Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think for men, willingness to take on male clients makes them more likely to be successful prostitutes.

I think they're two separate groups - male escorts for women, whose job is more escort and less sex - although sex is often part of the package - and men for men prostitutes.

Which one makes more, I don't know, but I'd personally want to be in the former group.

I suspect I care a hell of a lot more about the harm done to females (and some males) who are prostituted and trafficked than many of you pro-buying-sex folks are

Now I see - you're just completely confused on the subject.

In legal prostitution, none of them are [legally] trafficked and none are "prostituted". They've chosen it as a job, just as you chose yours. You don't care more at all, you're just on a different subject.

Otherwise, since when does being a woman give you the entitlement to tell other women what to do with their lives and bodies?

Being against legal, soundly legislated prostitution is exactly equivalent to being anti-abortion - you're telling women how they should live their lives, and I don't believe anyone should have a right to do that.
 
Wow, this is so completely wrong. But not a surprising "interpretation" from you, and certainly in keeping with your general mind-reading skills.

I suspect I care a hell of a lot more about the harm done to females (and some males) who are prostituted and trafficked than many of you pro-buying-sex folks are. I have exactly zero desire to punish any of the victims of sex trafficking.

On the other hand, I also have no desire to try to white wash it into "just a different kind of work" where we pretend that the 2% of successful OF, Porn, and high class escorts are somehow representative of the entirety of the industry that sells bodies as if they're breathing fleshlights. And I definitely am not willing to just sit idly by while some people misrepresent it as some idyllic lifestyle where a female can totally and easily make it rich with barely any effort at all and no risks worth noting.


You should please note that the OP was talking about what happens here, in this country. In this country, sex work is legal.

In this country, the vast majority of sex workers are in the game voluntarily. Many of them are women who were in reasonably well paid work (the two customers I have who are sex workers were a chartered accountant and high-school teacher). TheAtheist mentions the ones he has met recently as a psychology master's student, a solo mum, a receptionist and a business studies graduate. These are not the exception, they are the norm (and that would not have been the case 20 years ago before prostitution was legalized). These women can stop what they are doing and find other work in a heartbeat... they choose not to do so - and why would they when they get up to five times the pay for less than half the work hours!?

The sex-trafficking trade in this country is all but non-existent because pimps and criminal gangs have been shut out of the game. Word gets around if any of that is going on, and the brothel keepers and employees will report it to the Police immediately. And why wouldn't they? Police no longer harass and arrest sex workers, they protect them!!
 
Police no longer harass and arrest sex workers, they protect them!!

It actually goes further than that. Cops and hookers have such a good relationship that there's an informal information-sharing system in place where police tell the brothels and street girls they want to find bloke X, and brothels or girls will call the cops if he visits them. Crooks use prostitutes and the cops know that and find it much easier to work with the girls than against them.
 
I suspect you're just being silly now.

Again, relying on TV interviews (I think in this case it was an 'Andrew Denton' program) when he asked about male prostitutes for women, the woman being interviewed said something along the lines of: "It's so rare we don't tend to have male sex workers for women, but a couple of the male drivers have subbed in from time to time."

That makes me suspect that there may be more demand for male 'escorts' i.e. educated, well dressed, well groomed, that can be used for 'arm candy' and this may be a distinct industry from sex workers.

Note that male for male sex workers appears to be a much bigger demand.
 
Well, come on. You're not really saying anything. Pretty much any guy has at least considered paying for a prostitute's services, even if only in passing.

So you considered actually being a prostitute? Males servicing females are vanishingly rare here, and the stamina workload would likely limit your potential income anyway. Not a lot of guys plowing down 3 per hour all day long, and all that. So are you saying you considered the, uh, catcher's end of the game? How seriously did you pursue this, or do you mean you "considered" it for like three seconds on the couch one night while watching TV?
I did not seriously pursue it, but it was something that I considered at one time. I don't care to go into any more detail.
 
Your kidding yourself if you think that prostitutes are treated with anywhere near the same level of respect as your average service worker.
You're kidding yourself if you think your toxic American attitude towards the sex industry is the norm in places where it is legal and regulated.

You know, like we have been talking about for 77 pages. Maybe take a look at some of the thread history before bringing your attitude.
 
Last edited:
Your kidding yourself if you think that prostitutes are treated with anywhere near the same level of respect as your average service worker.

What difference does this make with respect to it's legality? If someone chooses* a profession that society shuns them for does not necessitate it being made illegal.

And I want you to go back and carefully read that word: chooses. Of course like any other work, being coerced or enslaved should remain illegal. If someone does it to support a drug habit how does making the act illegal help anyone?
 
Prosecute the ever loving **** out of those who try to buy sex. IMO, prosecute them as rapists.

The Taliban, Iran, Saudi-Arabia and several other countries agree and do so.
Yet prostitution still exists there and for some reason it has not worked.
By the way, do you also advocate this for women hiring male prostitutes?
 
Wow, this is so completely wrong. But not a surprising "interpretation" from you, and certainly in keeping with your general mind-reading skills.

I suspect I care a hell of a lot more about the harm done to females (and some males) who are prostituted and trafficked than many of you pro-buying-sex folks are. I have exactly zero desire to punish any of the victims of sex trafficking.

On the other hand, I also have no desire to try to white wash it into "just a different kind of work" where we pretend that the 2% of successful OF, Porn, and high class escorts are somehow representative of the entirety of the industry that sells bodies as if they're breathing fleshlights. And I definitely am not willing to just sit idly by while some people misrepresent it as some idyllic lifestyle where a female can totally and easily make it rich with barely any effort at all and no risks worth noting.

Just upthread I posted a link to a (dutch) article which looks at and interviews students doing escort work. They are neither trafficked nor forced, they consider it a quicker way to make money than the usual student jobs.
Prostitutes in the red-light districts have their own union, which actively seeks to help those that are forced into prostitution, but also worked hard to legalize the profession.

That is not to say there is no forced prostitution of course, especially the internet made it harder to police things, though by law visiting a prostitute that is forced rather than choosing to be one is illegal and is a prosecutable offense.
 
Close to 1500 posts in this thread, where males discuss with other males, the pros and cons of treating females as non-entities to be literally used as objects for satiating male desires.
You appear to have been reading a completely different thread to the rest of us.
:rolleyes:
 
I think they're two separate groups - male escorts for women, whose job is more escort and less sex - although sex is often part of the package - and men for men prostitutes.
There's also the more 'specialised' end of the market, catering to BDSM fans who don't have regular partners. Quite a few professional male doms, though not as many as female.
 
I also think prostitution is not "like any other job". This is my "secretary with perks" argument: If you offer your secretary a raise if she takes other extra responsabilities, cooking for you, driving for you, whatever, it´s all OK. She can accept or decline, no biggie. But if you offer her a raise for a little bj every now and then... then you´re breaking the law! Immoral and illegal behavour. Why is that? Is it not like any other job?

What I mean is that there is a disconnect if you think that prostitution is like any other job, but you also think sex harassment laws make sense.
 
I didn´t know anyone would remember, I said it years ago in a similar thread. I just wanted to see how the argument may fare this time.
 
I didn´t know anyone would remember, I said it years ago in a similar thread. I just wanted to see how the argument may fare this time.
What was the response?

Because my response can be summed up in two words: Job Description. A secretary (which we call an Executive Assistant, or EA now) isn't employed to give blowjobs. It's outside their job description. They're not employed to drive your car, do your washing, or weed your garden either. They're employed to manage your calendar, screen your calls, and book your travel. Basing a raise on whether they'll give you a blowjob or not is sexual harassment, which is illegal.
 
What was the response?

Because my response can be summed up in two words: Job Description. A secretary (which we call an Executive Assistant, or EA now) isn't employed to give blowjobs. It's outside their job description. They're not employed to drive your car, do your washing, or weed your garden either. They're employed to manage your calendar, screen your calls, and book your travel. Basing a raise on whether they'll give you a blowjob or not is sexual harassment, which is illegal.

That won´t do. Why is it legal to offer a raise if the job description change involves driving, washing etc. and illegal if the change involves sex?

Because it´s not like any other job, that´s what I´m saying. Now ask yourself why sex harassment is what it is and you can get an idea what is special about this job, and why some people may think it should not be legal, without "outdated prudish mentality" etc. Or perhaps sex harassment laws are based on such outdated prudish mentality. One or the other.
 
Last edited:
That won´t do. Why is it legal to offer a raise if the job description change involves driving, washing etc. and illegal if the change involves sex?

Because it´s not like any other job, that´s what I´m saying. Now ask yourself why sex harassment is what it is and you can get an idea what is special about this job, and why some people may think it should not be legal, without "outdated prudish mentality" etc. Or perhaps having sex harassment laws are based on such outdated prudish mentality. One or the other.


We somehow managed to progress from it being considered perfectly reasonable for it to legal and the "right" of a husband to force his wife to have sex, to it being considered sexual assault if the wife did not consent.

Consent is the key element here. Not whether it is prudish or icky.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom