Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your point is simply the aphorism "the perfect is the enemy of good". Criminals whether in the police force or not will indeed be criminals.

No, you missed the point. He said, very clearly, that legalization protects sex workers from criminally abusive cops. Perhaps I'm mistaken here, but weren't they already protected from cops criminally abusing them? Or was that allowed prior to legalization? As you say, criminals be criminals, and legalization doesn't change that particular aspect.
 
No, you missed the point. He said, very clearly, that legalization protects sex workers from criminally abusive cops.

I think it is you that missed the point. He didn't say that legalization protects sex workers from criminally abusive cops. He said it gives sex workers meaningful recourse against criminally abusive cops.

Criminalizing sex work has a chilling effect on sex workers reporting victimization (at the hands of cops or anyone else).

People who are victimized in the course of committing a crime don't like to report that to the authorities, even when they have a sound legal basis for reporting the crime that's being committed against them. Legalizing the work they do makes it much safer and more productive for them to report crimes committed against them in the course of their work.

That's what TG is saying, and I think he's right.

I think it's also almost certain that legalizing sex work will have at least some chilling effect on cops seeking to harass or extort or abuse sex workers. Simply because it removes a major deterrent against reporting such criminal cop behavior.
 
I think it is you that missed the point. He didn't say that legalization protects sex workers from criminally abusive cops. He said it gives sex workers meaningful recourse against criminally abusive cops.

Criminalizing sex work has a chilling effect on sex workers reporting victimization (at the hands of cops or anyone else).

People who are victimized in the course of committing a crime don't like to report that to the authorities, even when they have a sound legal basis for reporting the crime that's being committed against them. Legalizing the work they do makes it much safer and more productive for them to report crimes committed against them in the course of their work.

That's what TG is saying, and I think he's right.

I think it's also almost certain that legalizing sex work will have at least some chilling effect on cops seeking to harass or extort or abuse sex workers. Simply because it removes a major deterrent against reporting such criminal cop behavior.

I don't disagree that legalization offers at least a theoretical resolution, but with how often we hear about the bordeine criminali enterprise of NZ police work in the first place, it's by no means a powerhouse point. A step in the right direction, sure.

The role of police in this topic is squirrelly. It is said they abused the bejesus out of sex workers, and now the cops use them as snitches, which sounds like a good way to become a dead prostitute to my ears. Also, why "crooks" would use legal hookers who publicly rat them out when they could likely have their own more discrete illegal workers is something that makes little sense to me either.

Again, it's not an argumentative stance. Kind of poking around at the three thousand questions that come up, none of which get a very satisfactory answer. Pretty sure we are not getting closer to them though.
 
Nothing has been "explained". That's the point. What has been "explained" is that NZ prostitutes are gorgeous, well educated professionals pulling up to $500/hr as a choice. Ok, great! But that leaves hanging what happened to the workers who don't command such rates, that (if what I'm reading online is accurate) historically made up the majority of sex workers. Are kiwis so fabulously wealthy that they can afford such luxuries, to the point of no demand for cheaper/less genteel servicing? Or are they so compliant with law that they refuse a black market option on principle? Do the previously trafficked/addicted workers go to work at McDonalds? If so, that's a societal phenomenon that is pretty unique, and makes prostitution specifically "not the subject".

If you don't know how it happened, that's fine, of course. Or if the narrative just works for you, or whatever. But at some level, surely you understand that saying "we made it legal and much more expensive and the problems just vanished" falls a little flat, explanation-wise. A bit like saying "we legalized opioids and all our problems disappeared. Don't ask so many questions". Which, coincidentally, is exactly what we are battling in the States rn. The market may change, but the inherent problems don't just conveniently go away.

Yes, this has been explained to you.

For the most part, the people you describe do not exist. People who meet your description simply do not go into that line of work (somewhat like the way that 4ft 11in people don't get selected for adult basketball teams, or 6ft 2in 275lb people don't apply for jockey apprenticeships).
 
Yes, this has been explained to you.

For the most part, the people you describe do not exist. People who meet your description simply do not go into that line of work (somewhat like the way that 4ft 11in people don't get selected for adult basketball teams, or 6ft 2in 275lb people don't apply for jockey apprenticeships).

Factually untrue. Many classically unattractive or unwilling addicts and/or trafficked women have engaged in prostitution all over the world and throughout history, and that need not be dignified with a request for statistics. Such women may not meet with success as the well-educated and fabulously wealthy knockouts you've touted, but to say they don't exist is at odds with anyone whose ever actually seen hookers.
 
Allow me to introduce myself. I'm Thermal. When I can't get a straight or honest answer, I get progressively amped up and more blunt..

Oh, you've had plenty of straight AND honest answers alright, its just that you've simply chosen to ignore them in favor of your own biases, as your posts subsequent to having been given those answers clearly show.

Now, if you do not believe what we have been telling you, go straight to the horse's mouth... write to the NZPC (New Zealand Prostitutes Collective) Here are their contact details...

National Branch

204 Willis St, Te Aro, Wellington 6011

Phone 04-382 8791
International +64 4 382 8791
Mobile and media inquiries 027 496 0700 (this can be contacted any day of the week)
Email [email protected] (monitored 7 days a week).

Office hours: Monday to Thursday 10am to 6pm
​

Ask them for their input. Ask them if the lives of New Zealand's sex workers has dramatically improved over the last 20 years since legalization.
 
Factually untrue. Many classically unattractive or unwilling addicts and/or trafficked women have engaged in prostitution all over the world and throughout history, and that need not be dignified with a request for statistics. Such women may not meet with success as the well-educated and fabulously wealthy knockouts you've touted, but to say they don't exist is at odds with anyone whose ever actually seen hookers.

There's you mistake. We are talking about this country, now, not the world in the past.

I am telling you, that the days of the drugged-up, gang pimped, $20 hooker in this country are over... they have been for some years. Its the 2003 legislation that was directly responsible for ending them.
 
Last edited:
Oh, you've had plenty of straight AND honest answers alright, its just that you've simply chosen to ignore them in favor of your own biases, as your posts subsequent to having been given those answers clearly show.

Now, if you do not believe what we have been telling you, go straight to the horse's mouth... write to the NZPC (New Zealand Prostitutes Collective) Here are their contact details...

National Branch

204 Willis St, Te Aro, Wellington 6011

Phone 04-382 8791
International +64 4 382 8791
Mobile and media inquiries 027 496 0700 (this can be contacted any day of the week)
Email [email protected] (monitored 7 days a week).

Office hours: Monday to Thursday 10am to 6pm
​

Ask them for their input. Ask them if the lives of New Zealand's sex workers has dramatically improved over the last 20 years since legalization.

smartcooky, I'm going to ask you to jot some notes, here.

Do you understand that I am complely in agreement that sex workers, and in fact any workers, would have their lives improved through legalization of their trade? I have said just that, clearly and repeatedly, since the very beginning of the thread.

smartcooky. Do you understand that you are pretending that I am making entirely different arguments than I am actually making?

smartcooky (and at this point I should probably be putting that in scare quotes). Do you understand that actually reading what I'm posting will make for a more productive discussion than making **** up?
 
Do you understand that I am complely in agreement that sex workers, and in fact any workers, would have their lives improved through legalization of their trade? I have said just that, clearly and repeatedly, since the very beginning of the thread.

Then you have been hiding it very well!

In how many of those customer service occupations are you naked and alone with a man who believes he has rented your body for whatever sexual ends he deems fair to him? I mean, prostitution has built-in vulnerabilities not present in most lines of work.

And it's not like comparable damage can happen to a prostitute, compared to a sales associate. It would take a bit longer to be able to sexually assault someone in a public place, compared to the nude woman and client in a private room. The prostitute is physically a hairsbreadth away from the y/n line by the nature of the work. A cashier, not so.



That's what I was saying to The Atheist upthread. It sounds to an American ear like suggesting "hey, let's legalize protection rackets. That'll be fine". It's kind of not-fine by it's nature.



How'd that work after prohibition got repealed in the US? Dried up that criminal activity, did it? I think they just expand into new territory, rather than go to work at Wal Mart.

To our Aussie and Kiwi parents: did you discuss prostitution as a good way to make screaming good money working part time, with little to no experience at all? The Atheist, to his credit, has acknowledged that he did not.

And no weaseling, please. I'm not asking if they showed an interest in that line of work as a career. I'm asking if you suggested to your teenage daughter or son that sucking a few strangers' cocks a week is a stellar way of getting yourself off to a good financial start. I mean, since it is no big deal and all. You can sell your labor as a burger flipper for minimum wage in near sweatshop conditions, or casually get boned on your own terms for many times more. If you are sincere in your assertion that it is no big deal, why not suggest it as a valid opportunity (and no, I don't mean to advocate it any more highly than any other possibility, but simply mention it as a viable possibility if they might be ok with it)?

Eta: oh, and im not asking for the mindlessly generic "I support my child's career decisions" thing. I'm asking if you said to your own children, who were starting out looking for a good paying job : "Have you considered prostitution?"
 
Last edited:
There's you mistake. We are talking about this country, now, not the world in the past.

{ETA: oh for God's sake, you said they don't go into that line of work. Yes, an addict or trafficked woman damn sure does, whether in history or today. They often have little or no choice}

I am telling you, that the days of the drugged-up, gang pimped, $20 hooker in this country are over... they have been for some years. Its the 2003 legislation that was directly responsible for ending them.

And what I am asking is "why". As a market force, the demand would presumably remain for lower cost workers, as the prices you have claimed are phenomenal (The Atheist claims generally lower rates, and I believe he has first hand (well, maybe second) experience.

Keep in mind, I understand you are not an authority. It just seems like the seedy servicing would not be deterred by the legal availability of pricier services. Cheap weed and opiods, for instance, are still available on the black market much cheaper than the legal varieties here in the States.

"I don't know" is a perfectly reasonable answer, btw. My impression from other online reading is that it never went anywhere, it just doesn't get talked about as much.
 
Last edited:
And what I am asking is "why". As a market force, the demand would presumably remain for lower cost workers, as the prices you have claimed are phenomenal (The Atheist claims generally lower rates, and I believe he has first hand (well, maybe second) experience.

Keep in mind, I understand you are not an authority. It just seems like the seedy servicing would not be deterred by the legal availability of pricier services. Cheap weed and opiods, for instance, are still available on the black market much cheaper than the legal varieties here in the States.
"I don't know" is a perfectly reasonable answer, btw. My impression from other online reading is that it never went anywhere, it just doesn't get talked about as much.

Uhh, as far as weed, no. Theres pretty much no illegal market really at all here in New Mexico anymore.

ETA: from what I'm told, concentrated THC is just vastly better, cheaper on a dose by dose basis then the cheapest leaves on the street, and only a total idiot would buy concentrated THC on the black market.
 
Last edited:
Uhh, as far as weed, no. Theres pretty much no illegal market really at all here in New Mexico anymore.

Dude, I can totally hook you up. :)

Here in Jersey, it's legal, but dispensary prices are jacked to like double street sales. Your market may have bottomed itself out, I dunno.

An Oxy pill definitely goes for less on the street corner than prescription cost, assuming no health insurance to cover it. But that's a different hustle.
 
Dude, I can totally hook you up. :)

Here in Jersey, it's legal, but dispensary prices are jacked to like double street sales. Your market may have bottomed itself out, I dunno.

An Oxy pill definitely goes for less on the street corner than prescription cost, assuming no health insurance to cover it. But that's a different hustle.

With the notable caveat that there's a good chance your street oxy pill isn't oxy at all, but rather some fentanyl product from your friendly neighborhood pill press. Again, something to be said about the quality of goods being sold on the legitimate market generally being much more reliable than their black market alternatives. I think a lot of narcotic enjoyers would happily pay the premium for Oxy of known, pharmaceutical quality than the variable and frequently deadly dose of the fentanyl counterfeits.

Probably an analogous situation with sex workers, where at least the regulated sex workers are getting regular STD screening and are supposed to insist on using condoms with all their clients, and probably won't end up sticking a knife in your face and doing a runner with your wallet.
 
Last edited:
And what I am asking is "why". As a market force, the demand would presumably remain for lower cost workers, as the prices you have claimed are phenomenal (The Atheist claims generally lower rates, and I believe he has first hand (well, maybe second) experience.

Market forces aren't much use if the product isn't there... and it isn't.


Keep in mind, I understand you are not an authority. It just seems like the seedy servicing would not be deterred by the legal availability of pricier services. Cheap weed and opiods, for instance, are still available on the black market much cheaper than the legal varieties here in the States.

Relatively speaking, sex-worker rates are probably not as pricey as you imagine, its just your US perspective slanting your view. In the US almost everything is cheaper than it is here, for example, gas is less than US$4.00/gal over there (NZ$6.40/gal). Here, its NZ$15/gal (US$9.00/gal)
 
Last edited:
Dude, I can totally hook you up. :)

Here in Jersey, it's legal, but dispensary prices are jacked to like double street sales. Your market may have bottomed itself out, I dunno.

An Oxy pill definitely goes for less on the street corner than prescription cost, assuming no health insurance to cover it. But that's a different hustle.

Ohhh there's a glut in the market here. I drive by 4 dispensaries between my house and work. But, form what I've heard from people that do it its like why risk getting **** and getting busted or robbed when I can do it legally. And its also super easy to get a medical card, which makes it even cheaper.

And of course the junkies are looking for fentanyl not weed.
 
Last edited:
With the notable caveat that there's a good chance your street oxy pill isn't oxy at all, but rather some fentanyl product from your friendly neighborhood pill press. Again, something to be said about the quality of goods being sold on the legitimate market generally being much more reliable than their black market alternatives. I think a lot of narcotic enjoyers would happily pay the premium for Oxy of known, pharmaceutical quality than the variable and frequently deadly dose of the fentanyl counterfeits.

Possible. The big hustles here (of which I was on a jury involving one of the accused doctors) is getting an unnecessary scrip and doling out on ye olde curb. Also, a few years back, one of my wife's doctors (get this) had his wife murdered by trying to burn the Pagans (MC club/gang) in the same kind of deal. Likely there's a lot of regional differences in the market.

Probably an analogous situation with sex workers, where at least the regulated sex workers are getting regular STD screening and are supposed to insist on using condoms with all their clients, and probably won't end up sticking a knife in your face and doing a runner with your wallet.

Probably not. But such a worker with that approach has about a one week life expectancy on the job, I would think.
 
Market forces aren't much use if the product isn't there... and it isn't.

Which, yet again, I'm pretty sure it is.

Relatively speaking, sex-worker rates are probably not as pricey as you imagine, its just your US perspective slanting your view. In the US almost everything is cheaper than it is here, for example, gas is less than US$4.00/gal over there (NZ$6.40/gal). Here, its NZ$15/gal (US$9.00/gal)

Yet again, made up ****. Like probably everyone else, I'm adjusting very +/- for the approximate exchange rate as we go. Most of us do this on any thread with varying currencies being thrown around.

Seriously, man, making **** up is really not productive.

Eta: gas and other shipped importables will of course have a higher end use cost. We are talking about...ahem...domestically available goods, so I'm going by approximate exchange rates. Your claims about million dollar homes owned by prostitutes are not diminished by this, depending on which side of your mouth you are talking out of
 
Last edited:
Q
Ohhh there's a glut in the market here. I drive by 4 dispensaries between my house and work. But, form what I've heard from people that do it its like why risk getting **** and getting busted or robbed when I can do it legally. And its also super easy to get a medical card, which makes it even cheaper.

Here, cheap is cheap, and dispensaries are still relatively few and far between. The guy down the block who's been discretely selling for years is likely more convenient (since possession is not even technically a crime) than going through the public ordeal.

And of course the junkies are looking for fentanyl not weed.

Ours are pretty much get what they can get, but admittedly I'm not much in touch with that market. Mostly job site banter from users
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom