. The obvious contempt for your audience's intelligence that this shows cannot be gainsaid. You ARE aware there is an audience, right?

And both of them fell considerably short of anything that could be considered success, although some of the ideas were quite interesting.
"Some of the ideas were quite interesting." Who are you talking to, anyway, and what are you talking about? This is perfectly straightforward; you take some CO2, you put it in a container, you shine light through it, and these parts of the spectrum here, here, and over here are blocked. What you're trying to say is that that magically stops happening when the CO2 is in the atmosphere. Which is basically the same sort of woo that cretinists or physics cranks try; not to mention psychics and everybody with a cure-all that functions by harnessing "quantum energie(sic)."

If you haven't got an answer, why not just admit it instead of all these histrionics? It's not so bad. You're making yourself look worse trying to avoid admitting it than you would by just giving in, or even by just closing your mouth and walking away.

And it could well be that if some of them were carried a bit farther, they might address the questions.

Sorry, but that's reality.
:id:

:dl:

I'm sorry, you were saying? Reality? You mean like the reality of what happens when an infrared photon encounters a CO2 molecule?

Never mind. You probably don't get it.
 
I proved it quite conclusively, and you denying it is basically denial of inconvenient reality. It has a certain effect on how I and anyone else who reads this exchange judiciously will see whatever else you might have to say.

Shame for you that your posts are not deleted once they're read. You asked how carbon dioxide behaves differently in the environment than in the lab. Later, you admitted it did and you further said that the reasons were understood and documented.

It's been shown a hundred times. Besides, you haven't answered what I already wrote with integrity; why should I answer further in the absence of trustworthy answers and acknowledgement of error or dishonesty (your choice) in your previous retorts (they don't deserve to be called "replies," since they don't address what I said)?

You were writing to mhaze so I didn't reply to your question. I merely wanted to point out to the ever-present "third person" whom you seem to have more in mind when replying than the question. OK, I'll answer your question from my point of view:

No one knows, not even you. Of course, you can argue and probably correctly so, that a photon with the correct energy to shift one of carbon dioxides pi electrons to a permitted excited state will do so in nature as in the lab. I wouldn't argue with that but that's a truly fatuous fact, isn't it? That has little to do with what might/might not be causing GW or AGW. The question is how much of the human-added carbon dioxide is available for such excitation and what could possibly interfere with the warming effects of carbon dioxide that is so available. Again, no one knows, not even you. That's one of the primary questions right now and, if you don't feel like getting to the answer through the scientific process, some of us do.

I don't believe I see a reason to continue until you've done that. If you'd like to ask more questions, answer my allegations first. Until then, I'm prepared to stand you off indefinitely, continuing to ask when you will answer, and confident in the judgment of any third person who reads this.

Frankly, Schneibster, the day that I worry what a crank thinks is the day I will wander into the desert and into oblivion. I don't care if you answer any questions. Your answers are usually nasty browbeatings of people whom you consider lesser beings. I don't like scientific bullies and consider you one. Maybe I'm wrong about you. You've seemed to tone down since the first time you tried to shout me down but, as the Santana song goes, "how should I know; why shoud I care?".

And, I can't believe you're still addressing this "moral majority" of your own making. You know, the one that will agree with your idiocies and ostracize me so that I will leave the JREF in tears and disgrace. In case you haven't noticed, that hasn't happened. As a matter of fact, I've made quite a few friends here. Some of those people I consider as or more learned than you in Physics but much more mature, sane and social. That makes you eminently dispensible.
 
Last edited:
Apparently, currently by making statements that are dishonest, by the evidence immediately available to anyone who cares enough to review this thread.

In one post? Well, perhaps better- but then again, I stuck around and defended it.

Dishonest? Hmm...

Well, you certainly are making a defense of sorts.

But those challenges have been around for a while, so you should go check the other threads. Then, do your homework a bit. Then, come back with a scientific argument. It would help if you have references to prove your position, too.

Note the subject of this thread please.
 
Still and all, a 1500-year-plus-or-minus-500-years cycle that peaked 500 years ago and is claimed to be peaking again now is a bit of an anomaly, I'd say. Not much of anywhere to hide there, is there? :D

I'm happy to see that the mutual-admiration Schneibster/ Capel Dodger team has reunited to try to monopolize AGW threads with their simplistic views but it won't work this time. There are enough posters on this thread with real, honest questions based on fact that this stuff won't succeed.

Anyway, Schneibster, since you were gone so long, AUP has acknowledged that the study of AGW is a study of anomalies. You didn't read that part? So, try to keep up. We're doing science here. If you're not interested in that, take your friend to the park and throw some sticks in her direction.
 
I'm happy to see that the mutual-admiration Schneibster/ Capel Dodger team has reunited to try to monopolize AGW threads with their simplistic views but it won't work this time. There are enough posters on this thread with real, honest questions based on fact that this stuff won't succeed.

Anyway, Schneibster, since you were gone so long, AUP has acknowledged that the study of AGW is a study of anomalies.

AUP (in spite of our many differences) has also acknowledged that AGW is overlaid on top of natural cycles.

A fascinating issue we have not yet explored because it creates a quantifiable limit on AGW. (hypothesized AGW, of course, hypothesized both as to existence and extent)
 
Shame for you that your posts are not deleted once they're read. You asked how carbon dioxide behaves differently in the environment than in the lab. Later, you admitted it did and you further said that the reasons were understood and documented.
Oh really? Where was that?

As I said at the time, you understood neither the answer I provided to the original question, nor the answer I provided to the shifted goalposts question, and you've proven it here.

You were writing to mhaze so I didn't reply to your question. I merely wanted to point out to the ever-present "third person" whom you seem to have more in mind when replying than the question. OK, I'll answer your question from my point of view:

No one knows, not even you.
LOL! Really now, are you ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN that no one knows how CO2 behaves in the lab?

Of course, you can argue and probably correctly so, that a photon with the correct energy to shift one of carbon dioxides pi electrons to a permitted excited state will do so in nature as in the lab. I wouldn't argue with that but that's a truly fatuous fact, isn't it?
Only if you don't believe in the conservation of energy. Or the symmetry of physical results across position or time, which amounts to the same thing.

That has little to do with what might/might not be causing GW or AGW.
OK, so you're stating here for the record that CO2 has nothing to do with global warming, and that CO2 absorbing and re-radiating infrared photons in a random direction doesn't increase the retention of heat by the Earth, in the face of nearly two centuries of physics and physical chemistry. Do I have that right?

The question is how much of the human-added carbon dioxide is available for such excitation and what could possibly interfere with the warming effects of carbon dioxide that is so available.
What could interfere with the absorption of a photon of a particular wavelength if it encounters a CO2 molecule? Or are you now making a distinction between human-added CO2, and natural CO2? Do you believe they have different spectra?

Again, no one knows, not even you. That's one of the primary questions right now and, if you don't feel like getting to the answer through the scientific process, some of us do.
"Scientific process" that ignores basic physics. Right.

Frankly, Schneibster, the day that I worry what a crank thinks is the day I will wander into the desert and into oblivion.
Heh, the guy who doesn't think physics is a science, believes in magic "human-made" CO2 that doesn't absorb photons, and thinks the law of the conservation of energy might be optional, just called me a crank.

I don't care if you answer any questions. Your answers are usually nasty browbeatings of people whom you consider lesser beings.
No, I just can't stand crank physics, or any other crank science.

I don't like scientific bullies and consider you one. Maybe I'm wrong about you. You've seemed to tone down since the first time you tried to shout me down but, as the Santana song goes, "how should I know; why shoud I care?".
This is simple and straightforward: I don't like cranks, and after this post, it's abundantly clear you are one. You haven't changed a single little bit since I first met you, and I wasn't wrong then and I'm not wrong now. You believe in magic chemistry that doesn't have anything to do with physics, optional conservation of mass-energy, and that there's some magic CO2 out there that doesn't behave the same way in the atmosphere as it does in a lab. You make nasty comments about others because they know more than you do and you're jealous. You pick and choose among opinions about scientific theory based upon whether you like the implications, or the politics of the people who espouse them, rather than on the basis of whether they accurately describe the world. I could hardly care less what you think of me, since I've reached out to you several times and gotten nothing but bile from you. I won't make the mistake of bothering to do it again.
 
Dishonest? Hmm...

Well, you certainly are making a defense of sorts.

But those challenges have been around for a while, so you should go check the other threads. Then, do your homework a bit. Then, come back with a scientific argument. It would help if you have references to prove your position, too.

Note the subject of this thread please.
How about if I note that yet again, you have not answered how precisely if CO2 absorbs infrared photons and re-emits them in random directions, we should expect it NOT to cause global warming. What you asked was:
"3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?"
I showed that global temperature MUST have a relationship to atmospheric CO2 levels, unless physics is wrong. That is a clear and incontrovertible answer to your question, and so far, you've tried six different methods of ignoring it or getting around it. I'm just going to keep bringing it up until you answer it, so I'd get started, and there are plenty of people who know physics works, so I'd say you've got a really difficult problem in front of you. Have fun.
 
We're doing science here. If you're not interested in that, take your friend to the park and throw some sticks in her direction.
"Science" that denies the existence of the laws of physics, or their universality; "science" that maintains there is "special" CO2 that behaves differently from any other CO2 we've ever measured; "science" that proposes a 1500 year cycle to explain two approximately identical events separated by 500 years. I see no science here.
 
How about if I note that yet again, you have not answered how precisely if CO2 absorbs infrared photons and re-emits them in random directions, we should expect it NOT to cause global warming. What you asked was:
"3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?"
I showed that global temperature MUST have a relationship to atmospheric CO2 levels, unless physics is wrong.

Interesting.

You are correct, I have not answered your question.

That is because I have no interest in helping you answer the challenge that you set out so eagerly upon. So do your best. Include references please.
 
Oh really? Where was that?

Too tired for this. Review your past posts, OK? Not going to repost your idiocies for you. They're there for all to see.

As I said at the time, you understood neither the answer I provided to the original question, nor the answer I provided to the shifted goalposts question, and you've proven it here.

Seeing as no one has supported you on this, I don't think I'm the only one who "misunderstood" you. Sorry. You provided a stilted question for yourself to answer. We're all still waiting for what you consider your usual brilliance.

LOL! Really now, are you ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN that no one knows how CO2 behaves in the lab?

That's not what I wrote. You're being disingenuous again. Of course, we know how CO52 behaves in the lab. We have reams of data on it. I asked you why the concentrations didn't track well with the observed thermal data. You earlier claimed that you knew. Are you going to disappoint us yet again?

Only if you don't believe in the conservation of energy. Or the symmetry of physical results across position or time, which amounts to the same thing.

Again, the lab data are irrelevant to the discussion as the temperature of the planet is apparently not directly correlated to carbon dioxide concentration. Your evasion is noted but it still does not support your argument. You claimed you knew. Do you know or not? It's time to stop dancing and give an answer.

OK, so you're stating here for the record that CO2 has nothing to do with global warming, and that CO2 absorbing and re-radiating infrared photons in a random direction doesn't increase the retention of heat by the Earth, in the face of nearly two centuries of physics and physical chemistry. Do I have that right?

I am stating no such thing. You really are too confident that I have the memory capacity of a gnat. I fully remember what you said. I'm not convinced that GW is AGW. That has everything to do with the climatological activity (note, not concentration) of carbon dioxide. There, now I'm throwing you another chemistry concept that you are probably as familiar with as stereochemistry. :rolleyes: So, build your strawmen high. I really don't care. I told you already the esteem in which I hold your opinion.

What could interfere with the absorption of a photon of a particular wavelength if it encounters a CO2 molecule? Or are you now making a distinction between human-added CO2, and natural CO2? Do you believe they have different spectra?

Another strawman. You're the one who earlier wrote that the reasons why the temperature of the planet deviate from the recorded carbon dioxide concentrations were understood and documented. I asked for the reasons that you claimed you knew. Now, all I'm getting is dancing and straw men. Again, do you know or don't you? I'm pretty sure you don't but getting you to admit that you don't know anything is damned well near impossible.

"Scientific process" that ignores basic physics. Right.

When basic physics accurately predicts everything in the universe, perhaps we'll begin thinking of you as a true scientist. We've covered this before, you and I, haven't we, Schneibster? Can you explain stereochemical effects yet? We don't ignore basic physics. It's just that basic physics don't explain everything. That's why there are other sciences. Has no one clued you into that yet?

Heh, the guy who doesn't think physics is a science, believes in magic "human-made" CO2 that doesn't absorb photons, and thinks the law of the conservation of energy might be optional, just called me a crank.

Here's an ad hom you can't back up. Please post any time I've ever stated that physics is not a science. And, like I said, it's activity, not concentration, that matters. Anyone who knows thermodynamics knows that. And, yes, I do think of you as a crank. You take a lot on faith that a scientist would only accept based on evidence. Yet, when you're asked for evidence you revert to this tired line of argumentation. Strawmen, half truths, unsupportable calumnies, evasion. All part of the Schneibster waltz we've all seen ad nauseam.

No, I just can't stand crank physics, or any other crank science.

Cry me a river. Most of us on this thread are here in the hope of investigating claims and reaching an understanding based on evidence. All other (you, included) may be excused. If you don't want to participate, please absent yourself. Otherwise, you're welcome to chip in your thoughts while we're using the scientific process.

This is simple and straightforward: I don't like cranks, and after this post, it's abundantly clear you are one. You haven't changed a single little bit since I first met you, and I wasn't wrong then and I'm not wrong now. You believe in magic chemistry that doesn't have anything to do with physics, optional conservation of mass-energy, and that there's some magic CO2 out there that doesn't behave the same way in the atmosphere as it does in a lab. You make nasty comments about others because they know more than you do and you're jealous. You pick and choose among opinions about scientific theory based upon whether you like the implications, or the politics of the people who espouse them, rather than on the basis of whether they accurately describe the world. I could hardly care less what you think of me, since I've reached out to you several times and gotten nothing but bile from you. I won't make the mistake of bothering to do it again.

Yes, I know, you're always right. That's your problem, not mine. That's precisely why you are a crank and you won't listen to any other opinions. Your mind is as closed as the Sago mine. Whether you like me or not, is immaterial. I plainly don't like you because I think your attitude and methods are antithetical to science, skepticism and knowledge. I don't like bullies and your obvious attempts to paint me as someone who doesn't respect physics is proof enough for me that you are nothing more than a crank. Reach out all you want. You and I are on opposite sides of the fence on how science should be used. For me, science is to be used to further the knowledge of the universe and help people, even non-scientists, understand their world. I won't even speculate as to what you believe science should be as it would probably make me nauseous. Have you noticed that your staunchest supporter doesn't even know what entropy is? If you want to attract that type of following, you're on the right track. Maybe AGW is true, maybe it isn't. The rest of us will determine what it is without your help.
 
"Science" that denies the existence of the laws of physics, or their universality; "science" that maintains there is "special" CO2 that behaves differently from any other CO2 we've ever measured; "science" that proposes a 1500 year cycle to explain two approximately identical events separated by 500 years. I see no science here.

:rolleyes: No. Science that goes beyond what elementary physics can explain*. Perhaps you haven't noticed that there are other sciences at work here. If there are specious claims made about historical climate, then the scientific method will demonstrate that or, perhaps you don't believe in the scientific method. If there is no science here, then you may leave. Leave us dimwits to try to rediscover what you already know, OK, genius? :p

*when you can explain stereochemistry with elementary physics, the world may begin listening to your attempts to stifle the use of other fields of expertise. I thought you'd be too smart to pursue the sophomoric line of thinking that, because a molecule exhibits a certain activity per mole in the lab, it must therefore do the same in the environment. Please cite any environmental model that is based on physics that accurately predicts the activity of all molecules in the environment. Any.
 
Too tired for this. Review your past posts, OK? Not going to repost your idiocies for you. They're there for all to see.
No, you claim they are and when challenged to provide a reference, can't.

Seeing as no one has supported you on this, I don't think I'm the only one who "misunderstood" you.
It doesn't matter whether anyone supports me or not. It's there in black and white, and you just confounded both of the answers I supplied with one another, and then claimed to understand them.

Yes, you are. Extremely.

You provided a stilted question for yourself to answer.
Sigh. Here we go again. What stilted question was that, ST? Go look it up for yourself. It doesn't exist. Oh yes it does. Then provide a link. Find it yourself.

Do you ever get tired of this, or assume that anyone who reads this has comprehension skills greater than third grade?

We're all still waiting for what you consider your usual brilliance.
No, you're all not answering what I said because you don't have an answer, and trying to cover that up.

That's not what I wrote.
Then you interpret it for me. It sure looks that way to me. In the absence of any clarification from you, which you have not provided other than to say what you claim you did not mean, I'll stick to it. If you'd like to correct it, feel free.

You're being disingenuous again.
Oh, really? How? Please provide a quote of where I'm being disingenuous, when you make yet another claim and refuse to substantiate it.

Of course, we know how CO52 behaves in he lab. We have reams of data on it.
But not in the atmosphere, right? Riiiiiiiiiight. It's DIFFERENT in the atmosphere, right?

I asked you why the concentrations didn't track well with the observed thermal data. You earlier claimed that you knew. Are you going to disappoint us yet again?
You're on your own, sport. As I said, you confounded two separate statements, neither of which you understood, and made a claim of what I said based on that. It's not my problem if you don't have reading comprehension beyond the third grade level.

Again, the lab data are irrelevant to the discussion as the temperature of the planet is apparently not directly correlated to carbon dioxide concentration.
So, the lab data are irrelevant to how CO2 behaves in the atmosphere. Which is precisely what I said you said. You believe in magic CO2.

Your evasion is noted but it still does not support your argument.
What evasion? You mean pointing out that you misunderstood two statements, confounded them, and claimed I said something I didn't say? Sorry, like I said, I'm not responsible for your sub-third grade reading comprehension level.

You claimed you knew. Do you know or not? It's time to stop dancing and give an answer.
To a question about something you made up? I'd say it's time you admitted you didn't understand what I said, and started asking some questions until you DO understand and can demonstrate it. Alternatively, you could try going back and reading it again, and trying to understand that it's two different answers, to two different questions, not to be confused with one another, and not to be mixed together. Then you could demonstrate your New Clue by asking questions relevant to one answer or the other, instead of the word salad you've made up about them.

I am stating no such thing.
Well, you sure coulda fooled me, because I said, "CO2 absorbs energy, and re-radiates it in a random direction, and that makes the Earth warmer," and you said, "That has little to do with what does or does not cause GW or AGW." Looks like that reading comprehension thing rearing its ugly head again to me.

You really are too confident that I have the memory capacity of a gnat.
No, you've demonstrated that your reading comprehension level is sub-third grade.

I fully remember what you said. I'm not convinced that GW is AGW.
So? The question I was answering had nothing to do with whether the GW is AGW or not. Reading comprehension again.

That has everything to do with the climatological activity (note, not concentration) of carbon dioxide.
So there's magic CO2 that behaves differently in the atmosphere. It's not clear whether you think that's the man-made kind, or the natural kind, and I'm not especially clear on what possible difference you think there might be, so I'll choose one and say that you think the magic CO2 comes from human activity. It could as easily be the natural CO2 that you think is magic, but it would be more consistent if it were the man-made kind.

See, otherwise it doesn't matter where the CO2 comes from; that's not what the question was about. The question was, can you substantiate a relationship between CO2 concentration and temperature? And the answer is, yes, I can, CO2 absorbs infrared photons and re-radiates them in a random direction, and that means that some of them don't make it to space, and that means that there's more energy on the Earth's surface, and that means that the temperature goes up, unless you don't "believe in" physics.

There, now I'm throwing you another chemistry concept that you are probably as familiar with as stereochemistry. :rolleyes:
As it happens, I am very familiar with stereochemistry, but that is neither here nor there.

So, build your strawmen high. I really don't care. I told you already the esteem in which I hold your opinion.
Well, you're rapidly dropping in mine, because you keep making claims you can't substantiate, keep telling me you believe in magic CO2 that doesn't behave the same in the laboratory and the atmosphere, and keep telling me you believe that man-made CO2 is magic and doesn't contribute to GW.

Another strawman. You're the one who earlier wrote that the reasons why the temperature of the planet deviate from the recorded carbon dioxide concentrations were understood and documented. I asked for the reasons that you claimed you knew. Now, all I'm getting is dancing and straw men. Again, do you know or don't you? I'm pretty sure you don't but getting you to admit that you don't know anything is damned well near impossible.
Hey, at least I don't believe in magic CO2. And at least I believe the laws of physics apply everywhere and everywhen the same.

When basic physics accurately predicts everything in the universe, perhaps we'll begin thinking of you as a true scientist.
So, now physics has to explain everything in the universe or it's not correct? Yet another weird belief to add to the magic CO2 and the denial of the laws of physics.

We've covered this before, you and I, haven't we, Schneibster? Can you explain stereochemical effects yet? We don't ignore basic physics. It's just that basic physics don't explain everything. That's why there are other sciences. Has no one clued you into that yet?
First, stereochemistry is aside from the point; and second, you got in trouble with me originally because you got mad when you said something stupid about chemistry and physics and got challenged on it and didn't have an answer. Pretty much like you're doing right now.

Here's an ad hom you can't back up. Please post any time I've ever stated that physics is not a science.
Sure.
That's one of the primary questions right now and, if you don't feel like getting to the answer through the scientific process, some of us do.
I used physics, and you said I wasn't using "the scientific process." I.e., you think physics isn't a science.

And, like I said, it's activity, not concentration, that matters.
And so there's magic, "inactive" CO2, and "active" CO2, and one is natural, and one is man-made. OK. Whatever. That's what you've been saying the whole time.

Anyone who knows thermodynamics knows that.
Knows what? That there is magic inactive CO2 that doesn't absorb photons? OK. How would they know that from thermodynamics?

And, yes, I do think of you as a crank.
Again, I'm a crank, and this is coming from someone who doesn't think physics is a science, believes in magic CO2, and thinks natural and man-made CO2 are somehow different; one is "active" and one is "inactive." OK. Whatever.

You take a lot on faith that a scientist would only accept based on evidence.
Like what? Like that physics works? Again, OK, whatever.

Yet, when you're asked for evidence you revert to this tired line of argumentation.
You mean the one where I present facts that you don't have any answers for.

Strawmen, half truths, unsupportable calumnies, evasion. All part of the Schneibster waltz we've all seen ad nauseam.
Well, I seem to have substantiated every one, from your own words. Hey, it's what YOU SAID. Sorry. Perhaps you have as much trouble understanding what you have written as you do understanding what others have. That's a pretty major problem if you want to have a sensible conversation on a web forum. You probably ought to do something about it.

Cry me a river. Most of us on this thread are here in the hope of investigating claims and reaching an understanding based on evidence. All other (you, included) may be excused. If you don't want to participate, please absent yourself. Otherwise, you're welcome to chip in your thoughts while we're using the scientific process.
That doesn't include physics. Sorry, I think I'll stick around a while. Wouldn't want anyone to stumble across this and think that you people were talking sense or anything.
 
Interesting.

You are correct, I have not answered your question.

That is because I have no interest in helping you answer the challenge that you set out so eagerly upon. So do your best. Include references please.

Read the 4AR, then, if you have any questions, please feel free to ask them. It's the case for, by the scientists researching the field.
 
:rolleyes: No. Science that goes beyond what elementary physics can explain*.
Oh, my goodness, teh speshul scients! Everybody's got speshul scients that explains everything. And you call me a crank. This is way, way out there, about a hundred points on the Baez crank index. I guess it must be teh speshul scients that makes the magic CO2 not absorb photons.

Perhaps you haven't noticed that there are other sciences at work here.
You mean like, geophysics? :D

If there are specious claims made about historical climate, then the scientific method will demonstrate that or, perhaps you don't believe in the scientific method. If there is no science here, then you may leave. Leave us dimwits to try to rediscover what you already know, OK, genius? :p
No, like I said, I wouldn't want anyone to stumble across this and think you people had the least clue what you're talking about; they'd be all off into magic CO2, and how the CO2 that is man-made is different from the rest of the CO2, and how physics isn't a science, and so forth. A real train wreck.

*when you can explain stereochemistry with elementary physics, the world may begin listening to your attempts to stifle the use of other fields of expertise.
Stifle? This is the claim you made in that other thread, and this stuff about stereochemistry has now been brought up three times. I will therefore answer, despite the fact that it is off-topic, since you insist.

Stereochemistry is the study of the arrangement of atoms within a molecule, more precisely, the study of how many different spatial arrangements are possible for the same structural formula, and how those different spatial arrangements differ when they react with other chemicals. In most cases, because we live in a three-dimensional universe, that number is two; thus, "stereo"chemistry. This is called "chiral" stereochemistry, where chiral refers to handedness, as in left hand and right hand, which implies mirror imaging. A stereoisomer is a molecule that has the same structural formula as another, but whose atoms are arranged in a mirror image in space.

Now, this concerns atoms; and it concerns position; and it concerns spatial arrangement. And all of these things are matters of physics. Furthermore, since it studies how such isomers differ in their interactions with other chemicals, it concerns the interactions of atoms in the molecules with one another, and that also is a matter of physics. Theoretically, all such interactions could be described purely in terms of quantum mechanics; however, an enormous amount of computing power would be required due to the complexities of these interactions, and this is also true of other types of chemistry. Stereochemistry, therefore, provides a higher-level view, in which the units are molecules and their isomers rather than individual atoms; this higher-level view is more tractable, permitting the use of much more compact modeling, perhaps even without computers other than pencil and paper. Little or no detail is lost, due to the symmetries of physics, when using this approach. However, again theoretically, all of this could be worked out on the basis of individual quantum interactions, and fully described in those terms.

That is what I said, that is what I meant, and it is self-evidently true. Of course, if you don't think physics is a science, then you probably don't think so, but that's not my problem. You asked, I answered, we're done.

I thought you'd be too smart to pursue the sophomoric line of thinking that, because a molecule exhibits a certain activity per mole in the lab, it must therefore do the same in the environment. Please cite any environmental model that is based on physics that accurately predicts the activity of all molecules in the environment. Any.
Again, now you want physics to describe every last detail, or it's not a science. While theoretically possible, this would require even more processing power; and because we know how the underlying interactions work, we can easily make optimizing assumptions that allow models that use much less power, though still quite a lot. And in fact, that's precisely what the people who make climate models do; and lo and behold, it's the same sort of thing they used to figure out how stereochemistry works. But that's not all.

Stereochemistry is based on a model. It's the model of the atom and its interaction with other atoms to form molecules. Now, you've said that models of the atmosphere don't work; it's pretty obvious that you're anti-model. So now you have a major problem trying to do stereochemistry; you don't believe your models work! How do you do your job?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom