Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
What I´m saying is that it´s inconsistent for a society to legalise prostitution, treating it like a normal job, and at the same time have laws that forbid things such as asking a secretary for sex in exchange or a raise, for example. If it´s just a normal job, you should be able to ask your secretary whether she wants to enlarge her job description. She can freely say yes or no, like she can freely say she wants the extra hours making photocopies or not. Why not, as long as she consents? Why are these pesky harassment laws so prudish?


Making photocopies is part of work. Pleasuring the creepy boss isn't. Sounds straightforward.

I get your point. Here's what might be an answer to your question. While I don't know about the legality per se on this, but in a corporate environment, if the boss asks people reporting to him to do his laundry, then I'm pretty sure the boss would be disciplined, maybe fired.

So there's no disconnect there. (Although I agree, it's probably not a criminal offense to ask your secretary to wash your clothes. On the other hand, if your boss offered you a raise if you'd agree to be punched in the face whenever he wanted to, then I expect --- not a lawyer, I'm guessing here --- you could maybe frame a complaint that might stand in a court of law.)

I see what disconnect you're pointing at, Abooga. But I don't think that disconnect's really there. (IANAL, etc.)
 
Making photocopies is part of work. Pleasuring the creepy boss isn't. Sounds straightforward.

I get your point. Here's what might be an answer to your question. While I don't know about the legality per se on this, but in a corporate environment, if the boss asks people reporting to him to do his laundry, then I'm pretty sure the boss would be disciplined, maybe fired.

So there's no disconnect there. (Although I agree, it's probably not a criminal offense to ask your secretary to wash your clothes. On the other hand, if your boss offered you a raise if you'd agree to be punched in the face whenever he wanted to, then I expect --- not a lawyer, I'm guessing here --- you could maybe frame a complaint that might stand in a court of law.)

I see what disconnect you're pointing at, Abooga. But I don't think that disconnect's really there. (IANAL, etc.)

But the secretary doesn't. ;)

"Secretary" seems to be distracting the point, methinks. How about a personal assistant (in the hope that pedantics will drop the clerical restrictions)?

In a country where selling sex is legal, would it be ok for a 55 year old boss to ask his 18 yo personal assistant for some anal as part of his or her regular duties? Just ask, mind you. I'd say hellz to the no, and it would possibly be terrifying, or at least creepy beyond words. But that's because I think sex is "special", or at least broadly in a special case of treatment. Our "selling sex is just like any other job" crew presumably wouldn't agree?
 
In a country where selling sex is legal, would it be ok for a 55 year old boss to ask his 18 yo personal assistant for some anal as part of his or her regular duties? Just ask, mind you. I'd say hellz to the no, and it would possibly be terrifying, or at least creepy beyond words. But that's because I think sex is "special", or at least broadly in a special case of treatment. Our "selling sex is just like any other job" crew presumably wouldn't agree?

A superior asking for sex from a subordinate in a non-sexual job would be inappropriate because that's not the job. Employment is an agreement that one party will do X type of labor in exchange for Y amount of compensation. Your scenario of a boss asking his PA for sex would be just as wrong as my boss asking me to perform a little surgery or pick up her shopping, or your boss asking you to choreograph an aeriel trapeze act for clowns and trained dolphins (I'm assuming that whatever field you work in is not related to circus choreography. I could be wrong. Is your job circus choreography? If so please tell me all about in a new thread because I want to hear all about it and also I have many, many ideas and suggestions). Whether you personally feel sex is a special activity in some way or not, demanding any activity that's radically outside the job duties is inappropriate; it's a labor abuse (ha! and today's Labor Day!) regardless of whether it's also moral, social, criminal, ethical, whathaveyou abuse.

Of course if someone voluntarily enters into a relationship or just chooses to have casual sex with their boss that's their business, and while I would view that as extremely unwise it's not necessarily wrong -- provided it's really a freely chosen thing and not pressured, direct or indirect. Which might be hard to actually tell which is one reason I find that unwise.
 
But the secretary doesn't. ;)

"Secretary" seems to be distracting the point, methinks. How about a personal assistant (in the hope that pedantics will drop the clerical restrictions)?

In a country where selling sex is legal, would it be ok for a 55 year old boss to ask his 18 yo personal assistant for some anal as part of his or her regular duties? Just ask, mind you. I'd say hellz to the no, and it would possibly be terrifying, or at least creepy beyond words. But that's because I think sex is "special", or at least broadly in a special case of treatment. Our "selling sex is just like any other job" crew presumably wouldn't agree?


This seems completely straightforward.

Offering an increase in remuneration, for a commensurate increase in responsibility, would be okay, if it were work-related. (Even that, within limits. I couldn't possibly ask a junior manager reporting into me if he'd like to make a few extra bucks by doing the janitor's work. Nor would I be authorized to offer such a raise, in any decent corporate job.)

But any work that isn't related to the professional reguirements of the organization, cannot possibly be demanded, or requested for, not on a professional footing. It doesn't necessarily have to be a secretary, you can't ask anyone reporting into you (be they an engineer reporting to you, or a qualified chartered accountant working as analyst for you) to run personal errands for you. If you do, you're liable to be disciplined, and likely enough terminated. This, without question, in any half-decent corporate. Certainly in theory, and actually in practice as well.

-----

I agree, the issue becomes a bit less straightforward when it comes to the law. But only just a wee bit, not enough to make it the kind of contradiction that Abooga argues it is.

True, your asking your secretary (or technical resource, or credit analyst) to do your laundry will probably not result in criminal liability. It may open the organization up for civil liability if it does not take action, but I doubt there'll be criminality here, or actual jail terms. While asking them to offer sexual services would. But I doubt sex is the one only such thing, that will attract criminal action. Like I said already, I'm pretty sure if the boss offered raises to his reports --- whether secretary, or qualified engineer or CA or MBA or whatever --- in exchange for agreeing to getting punched in the face, then, over and above said boss getting kicked out from the company, I'm pretty sure the weirdo boss would be personally liable for criminal action.

(Like I said, I'm only arguing on general principles here. On the other hand, so is Abooga, apparently, and so are you, so maybe I needn't feel too diffident about my ignorance of the law on this matter. But, like I said, should someone actually know what the law has to say about all of this --- either because they're legally qualified, or because they've taken the trouble to look this up in some detail --- then I'm sure the discussion would carry more weight, than merely speaking about this on general principles. ...But as things stand, like I said, while I do see the point Abooga's trying to make, I think he's honestly mistaken in thinking there's a double standard here.)
 
A superior asking for sex from a subordinate in a non-sexual job would be inappropriate because that's not the job. Employment is an agreement that one party will do X type of labor in exchange for Y amount of compensation. Your scenario of a boss asking his PA for sex would be just as wrong as my boss asking me to perform a little surgery or pick up her shopping, or your boss asking you to choreograph an aeriel trapeze act for clowns and trained dolphins

Negative. The specializations you chose require specialized licenses and training. Simply bending over and holding on tight does not.

My limited experience with actual PAs is that they assist in literally anything, from scheduling meetings to ordering take out and picking up the dry cleaning. Sexual assistance, if it is as casual a thing as some here insist, could fall somewhere in that job description, at least as an option. Insisting that it wouldn't for technical reasons is dodging the point.

(I'm assuming that whatever field you work in is not related to circus choreography. I could be wrong. Is your job circus choreography? If so please tell me all about in a new thread because I want to hear all about it and also I have many, many ideas and suggestions).

I run residential construction in New Jersey. Yes, my job is solidly in circus choreography more than I like to admit.

Whether you personally feel sex is a special activity in some way or not, demanding any activity that's radically outside the job duties is inappropriate; it's a labor abuse (ha! and today's Labor Day!) regardless of whether it's also moral, social, criminal, ethical, whathaveyou abuse.

Only if you think sex work is not like other work. You know, it's "special".

Again, my challenge here is to the posters who are trying to act like sex work is like any other. It's not, by any standard. It is highly restricted morally, socially, criminally, ethically, and whathaveyou-illy.

Of course if someone voluntarily enters into a relationship or just chooses to have casual sex with their boss that's their business, and while I would view that as extremely unwise it's not necessarily wrong -- provided it's really a freely chosen thing and not pressured, direct or indirect. Which might be hard to actually tell which is one reason I find that unwise.

Agreed. Shouldn't be though, if it's no big deal then, should it? Or are you saying that romantic and emotional entanglements are so likely that it's a bad idea out of the gate? I know exactly what you mean.
 
Negative. The specializations you chose require specialized licenses and training. Simply bending over and holding on tight does not.

Those examples were bad, then. I would hold the same principle for unspecialized work. If my boss asked me to take out her garbage, or do her laundry, or sing a Kenny Rogers song I would balk equally as much. The job is the job, it's not servitude.

My limited experience with actual PAs is that they assist in literally anything, from scheduling meetings to ordering take out and picking up the dry cleaning. Sexual assistance, if it is as casual a thing as some here insist, could fall somewhere in that job description, at least as an option. Insisting that it wouldn't for technical reasons is dodging the point.

No. Sex doesn't have to be noncasual in order to be inappropriate for a job duty, if that wasn't part of the job. You seem intent on establishing only two possible options: either sex is special or else it must be something that can be assigned as a job task. There is a tremendous gulf between those two things.

Only if you think sex work is not like other work. You know, it's "special".


No. Again: there are more positions than "sex is special" and "sex can be demanded as part of job duties". This attempt to force one of those two choices as the only possible options is ridiculous.

Again, my challenge here is to the posters who are trying to act like sex work is like any other. It's not, by any standard. It is highly restricted morally, socially, criminally, ethically, and whathaveyou-illy.

Declaring that to be so does not make it so. Others disagree.

Agreed. Shouldn't be though, if it's no big deal then, should it? Or are you saying that romantic and emotional entanglements are so likely that it's a bad idea out of the gate? I know exactly what you mean.

I seriously doubt you know exactly what I mean, you are persistently on the wrong page here. I believe work is work, personal life is personal life, and mixing the two leads to irritation and complication. This does not require believing that sex is particularly special. It doesn't have to be special in order to be unwise to mix it with work (unless that's part of the job). I don't think religion is special, or obsession with pop stars, or Crossfit, or collecting too many cats, but I wouldn't advise involving any of those things with work (unless that's part of the job). Work is work. Anything else is anything else.
 
But the secretary doesn't. ;)

Ka-boom! Nice hit.

In a country where selling sex is legal, would it be ok for a 55 year old boss to ask his 18 yo personal assistant for some anal as part of his or her regular duties?

Let me put on my employment law expert hat on for a second, because the answer is very straightforward.

Employment conditions are set at the commencement of employment.

It is perfectly valid and legal for an employer to list sexual favours being performed as part of a job, but the employee would have to consent to that prior to commencing employment.

Changes to employment contracts can be made if both parties consent to the changes, so there's nothing stopping the employer trying to do that, but the employee has a right to refuse the change*.

If the boss says to an employee that a raise/bonus/anything is dependent on sexual favours, then he would be breaching employment law and subject to stiff penalties. He would be fined by the labour court and ordered to pay compensation to the employee.

*Given the state of the western world in 2023, I think any employer trying either of those options would be Page 1 news pretty promptly and cause a backlash that would sink the business.
 
Ka-boom! Nice hit.



Let me put on my employment law expert hat on for a second, because the answer is very straightforward.

Employment conditions are set at the commencement of employment.

It is perfectly valid and legal for an employer to list sexual favours being performed as part of a job, but the employee would have to consent to that prior to commencing employment.

Changes to employment contracts can be made if both parties consent to the changes, so there's nothing stopping the employer trying to do that, but the employee has a right to refuse the change*.

If the boss says to an employee that a raise/bonus/anything is dependent on sexual favours, then he would be breaching employment law and subject to stiff penalties. He would be fined by the labour court and ordered to pay compensation to the employee.

*Given the state of the western world in 2023, I think any employer trying either of those options would be Page 1 news pretty promptly and cause a backlash that would sink the business.

Straight answer, excellent. So sex as work would be legal outside a brothel or street solicitation? That's different. So ok. Even if on the legal side of the line, would such a request fly in the real world? If my daughter said such a thing was asked, I wouldn't have her working within ten miles of that creepshow, personally.

On another note, the relationships you and smartcooky have described sound more like a high end call girl arrangement. I mean, $200-500/hr is more than average jingle. And I can actually picture a working arrangement on those terms.

But what happened to the trafficked/addicted desperate workers? I mean, black markets thrive no matter the legality of the above board product, if the market is there. Say, a less than "hot" worker (whose competition in the legal brothels would push her out) offering her services for half or less? Or being forced into $50 Hummers by a gang or dealer? Where did they go?
 
If the boss says to an employee that a raise/bonus/anything is dependent on sexual favours, then he would be breaching employment law and subject to stiff penalties.

Nice choice of words

On another note, the relationships you and smartcooky have described sound more like a high end call girl arrangement. I mean, $200-500/hr is more than average jingle. And I can actually picture a working arrangement on those terms.

Nope. There are likely "high end call girl" escort services over and above what TheAtheist and I have been describing. Which sort of deals with the next bit of your post

But what happened to the trafficked/addicted desperate workers? I mean, black markets thrive no matter the legality of the above board product, if the market is there. Say, a less than "hot" worker (whose competition in the legal brothels would push her out) offering her services for half or less? Or being forced into $50 Hummers by a gang or dealer? Where did they go?

They simply, for the most part, no longer exist in our Society. Over the course of 20 years of legalized sex-work, they have been "phased out". One of the reasons for this is that prostitution, by its very nature, has to have a public facing component which usually involves street walking. That makes them very easy to spot, so easy that even cops can spot them. It didn't take very long for these girls to work out that if they cleaned up their act, they get better pay and get to keep all their earnings working in a legit brothel, and rather than get picked up by cops, they get protected by them.

As for the gang pimps, it didn't take them long to realize they were on a loser. The competition they were facing was unbeatable, and protected by the law and the cops - because why would anyone want to go to a sex-worker who is being pimped out by a gang member for pennies and drugs, when they can go to a sex worker who is legit, legal, registered and has regular health checkups. Its a no-brainer.

There are no black market prostitutes simply because there is no longer a market for them.
 
That won´t do. Why is it legal to offer a raise if the job description change involves driving, washing etc. and illegal if the change involves sex?
You can't just change someone's job description like that. You have employed them for a specific purpose. Suddenly and arbitrarily changing someone's terms of employment without negotiation is not on. There are laws and regulations about that sort of thing.

At least, there are in civilised countries.

Because it´s not like any other job, that´s what I´m saying. Now ask yourself why sex harassment is what it is and you can get an idea what is special about this job, and why some people may think it should not be legal, without "outdated prudish mentality" etc. Or perhaps sex harassment laws are based on such outdated prudish mentality. One or the other.
Sexual harassment laws are based on sexual harassment. I don't know what laws you're looking at.
 
Let me put on my employment law expert hat on for a second, because the answer is very straightforward.

Employment conditions are set at the commencement of employment.

It is perfectly valid and legal for an employer to list sexual favours being performed as part of a job, but the employee would have to consent to that prior to commencing employment.

Changes to employment contracts can be made if both parties consent to the changes, so there's nothing stopping the employer trying to do that, but the employee has a right to refuse the change*.

If the boss says to an employee that a raise/bonus/anything is dependent on sexual favours, then he would be breaching employment law and subject to stiff penalties. He would be fined by the labour court and ordered to pay compensation to the employee.

*Given the state of the western world in 2023, I think any employer trying either of those options would be Page 1 news pretty promptly and cause a backlash that would sink the business.
It's worth remembering at this point that many people who are objecting to the idea of legal sex work are from America, where employment law is ****** up beyond all recognition.
 
Yes but reality has to be given equal weight to random stuff people make up that could happen.
 
Just for the benefit of Abooga, a recent story will serve as an example of what happens when an employer breaks employment law in this country...

https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/13...o-f-off-after-dismissing-worker-in-group-chat

To summarize, we'll call the employee (who has name suppression) "Fred", and the employer "John".

- Fred responded to John's Facebook advert for people wanting work experience in his Silviculture business
- John asked him to come to work, and to come back the next day but Fred was not given an employment agreement or contract.
- Fred was told the rate of pay would be $25 per hour
- Fred's wage rate was cut back to $21 on his third day of work
- Some weeks later, John dismissed Fred without cause in a group chat, and Fred subsequently filed a complaint with the ERA (Employment Relations Authority)
- when the ERA called John about the complaint, he told them to "**** off!"

So, what did John's malarkey cost him?
$42,787.60, consisting of

$3927.60 arrears of wages.
$360 annual holidays.
$9000 compensation for lost wages.
$22,500 compensation for hurt and humiliation.
$4000 in penalties to the crown.
$3000 in penalties to the employee.

The lesson here for John? Do NOT **** with the ERA!!
‎
‎
 
OK let me try again. I think Thermal is the only one who gets it.

But it´s incredible how many of you have missed the fact that in my example the boss is not trying to change the employee´s job description, he´s just making an offer. Stop saying that he´s breaking employment laws that forbid the one sided change of job conditions.

AFAIK a boss can OFFER an employee a change of the job description. It happened to me recently, it´s very normal. New responsibilities, a change of work conditions and salary. Nothing illegal with OFFERING an employee, if they want, no problem if they refuse, that they do laundry, laying bricks, typing, taking dogs for a walk, welding beams...
But if the offer is for sex related things... then it´s harassment? Again, it´s just an OFFER.

But in a place where sex related work is decriminalised, shouldn´t it be perfectly legal for the boss to be able to OFFER his employees new jobs or changes of their job description, involving sex?

Unless the answer is yes, there is a disconnect there. Sex work is special or isn´t?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom