Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, for the sake of the argument, IF all the legal requirements were met (make it public, put it in writing etc. ) in the offer of this new position (for example "sex puppet of the boss"). In a sex-work-decriminalised society, let´s assume that such work offer is legal. Open to anyone.

Would it be legal for the boss to offer it to his current workers?

And again the same answer as you've been told a few times is yes.

However outside your strange hypothetical world there are many issues that could open the company to liabilities.
 
And again the same answer as you've been told a few times is yes.

However outside your strange hypothetical world there are many issues that could open the company to liabilities.

Yes? Legal? But doens´t it contradict the current harassment laws?

"Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions."

Doesn´t showing the add for the position of "sex puppet of the boss" constutute "asking for sexual contact in return for employment benefits"? Perhaps with extra paperwork, but it´s THE SAME THING!
 
Yes? Legal? But doens´t it contradict the current harassment laws?

"Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions."

Doesn´t showing the add for the position of "sex puppet of the boss" constutute "asking for sexual contact in return for employment benefits"? Perhaps with extra paperwork, but it´s THE SAME THING!

You seem to want to have one foot in your hypothetical world, and one foot in the real world.

Can we go back to you supporting your claim/argument that: I don´t think it´s nonsensical, I think it´s the logical outcome.

Please provide your logic.
 
You seem to want to have one foot in your hypothetical world, and one foot in the real world.

Can we go back to you supporting your claim/argument that: I don´t think it´s nonsensical, I think it´s the logical outcome.

Please provide your logic.

What do you mean? My logic is that in my hypothetical sex-work-decriminalised world in which there is a legal work offer for "sex puppet of the boss", sex harassment laws could not work the same as in our world. You could not have a law that forbids "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." and make it legal for the boss to publish said add.

Why is it so hard to understand this? Do you agree or not?
 
Last edited:
What do you mean? My logic is that in my hypothetical sex-work-decriminalised world in which there is a legal work offer for "sex puppet of the boss", sex harassment laws could not work the same as in our world. You could not have a law that forbids "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions.".

Why is it so hard to understand this? Do you agree or not?

No such a "law" still makes sense in a society in which sex-work has been decriminalised, that phrase that you have latched onto (cherry picked?) does not say quite what you think it does. That sentence would not apply to the role of "sex provider for manager".

Perhaps if I move it away from sex it will be clearer to you what it is talking about.

I am a manager, I have a role I am looking to fill. I say "bung me a thousand quid and the job is yours".

That is what the phrase you've chosen to use as your entire "argument" is saying i.e.

I am a manager, I have a role I am looking to fill. I say "give me a shag and the job is yours".


Does that make it clearer what the sentence you keep quoting means?
 
It´s almost like... "sex" and "work" should not be mixed or something, right?

No, its not like that at all. We are merely using the workplace as one of many examples

-Making comments or jokes about sex or private body parts.
-Using sex or gender-related name calling.
-Sharing letters, notes, emails, texts, IMs, or online postings that talk about -sex or private body parts.
-Teasing anyone about their sexuality, sexual development, or gender identity.
-Harassing anyone for not fitting their idea of social gender norms.
-Touching you own or anyone else’s private body parts in a sexual way.
-Intentionally exposing their private body parts.
-Blocking someone’s path so they can't get away from you.

All of these are examples of sexual harassment and they don't just have to happen in the workplace. They can happen at school or university, among flatmates in a flat, among friends at a social gathering, in a public place such as a gymnasium, movie theatre, swimming pool, sports venue etc

In this country, sex work is considered to be just like any other job. This is not an opinion, it is a fact of law that is not up for debate. Just because you personally are too prudish to understand is your problem, not ours.
 
Notice that they are still playing around with with the same abstract-and-concrete confusion. Arthwolipot's version is a new take on it:



The principle is to recognize that sex work is indeed different but then to say that since other 'professions' are also different from each other, albeit in other respects, it's all the same thing.
I wonder what kind of exam papers or certificates you have to present as a prostitute to prove that you have the skills needed for the 'job' you apply for at the brothel as you would usually have to do when applying "for custodial work, or construction work."
The latter are pretty easy to find:
Best Custodial Maintenance Worker Certifications
Construction Skills Certification Scheme

By the way, this one-minute clip has nothing at all to do with prostitution, and yet its argument is very similar to the the one against the a-job-like-any-other idea:
Mehdi takes down GOP defense of Trump (MSNBC on YouTube - 0:57 min)


ETA: I can see that Australia lumps prostitutes together with, for instance, First Aid Trainers and Religious Assistants:
Group: 4518 Other Personal Service Workers


I wonder why!
I can see how first aid can be a very personal service, but why would first aid training be any more personal than other teaching jobs?!
Do Australians use actual people when training mouth-to-mouth resuscitation?
Don't they have CPR manikins in Australia? :confused:

Bunkum!
 
Let´s break it down:

1. In a sex-work-decriminalised society a boss could publish an add for a job such as "secretary with perks".

2. Said boss could advertise this position among his employees (for example posting the add in the office information panel... or verbally...

3. Current laws say: "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." and can be interpreted to include the boss´s advert.

Thus... either the add or the harassment law is not valid.

Which part of the argument do you have a problem with?
 
Let´s break it down:

1. In a sex-work-decriminalised society a boss could publish an add for a job such as "secretary with perks".

2. Said boss could advertise this position among his employees (for example posting the add in the office information panel... or verbally...

3. Current laws say: "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." and can be interpreted to include the boss´s advert.

Thus... either the add or the harassment law is not valid.

Which part of the argument do you have a problem with?
 
Let´s break it down:

1. In a sex-work-decriminalised society a boss could publish an add for a job such as "secretary with perks".

2. Said boss could advertise this position among his employees (for example posting the add in the office information panel... or verbally...

3. Current laws say: "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." and can be interpreted to include the boss´s advert.
Thus... either the add or the harassment law is not valid.

Which part of the argument do you have a problem with?

That's the point that it fails - that is not what that single sentence actually means.

And in the UK this is what is considered sexual harassment - direct from the legislation itself (Equality act)
26Harassment
(1)A person (A) harasses another (B) if—
(a)A engages in unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic, and
(b)the conduct has the purpose or effect of—
(i)violating B's dignity, or
(ii)creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for B.​
(2)A also harasses B if—
(a)A engages in unwanted conduct of a sexual nature, and
(b)the conduct has the purpose or effect referred to in subsection (1)(b).​
(3)A also harasses B if—
(a)A or another person engages in unwanted conduct of a sexual nature or that is related to gender reassignment or sex,
(b)the conduct has the purpose or effect referred to in subsection (1)(b), and
(c)because of B's rejection of or submission to the conduct, A treats B less favourably than A would treat B if B had not rejected or submitted to the conduct.​
(4)In deciding whether conduct has the effect referred to in subsection (1)(b), each of the following must be taken into account—
(a)the perception of B;
(b)the other circumstances of the case;
(c)whether it is reasonable for the conduct to have that effect.​
(5)The relevant protected characteristics are—
age;
disability;
gender reassignment;
race;
religion or belief;
sex;
sexual orientation.​

Please explain how that would no longer be "logical" if sex-work is decriminalised.
 
Last edited:
But what happened to the trafficked/addicted desperate workers? I mean, black markets thrive no matter the legality of the above board product, if the market is there. Say, a less than "hot" worker (whose competition in the legal brothels would push her out) offering her services for half or less? Or being forced into $50 Hummers by a gang or dealer? Where did they go?

There are still trafficked workers, but they're a tiny minority, because there's no real demand for them here when there's an actual surplus of prostitutes.

Along with that, migrants are checked by immigration services, and obviously licensed brothels have an incentive to highlight trafficking to both the collective and police, so what trafficking there is tends to be underground and confined to closed [ethnic] groups.

It's worth remembering at this point that many people who are objecting to the idea of legal sex work are from America, where employment law is ****** up beyond all recognition.

That's true, wher laws exist at all.

OK let me try again. I think

And again, and again, and again, ad nauseum.

You've created an absurdly unlikely scenario and can't accept that it's illegal in places where clear employment laws exist, but congrats on getting people to respond for a couple of pages.

Well played.
 
So Darat, are you saying that a boss can currently offer* an employee a raise for blowjobs**?

*in a sex-decriminalized place and respecting employment laws, such as the need to present the offer in writing, make it public, etc.

** taking into account that the offer is for a new job, or a change of work description, which changes it to "secretary with perks", all in accordance with employment laws.
 
Last edited:
You've created an absurdly unlikely scenario and can't accept that it's illegal in places where clear employment laws exist, but congrats on getting people to respond for a couple of pages.

Well played.

I don´t know... I´m getting mixed responses, some say that it would be illegal to offer such sex work and other say that it would be perfectly legal. Darat seems to say that in the UK OFFERING such sex work is not covered by sexual harassment laws.

You think it´s illegal? So you intepret "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." like I do? That it means (among other things) "offering the job of "secretary with perks"
 
Last edited:
So Darat, are you saying that a boss can currently offer* an employee a raise for blowjobs**?

*in a sex-decriminalized place and respecting employment laws, such as the need to present the offer in writing, make it public, etc.

** taking into account that the offer is for a new job, or a change of work description, which changes it to "secretary with perks", all in accordance with employment laws.

As you have posted it the answer is no - just like the boss can't offer an employee a raise for giving him a thousand pounds, you can't be asked for sex to secure a promotion or a raise.

It would in your hypothetical world be possible to have a job role which includes sex with the boss, if the current employment laws were in place making the role only available to one person would not follow the employment laws.

In other words the boss would have to decide on who to give the job to without consideration of the employee's disability status, gender reassignment, race, religion or belief, sex and sexual orientation.
 
I don´t know... I´m getting mixed responses, some say that it would be illegal to offer such sex work and other say that it would be perfectly legal. Darat seems to say that in the UK OFFERING such sex work is not covered by sexual harassment laws.

You think it´s illegal? So you intepret "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." like I do? That it means (among other things) "offering the job of "secretary with perks"

It's your interpretation that is wrong. It is saying that if your boss had said to you "got a new job for you but you need to shag me to get it" that is not allowed.
 
1. In a sex-work-decriminalised society a boss could publish an add for a job such as "secretary with perks".

Perhaps... IF he registers his business as a brothel. But he won't get any takers unless the applicant is a registered sex-worker, and he won't be able to employ anyone for that position who isn't

2. Said boss could advertise this position among his employees (for example posting the add in the office information panel... or verbally...

As above, and IF makes it clear that any applicant from within his own business would have to first register as a sex-worker. But not verbally - it must be in writing.

3. Current laws say: "Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions." and can be interpreted to include the boss´s advert.

Probably, but only if he has registered his business as a brothel.

I know exactly what you are trying to do. You are attempting to shoehorn the facts by incrementally joining a set of dubious dots to get from a untenable position to a tenable position in order to promote your chosen narrative. Its what you have tried to do on this topic previously - it didn't work then, and it won't work now.
‎
‎
 
Last edited:
It's your interpretation that is wrong. It is saying that if your boss had said to you "got a new job for you but you need to shag me to get it" that is not allowed.

Ok fine, but it´s a distinction without a difference. And you say it would be legal to offer such a job to an employee, but from the responses of other posters, it seems that many view it as obviously illegal and a workplace harassment issue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom