Too tired for this. Review your past posts, OK? Not going to repost your idiocies for you. They're there for all to see.
No, you claim they are and when challenged to provide a reference, can't.
Seeing as no one has supported you on this, I don't think I'm the only one who "misunderstood" you.
It doesn't matter whether anyone supports me or not. It's there in black and white, and you just confounded both of the answers I supplied with one another, and then claimed to understand them.
Yes, you are. Extremely.
You provided a stilted question for yourself to answer.
Sigh. Here we go again. What stilted question was that, ST? Go look it up for yourself. It doesn't exist. Oh yes it does. Then provide a link. Find it yourself.
Do you ever get tired of this, or assume that anyone who reads this has comprehension skills greater than third grade?
We're all still waiting for what you consider your usual brilliance.
No, you're all not answering what I said because you don't have an answer, and trying to cover that up.
Then you interpret it for me. It sure looks that way to me. In the absence of any clarification from you, which you have not provided other than to say what you claim you did not mean, I'll stick to it. If you'd like to correct it, feel free.
You're being disingenuous again.
Oh, really? How? Please provide a quote of where I'm being disingenuous, when you make yet another claim and refuse to substantiate it.
Of course, we know how CO52 behaves in he lab. We have reams of data on it.
But not in the atmosphere, right? Riiiiiiiiiight. It's DIFFERENT in the atmosphere, right?
I asked you why the concentrations didn't track well with the observed thermal data. You earlier claimed that you knew. Are you going to disappoint us yet again?
You're on your own, sport. As I said, you confounded two separate statements, neither of which you understood, and made a claim of what I said based on that. It's not my problem if you don't have reading comprehension beyond the third grade level.
Again, the lab data are irrelevant to the discussion as the temperature of the planet is apparently not directly correlated to carbon dioxide concentration.
So, the lab data are irrelevant to how CO2 behaves in the atmosphere. Which is precisely what I said you said. You believe in magic CO2.
Your evasion is noted but it still does not support your argument.
What evasion? You mean pointing out that you misunderstood two statements, confounded them, and claimed I said something I didn't say? Sorry, like I said, I'm not responsible for your sub-third grade reading comprehension level.
You claimed you knew. Do you know or not? It's time to stop dancing and give an answer.
To a question about something you made up? I'd say it's time you admitted you didn't understand what I said, and started asking some questions until you DO understand and can demonstrate it. Alternatively, you could try going back and reading it again, and trying to understand that it's two different answers, to two different questions, not to be confused with one another, and not to be mixed together. Then you could demonstrate your New Clue by asking questions relevant to one answer or the other, instead of the word salad you've made up about them.
I am stating no such thing.
Well, you sure coulda fooled me, because I said, "CO2 absorbs energy, and re-radiates it in a random direction, and that makes the Earth warmer," and you said, "That has little to do with what does or does not cause GW or AGW." Looks like that reading comprehension thing rearing its ugly head again to me.
You really are too confident that I have the memory capacity of a gnat.
No, you've demonstrated that your reading comprehension level is sub-third grade.
I fully remember what you said. I'm not convinced that GW is AGW.
So? The question I was answering had nothing to do with whether the GW is AGW or not. Reading comprehension again.
That has everything to do with the climatological activity (note, not concentration) of carbon dioxide.
So there's magic CO2 that behaves differently in the atmosphere. It's not clear whether you think that's the man-made kind, or the natural kind, and I'm not especially clear on what possible difference you think there might be, so I'll choose one and say that you think the magic CO2 comes from human activity. It could as easily be the natural CO2 that you think is magic, but it would be more consistent if it were the man-made kind.
See, otherwise it doesn't matter where the CO2 comes from; that's not what the question was about. The question was, can you substantiate a relationship between CO2 concentration and temperature? And the answer is, yes, I can, CO2 absorbs infrared photons and re-radiates them in a random direction, and that means that some of them don't make it to space, and that means that there's more energy on the Earth's surface, and that means that the temperature goes up, unless you don't "believe in" physics.
There, now I'm throwing you another chemistry concept that you are probably as familiar with as stereochemistry.
As it happens, I am very familiar with stereochemistry, but that is neither here nor there.
So, build your strawmen high. I really don't care. I told you already the esteem in which I hold your opinion.
Well, you're rapidly dropping in mine, because you keep making claims you can't substantiate, keep telling me you believe in magic CO2 that doesn't behave the same in the laboratory and the atmosphere, and keep telling me you believe that man-made CO2 is magic and doesn't contribute to GW.
Another strawman. You're the one who earlier wrote that the reasons why the temperature of the planet deviate from the recorded carbon dioxide concentrations were understood and documented. I asked for the reasons that you claimed you knew. Now, all I'm getting is dancing and straw men. Again, do you know or don't you? I'm pretty sure you don't but getting you to admit that you don't know anything is damned well near impossible.
Hey, at least I don't believe in magic CO2. And at least I believe the laws of physics apply everywhere and everywhen the same.
When basic physics accurately predicts everything in the universe, perhaps we'll begin thinking of you as a true scientist.
So, now physics has to explain everything in the universe or it's not correct? Yet another weird belief to add to the magic CO2 and the denial of the laws of physics.
We've covered this before, you and I, haven't we, Schneibster? Can you explain stereochemical effects yet? We don't ignore basic physics. It's just that basic physics don't explain everything. That's why there are other sciences. Has no one clued you into that yet?
First, stereochemistry is aside from the point; and second, you got in trouble with me originally because you got mad when you said something stupid about chemistry and physics and got challenged on it and didn't have an answer. Pretty much like you're doing right now.
Here's an ad hom you can't back up. Please post any time I've ever stated that physics is not a science.
Sure.
That's one of the primary questions right now and, if you don't feel like getting to the answer through the scientific process, some of us do.
I used physics, and you said I wasn't using "the scientific process." I.e., you think physics isn't a science.
And, like I said, it's activity, not concentration, that matters.
And so there's magic, "inactive" CO2, and "active" CO2, and one is natural, and one is man-made. OK. Whatever. That's what you've been saying the whole time.
Anyone who knows thermodynamics knows that.
Knows what? That there is magic inactive CO2 that doesn't absorb photons? OK. How would they know that from thermodynamics?
And, yes, I do think of you as a crank.
Again, I'm a crank, and this is coming from someone who doesn't think physics is a science, believes in magic CO2, and thinks natural and man-made CO2 are somehow different; one is "active" and one is "inactive." OK. Whatever.
You take a lot on faith that a scientist would only accept based on evidence.
Like what? Like that physics works? Again, OK, whatever.
Yet, when you're asked for evidence you revert to this tired line of argumentation.
You mean the one where I present facts that you don't have any answers for.
Strawmen, half truths, unsupportable calumnies, evasion. All part of the Schneibster waltz we've all seen ad nauseam.
Well, I seem to have substantiated every one, from your own words. Hey, it's what YOU SAID. Sorry. Perhaps you have as much trouble understanding what you have written as you do understanding what others have. That's a pretty major problem if you want to have a sensible conversation on a web forum. You probably ought to do something about it.
Cry me a river. Most of us on this thread are here in the hope of investigating claims and reaching an understanding based on evidence. All other (you, included) may be excused. If you don't want to participate, please absent yourself. Otherwise, you're welcome to chip in your thoughts while we're using the scientific process.
That doesn't include physics. Sorry, I think I'll stick around a while. Wouldn't want anyone to stumble across this and think that you people were talking sense or anything.