Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yep - see the definition of sexual harassment I've posted, he's now up for the company being took to an employment tribunal for sexual harassment.
Right then. So if the boss refrains from winking then he can coldly show his employees the job advert for "secretary with perks" and it's all perfectly OK. Riiiiight...
 
I really don't understand how you're not getting this.


When he first raised it, a page or two back -- well, second time, apparently, over the years -- I thought he was sincerely mistaken. Thought up a valid angle, but went wrong with the thinking it through.

But now that it's been explained to him, multiple times, using different approaches, and he's simply ignoring it all and simply going back to repeating his piece unthinkingly, and without addressing how people have directly discussed his point, I think his "still not getting it" is either a pose, else the cognitive dissonance thing that keeps him from seeing what's sitting in front of him in plain sight.
 
My mistake.

This seems like a non-trivial factor.

sex workers on the street now have meaningful recourse for when they are victimized, including against the police (who are frequent abusers of illegal sex workers)

Ya if cops are the violent criminal abusers you assume (and prob rightly so), I don't know that legalization is that much of a safeguard. Unless you believe that a criminally abusive cop would be above his criminal abuses and refuse to toss a bag of meth at the worker and charge her with possession? Your faith in criminally abusive law enforcement officers is indeed touching.

De-criminalizing sex work means that sex workers are no longer easy victims.

Edit to add: The continued existence of street sex work makes me wonder about your previous comments about how being a sex worker is an express ticket to a life of leisure. Seems not all sex workers are getting cushy brothel jobs charging exorbitant rates. Maybe not so easy as you might presume.

Please jot this down: I am not claiming anything about them. Our Kiwi contingent is making the claims. If you pay a bit of attention, I am questioning the idyllic scenario presented.
 
Ya if cops are the violent criminal abusers you assume (and prob rightly so), I don't know that legalization is that much of a safeguard. Unless you believe that a criminally abusive cop would be above his criminal abuses and refuse to toss a bag of meth at the worker and charge her with possession? Your faith in criminally abusive law enforcement officers is indeed touching.

"The worst cop imaginable will always be able to abuse their authority" is true I suppose, but also seems to be an argument against any incremental reform short of total police abolition. Comrade Thermal, go off King :rolleyes:

While we wait for the revolution that sends every pig off to the gulag to atone for being a class traitor, I think you would concede that taking a huge piece of leverage out of their back pocket probably does a lot to de-escalate tension between the police and sex workers. I guess the pig that got stitched up for extorting a sex worker forgot his drop bag at home that day...

Please jot this down: I am not claiming anything about them. Our Kiwi contingent is making the claims. If you pay a bit of attention, I am questioning the idyllic scenario presented.

It doesn't have to be idyllic to be a massive improvement over the dismal conditions that we all know exist in the sex black market.
 
Last edited:
Right then. So if the boss refrains from winking then he can coldly show his employees the job advert for "secretary with perks" and it's all perfectly OK. Riiiiight...

Yes the law is quite clear, if he doesn't do so in a way that is sexual harassment he can indeed show his employees the ad he is going to run. If he uses the advert to sexually harass his employees than he will open the company up to the likes of employment tribunals for a claim of sexual harassment.

That seems straightforward and very easy to understand, at least to me.

Still not seeing this "logic" you said was behind your position.
 
Come on Thermal, you were being perfectly reasonable up until this nonsense.

Allow me to introduce myself. I'm Thermal. When I can't get a straight or honest answer, I get progressively amped up and more blunt. What you are responding to now is a good example. No one opined that Rudy's actions would have been perfectly normal in NZ, or that it was a good example of why willing prostitution should be legalized. It was just how disgusting and abusive he was. I think the same thinking should apply here, that paid sex in the office is out of bounds. Yet here we are.

Do you really think there's no way for places with legalized sex work to prevent every creepy boss from indemnifying themselves from sexual harassment this way?

is there any real example of this actually happening? Surely NZ has scummy bosses that would love to combine "sex worker" and "secretary" into one job position legally. This change in policy is over a decade old, surely you have an example you can point to demonstrating how legalized sex work has totally upended the restrictions against workplace sexual harassment.

That's why I'm asking about it. Pretty sure there are some fundemental differences in outlook here, so establishing a baseline is crucial. The bull **** replies are getting tedious, so I'm trying to get clarity. I don't believe it's going to happen anymore so I may need to bail.
 
Last edited:
Ya if cops are the violent criminal abusers you assume (and prob rightly so), I don't know that legalization is that much of a safeguard. Unless you believe that a criminally abusive cop would be above his criminal abuses and refuse to toss a bag of meth at the worker and charge her with possession? Your faith in criminally abusive law enforcement officers is indeed touching.

...snip...

Your point is simply the aphorism "the perfect is the enemy of good". Criminals whether in the police force or not will indeed be criminals.
 
Again missing the point that in my example it is just an offer. For example, personally, I was recently offered to take the "health and safety manager" position in my company. Not what I originally signed for, more responsibilities, better pay... AFAIK perfectly legal for them to offer it to me. I accepted, no biggie, these things are very common.


Apples to apples would have been if you had been OFFERED a raise if you agreed to babysit your boss's kids thrice a week. No half-decent corporate would authorize him to offer that in the first place --- assuming you're a clerical or managerial appoint.

If you'd remove your fingers from your ears, and open your eyes, and stop your chant of la-la-la-la, and read the responses to you, you'd see that your argument, while to an extent valid, doesn't actually go far enough, and doesn't actually hold up.
 
Allow me to introduce myself. I'm Thermal. When I can't get a straight or honest answer, I get progressively amped up and more blunt. What you are responding to now is a good example. No one opined that Rudy's actions would have been perfectly normal in NZ, or that it was a good example of why willing prostitution should be legalized. It was just how disgusting and abusive he was. I think the same thinking should apply here, that paid sex in the office is out of bounds. Yet here we are.



That's why I'm asking about it. Pretty sure there are some fundemental differences in outlook here, so establishing a baseline is crucial. The bull **** replies are getting tedious, so I'm trying to get clarity. I don't believe it's going to happen anymore so I may need to bail.

The Air Bud approach to law doesn't actually work in real life. Every judge and jury in the world will be able to find a dissonance free way for sex work and prohibitions against sexual harassment to coexist.

It's quite unclear what you intend to tease out by pretending to be stupid here.
 
We call this "On crap, someone has found a hill again."

I'm gonna pour gas on the fire.

Obviously a bisexual boss could preempt any sexual harassment claims by allowing either male or female applicants for his blowjob secretary role. The equal opportunity sex pest boss, truly immune from all legal recourse

:blush:
 
I'm gonna pour gas on the fire.

Obviously a bisexual boss could preempt any sexual harassment claims by allowing either male or female applicants for his blowjob secretary role. The equal opportunity sex pest boss, truly immune from all legal recourse

:blush:

I don't understand why the prostitutes don't just run faster.
 
I'm gonna pour gas on the fire.

Obviously a bisexual boss could diffuse any sexual harassment claims by allowing either male or female applicants for his blowjob secretary role. The equal opportunity sex pest boss, truly immune from all legal recourse

:blush:

To be a tad serious about your funny, it wouldn't in the UK. That would only protect him from an accusation of sex-discrimination. Sexual harassment is something quite different.
 
"The worst cop imaginable will always be able to abuse their authority" is true I suppose, but also seems to be an argument against any incremental reform short of total police abolition. Comrade Thermal, go off King :rolleyes:

While we wait for the revolution that sends every pig off to the gulag to atone for being a class traitor, I think you would concede that taking a huge piece of leverage out of their back pocket probably does a lot to de-escalate tension between the police and sex workers. I guess the pig that got stitched up for extorting a sex worker forgot his drop bag at home that day...



It doesn't have to be idyllic to be a massive improvement over the dismal conditions that we all know exist in the sex black market.

Again, as I keep saying, decriminalization at the least seems like the move, no argument. Where the line goes from there is what I'm messing around with.
 
It's been explained to you every possible way, from every possible angle, at ever possible level of language.

You at page 42 trying to rebrand your trademark stubborn to the point of parody stubbornness as anything else changes nothing.
 
It's been explained to you every possible way, from every possible angle, at ever possible level of language.

You at page 42 trying to rebrand your trademark stubborn to the point of parody stubbornness as anything else changes nothing.

Add the above to your previous content-free personalizations.

With different posters, and on different levels and subtopics and perspectives, there has been a lot of interesting and productive discussion. Your contributions continue to not provide any. Thanks again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom