Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Why did you ask a question that you answered yourself later?
I didn't. I asked, how does the rest of the atmosphere affect the absorption and re-emission of photons by CO2? That has nothing to do with any alleged or proven other affects on temperature or heat flow that are extraneous to that specific subject. I note that you have mischaracterized my question, and my answer, and appear to understand neither.

Asking a subset question is not "shifting the goalpost".
It wasn't a subset; it was a completely separate matter introduced to obfuscate the fact that a proper answer to the original question was given, which is the precise definition of "shifting the goalposts," in both technique and intent.

As usual, your answers are self-contradictory and less than honest.
This looks like projection, since both of your comments are demonstrably aside from the points they purport to address, and you threw in some ad hominem attack to go with it.
 
I didn't. I asked, how does the rest of the atmosphere affect the absorption and re-emission of photons by CO2? That has nothing to do with any alleged or proven other affects on temperature or heat flow that are extraneous to that specific subject. I note that you have mischaracterized my question, and my answer, and appear to understand neither.

Not at all. You maintain that carbon dioxide is the operative factor in GW then you go on to say that, well, temperatures are not tracking in lockstep with carbon dioxide concentrations but it's been document why. So why? You seem to know. Spill it.

It wasn't a subset; it was a completely separate matter introduced to obfuscate the fact that a proper answer to the original question was given, which is the precise definition of "shifting the goalposts," in both technique and intent.

It is a subset. How is a request that a direct correlation between carbon dioxide concentrations and global temperature not be a subset of a request for proof that humans are causing global warming via contribution of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere? Please also describe to us the physics you used to determine mhaze's intent.

This looks like projection, since both of your comments are demonstrably aside from the points they purport to address, and you threw in some ad hominem attack to go with it.

No projection. Just pointing out to you the contradition in your post. Something that seems to be de riguer for you.

Ah, the king of ad homs can't take it? I knew you wouldn't stay away long after stomping off in protest of the new Forum rules. Made up any good books lately? :eek:
 
Not at all.
I proved it quite conclusively, and you denying it is basically denial of inconvenient reality. It has a certain effect on how I and anyone else who reads this exchange judiciously will see whatever else you might have to say.

You maintain that carbon dioxide is the operative factor in GW then you go on to say that, well, temperatures are not tracking in lockstep with carbon dioxide concentrations but it's been document why. So why? You seem to know. Spill it.
It's been shown a hundred times. Besides, you haven't answered what I already wrote with integrity; why should I answer further in the absence of trustworthy answers and acknowledgement of error or dishonesty (your choice) in your previous retorts (they don't deserve to be called "replies," since they don't address what I said)? I don't believe I see a reason to continue until you've done that. If you'd like to ask more questions, answer my allegations first. Until then, I'm prepared to stand you off indefinitely, continuing to ask when you will answer, and confident in the judgment of any third person who reads this.
 
Oh, and by the way, that's still one question answered and two to go. Until you make a factual, honest response, you might as well not waste electrons.
 
Ha! So even the very questions he's asking are dishonest according to his own previously stated beliefs. Very nice.
 
OK. Medieval warm period, 500 years or less ago. Whether I buy it or not, YOUR sources do.

Next?

Actually, this cycle is 1500 plus or minus 500 years. Whether this means that the period of the cycle is between one and two thousand years but not yet exactly ascertained, or that it's a cycle each period of which can be between one and two thousand years (which is a pretty poor example of a cycle, to my mind) is not certain. I have actually looked at the referenced Singer weaseling and it's not clear from that.

What seems to happen is that a 1500-year cycle based on D-O events (which involve warming around Greenland and cooling in the Southern Oceans, the second of which goes unmentioned by said weasel) is latched onto as a purely statistical counter-argument to a physical argument, then the plus or minus is introduced to fit with the Medieval Warm Period.

The chosen climate reconstruction shown is from 1991, based on work done in 1990. So we're seventeen years on from that, during which time quite a lot has been going on. The past is such a comfortable place of refuge, isn't it :rolleyes:?

Back in 1990 Singer was still claiming that global warming wouldn't occur. Only since then has he searched out this 1500 year cycle as events unfolded. Otherwise he's have predicted warming, based on said cycle only having entered the warming phase in 1850.

Any port in a storm, as they say. Apart from New Orleans, obviously. And Galveston.


eta : On the climate reconstruction graph the upper y-axis runs from 0 to 5 to 1. This clearly a typo and should be 0 to 0.5 to 1. A bit sloppy, to my mind. Heaven forfend that it be deliberate.
 
Last edited:
Still and all, a 1500-year-plus-or-minus-500-years cycle that peaked 500 years ago and is claimed to be peaking again now is a bit of an anomaly, I'd say. Not much of anywhere to hide there, is there? :D
 
Ha! So even the very questions he's asking are dishonest according to his own previously stated beliefs. Very nice.

This is the fun-house AGW thread du jour. The speculative arm-waving is enough to drive an Aristotle to the bottle. I mostly ignore it, but I was driven to comment on CO2 trapped in deep ice reacting with H2O to create hydrocarbons, thus invalidating the ice-core records. I'm not made of stone, after all :).

Our stalwart friend a_unique_person keeps the pot stirred, otherwise this thread would just become an extension of ClimateAudit. As it is, it remains an outreach project.
 
Still and all, a 1500-year-plus-or-minus-500-years cycle that peaked 500 years ago and is claimed to be peaking again now is a bit of an anomaly, I'd say. Not much of anywhere to hide there, is there? :D

Five hundred years ago is meant to be the Litlle Ice Age, unless you want to project 1500 years forward from the Roman Warm Period - and why not? There are no rules involved. The Medieval and Roman Warm Periods were invested in long before this 1500 year cycle was recruited, so what we've got is two 1000-ish year cycles - unless the current cycle has a way to run, in which case it's gonna get damn' hot at this rate.

Like I say, it's a fun-house.
 
I proved it quite conclusively

Howdy, Schneib. People been missin you round here. But I must tell you, no, you've not proved it. I'm certain you can give it a good try, though. It's very simple, so there is no reason to complicate the matter with lots of verbage. Note the word "correlation". And the word "causation". You know what they mean. Note the inclusion of the phrase "any relationship".
Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?
​
I've tried to help Warmers solve this one by offering to let them use the 135 data sets of historical CO2 readings compiled by Beck, in addition to the Mauna Loa data. At least, to some extent - that is to say, we might be able to agree on some group of data sets on some rational basis.

Then, I'm sure we could agree on some temperature series.

At that point, the challenge is to show correlation, causation, or any relationship between the data sets selected.

I'm just trying to clarify the issue for you here, there is no shifting of goal posts yada-yada-yada, and no reason for a bunch of verbage at all.

It's a simple question about two sets of data, that is all.
 
Perhaps if you'd said anything salient as to why you think the laws that govern the interactions of CO2 and photons are different in the atmosphere than in the laboratory, I might bother to respond with something other than a reiteration of my statement that I answered your question definitively and have not heard a single argument that could hold water against that answer. As it is, you haven't, and are merely attempting to ignore that fact.
 
Oh, and by the way, looks like you've got a little problem with that whole 1500 year cycle thing, too. There's one more fruit hanging in reach, but I'm sated now. Perhaps it will dangle a bit longer.
 
Perhaps if you'd said anything salient as to why you think the laws that govern the interactions of CO2 and photons are different in the atmosphere than in the laboratory, I might bother to respond with something other than a reiteration of my statement that I answered your question definitively and have not heard a single argument that could hold water against that answer. As it is, you haven't, and are merely attempting to ignore that fact.

No rush. If you think of a way to approach the problem and show a relation, let me know. Didn't say it was easy, of course.
 
Since you haven't refuted it, and don't appear to be able to, we'll take that one as settled. I note that you also have not refuted my answer to #2.
 
Your non answer to #1 does not require any more discussion.

You are welcome to provide a coherent paragraph or two in response to #2. Please provide references from peer reviewed literature if you do, and indicate that you have some comprehension of the subject.

Otherwise, don't expect to be taken seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom