Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again missing the point that in my example it is just an offer. For example, personally, I was recently offered to take the "health and safety manager" position in my company. Not what I originally signed for, more responsibilities, better pay... AFAIK perfectly legal for them to offer it to me. I accepted, no biggie, these things are very common.

And?
 
It's chalk and cheese. Do jobs just not have duty statements where you come from?

We weren´t talking about duty statements. You said "you're conflating changing someone's job description to include sex related duties with exchanging enefits for sexual favours."

I say those two could be the same thing. The sexual favours can be "offering an employee the change of their job description to include sex related duties" and "exchanging benefits" would be the pay rise offered for the "prommotion".
 
Then please provide your logic.

ETA: And to be clear - this is what sexual harassment means in terms of UK employment

https://www.acas.org.uk/sexual-harassment

Please explain how sex work being decriminalised means that would no longer makes sense.


Let me use this other source for now: https://legalvoice.org/sexual-harassment-at-work/)

"Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions."

In your opinion, the reason for this to to be illegal is because sex work is illegal? In a sex-decriminalised society that wouldn´t be sexual harassment? (as long as he only "asks")
 
Let me use this other source for now: https://legalvoice.org/sexual-harassment-at-work/)

"Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions."

In your opinion, the reason for this to to be illegal is because sex work is illegal? In a sex-decriminalised society that wouldn´t be sexual harassment? (as long as he only "asks")

You said: I don´t think it´s nonsensical, I think it´s the logical outcome.

Please provide your logic.
 
Out of the blue. A very normal thing to happen. If a new post opens in a company, specially if the post is not full time, it is common to offer a worker if they want it. Makes perfect sense, the worker already knows the company, doesn´t need that much training, the worker may want the extra pay etc. These things happen all the time. It can happen the other way around too, a worker may ask the boss for a change of the work conditions, a friend of mine did this recently and landed in a better paid job in her company.
No, it isn't "perfectly normal". I would be pretty disturbed if that happened to me, quite frankly. This is not the same thing as being invited to apply to an advertised position, which would be quite reasonable in my opinion.

ETA, not a separate job offer, more like an extra job to take, in addition to my other duties.
Ah, I get it. So not an entirely new position then. Here, these kinds of duties are advertised so that anybody has an opportunity to apply, rather than being offered only to a single person, which is cronyism.

We're getting pretty far off the topic here. But your hypothetical wouldn't fall foul of only sexual harassment law, it looks like it would fall foul of corruption law too.
 
In your opinion, the reason for this to to be illegal is because sex work is illegal? In a sex-decriminalised society that wouldn´t be sexual harassment? (as long as he only "asks")
"Sex-decriminalised society"? As if sex is criminalised? I think you meant to say "sex work decriminalised society".

And what makes you think decriminalising sex work makes sexual harassment not sexual harassment?
 
We weren´t talking about duty statements. You said "you're conflating changing someone's job description to include sex related duties with exchanging enefits for sexual favours."
We were talking about duty statements. You clearly don't have the slightest clue what one of those is.

You're still not getting this.
 
No, it isn't "perfectly normal". I would be pretty disturbed if that happened to me, quite frankly. This is not the same thing as being invited to apply to an advertised position, which would be quite reasonable in my opinion.

Ah, I get it. So not an entirely new position then. Here, these kinds of duties are advertised so that anybody has an opportunity to apply, rather than being offered only to a single person, which is cronyism.

We're getting pretty far off the topic here. But your hypothetical wouldn't fall foul of only sexual harassment law, it looks like it would fall foul of corruption law too.

And of course, anti-discrimination laws.
 
But is it like that for every kind of offer? When they offered me to take the position of Health and Safety manager, they were trying to change my job description? No, they just made an offer. Again, this is very very common. Jobs change, new positions get created, and often filled by people from the same company (which is convenient and logical). Pretending this is illegal is... surreal...

Of course, you snipped out the part of my post that doesn't fit your preferred narrative... here let me remind you...

An offer or request by an employer to change an employee's job description (at least in this country), must be made in writing! Do you think the boss is going to commit an offer of sex for money to paper and then sign his name to it?
 
Let me use this other source for now: https://legalvoice.org/sexual-harassment-at-work/)

"Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions."

In your opinion, the reason for this to to be illegal is because sex work is illegal?

WRONG; Its illegal because sexual harrassment is illegal

In this country, sex-work is legal, but sexual harassment is not!

In a sex-decriminalised society that wouldn´t be sexual harassment? (as long as he only "asks")

Firstly, its not a "sex decriminalized" society, is a sex-work decriminalized society. This is the bit that probably escapes you.

Secondly, in any civilized western society, even asking your employee for sex is sexual harassment, and therefore illegal.
 
No, it isn't "perfectly normal". I would be pretty disturbed if that happened to me, quite frankly. This is not the same thing as being invited to apply to an advertised position, which would be quite reasonable in my opinion.

Ah, I get it. So not an entirely new position then. Here, these kinds of duties are advertised so that anybody has an opportunity to apply, rather than being offered only to a single person, which is cronyism.

We're getting pretty far off the topic here. But your hypothetical wouldn't fall foul of only sexual harassment law, it looks like it would fall foul of corruption law too.

How odd. Here in Spain AFAIK it´s only compulsory for the public sector to publish their job offers. Google isn´t helping me in finding out for sure.
 
WRONG; Its illegal because sexual harrassment is illegal

In this country, sex-work is legal, but sexual harassment is not!



Firstly, its not a "sex decriminalized" society, is a sex-work decriminalized society. This is the bit that probably escapes you.

Secondly, in any civilized western society, even asking your employee for sex is sexual harassment, and therefore illegal.

Yes, I meant sex-work-decriminalized society.

You say: "in any civilized western society, even asking your employee for sex is sexual harassment, and therefore illegal" ... but that´s unless your employee is a sex worker, right?
 
Of course, you snipped out the part of my post that doesn't fit your preferred narrative... here let me remind you...

Originally Posted by smartcooky View Post
An offer or request by an employer to change an employee's job description (at least in this country), must be made in writing! Do you think the boss is going to commit an offer of sex for money to paper and then sign his name to it?

I ignored it because it doesn´t matter for the sake of the argument. What if my hypothetical dirty boss puts it in writing? Is it legal then?
 
WRONG; Its illegal because sexual harrassment is illegal

In this country, sex-work is legal, but sexual harassment is not!



Firstly, its not a "sex decriminalized" society, is a sex-work decriminalized society. This is the bit that probably escapes you.

Secondly, in any civilized western society, even asking your employee for sex is sexual harassment, and therefore illegal.

OK, for the sake of the argument, IF all the legal requirements were met (make it public, put it in writing etc. ) in the offer of this new position (for example "sex puppet of the boss"). In a sex-work-decriminalised society, let´s assume that such work offer is legal. Open to anyone.

Would it be legal for the boss to offer it to his current workers?
 
Again missing the point that in my example it is just an offer. For example, personally, I was recently offered to take the "health and safety manager" position in my company. Not what I originally signed for, more responsibilities, better pay... AFAIK perfectly legal for them to offer it to me. I accepted, no biggie, these things are very common.


Notice that they are still playing around with with the same abstract-and-concrete confusion. Arthwolipot's version is a new take on it:
Okay, I'm just going to come out and say it.

Yes, sex work is different.


The principle is to recognize that sex work is indeed different but then to say that since other 'professions' are also different from each other, albeit in other respects, it's all the same thing.
I wonder what kind of exam papers or certificates you have to present as a prostitute to prove that you have the skills needed for the 'job' you apply for at the brothel as you would usually have to do when applying "for custodial work, or construction work."
The latter are pretty easy to find:
Best Custodial Maintenance Worker Certifications
Construction Skills Certification Scheme

By the way, this one-minute clip has nothing at all to do with prostitution, and yet its argument is very similar to the the one against the a-job-like-any-other idea:
Mehdi takes down GOP defense of Trump (MSNBC on YouTube - 0:57 min)


ETA: I can see that Australia lumps prostitutes together with, for instance, First Aid Trainers and Religious Assistants:
Group: 4518 Other Personal Service Workers
Description
This unit group covers Personal Service Workers not elsewhere classified.
It includes Civil Celebrants, Hair or Beauty Salon Assistants, Sex Workers or Escorts, Body Artists, First Aid Trainers and Religious Assistants.

I wonder why!
I can see how first aid can be a very personal service, but why would first aid training be any more personal than other teaching jobs?!
Do Australians use actual people when training mouth-to-mouth resuscitation?
Don't they have CPR manikins in Australia? :confused:
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom