Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
If my options were:

A) lug 80lb bags of concrete all day for $15/hr until my back is so damaged I can barely walk and now I get to see just how ****** the US welfare system is.

OR

B) prostitution for 4 or 5x as much money.

You bet your ass I'd give B a try.

Full credit for being the first in the thread to say this, even though heavily qualified with an unrealisticly harsh sole alternative. Also, push come to shove, are you sure about that? You'd likely be a catcher, not a pitcher, to succeed in that line of work, if you catch my drift.

I think what you are missing is, is that while most people would choose option C (a well-paying job that doesn't practically kill you), a lot of people don't have that option. Secondarily, there are people who would choose B over C. And who are we to judge them for it?

Indeed, and as I've been saying over and over, I don't judge the women for it. As I see it, they are making their own choice. I'm questioning client side motivations and societal impacts. Its like selling alcohol; the seller is not the problem. The users, and wider society has to deal with the fallout. Doesn't make me much of a good thread boogeyman, but ya go with what you got.
 
But all that is just morality, a puritanical quirk that humans have imposed on themselves. Go far enough back in the history of humanity, and what we would call public sex acts were the norm. There are also plenty of things in Society that used to be illegal and would get you arrested if you did them, but which are now legal and accepted - opening your retail or liquor store on a Sunday, dancing in public, playing pinball, criticizing God and the church, and drinking while the polls are open on election day.

Go back in time far enough and we were doing a lot of things that are barbaric and repulsive by modern standards.

I agree with 3point14. Remove the morality and the emotion, and sex workers are simply people who provide a service in return for payment. In this country, we have tried to de-stigmatize and normalize the trade as much as possible. After 20 years, we have made good progress, and IMO we are way ahead of most of the civilized world, but we still have a ways to go.

Remove the morality and emotion and we're not even human anymore.

Although I am glad to hear that it works for you guys. It has failed pretty miserably up here, even where legal.
 
Close to 1500 posts in this thread, where males discuss with other males, the pros and cons of treating females as non-entities to be literally used as objects for satiating male desires.

Seems like a lot of the "sex works is work" crowd seem to gloss right over the rampant drug use, physical abuse, coercion, and trafficking involved. Lots of people seem to have watched Pretty Woman and think that's a true depiction, and every prostitute is just a "happy hooker" waiting to be swept off their feet.

We'll just ignore the massively increased risk of sexually transmitted illnesses, potential pregnancy, and physical damage endured... all in the name of males feeling entitled to the use of a female's body with no care or consideration for that female as an actual human being.

I've seen comparisons to waiters and plumbers and janitors... but all of you treat employees in those jobs as being whole people. A waiter isn't just a set of feet and hands that brings you your dinner, they're an entire person with whom you'll have a passing discussion and take pains to be kind to them and appreciate their work. A plumber is not just a meatsack for a pipe wrench, but someone who is a whole person and you expect them to have an entire life outside of their job. Even the janitor who cleans your toilets is treated as a complete being with a personality and likes and dislikes, and almost every one of you would be kind and considerate of them.

But "sex workers"... yeah. As much lip service as you might put to it, you're literally paying someone to be nothing more than an object to be used and discarded. At the end of the day, it boils down to "I want to get my rocks off, but I don't want to be hassled with the bother of treating another human like a whole being, I just want to stick my dick in a hole and rock one".

And the crowd that goes around parroting that "Sex work is work" are engaged in a giant lie, an attempt to degrade females and strip them of their fundamental humanity, to place females as subservient to the ever-present desire of males to experience sexual release.
 
Full credit for being the first in the thread to say this, even though heavily qualified with an unrealisticly harsh sole alternative. Also, push come to shove, are you sure about that? You'd likely be a catcher, not a pitcher, to succeed in that line of work, if you catch my drift.

Well, I mainly meant, if I was equipped for such work. So to speak. Or for lonely housewives in my area! :rolleyes:

Indeed, and as I've been saying over and over, I don't judge the women for it. As I see it, they are making their own choice. I'm questioning client side motivations and societal impacts. Its like selling alcohol; the seller is not the problem. The users, and wider society has to deal with the fallout. Doesn't make me much of a good thread boogeyman, but ya go with what you got.

Its not really comparable. Alcohol abuse and (some) illegal drugs make people quite anti-social. Well beyond their need for the next fix. There's precautions against STD's and pregnancy that essentially negate a sort of quasi-comparability.

Society really has it backwards. Alcohol should be banned, prostitution should be legal. But we tried that first one and everyone that wanted to ignore the law did it anyways.
 
Last edited:
And the crowd that goes around parroting that "Sex work is work" are engaged in a giant lie, an attempt to degrade females and strip them of their fundamental humanity, to place females as subservient to the ever-present desire of males to experience sexual release.

Utter nonsense, as evinced by women who work in the industry.

I'll grant your ignorance of legal prostitution has probably given you your view on the subject, so thanks for highlighting that.

Wow, it's almost like you haven't actually read what people have written.

100% correct.
 
I would put it slightly differently, sex for some folk can just be an act, for some folk it also carries an emotional component. If you are one of the later than prostitution is not a career for you. I've known plenty of people - not prostitutes - that sex is "just an act", they'll have sex at the drop of ..er a hat with anything with a pulse and not think about any kind of emotional connection. I suppose you could consider those folk "amateur" prostitutes, they don't make a living from it.
And the other thing is that people for whom sex does necessarily include an emotional component tend not to employ the services of prostitutes.
 
There are pretty much no other jobs you can get paid this well in without training. $50k part freaking time, making your own hours, is no joke. Yet not a soul oh-so-vehemently arguing here has ever considered it. I guess this must be the International Independently Wealthy Skeptics Forum.
Except me.
 
Go back in time far enough and we were doing a lot of things that are barbaric and repulsive by modern standards.

STO

Remove the morality and emotion and we're not even human anymore.

Oh, rubbish!!. This is just another one of your all-or-nothing arguments

You can have morals and emotions, and be OK with some things and not with others.

I'm morally opposed to the death penalty, infanticide, suicide and the idea of selective genetic breeding of humans, but I'm morally just fine with legalizing prostitution, abortion and voluntary euthenasia. These are not conflicting positions to hold.

Although I am glad to hear that it works for you guys. It has failed pretty miserably up here, even where legal.

In reality, the USA hasn't really tried all that hard to make it work. You haven't tried the model used in Australia and New Zealand. If you use something like you have in Nevada, where criminal gangs still run the show, its always going to fail out of the gate.
 
Last edited:
Except me.
To be clearer: I have briefly considered it for myself, but decided against it because I am one of those people for whom sex does include an emotional component, but I stand by this post I made last year:

As a parallel from someone who answered the same way but for a different reason, and since my response to the question (which I think is entirely relevant and on-topic, and not bickery) was swept up with the spring cleaning, I say yes, I would be quite happy with a child of mine being a sex worker so long as it is voluntary, legal and safe. If that's the career they choose, I would support them in whatever way I could.
 
NVM, clarified

ETA: I'll ask anyway: arthwollipot, do you mean you considered using the services, or being a provider of them?
 
Last edited:
As a parallel from someone who answered the same way but for a different reason, and since my response to the question (which I think is entirely relevant and on-topic, and not bickery) was swept up with the spring cleaning, I say yes, I would be quite happy with a child of mine being a sex worker so long as it is voluntary, legal and safe. If that's the career they choose, I would support them in whatever way I could.

That's more or less where I land too.

My only real resevations would be

1) that they are kind of person to get emotionally involved when it comes to sex and they'd find the work distressing, but that's probably just me projecting my own sentimentality about such things

and, much more pressingly

2) that whatever local culture we lived in wasn't insanely punitive, either formally or informally, towards sex workers.

Assuming this was a job that they'd be reasonably happy performing (I mean, who really likes their job beyond the paycheck that comes with it) and they weren't treated as some pariah in the community, I wouldn't be rending my garments.
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure you're a valuable member of the [insert corporation name here] team! Didn't you enjoy that pizza lunch a few weeks back :D

Of course - I mean it's not like we have whole departments that delight in reducing humans to nothing but a resource for a company, imagine the outrage if a company had a department named "Human Resources"!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom