Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Which, yet again, I'm pretty sure it is.

Well, I live here, and I'm telling you it isn't.

I'm frequently out in Nelson on a Friday night, and I'm telling you I haven't seen a street hooker in probably 15 years or more. There is, of course, the well known "Secrets Gentlemen's Club" above the Thai restaurant in Hardy Street (always thought that street was well named) that does a roaring trade, but that is a registered brothel, and the girls who work there are not permitted to "trawl for trade" outside the building.

But, even if you could find one, she would be legally registered, with an ACC employment code, paying taxes and ACC levies, and NOT being pimped by anyone, and not drugged-up (because she would lose her registration status, and be instantly out of a job).

TheAtheist lives in Auckland, and he can tell you that "'K Road" and "Ponsonby", which were famous (infamous?) for being Auckland's chief red-light districts in the 1970s to 1990s, where there were a dozen or more strip clubs, street walkers plying their trade on all four corners of every intersection, has changed dramatically. You'll hardly even see a street hooker there these days. Ponsonby (one of its most famous pubs was called The Gluepot, the name says it all) has gone from slumsville to one of the snootiest districts in Auckland. 'K Road is not far behind.


Yet again, made up ****. Like probably everyone else, I'm adjusting very +/- for the approximate exchange rate as we go. Most of us do this on any thread with varying currencies being thrown around.

Seriously, man, making **** up is really not productive.

Nothing is made up. Look again. The price of fuel in NZ is more than double what it is in the US, in real economical terms.
 
Last edited:
Well, I live here, and I'm telling you it isn't.

I'm frequently out in Nelson on a Friday night, and I'm telling you I haven't seen a street hooker in probably 15 years or more. There is, of course, the well known "Secrets Gentlemen's Club" above the Thai restaurant in Hardy Street (always thought that street was well named) that does a roaring trade, but that is a registered brothel, and the girls who work there are not permitted to "trawl for trade" outside the building.

I have been deferring to your and TA's anecdotes, because you are on the ground there. But I have also linked to articles that seem to be in contradiction to your observatons. Not really arguing with you per se, just trying to get a handle on it. My observations are very limited on prostitution in the States as well, and I am qualifying them as such.

But, even if you could find one, she would be legally registered, with an ACC employment code, paying taxes and ACC levies, and NOT being pimped by anyone, and not drugged-up (because she would lose her registration status, and be instantly out of a job).

This is what I mean. Another NZ poster (banquetbear) argues at length that no registration was required or desired. I thought it would be a good idea. Setting the gloves aside, surely you can see how this discussion can be frustrating at times?

{ETA: being an addict is precisely why I would expect a black market to continue to flourish, if the addict was unable to work legally if addicted}

TheAtheist lives in Auckland, and he can tell you that "'K Road" and "Ponsonby", which were famous (infamous?) for being Auckland's chief red-light districts in the 1970s to 1990s, where there were a dozen or more strip clubs, street walkers plying their trade on all four corners of every intersection, has changed dramatically. You'll hardly even see a street hooker there these days. Ponsonby (one of its most famous pubs was called The Gluepot, the name says it all) has gone from slumsville to one of the snootiest districts in Auckland. 'K Road is not far behind.

Nothing is made up. Look again. The price of fuel in NZ is more than double what it is in the US, in real economical terms.

See my edit above. Imported oil would of course be more expensive compared to the States, which are a net exporter. My objection is your declaration that it is my skewed perspective. I think I am keeping relative values fairly in mind.
 
Last edited:
This is what I mean. Another NZ poster (banquetbear) argues at length that no registration was required or desired. I thought it would be a good idea. Setting the gloves aside, surely you can see how this discussion can be frustrating at times?

Well, he's sort of right, and sort of not right. but again this has been explained to you before

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13927413&postcount=1254

To clarify, it is only brothelkeepers who have to register, but even sole traders (including sex-workers) must register for tax and with the ACC.
 
Last edited:
You say: "in any civilized western society, even asking your employee for sex is sexual harassment, and therefore illegal" ... but that´s unless your employee is a sex worker, right?
Wrong. An employer - employee relationship is not a client - provider relationship.
 
ETA: I can see that Australia lumps prostitutes together with, for instance, First Aid Trainers and Religious Assistants:
Group: 4518 Other Personal Service Workers


I wonder why!
Because it's a catch-all category to accomodate for all the service occupations that don't fit neatly into other categories. Every section of ANZSCO has a category like this. Group 3999 "Other Miscellaneous Technicians and Trade Workers" states:

This unit group covers Technicians and Trades Workers not elsewhere classified. It includes Divers, Interior Decorators, Optical Dispensers / Dispensing Opticians, Optical Mechanics, Photographer's Assistants, Plastics Technicians and Fire Protection Equipment Technicians.
Why are Interior Decorators and Optical Mechanics in the same category as Photographer's Assistants and Fire Protection Equipment Technicians? Because they don't fit neatly into other categories.

I worked with ANZSCO extensively when I was employed for the 2016 Australia Census. Do not challenge my occupation-categorisation-fu.
 
That's why I'm asking about it. Pretty sure there are some fundemental differences in outlook here, so establishing a baseline is crucial. The bull **** replies are getting tedious, so I'm trying to get clarity. I don't believe it's going to happen anymore so I may need to bail.
You've been getting reasonable and honest answers to all of your questions all thread.
 
Factually untrue. Many classically unattractive or unwilling addicts and/or trafficked women have engaged in prostitution all over the world and throughout history, and that need not be dignified with a request for statistics. Such women may not meet with success as the well-educated and fabulously wealthy knockouts you've touted, but to say they don't exist is at odds with anyone whose ever actually seen hookers.
Oh yes, everyone knows what "hookers" look like because stereotypes.
 
TheAtheist lives in Auckland, and he can tell you that "'K Road" and "Ponsonby", which were famous (infamous?) for being Auckland's chief red-light districts in the 1970s to 1990s, where there were a dozen or more strip clubs, street walkers plying their trade on all four corners of every intersection, has changed dramatically. You'll hardly even see a street hooker there these days. Ponsonby (one of its most famous pubs was called The Gluepot, the name says it all) has gone from slumsville to one of the snootiest districts in Auckland. 'K Road is not far behind.
Same with King's Cross in Sydney. Most action you can get there is at Mardi Gras.
 
Because it's a catch-all category to accomodate for all the service occupations that don't fit neatly into other categories. Every section of ANZSCO has a category like this. Group 3999 "Other Miscellaneous Technicians and Trade Workers" states:

Why are Interior Decorators and Optical Mechanics in the same category as Photographer's Assistants and Fire Protection Equipment Technicians? Because they don't fit neatly into other categories.

I worked with ANZSCO extensively when I was employed for the 2016 Australia Census. Do not challenge my occupation-categorisation-fu.

I don't know precisely how the Aussie system works, but often, disparate trades are grouped together in catchall categories on the basis that the calculated levy rate are the same... for example, Baby sitters, Animal shelter operators, Genealogists, Life coaches, Personal fitness trainers and Tattooists are all lumped together because their ACC levy rates are all exactly the same
 
I don't know precisely how the Aussie system works, but often, disparate trades are grouped together in catchall categories on the basis that the calculated levy rate are the same... for example, Baby sitters, Animal shelter operators, Genealogists, Life coaches, Personal fitness trainers and Tattooists are all lumped together because their ACC levy rates are all exactly the same
That's possible, but ANZSCO is shared between our two countries (hence the name) and the conceptual model doesn't mention anything about calculated levys. It is a statistical model only.
 
In how many of those customer service occupations are you naked and alone with a man who believes he has rented your body for whatever sexual ends he deems fair to him?

You do know that's not how legal prostitution works right? It's not "I own you now".

Heck, I thought this didn't sound right so I checked an escort website here in the UK to see (where prostitution is illegal) and nope, the escorts have very clearly defined lists of what they will and won't do. I've never actually bought one so I can't say for sure if it holds true when you actually use the services, but it sounds more like you're paying for specifically agreed upon activities for a period of time, not "whatever sexual ends [you] deem fair".
 
OK, so my "secretary with perks" argument didn´t go so well this time either. I really thought I saw a disconnect in the way society views a boss asking a worker for sexual favours as such a horrible thing to do and then pretending that sex is just normal work. At least here in Spain I don´t think it would be illegal for a boss to ask his employees if they fancy a change of the type of work they do, as long as it is not forced on them. But it would, if it´s sex related. (and not just because sex work is not fully legal here). If sex work were decriminalised here, that would be a bit contradictory. It seems that way to me, but if I´m the only one... I´ll drop it. I promise not to bring it up again in x years time. Thank you all for your patience.
 
Last edited:
OK, so my "secretary with perks" argument didn´t go so well this time either. I really thought I saw a disconnect in the way society views a boss asking a worker for sexual favours as such a horrible thing to do and then pretending that sex is just normal work. At least here in Spain I don´t think it would be illegal for a boss to ask his employees if they fancy a change of the type of work they do, as long as it is not forced on them. But it would, if it´s sex related. (and not just because sex work is not fully legal here). If sex work were decriminalised here, that would be a bit contradictory. It seems that way to me, but if I´m the only one... I´ll drop it. I promise not to bring it up again in x years time. Thank you all for your patience.

It'll never go well in a skeptics forum, because you're wrong, and what's more you're not sincere. Your disingenuousness will be seen through no matter the value of x, and no matter which skeptically inclined folks are here responding to you. Like in the past, and like now, in future too you'll initially be taken at face value, and your error in reasoning patiently explained, and after a point your insincere intentions recognized.

Not to worry, as you are aware much worse than your nonsense is routinely examined here, and duly dismissed.
 
Last edited:
You do know that's not how legal prostitution works right? It's not "I own you now".

Heck, I thought this didn't sound right so I checked an escort website here in the UK to see (where prostitution is illegal) and nope, the escorts have very clearly defined lists of what they will and won't do. I've never actually bought one so I can't say for sure if it holds true when you actually use the services, but it sounds more like you're paying for specifically agreed upon activities for a period of time, not "whatever sexual ends [you] deem fair".

I thought it was obvious that I was referring to an abusive client, not an agreeable and cooperative one. You know abusive clients exist in the industry, right? We were actually talking about them.

And Jesus, the post you are commenting on is from over a year ago. Are we doing the Groundhog Day thing now?
 
Well, he's sort of right, and sort of not right. but again this has been explained to you before

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13927413&postcount=1254

To clarify, it is only brothelkeepers who have to register, but even sole traders (including sex-workers) must register for tax and with the ACC.

We were talking about registration along the lines of a business licence, not registering for freaking indicating your profession for accident coverage. Wouldn't have anything to do with the subject anyway, unless the addict was filing a claim for an accident, in which case they could claim there were unemployed, or otherwise not mention what they were doing to feed their habit. One has nothing to do with the other.
 
Again, blurring the distinction between employer - employee and client - provider.

The woman was not paid, or had any contractual agreement at all, save the promise of a million bucks later. You pretty sure you know what side of the employment line she was on?

You've been getting reasonable and honest answers to all of your questions all thread.

Sez you, of course.

Oh yes, everyone knows what "hookers" look like because stereotypes.

Or my decades of working and playing day and night within feet of them in my beloved Atlantic City and beyond.
 
Rudy hired a personal assistant, who was told up front that frequent oral was one of the assists required. There's no "job description" conflict or abuses there.

As you say, this isn't that difficult. You guys keep making excuses and trying to slide out on technicalities instead of addressing the broader point.

Any job north of very low end **** is going to include some flexibility (IME). I'm a construction contractor, and am the king of going beyond the four corners of my agreement as is practical. But what we are trying to suss out here is just how widely accepted this notion of sex work being so casual is, in the areas where it is legal. My assumption is that it would be treated like a vice. Loosely, like alcohol. Strict rules, both written and unwritten, regarding when and where, and generally not acceptable in any context in the workplace. Does that seem reasonable? I think it's reasonable.

Yet we get pushback that it's so "no big deal" that it's just like any other work, from flipping burgers to nursing. What I am trying to establish is some kind of foundational understanding of how it is looked at, without the "look at me I'm so progressive" bull **** posturing. It has been more of a battle than I would have expected.

Seems as though that sort of thing has been quite common in Hollywood since like Hollywood started making films. Making it illegal doesn't make it not happen.

We could of course pass laws that make prostitution legal but not as part of employment conditions... and also pass employment contract laws, and do away with at-will employment, like almost every single other developed country has. This would of course involve the US Congress so lol on it ever getting done.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom