arthwollipot
Limerick Purist Pronouns: He/Him
I really don't understand how you're not getting this.
Last edited:
OK let me try again. I think Thermal is the only one who gets it.
But it´s incredible how many of you have missed the fact that in my example the boss is not trying to change the employee´s job description, he´s just making an offer. Stop saying that he´s breaking employment laws that forbid the one sided change of job conditions.
AFAIK a boss can OFFER an employee a change of the job description. It happened to me recently, it´s very normal. New responsibilities, a change of work conditions and salary. Nothing illegal with OFFERING an employee, if they want, no problem if they refuse, that they do laundry, laying bricks, typing, taking dogs for a walk, welding beams...
But if the offer is for sex related things... then it´s harassment? Again, it´s just an OFFER.
But in a place where sex related work is decriminalised, shouldn´t it be perfectly legal for the boss to be able to OFFER his employees new jobs or changes of their job description, involving sex?
Unless the answer is yes, there is a disconnect there. Sex work is special or isn´t?
OK let me try again. I think Thermal is the only one who gets it.
But it´s incredible how many of you have missed the fact that in my example the boss is not trying to change the employee´s job description, he´s just making an offer. Stop saying that he´s breaking employment laws that forbid the one sided change of job conditions.
AFAIK a boss can OFFER an employee a change of the job description. It happened to me recently, it´s very normal. New responsibilities, a change of work conditions and salary. Nothing illegal with OFFERING an employee, if they want, no problem if they refuse, that they do laundry, laying bricks, typing, taking dogs for a walk, welding beams...
But if the offer is for sex related things... then it´s harassment? Again, it´s just an OFFER.
But in a place where sex related work is decriminalised, shouldn´t it be perfectly legal for the boss to be able to OFFER his employees new jobs or changes of their job description, involving sex?
Unless the answer is yes, there is a disconnect there. Sex work is special or isn´t?
The answer as everyone has told you is yes, as long as the offer is legal under the employment laws in the country. It's you that is saying it would be sexual harassment no one else. Now it could indeed be legally harassment depending on the circumstances.
Given the discrepancy in power, yes, each of these examples is harrassment.
If my boss suddenly were to OFFER I could do things, the implicit theat is there that not complying with that offer will affect my job, even though it's not in my job description. Thus declining it will not be easy.
Could easily be considered constructive dismissal over here if you felt you had to resign, for instance if your boss offered you a pay raise to take on cleaning his car and you felt he made it seem as if you had no choice. The other areas that would be problematic would be if the new role or responsibility was not offered to everyone to apply for, or was only offered to one gender, all ways such an offer could fall foul of employment legislation.Given the discrepancy in power, yes, each of these examples is harrassment.
If my boss suddenly were to OFFER I could do things, the implicit theat is there that not complying with that offer will affect my job, even though it's not in my job description. Thus declining it will not be easy.
It could be depending on the circumstances.What? It is harassment to offer a promotion?![]()
Okay, now you're conflating changing someone's job description to include sex related duties with exchanging benefits for sexual favours. Do you see how those two things are different?OK, OK, I just never seemed to get such a straightforward answer until now.
So, it would be legal then, and I guess those of you in the "sex work is just like any other work" camp don´t see anything wrong with a boss OFFERING a raise to his secretary in exchange of sex...
I´ve often thought that it that the reasons for its current illegality don´t stem from the fact that sex work is illegal, but from other reasons, such as the posibility of the abuse of power, for similar reasons as why it is forbidden in some proffessions to have sexual relationships between coworkers etc.
After some quick googling i found this:
"Quid pro quo sexual harassment happens when a supervisor or other manager asks or demands sexual contact from you in return for employment benefits or promotions."
(from https://legalvoice.org/sexual-harassment-at-work/)
So in your opinion, the reason for this to to be illegal is because sex work is illegal? In a sex-decriminalised society that wouldn´t be sexual harassment? (as long as he only "asks")
But it´s incredible how many of you have missed the fact that in my example the boss is not trying to change the employee´s job description, he´s just making an offer.
Stop saying that he´s breaking employment laws that forbid the one sided change of job conditions.
AFAIK a boss can OFFER an employee a change of the job description. It happened to me recently, it´s very normal. New responsibilities, a change of work conditions and salary. Nothing illegal with OFFERING an employee, if they want, no problem if they refuse, that they do laundry, laying bricks, typing, taking dogs for a walk, welding beams...
But if the offer is for sex related things... then it´s harassment? Again, it´s just an OFFER.
But in a place where sex related work is decriminalised, shouldn´t it be perfectly legal for the boss to be able to OFFER his employees new jobs or changes of their job description, involving sex?
Unless the answer is yes, there is a disconnect there. Sex work is special or isn´t?
Precisely. The example I used is being told your job is now to include cleaning your boss's car. If I was employed as a computer programmer cleaning the boss's car would be outside the remit of any kind of reasonable expectations, if I felt that the boss was implying I had to do so it would be a matter of resigning and taking the company to tribunal for constructive dismissal. Or simply taking them to a tribunal whilst still employed. It isn't that sex work is special in the sense that it is uniquely different, for example being told you now had to give your naked boss a full body massage would be the same type of thing for some people, it's that is different to most people's expectations of the job they have been employed to do.Okay, I'm just going to come out and say it.
Yes, sex work is different.
Sex work is not the same as clerical work, which is not the same as custodial work, which is not the same as construction work. Different industries operate under different principles, with different laws and regulations governing the industry.
If I accept an offer of clerical employment, it is with the understanding that my range of duties will be clerical in nature. Other duties are not what I signed up for. I didn't sign up for custodial work, or construction work. I might be unsuited for it. I certainly didn't seek the job on that basis. I applied for a clerical job. If suddenly my job description changes to something that I didn't apply for, I might have grounds to be a bit upset about that. I would certainly be looking for clerical work elsewhere - perhaps somewhere that such seismic shifts in assigned duties doesn't occur.
Add to that the power dynamic involved in a boss asking their employee to accept sexual duties, and you have grounds for legal action.
Okay, I'm just going to come out and say it.
Yes, sex work is different.
Sex work is not the same as clerical work, which is not the same as custodial work, which is not the same as construction work. Different industries operate under different principles, with different laws and regulations governing the industry.
If I accept an offer of clerical employment, it is with the understanding that my range of duties will be clerical in nature. Other duties are not what I signed up for. I didn't sign up for custodial work, or construction work. I might be unsuited for it. I certainly didn't seek the job on that basis. I applied for a clerical job. If suddenly my job description changes to something that I didn't apply for, I might have grounds to be a bit upset about that. I would certainly be looking for clerical work elsewhere - perhaps somewhere that such seismic shifts in assigned duties doesn't occur.
Add to that the power dynamic involved in a boss asking their employee to accept sexual duties, and you have grounds for legal action.
Could easily be considered constructive dismissal over here if you felt you had to resign, for instance if your boss offered you a pay raise to take on cleaning his car and you felt he made it seem as if you had no choice. The other areas that would be problematic would be if the new role or responsibility was not offered to everyone to apply for, or was only offered to one gender, all ways such an offer could fall foul of employment legislation.
But in the end the idea that sex work being completely decriminalised would mean a boss couldn't be accused of sexual harassment because it was made as an offer is simply nonsensical.
Okay, now you're conflating changing someone's job description to include sex related duties with exchanging benefits for sexual favours. Do you see how those two things are different?
Precisely. The example I used is being told your job is now to include cleaning your boss's car. If I was employed as a computer programmer cleaning the boss's car would be outside the remit of any kind of reasonable expectations, if I felt that the boss was implying I had to do so it would be a matter of resigning and taking the company to tribunal for constructive dismissal. Or simply taking them to a tribunal whilst still employed. It isn't that sex work is special in the sense that it is uniquely different, for example being told you now had to give your naked boss a full body massage would be the same type of thing for some people, it's that is different to most people's expectations of the job they have been employed to do.
By making an offer of sex for money, he IS trying to change his employee's job description.
No, I will not stop!! You do not control the narrative here.
I will not stop speaking the truth and I will not deny facts. By offering her money for sex, he IS trying to make a one-sided changes to her employment conditions - why, because she knows what is likely to happen if she refuses!!!
In other words, you were given a separate job offer, for a different job. Did this offer come out of the blue, or did you apply for it?Again missing the point that in my example it is just an offer. For example, personally, I was recently offered to take the "health and safety manager" position in my company. Not what I originally signed for, more responsibilities, better pay... AFAIK perfectly legal for them to offer it to me. I accepted, no biggie, these things are very common.
It's chalk and cheese. Do jobs just not have duty statements where you come from?No I don´t. It´s just different wording.
They are advertising the job and inviting you to apply for it. They aren't just changing your duty statement.So in your computer programming company, if they have an open job for cleaning the company cars, they can put an advert for it in the local paper, but... they can´t show you, the computer programmer, this advert, it would be illegal to do so?
In other words, you were given a separate job offer, for a different job. Did this offer come out of the blue, or did you apply for it?