Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps... IF he registers his business as a brothel. But he won't get any takers unless the applicant is a registered sex-worker



As above, and IF makes it clear that any applicant from within his own business would have to first register as a sex-worker. But not verbally - it must be in writing.



Probably, but only if he has registered his business as a brothel.

I know exactly what you are trying to do. You are attempting to shoehorn the facts by incrementally joining a set of dubious dots to get from an untenable position to a tenable position in order to promote your chosen narrative. Its what you have tried to do on this topic previously - it didn't work then, and it won't work now.
‎
‎

I don´t see it as dubious, it´s just a slippery slope that a sex-work-decriminalised society would lead to. Similar to the example of the German employment office forcing unemployed women to take sex work jobs in order not to lose employment benefits. Purely logical if sex work is like any other work. Just as logical as the boss getting away with workplace sex harassment laws as long as he fills the paperwork properly.
 
I don´t see it as dubious, it´s just a slippery slope that a sex-work-decriminalised society would lead to. Similar to the example of the German employment office forcing unemployed women to take sex work jobs in order not to lose employment benefits. Purely logical if sex work is like any other work. Just as logical as the boss getting away with workplace sex harassment laws as long as he fills the paperwork properly.

Please explain what paperwork would protect the boss from being guilty of sexual harassment in the workplace?

Hint: there isn't any, whether sex work is decriminalised or not.
 
Just imagine the scene, the boss arrives at his secretary´s desk and drops a paper. -"Have you seen the new vacancy?" wink, wink.

(paperwork submitted, workplace properly registered as brothel, work offer clearly stating that applicants need to be registered etc. etc.)

Legal? What would make it illegal, the winking? And if it´s legal, how different is that in essence from the boss bluntly offerint a raise for sexual favours?
 
Ok fine, but it´s a distinction without a difference. And you say it would be legal to offer such a job to an employee, but from the responses of other posters, it seems that many view it as obviously illegal and a workplace harassment issue.

The difference is huge, and no other member has posted anything which supports your interpretation or disagrees with what I've posted.
 
Just imagine the scene, the boss arrives at his secretary´s desk and drops a paper. -"Have you seen the new vacancy?" wink, wink.

(paperwork submitted, workplace properly registered as brothel, work offer clearly stating that applicants need to be registered etc. etc.)

Legal? What would make it illegal, the winking? And if it´s legal, how different is that in essence from the boss bluntly offerint a raise for sexual favours?

This has been explained to you multiple times, and you have simply handwaved it away. This is just a fringe reset from the last time you tried this crap. Its unimpressive

I don´t see it as dubious, it´s just a slippery slope that a sex-work-decriminalised society would lead to. Similar to the example of the German employment office forcing unemployed women to take sex work jobs in order not to lose employment benefits. Purely logical if sex work is like any other work. Just as logical as the boss getting away with workplace sex harassment laws as long as he fills the paperwork properly.

This is complete bollocks!

You have invented a fantastical, extremely unlikely scenario out of whole cloth; a scenario that resembles nothing that even remotely exists in reality. You are wasting everyone's time, including mine. I'm done with addressing your bull-****
 
Last edited:
The difference is huge, and no other member has posted anything which supports your interpretation or disagrees with what I've posted.

For example just on the previous page by the Atheist:

"You've created an absurdly unlikely scenario and can't accept that it's illegal in places where clear employment laws exist, but congrats on getting people to respond for a couple of pages."

He says illegal, you say legal...
 
This has been explained to you multiple times, and you have simply handwaved it away. This is just a fringe reset from the last time you tried this crap. Its unimpressive



This is complete bollocks!

You have invented a fantastical, extremely unlikely scenario out of whole cloth; a scenario that resembles nothing that even remotely exists in reality. You are wasting everyone's time, including mine. I'm done with addressing your bull-****

Ok, just for the sake of the argument, I even admit that the scenario is unlikely and only exploited by the likes of Heffner etc. but please just answer nevertheless:

Just imagine the scene, the boss arrives at his secretary´s desk and drops a paper. -"Have you seen the new vacancy?" wink, wink.

(paperwork submitted, workplace properly registered as brothel, work offer clearly stating that applicants need to be registered etc. etc.)

Legal? What would make it illegal, the winking? And if it´s legal, how different is that in essence from the boss bluntly offerint a raise for sexual favours?


How different are the two things, IN ESSENCE.? Aren´t they practically the same thing?
 
As we have been patiently explaining for 79 freaking pages, they largely disappear in a country where sex work is legal.

Nothing has been "explained". That's the point. What has been "explained" is that NZ prostitutes are gorgeous, well educated professionals pulling up to $500/hr as a choice. Ok, great! But that leaves hanging what happened to the workers who don't command such rates, that (if what I'm reading online is accurate) historically made up the majority of sex workers. Are kiwis so fabulously wealthy that they can afford such luxuries, to the point of no demand for cheaper/less genteel servicing? Or are they so compliant with law that they refuse a black market option on principle? Do the previously trafficked/addicted workers go to work at McDonalds? If so, that's a societal phenomenon that is pretty unique, and makes prostitution specifically "not the subject".

If you don't know how it happened, that's fine, of course. Or if the narrative just works for you, or whatever. But at some level, surely you understand that saying "we made it legal and much more expensive and the problems just vanished" falls a little flat, explanation-wise. A bit like saying "we legalized opioids and all our problems disappeared. Don't ask so many questions". Which, coincidentally, is exactly what we are battling in the States rn. The market may change, but the inherent problems don't just conveniently go away.
 
Nothing has been "explained". That's the point. What has been "explained" is that NZ prostitutes are gorgeous, well educated professionals pulling up to $500/hr as a choice. Ok, great! But that leaves hanging what happened to the workers who don't command such rates, that (if what I'm reading online is accurate) historically made up the majority of sex workers. Are kiwis so fabulously wealthy that they can afford such luxuries, to the point of no demand for cheaper/less genteel servicing? Or are they so compliant with law that they refuse a black market option on principle? Do the previously trafficked/addicted workers go to work at McDonalds? If so, that's a societal phenomenon that is pretty unique, and makes prostitution specifically "not the subject".

If you don't know how it happened, that's fine, of course. Or if the narrative just works for you, or whatever. But at some level, surely you understand that saying "we made it legal and much more expensive and the problems just vanished" falls a little flat, explanation-wise. A bit like saying "we legalized opioids and all our problems disappeared. Don't ask so many questions". Which, coincidentally, is exactly what we are battling in the States rn. The market may change, but the inherent problems don't just conveniently go away.

I'm guessing a lot of the buyer side is willing to put up with a higher price if it means having near-zero chance of being arrested, robbed, catching a disease, or unknowingly employing a hyper-exploited sex worker, which are more likely to occur on the sex blackmarket.

There might be some less cautious would-be buyers of illegal sex, but is that enough to support a parallel, illegal economy when a legal, safer alternative is readily available?

Brewing bathtub gin would help me avoid the steep taxes on store-bought alcohol, but this doesn't seem to be a popular option as far as I know. Dealing with the black market is a huge pain in the ass and people generally prefer legal alternatives when available, even if it's more expensive.
 
Last edited:
I'm guessing a lot of the buyer side is willing to put up with a higher price if it means having near-zero chance of being arrested, robbed, catching a disease, or unknowingly employing a hyper-exploited sex worker, which are more likely to occur on the sex blackmarket.

There might be some less cautious would-be buyers of illegal sex, but is that enough to support a parallel, illegal economy when a legal, safer alternative is readily available?

Brewing bathtub gin would help me avoid the steep taxes on store-bought alcohol, but this doesn't seem to be a popular option as far as I know. Dealing with the black market is a huge pain in the ass and people generally prefer legal alternatives when available, even if it's more expensive.

Which goes back to my much earlier point. If prostitution, including street walking, is legal, the black market doesn't actually exist, on paper. But the addicted or trafficked women are in exactly the same position, except maybe they now have to cut the tax man in on their coerced earnings as an added indignity.
 
The point that Abooga brings up reminds me of the assistant that Rudy Giuliani had, who claimed that knob gobbling was part of the job right up front. Man, everyone called Rudy boy a full tilt perv and abusive sick puppy. If he lived in New Zealand, I guess it would have been a normal day at the office.
 
Which goes back to my much earlier point. If prostitution, including street walking, is legal, the black market doesn't actually exist, on paper. But the addicted or trafficked women are in exactly the same position, except maybe they now have to cut the tax man in on their coerced earnings as an added indignity.

As far as I'm aware, "street walking" is not legal in these places, and there's nothing to indicate that the legal sex trade is prone to the same problems as the illegal one concerning addicted or otherwise coerced sex workers.

The whole point is to shut down the street level trade and move things into the controlled environment of a regulated brothel.
 
The point that Abooga brings up reminds me of the assistant that Rudy Giuliani had, who claimed that knob gobbling was part of the job right up front. Man, everyone called Rudy boy a full tilt perv and abusive sick puppy. If he lived in New Zealand, I guess it would have been a normal day at the office.

If Rudy were in a NZ and hired a legal prostitute then it would have been acceptable for him to make such a request. If Rudy were in NZ and hired a chef it would have been unacceptable for him to make such a request.

This isn't that difficult.
 
As far as I'm aware, "street walking" is not legal in these places, and there's nothing to indicate that the legal sex trade is prone to the same problems as the illegal one concerning addicted or otherwise coerced sex workers.

The whole point is to shut down the street level trade and move things into the controlled environment of a regulated brothel.

Yeah, that's been asserted up thread. Wikipedia disagrees. Street walking perfectly legal, with a few small restrictions.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_New_Zealando
 
If Rudy were in a NZ and hired a legal prostitute then it would have been acceptable for him to make such a request. If Rudy were in NZ and hired a chef it would have been unacceptable for him to make such a request.

This isn't that difficult.

One does often wonder how some folk manage to navigate the real world.
 
Just imagine the scene, the boss arrives at his secretary´s desk and drops a paper. -"Have you seen the new vacancy?" wink, wink.
(paperwork submitted, workplace properly registered as brothel, work offer clearly stating that applicants need to be registered etc. etc.)

Legal? What would make it illegal, the winking? And if it´s legal, how different is that in essence from the boss bluntly offerint a raise for sexual favours?

Yep - see the definition of sexual harassment I've posted, he's now up for the company being took to an employment tribunal for sexual harassment.
 
For example just on the previous page by the Atheist:

"You've created an absurdly unlikely scenario and can't accept that it's illegal in places where clear employment laws exist, but congrats on getting people to respond for a couple of pages."

He says illegal, you say legal...

No, we both say the same thing.
 
Yeah, that's been asserted up thread. Wikipedia disagrees. Street walking perfectly legal, with a few small restrictions.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_New_Zealando

My mistake.

This seems like a non-trivial factor.

Sex workers are now more willing to report crimes against them than they had been in the past.

sex workers on the street now have meaningful recourse for when they are victimized, including against the police (who are frequent abusers of illegal sex workers)

police officer who was jailed in 2009 for blackmailing a sex worker into giving him free sex)

De-criminalizing sex work means that sex workers are no longer easy victims.

Edit to add: The continued existence of street sex work makes me wonder about your previous comments about how being a sex worker is an express ticket to a life of leisure. Seems not all sex workers are getting cushy brothel jobs charging exorbitant rates. Maybe not so easy as you might presume.
 
Last edited:
If Rudy were in a NZ and hired a legal prostitute then it would have been acceptable for him to make such a request. If Rudy were in NZ and hired a chef it would have been unacceptable for him to make such a request.

This isn't that difficult.

Rudy hired a personal assistant, who was told up front that frequent oral was one of the assists required. There's no "job description" conflict or abuses there.

As you say, this isn't that difficult. You guys keep making excuses and trying to slide out on technicalities instead of addressing the broader point.

Any job north of very low end **** is going to include some flexibility (IME). I'm a construction contractor, and am the king of going beyond the four corners of my agreement as is practical. But what we are trying to suss out here is just how widely accepted this notion of sex work being so casual is, in the areas where it is legal. My assumption is that it would be treated like a vice. Loosely, like alcohol. Strict rules, both written and unwritten, regarding when and where, and generally not acceptable in any context in the workplace. Does that seem reasonable? I think it's reasonable.

Yet we get pushback that it's so "no big deal" that it's just like any other work, from flipping burgers to nursing. What I am trying to establish is some kind of foundational understanding of how it is looked at, without the "look at me I'm so progressive" bull **** posturing. It has been more of a battle than I would have expected.
 
Rudy hired a personal assistant, who was told up front that frequent oral was one of the assists required. There's no "job description" conflict or abuses there.

As you say, this isn't that difficult. You guys keep making excuses and trying to slide out on technicalities instead of addressing the broader point.

Come on Thermal, you were being perfectly reasonable up until this nonsense. Do you really think there's no way for places with legalized sex work to prevent every creepy boss from indemnifying themselves from sexual harassment this way?

is there any real example of this actually happening? Surely NZ has scummy bosses that would love to combine "sex worker" and "secretary" into one job position legally. This change in policy is over a decade old, surely you have an example you can point to demonstrating how legalized sex work has totally upended the restrictions against workplace sexual harassment.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom