Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Close to 1500 posts in this thread, where males discuss with other males, the pros and cons of treating females as non-entities to be literally used as objects for satiating male desires.

Seems like a lot of the "sex works is work" crowd seem to gloss right over the rampant drug use, physical abuse, coercion, and trafficking involved. Lots of people seem to have watched Pretty Woman and think that's a true depiction, and every prostitute is just a "happy hooker" waiting to be swept off their feet.

We'll just ignore the massively increased risk of sexually transmitted illnesses, potential pregnancy, and physical damage endured... all in the name of males feeling entitled to the use of a female's body with no care or consideration for that female as an actual human being.

I've seen comparisons to waiters and plumbers and janitors... but all of you treat employees in those jobs as being whole people. A waiter isn't just a set of feet and hands that brings you your dinner, they're an entire person with whom you'll have a passing discussion and take pains to be kind to them and appreciate their work. A plumber is not just a meatsack for a pipe wrench, but someone who is a whole person and you expect them to have an entire life outside of their job. Even the janitor who cleans your toilets is treated as a complete being with a personality and likes and dislikes, and almost every one of you would be kind and considerate of them.

But "sex workers"... yeah. As much lip service as you might put to it, you're literally paying someone to be nothing more than an object to be used and discarded. At the end of the day, it boils down to "I want to get my rocks off, but I don't want to be hassled with the bother of treating another human like a whole being, I just want to stick my dick in a hole and rock one".

And the crowd that goes around parroting that "Sex work is work" are engaged in a giant lie, an attempt to degrade females and strip them of their fundamental humanity, to place females as subservient to the ever-present desire of males to experience sexual release.

Doing a feminism by encouraging an approach that all but guarantees more exploitation and danger for women sex workers.

The anti-sex work feminists remind me a lot of the anti-abortion zealots. They don't care what harm is done to women so long as the wicked ones get adequately punished. Likewise anti-sex work zealots don't care what obvious harm the black market sex trade has on women, it's much more important that their moral outrage be codified into law.
 
Doing a feminism by encouraging an approach that all but guarantees more exploitation and danger for women sex workers.

The anti-sex work feminists remind me a lot of the anti-abortion zealots. They don't care what harm is done to women so long as the wicked ones get adequately punished. Likewise anti-sex work zealots don't care what obvious harm the black market sex trade has on women, it's much more important that their moral outrage be codified into law.

The pro-choice but anti-legal-sex work people are taking a rather strange line in my opinion.

Her body her choice... except when we decide we know whats best for her.
 
Close to 1500 posts in this thread, where males discuss with other males, the pros and cons of treating females as non-entities to be literally used as objects for satiating male desires.

Seems like a lot of the "sex works is work" crowd seem to gloss right over the rampant drug use, physical abuse, coercion, and trafficking involved. Lots of people seem to have watched Pretty Woman and think that's a true depiction, and every prostitute is just a "happy hooker" waiting to be swept off their feet.

We'll just ignore the massively increased risk of sexually transmitted illnesses, potential pregnancy, and physical damage endured... all in the name of males feeling entitled to the use of a female's body with no care or consideration for that female as an actual human being.

I've seen comparisons to waiters and plumbers and janitors... but all of you treat employees in those jobs as being whole people. A waiter isn't just a set of feet and hands that brings you your dinner, they're an entire person with whom you'll have a passing discussion and take pains to be kind to them and appreciate their work. A plumber is not just a meatsack for a pipe wrench, but someone who is a whole person and you expect them to have an entire life outside of their job. Even the janitor who cleans your toilets is treated as a complete being with a personality and likes and dislikes, and almost every one of you would be kind and considerate of them.

But "sex workers"... yeah. As much lip service as you might put to it, you're literally paying someone to be nothing more than an object to be used and discarded. At the end of the day, it boils down to "I want to get my rocks off, but I don't want to be hassled with the bother of treating another human like a whole being, I just want to stick my dick in a hole and rock one".

And the crowd that goes around parroting that "Sex work is work" are engaged in a giant lie, an attempt to degrade females and strip them of their fundamental humanity, to place females as subservient to the ever-present desire of males to experience sexual release.

So what is your suggestion?

How should society deal with prostitution?
 
There are pretty much no other jobs you can get paid this well in without training. $50k part freaking time, making your own hours, is no joke. Yet not a soul oh-so-vehemently arguing here has ever considered it. I guess this must be the International Independently Wealthy Skeptics Forum.

When I was young and attractive, I would have jumped at that opportunity. Except that it was illegal. That plus the social stigma precluded that as a viable option for me.
 
When I was young and attractive, I would have jumped at that opportunity. Except that it was illegal. That plus the social stigma precluded that as a viable option for me.

Shoot, when I was young, I couldn't give it away for free. Why would I think anyone would pay for it?
 
I suspect you're just being silly now.

Well, come on. You're not really saying anything. Pretty much any guy has at least considered paying for a prostitute's services, even if only in passing.

So you considered actually being a prostitute? Males servicing females are vanishingly rare here, and the stamina workload would likely limit your potential income anyway. Not a lot of guys plowing down 3 per hour all day long, and all that. So are you saying you considered the, uh, catcher's end of the game? How seriously did you pursue this, or do you mean you "considered" it for like three seconds on the couch one night while watching TV?
 
I've seen comparisons to waiters and plumbers and janitors... but all of you treat employees in those jobs as being whole people. A waiter isn't just a set of feet and hands that brings you your dinner, they're an entire person with whom you'll have a passing discussion and take pains to be kind to them and appreciate their work. A plumber is not just a meatsack for a pipe wrench, but someone who is a whole person and you expect them to have an entire life outside of their job. Even the janitor who cleans your toilets is treated as a complete being with a personality and likes and dislikes, and almost every one of you would be kind and considerate of them.

I'm desperately searching for a portal to EC's fantasy world where workers, especially lower paid service workers, are treated with respect as a matter of course. If anyone finds it please DM me immediately.
 
When I was young and attractive, I would have jumped at that opportunity. Except that it was illegal. That plus the social stigma precluded that as a viable option for me.

Again, a hetero male thinking he is getting a fountain of sex is just another kind of objectifying. The women here, as described to us, are not enjoying this much. So are you talking in terms of being the catcher, that you are not particularly into being? It makes a big difference, here.
 
As someone whose paid job responsibilities have at times included routinely cleaning toilets, I find it amusing when that particular task is used as an example of a demeaning job.

You know they need to be cleaned, and we have proper tools and training to do so, right? Give me fair pay and reasonable hours, I'll get your toilets clean enough for your dog to drink out of, which you know they're going to do anyhow. There is never any doubt in my mind that such a day's work has left the world a better place than if no one had bothered. Other jobs I've been better paid for have often invited such doubt.

I mean, I understand the point being made, that some people are generously suggesting that sex work is no more demeaning than cleaning toilets. But maybe it's a bad idea trying to assign different kinds of work different levels of demeaning-ness in the first place. And maybe some actual sex workers feel the same way.
 
Of course - I mean it's not like we have whole departments that delight in reducing humans to nothing but a resource for a company, imagine the outrage if a company had a department named "Human Resources"!

Old news.

The new term is "Human Capital"

I think it's great how employees have moved from being expendable resources to something the company owns.

The women here, as described to us, are not enjoying this much.

The point may have been missed by the way I described it - the women get very little to zero sexual enjoyment from the sex, but they love their job. They have great camaraderie, a ****-ton of laughs and take what appears to be genuine enjoyment from seeing their regulars. (I'd probably enjoy seeing someone who dropped me a couple of c-notes every time I saw them too)

On the sexual enjoyment angle, a lot of their lack of that is due to not actually wanting to get it from clients. They pretend to orgasm, so why would a guy try? He's had his sexual prowess confirmed. The main object of the job is to get the guy to orgasm asap, so why waste their time letting him have a munch for half an hour?
 
Doing a feminism by encouraging an approach that all but guarantees more exploitation and danger for women sex workers.

The anti-sex work feminists remind me a lot of the anti-abortion zealots. They don't care what harm is done to women so long as the wicked ones get adequately punished. Likewise anti-sex work zealots don't care what obvious harm the black market sex trade has on women, it's much more important that their moral outrage be codified into law.

Wow, this is so completely wrong. But not a surprising "interpretation" from you, and certainly in keeping with your general mind-reading skills.

I suspect I care a hell of a lot more about the harm done to females (and some males) who are prostituted and trafficked than many of you pro-buying-sex folks are. I have exactly zero desire to punish any of the victims of sex trafficking.

On the other hand, I also have no desire to try to white wash it into "just a different kind of work" where we pretend that the 2% of successful OF, Porn, and high class escorts are somehow representative of the entirety of the industry that sells bodies as if they're breathing fleshlights. And I definitely am not willing to just sit idly by while some people misrepresent it as some idyllic lifestyle where a female can totally and easily make it rich with barely any effort at all and no risks worth noting.
 
The pro-choice but anti-legal-sex work people are taking a rather strange line in my opinion.

Her body her choice... except when we decide we know whats best for her.

Yeah, that's where you guys go a bit out of the lane. You present prostitution as if it's "her choice". You dress it up in a Pretty Woman story, where it's totally a completely voluntary and desired "profession". And you ignore or hand-wave away that the vast majority of prostitutes don't want to be there, are frequently addicts - often made addicts at the hands of another, and are pretty regularly abused and raped. And they have no recourse to prosecute their rapists - even in those places where the victims of prostitution aren't criminalized, it's virtually impossible to press charges against a rapist. It's almost impossible to get a rapist prosecuted for females who aren't prostituted; for one who is it's not even an option.
 
I'm desperately searching for a portal to EC's fantasy world where workers, especially lower paid service workers, are treated with respect as a matter of course. If anyone finds it please DM me immediately.

Your kidding yourself if you think that prostitutes are treated with anywhere near the same level of respect as your average service worker.
 
I really really really want a video of Emily's Cat coming here to explain to the workers how they didn't actually chose to do the work they're doing
 
Again Emily's_Cat, I notice that you're still acting like you didn't read anything anyone said.

Please, point to anyone who supported sex trafficking at all. Anyone who agreed with people being forced or pressured into sex work. Anyone who made any of the arguments you're furiously projecting onto people here, in fact?

I'll save you the trouble. You can't. Everyone who has stated that they are fine with sex work has made it very explicit that they only refer to sex work that is safe and voluntary. Please take your strawmen out of here, I'm sure some people have hayfever.
 
No, just notes the actual statistics. The overwhelming majority of prostitutes are female, and the overwhelming majority of the users of prostitutes are male. And the overwhelming majority of participants in this thread are male.

Or you could admit to being wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom