Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
We somehow managed to progress from it being considered perfectly reasonable for it to legal and the "right" of a husband to force his wife to have sex, to it being considered sexual assault if the wife did not consent.

Consent is the key element here. Not whether it is prudish or icky.

But asking a secretary for sex in exchange of a rise does not negate consent.
 
I also think prostitution is not "like any other job". This is my "secretary with perks" argument: If you offer your secretary a raise if she takes other extra responsabilities, cooking for you, driving for you, whatever, it´s all OK. She can accept or decline, no biggie. But if you offer her a raise for a little bj every now and then... then you´re breaking the law! Immoral and illegal behavour. Why is that? Is it not like any other job?

What I mean is that there is a disconnect if you think that prostitution is like any other job, but you also think sex harassment laws make sense.

That is not for you to say.

The sex workers themselves consider it a job (and they are the only one's whose opinions really count for anything meaningful in this debate). If you had read recent posts here, you would know its a job they choose to do.

But asking a secretary for sex in exchange of a rise does not negate consent.

And who here, exactly, is advocating for this?

We somehow managed to progress from it being considered perfectly reasonable for it to legal and the "right" of a husband to force his wife to have sex, to it being considered sexual assault if the wife did not consent.

Consent is the key element here. Not whether it is prudish or icky.

THIS!!! :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
What I´m saying is that it´s inconsistent for a society to legalise prostitution, treating it like a normal job, and at the same time have laws that forbid things such as asking a secretary for sex in exchange or a raise, for example. If it´s just a normal job, you should be able to ask your secretary whether she wants to enlarge her job description. She can freely say yes or no, like she can freely say she wants the extra hours making photocopies or not. Why not, as long as she consents? Why are these pesky harassment laws so prudish?
 
What I´m saying is that it´s inconsistent for a society to legalise prostitution, treating it like a normal job, and at the same time have laws that forbid things such as asking a secretary for sex in exchange or a raise, for example. If it´s just a normal job, you should be able to ask your secretary whether she wants to enlarge her job description. She can freely say yes or no, like she can freely say she wants the extra hours making photocopies or not. Why not, as long as she consents? Why are these pesky harassment laws so prudish?

Harassment (in the legal sense) is illegal, sexual harassment is a subclass of harassment, bullying in the workplace is a subclass of harassment, harassment is not about prudery.

If a society decides to de-criminalise all forms of sex work sexual harassment would still be illegal.
 
Harassment (in the legal sense) is illegal, sexual harassment is a subclass of harassment, bullying in the workplace is a subclass of harassment, harassment is not about prudery.

If a society decides to de-criminalise all forms of sex work sexual harassment would still be illegal.

But in that decriminalised society, asking your secretary if she wants to expand her work description to include sex, would it be legal?
 
What I´m saying is that it´s inconsistent for a society to legalise prostitution, treating it like a normal job, and at the same time have laws that forbid things such as asking a secretary for sex in exchange or a raise, for example.

No it's not, you just have no understanding of labour laws or prostution.
 
What I´m saying is that it´s inconsistent for a society to legalise prostitution, treating it like a normal job, and at the same time have laws that forbid things such as asking a secretary for sex in exchange or a raise, for example. If it´s just a normal job, you should be able to ask your secretary whether she wants to enlarge her job description. She can freely say yes or no, like she can freely say she wants the extra hours making photocopies or not. Why not, as long as she consents? Why are these pesky harassment laws so prudish?

Your problem is that you are using sex as the connecting point between the two, but you are wrong to do this. There is in fact a complete disconnect between these two, and as quadraginta points out, that disconnect is consent.

- A sex worker is offering her services as a sex partner, so it is perfectly acceptable to offer her money for sex, because that is her job.

- A secretary is offering her services as a clerical worker, NOT as a sex worker, so it is unacceptable to offer her money for sex, because that is NOT her job.

and along those lines...

- A secretary is offering her services as a clerical worker, NOT as a car detailer so it is unacceptable to offer her money to wash your car, because that is NOT her job.
 
Last edited:
Your problem is that you are using sex as the connecting point between the two, but you are wrong to do this. There is in fact a complete disconnect between these two, and as quadraginta points out, that disconnect is consent.

- A sex worker is offering her services as a sex partner, so it is perfectly acceptable to offer her money for sex, because that is her job.

- A secretary is offering her services as a clerical worker, NOT as a sex worker, so it is unacceptable to offer her money for sex, because that is NOT her job.

and along those lines...

- A secretary is offering her services as a clerical worker, NOT as a car detailer so it is unacceptable to offer her money to wash your car, because that is NOT her job.

But as far as I know it´s not illegal to offer her money to wash your car. But it would be illegal to offer her money for sex.

And you´re saying that the difference between these two is not sex?
 
But asking a secretary for sex in exchange of a rise does not negate consent.

But in that decriminalised society, asking your secretary if she wants to expand her work description to include sex, would it be legal?


As long as that request didn't fall foul of employment laws. For example in the UK a major change in contractual terms such as a job description requiring a new role requires consent from both sides. What happens after such an offer of a new role was refused could open the company up to matters such as constructive dismissal, harassment, sexual-harassment, bullying, discrimination and so on.

Sex-work being completely decriminalised has nothing to do with the criminal and civil matter of sexual harassment.
 
As long as that request didn't fall foul of employment laws. For example in the UK a major change in contractual terms such as a job description requiring a new role requires consent from both sides. What happens after such an offer of a new role was refused could open the company up to matters such as constructive dismissal, harassment, sexual-harassment, bullying, discrimination and so on.

Sex-work being completely decriminalised has nothing to do with the criminal and civil matter of sexual harassment.

Are you saying that it is currently legal to offer a secretary for a raise in exchange for sex, as long as it is clear that it would require consent etc? I´ve always thought the offer itself to be illegal according to current laws...
 
Are you saying that it is currently legal to offer a secretary for a raise in exchange for sex, as long as it is clear that it would require consent etc? I´ve always thought the offer itself to be illegal according to current laws...

You were asking about your hypothetical world in which sex-work had been completely decriminalised. That is the scenario I was replying to.
 
You were asking about your hypothetical world in which sex-work had been completely decriminalised. That is the scenario I was replying to.

Not necessarily hypothetical, sex work is decriminalised in some places. Is it legal in those places to offer a raise in exchange for sex to an employee and should it be so?
 
But as far as I know it´s not illegal to offer her money to wash your car. But it would be illegal to offer her money for sex.

And you´re saying that the difference between these two is not sex?

Correct.

While not a criminal offense, it would be considered inappropriate, and a violation of employment law, to offer money to your secretary to wash your car, and in this country at least, would be considered harassment. If she chose to, she could drag you in front of the employment tribunal for such behaviour.
 
Last edited:
Correct.

While not a criminal offence, it is considered inappropriate to offer money to your secretary to wash your car, and in this country at least, would be considered harassment. If she chose to, she could drag you in front of the employment tribunal for such behaviour.

Are you sure? I think it´s illegal to ask an employee to do something outside of their job descrioption in their current job, but to offer them a new job or a extension of the job description? Just to offer it? That´s just everyday stuff!
 
I was recently offered to take up new responsibilities in my job, outside of its original job description, with the prospect of a possible raise in the future. Was that illegal?
 
I was recently offered to take up new responsibilities in my job, outside of its original job description, with the prospect of a possible raise in the future. Was that illegal?

No one can tell from the information you give. Minimally we would need to know country, which state if a federated country for which laws will apply, then what does your current contract say, what is the new role, how is the future raise going to be adjudged?
 
I don't think there's any country in which it is illegal to offer a job. Unless it's sex related.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom