Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, so my "secretary with perks" argument didn´t go so well this time either. I really thought I saw a disconnect in the way society views a boss asking a worker for sexual favours as such a horrible thing to do and then pretending that sex is just normal work. At least here in Spain I don´t think it would be illegal for a boss to ask his employees if they fancy a change of the type of work they do, as long as it is not forced on them. But it would, if it´s sex related. (and not just because sex work is not fully legal here). If sex work were decriminalised here, that would be a bit contradictory. It seems that way to me, but if I´m the only one... I´ll drop it. I promise not to bring it up again in x years time. Thank you all for your patience.

If it's any consolation, I totally see what you were saying. I just didn't have anything to contribute.
 
This is so ******* dumb.

My boss can't ask me to wash his car or mow his lawn. This idea that if sexual transactions are legal it becomes a paradox to not sexually assault your workers because "it's the same thing" just makes no sense.
 
Last edited:
OK, so my "secretary with perks" argument didn´t go so well this time either. I really thought I saw a disconnect in the way society views a boss asking a worker for sexual favours as such a horrible thing to do and then pretending that sex is just normal work. At least here in Spain I don´t think it would be illegal for a boss to ask his employees if they fancy a change of the type of work they do, as long as it is not forced on them. But it would, if it´s sex related. (and not just because sex work is not fully legal here). If sex work were decriminalised here, that would be a bit contradictory. It seems that way to me, but if I´m the only one... I´ll drop it. I promise not to bring it up again in x years time. Thank you all for your patience.


I guess you haven't heard of the international Me Too movement consisting of people who were all traumatized by their boss asking them to wash their car.
 
Or my decades of working and playing day and night within feet of them in my beloved Atlantic City and beyond.


When I was a teacher at the Hotel & Restaurant School of Copenhagen, we had a problem with the students' entrance being in the street where johns were cruising to pick up very young prostitutes. What they call the Babystrich in German.

It wasn't a problem in the morning, but when the students left the school in the afternoon, the johns would try to pick them up because they couldn't tell the difference. Neither could I.
One afternoon when I was leaving, what I thought was a student was waiting alone in the rain apparently to be picked up, so I offered her to use the school's telephone to call the friend or relative who (I thought) was supposed to pick her up, but she declined.

My misunderstanding didn't occur to me until I got home and was telling my girlfriend the story.
 
I don´t know...

And won't learn.

This is so ******* dumb.

Not just dumb, spectacularly dumb.

I'm astonished that there's been three pages since I last looked at it. Haven't bothered reading of them, because it's turning into the same inane scenario as the Thread Which Shall Not Be Named.

This stuff isn't that hard to grasp, but hey, here we are on page whatever.
 
And won't learn.



Not just dumb, spectacularly dumb.

I'm astonished that there's been three pages since I last looked at it. Haven't bothered reading of them, because it's turning into the same inane scenario as the Thread Which Shall Not Be Named.

This stuff isn't that hard to grasp, but hey, here we are on page whatever.

It does get a bit tiresome to have to defend from slippery slope hysterics when you're dealing with a policy that has already been in effect for two decades now.

Surely the blowjob secretary issue would have emerged by now if this were a real potential negative outcome of such policies, right? Why should we entertain these hypotheticals when 20 years of real data exists?
 
Last edited:
I guess you haven't heard of the international Me Too movement consisting of people who were all traumatized by their boss asking them to wash their car.

Hey, that's a great way of putting it!
 
Anyway, I don't think New Zealand is a good model in general. It's a relatively tiny island community, BFE in the South Pacific. It's economics and industries are going to have distinctly New Zealand characteristics, that don't necessarily translate to other nations in other parts of the world. Even if it turns out to be true that New Zealand's prostitutes are all sex-positive pro-ams with middle class salaries and benefits, this doesn't really tell us anything useful how to manage prostitution, sex trafficking, and brothels in places like Europe or North America.
 
Anyway, I don't think New Zealand is a good model in general. It's a relatively tiny island community, BFE in the South Pacific. It's economics and industries are going to have distinctly New Zealand characteristics, that don't necessarily translate to other nations in other parts of the world. Even if it turns out to be true that New Zealand's prostitutes are all sex-positive pro-ams with middle class salaries and benefits, this doesn't really tell us anything useful how to manage prostitution, sex trafficking, and brothels in places like Europe or North America.

I actually brought that up a dozen or two pages ago. NZs entire nationwide sex worker population was smaller than my South Jersey carpenter's union local chapter. The average income, etc of the nations would come into play as well, not to mention the prevailing cultural outlooks.

Adjusted for relative populations, the States have 3-6 times as many sex workers per capita as New Zealand. That's a big difference in and of itself, particularly in how we treat the demand for low cost sex work. I don't think it would vanish with legalization, as the legal Nevada brothels are not exactly rolling in wealth and popularity.
 
I actually brought that up a dozen or two pages ago. NZs entire nationwide sex worker population was smaller than my South Jersey carpenter's union local chapter. The average income, etc of the nations would come into play as well, not to mention the prevailing cultural outlooks.

Adjusted for relative populations, the States have 3-6 times as many sex workers per capita as New Zealand. That's a big difference in and of itself, particularly in how we treat the demand for low cost sex work. I don't think it would vanish with legalization, as the legal Nevada brothels are not exactly rolling in wealth and popularity.

Isn't it true that position is only legal in some way out of the way counties in Nevada, not Reno and Vegas... yet in Vegas its extremely easy to pick one up, even though its illegal?

BTW I am totally NOT speaking from experience or something here. I have technically been to Nevada, but only for connecting flights. I've never left the airport.

Also, its not as if tiny NZ is the only country where prostitution is legal and we have no where else to look for other models. It is in many European countries.

ETA: and btw I find Harry Reid an awful airport, narrow, crowded due to the gambling machines everywhere, and usually someone puking in the mens room, and aside from that new dome theater thing that looks pretty cool my desire to ever visit Vegas is nil.
 
Last edited:
Isn't it true that position is only legal in some way out of the way counties in Nevada, not Reno and Vegas... yet in Vegas its extremely easy to pick one up, even though its illegal?

BTW I am totally NOT speaking from experience or something here. I have technically been to Nevada, but only for connecting flights. I've never left the airport.

Also, its not as if tiny NZ is the only country where prostitution is legal and we have no where else to look for other models. It is in many European countries.

Yeah, it's legal.in a half dozen counties, two of which have no operating brothels. But to someone heeled and motivated enough for a limo or plane hop from Vegas, not exactly insurmountable, considering the jingle floating around Vegas. The wife and I jump.on a cheap plane ride to Massachusetts or Florida without batting an eye.
 
Yeah, it's legal.in a half dozen counties, two of which have no operating brothels. But to someone heeled and motivated enough for a limo or plane hop from Vegas, not exactly insurmountable, considering the jingle floating around Vegas. The wife and I jump.on a cheap plane ride to Massachusetts or Florida without batting an eye.

Well, my main point is judging the state's working girls in the legal areas may not be a fair representation of the ladies in the biggest city with all the glam, where its technically illegal but, I think, all but unenforced. I caught part of a documentary about a legal brothel in Nevada, and man, it seemed sad.
 
Well, my main point is judging the state's working girls in the legal areas may not be a fair representation of the ladies in the biggest city with all the glam, where its technically illegal but, I think, all but unenforced. I caught part of a documentary about a legal brothel in Nevada, and man, it seemed sad.

Exactly my point. The prostitute market is "cheap and available" there. Not much interest from the Vegas/Reno connoisseurs in a hundred dollar hop to where it's perfectly up and up. That's my meta point about the NZ model; I'm not sure it would fly here.

Eta: yes, there are other models to look at. I'm using the OP one as a jumping off poimt
 
Last edited:
Also I'm pretty sure NZ is well off the main human trafficking routes. Even if the EU legalized prostitution tomorrow, on the NZ model, I bet there'd still be a lot of mistreated, underpaid, trafficked sex work going on.
 
I thought it was obvious that I was referring to an abusive client, not an agreeable and cooperative one. You know abusive clients exist in the industry, right? We were actually talking about them.
Abusive clients exist in all industries. I have abusive clients myself. There are systems and procedures in place to deal with abusive clients and ensure that they do not continue to abuse. In the case of sex workers (and not so much in my industry, much though we fantasise about it sometimes), some of those systems and procedures are physical - just like it is in a bar or a nightclub.
 
Or my decades of working and playing day and night within feet of them in my beloved Atlantic City and beyond.
Oh, of course. Atlantic City. That well-known bastion of honest people with good morals and the best interests of others in the forefront of their minds.

Sorry, got a little sarcastic there. If you're using Atlantic City, of all places, as your model, it's no wonder you have such a ****** up view of sex work.
 
...I'm not sure it would fly here.
Why not? Are Americans and Europeans just so fundamentally different from Kiwis and Australians? We're all people. We all live in societies that have laws. What's to stop a NZ-style prostitution law being enacted in Atlantic City? Is it just the culture? Culture can change, if the people want it to. Legalising prostitution just makes so much sense that it seems absurd to me why people would ever be against it. Apart from the religious-based moralistic stigma attached to anything sexy, that is, which is to me understandable, if inappropriate.
 
Also I'm pretty sure NZ is well off the main human trafficking routes. Even if the EU legalized prostitution tomorrow, on the NZ model, I bet there'd still be a lot of mistreated, underpaid, trafficked sex work going on.
For a while, I'm sure there would. But as long as the laws were effectively enforced, the authorities will catch up with the illegal players. It won't eliminate the exploitation entirely - would that it could - but it would dramatically reduce it.

Europe is a hard sell because it would require a lot of different players to all agree. For that matter, the US would be the same. But that's not a reason to not bother trying.
 
For a while, I'm sure there would. But as long as the laws were effectively enforced, the authorities will catch up with the illegal players. It won't eliminate the exploitation entirely - would that it could - but it would dramatically reduce it.

Europe is a hard sell because it would require a lot of different players to all agree. For that matter, the US would be the same. But that's not a reason to not bother trying.

Indeed.

When there ceases to be money in illegal activities and they become unprofitable, those illegal activities tend to diminish rapidly - too much effort and risk for not enough reward. Prohibition is a good example. Sure you still get a very small black market for untaxed liquor, but its nowhere near the massive levels it was in the 1920s. When prohibition ended, the mobs turned to drugs and prostitution.

In this country, there used to be a huge burglary and store break-in problem with people stealing stereos, TVs and other home entertainment goods. That has diminished with the flood of relatively cheap goods of that type. Almost all burglaries now are looking for small items such as cash and jewellery. Store break-in are almost all after cigarettes, vape supplies and small items that are easy to fence.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom