Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm guessing the stigma is a decent part of why this work is so lucrative, because there's a large slice of the population which would not consider this work even if it offered a substantially higher standard of living to the viable alternative jobs. If it were really not seen as that big of a deal I suppose the going rates for sex workers would probably drop more in line with the wages of other service jobs.

The stigma giveth and taketh away. If you're someone who truly has no compunctions about sex work and isn't worried about being outed publicly the wage differential makes this a no-brainer decision compared to other hospitality and service work.

If this were true, toilet cleaning and **** shoveling would be lucrative gigs. They are not.

Prostitution is a lucrative gig because many men are willing to pay a premium for putang, full stop. Any stigma falls outside shop hours, like when you tell people what you do for a living.

Eta: re "the no brainer": yet there it is. Kind of what makes me think there are very very few people who compartmentalize the work this way.
 
Last edited:
If this were true, toilet cleaning and **** shoveling would be lucrative gigs. They are not.

If not the stigma, then what explains why sex workers are making so much more than other "general labor" jobs.

Prostitution is a lucrative gig because many men are willing to pay a premium for putang, full stop. Any stigma falls outside shop hours, like when you tell people what you do for a living.

I'm not sure what you mean by this. Sex work is subject to market forces like anything else, the rates are whatever the market will bear depending on the supply of sex workers and the demand of potential clients. Clients would pay less if that's what the market rate was.
 
Last edited:
If this were true, toilet cleaning and **** shoveling would be lucrative gigs. They are not.

Prostitution is a lucrative gig because many men are willing to pay a premium for putang, full stop. Any stigma falls outside shop hours, like when you tell people what you do for a living.

Eta: re "the no brainer": yet there it is. Kind of what makes me think there are very very few people who compartmentalize the work this way.

Lets take that as a given, what does that have to do with legalising and regulating prostitution for the people that do compartmentalize the work that way?
 
Eta: re "the no brainer": yet there it is. Kind of what makes me think there are very very few people who compartmentalize the work this way.

I'm guessing it's really, really hard to parse whether people are wary of sex work because of an internal objection to it rather than the more practical recognition that being a sex worker carries a lot of general stigma.

Like, even if you're 100% cool with the idea of sex work and have no qualms about it in abstract, you still have to know that being a sex worker is going to make you an object of scorn and derision for a pretty big slice of the population, and if you're ever publicly outed as a sex worker, it's probably not going to be possible to escape that reputation even if you quit being a sex worker.

That's what I'm talking about with stigma. Teachers get fired when it's discovered they make side money on OnlyFans, but don't when they're discovered moonlighting as a waitress at Applebees.
Or in worse cases, you get fired for previously being a stripper. Sex work makes you a permanent pariah in at lot of people's eyes.

https://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/2013/05/former_west_ottawa_teacher_who.html
 
Last edited:
Which in a way shows how utterly warped our view of sex is.

"I was trained to overcome the hesitation to kill other people for money" = "You're a glorious example to our youth and should be hailed"

"I did something that harmed noone else and made at least one participant feel really good, maybe even happy" = "You're a vile degenerate and need to be shunned"

As for knowing prostitutes, I probably did, maybe even do. In the Netherlands about 7% of students do escort work and that number seems reasonably stable. With the main draw being that a few nights of work they find at least not horrible they earn more than their peers do working full time next to their studies. Given the number of students I knew during my college years statistics would suggest I met a few.

https://nos.nl/op3/artikel/2148715-student-en-sekswerker-het-verdient-beter-dan-de-jumbo

The link is (obviously) in dutch so you'd need google translate.
It also mentions that even in our quite open society there is still a stigma and that there are also downsides which means it certainly isn't for everyone.

And that is fine, people should be free to choose. Which is still my stance, if someone without coercion decides this is a way they want to make a living, why should someone else's morality forbid this?
 
It shouldn't.

Would I do it? No. Not for any moral reasons, but because it's just not something I would do. Equally I wouldn't work in a care home. In fact I'd rather be a prostitute (assuming it's safe and legal etc etc) than work in a care home. Does that mean I think working in a care home is somehow "different" or something? Nope. It's just something I know I absolutely could not do.

I think Thermal that your claim that 3.14's "not answering the direct question" is an answer in and of itself is absolutely wrong. He's not refusing to answer because he finds sex work different to the things he listed, he's saying that it's exactly the same as the things he listed. No, he wouldn't be a prostitute or a cop or work in crime scene cleanup, but that doesn't mean he thinks there's anything wrong with any of those professions. He just wouldn't do it.

I have a friend who is a sex worker. Not a prostitute but a camgirl. She's safe, she makes decent money and she's happy. Why is that a problem? Why would it be a problem if she decided to also have sex for money instead of just simulating it for paying viewers?
 
I'm guessing it's really, really hard to parse whether people are wary of sex work because of an internal objection to it rather than the more practical recognition that being a sex worker carries a lot of general stigma.

Like, even if you're 100% cool with the idea of sex work and have no qualms about it in abstract, you still have to know that being a sex worker is going to make you an object of scorn and derision for a pretty big slice of the population, and if you're ever publicly outed as a sex worker, it's probably not going to be possible to escape that reputation even if you quit being a sex worker.

Which brings it back front and center: how are we looking at this work, across the culture? Looking at it one on one, a sex worker with a pseudonym and relative anonymity with her client is one thing, but a personally known public figure, especially in a position of authority over children, is another. I don't know if it is stigma so much an appropriate image. It would be weird for your Congressional representative to be running a glory hole in the local club, too, even though it should be nobody's business.

That's what I'm talking about with stigma. Teachers get fired when it's discovered they make side money on OnlyFans, but don't when they're discovered moonlighting as a waitress at Applebees.
Or in worse cases, you get fired for previously being a stripper. Sex work makes you a permanent pariah in at lot of people's eyes.

https://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/2013/05/former_west_ottawa_teacher_who.html

I sort of agree with a teacher running sex work being a problem, because it inevitably becomes a major distraction with the teenage male students. In a better world, that could be compartmentalized, but in this one, libido takes a disproportionate role.
 
Which brings it back front and center: how are we looking at this work, across the culture? Looking at it one on one, a sex worker with a pseudonym and relative anonymity with her client is one thing, but a personally known public figure, especially in a position of authority over children, is another. I don't know if it is stigma so much an appropriate image. It would be weird for your Congressional representative to be running a glory hole in the local club, too, even though it should be nobody's business.



I sort of agree with a teacher running sex work being a problem, because it inevitably becomes a major distraction with the teenage male students. In a better world, that could be compartmentalized, but in this one, libido takes a disproportionate role.

You are aware that teenage female students like sex too right? And watch porn too? And have a libido equal to the male students?
 
Which brings it back front and center: how are we looking at this work, across the culture? Looking at it one on one, a sex worker with a pseudonym and relative anonymity with her client is one thing, but a personally known public figure, especially in a position of authority over children, is another. I don't know if it is stigma so much an appropriate image. It would be weird for your Congressional representative to be running a glory hole in the local club, too, even though it should be nobody's business.

Not sure I agree. My interests as a working person are more in line with a person who is a sex worker than someone who is a landlord or other idle rich, which seems to make up a lot of the current crop of supposed "representatives". I will concede that my live-and-let-attitude about sex work may not be the norm.



I sort of agree with a teacher running sex work being a problem, because it inevitably becomes a major distraction with the teenage male students. In a better world, that could be compartmentalized, but in this one, libido takes a disproportionate role.

I see you didn't comment on the example of the woman fired for previously being a stripper. Zero risk of that being an ongoing distraction, so it seems more transparently about moral opprobrium (those kinds should not be respected teachers) than any practical concern.

I'm not sure I agree with the implied "boys will be boys" defense you're arguing, where the "distraction" would be boy students presumably being unable to control their own behavior. You're basically giving a heckler's veto to children that are in school in no small part to learn socially acceptable behavior, including how to exist in mixed gender company without being a sexist prick.

How much tolerance there is in any given society for boys and men to act like chauvinist pigs is culturally determined, and boys that can't resist the temptation to sexually harass their teachers or other school staff need to be disciplined, not validated by punishing the teacher.

A big part of public schooling is about learning acceptable social skills, which includes acting respectfully around women you think are hot. Better to learn this in the controlled and padded environment of K-12 school than more harshly in adult life.
 
Last edited:
It shouldn't.

Would I do it? No. Not for any moral reasons, but because it's just not something I would do. Equally I wouldn't work in a care home. In fact I'd rather be a prostitute (assuming it's safe and legal etc etc) than work in a care home. Does that mean I think working in a care home is somehow "different" or something? Nope. It's just something I know I absolutely could not do.

I think Thermal that your claim that 3.14's "not answering the direct question" is an answer in and of itself is absolutely wrong. He's not refusing to answer because he finds sex work different to the things he listed, he's saying that it's exactly the same as the things he listed. No, he wouldn't be a prostitute or a cop or work in crime scene cleanup, but that doesn't mean he thinks there's anything wrong with any of those professions. He just wouldn't do it.

I've asked this question a bunch of times. A few posters answer straight, like TG saying he lacks the people skills. Some get very indirect and change the subject. All, though, say "no way Josė, not me", despite what a easy peasy money maker it is ...ahem....laid out to be.

Look at the other jobs posters compare it with: flipping burgers, hauling trash, lugging concrete, grave digging. There's a palpable undercurrent that this is not "respectable" work. As I've said, I'm poking around with that a bit, as I'm not really crazy about it either but I'm not entirely sure why. Sometimes a discussion sheds some light. For me, the "It's just like any other work" thing is falling pretty flat. It's highly unique, compared to other work. I'm sussing out whether it's just "not for me", or if it's "not for most of us", or what.

I have a friend who is a sex worker. Not a prostitute but a camgirl. She's safe, she makes decent money and she's happy. Why is that a problem? Why would it be a problem if she decided to also have sex for money instead of just simulating it for paying viewers?
There's a big difference between any simulation and The Real Thing. Movies, Video Games and paintball were brought up earlier (in a slightly different context). Amongst a group of mature adults, a co-workers OnlyFans page might be treated discretely. It could also be majorly distracting to daily operations with a less refined workforce, much like someone's strong political posturing outside the office might spill over where it is harmful to the workforce.
 
You are aware that teenage female students like sex too right? And watch porn too? And have a libido equal to the male students?

And you are aware that prostitution and OF run at like 90% geared towards servicing males, right? It's not a margin call whether there are more female (and male) sex workers servicing male clientele or not.
 
And you are aware that prostitution and OF run at like 90% geared towards servicing males, right? It's not a margin call whether there are more female (and male) sex workers servicing male clientele or not.

Yes, but knowing a teacher is a prostitute would be equally distracting to the girls as the boys, as both are equally preoccupied with sex, regardless of the above mentioned.
 
Amongst a group of mature adults, a co-workers OnlyFans page might be treated discretely. It could also be majorly distracting to daily operations with a less refined workforce, much like someone's strong political posturing outside the office might spill over where it is harmful to the workforce.

I tend to agree, but I'd point out that you're reversing the blame. I wouldn't blame a cam girl for becoming the object of gossip around the office, I'd blame the workers who don't know how to act like adults in the workplace, and if there was any serious issue, the best way to deal with it without getting your ass sued off would be to discipline the people creating a hostile work environment, not the cam girl.

I recall the first chemical plant I worked at in South Carolina that got a black supervising engineer. A handful of the good ole boy operators couldn't help but say all kinds of racist stuff behind his back, but fortunately for them it never amounted to much more than racist idle chatter. Had it become a problem, you would expect that these racist people creating the issue would be dealt with, rather than a policy of "we don't hire black management, it causes problems" being considered acceptable.

There's probably a wide subset of people, especially men, who hold pretty retrograde notions about sexually promiscuous women, especially sex workers. If that leads them to creating a hostile work environment for a woman colleague it's pretty clear to me who should pay the price for that.
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure they do. You mentioned yourself that there are "indecency laws" that heavily restrict sexual activity. I mean, we have more laws and rules, both written and unwritten, regarding sex than probably any other act in the human experience. Not so for any other activity. You don't get arrested for carrying lumber in public, or get put on a burger flipping offenders list for years, or shunned at family gatherings for ******* the cat at the dinner table. Sex is different, and very objectively, and pretty indisputably.

Bet "prostituting your brain" wouldn't get you arrested if you did so in public. Or on school grounds. Or have to register with a "mental offender registry".

But all that is just morality, a puritanical quirk that humans have imposed on themselves. Go far enough back in the history of humanity, and what we would call public sex acts were the norm. There are also plenty of things in Society that used to be illegal and would get you arrested if you did them, but which are now legal and accepted - opening your retail or liquor store on a Sunday, dancing in public, playing pinball, criticizing God and the church, and drinking while the polls are open on election day.

I agree with 3point14. Remove the morality and the emotion, and sex workers are simply people who provide a service in return for payment. In this country, we have tried to de-stigmatize and normalize the trade as much as possible. After 20 years, we have made good progress, and IMO we are way ahead of most of the civilized world, but we still have a ways to go.
 
Not sure I agree. My interests as a working person are more in line with a person who is a sex worker than someone who is a landlord or other idle rich, which seems to make up a lot of the current crop of supposed "representatives". I will concede that my live-and-let-attitude about sex work may not be the norm.

I see you didn't comment on the example of the woman fired for previously being a stripper. Zero risk of that being an ongoing distraction, so it seems more transparently about moral opprobrium (those kinds should not be respected teachers) than any practical concern.
Strippers do get photographed, and many have whole publicly available work portfolios. At a guess, that's an underlying concern.

I'm not sure I agree with the implied "boys will be boys" defense you're arguing, where the "distraction" would be boy students presumably being unable to control their own behavior. You're basically giving a heckler's veto to children that are in school in no small part to learn socially acceptable behavior, including how to exist in mixed gender company without being a sexist prick.

How much tolerance there is in any given society for boys and men to act like chauvinist pigs is culturally determined, and boys that can't resist the temptation to sexually harass their teachers or other school staff need to be disciplined, not validated by punishing the teacher.

Let's have a bet. Do you think I could produce ten disciplined female teachers with OF or stripper work for every one male you find? Let's not kid ourselves. Sex work is overwhelmingly male clientele and female subjects.

A big part of public schooling is about learning acceptable social skills, which includes acting respectfully around women you think are hot. Better to learn this in the controlled and padded environment of K-12 school than more harshly in adult life.

In a better, more mature world, I'd happily agree. The Kardashians just appeared on a TV nearby in mine.
 
In a better, more mature world, I'd happily agree. The Kardashians just appeared on a TV nearby in mine.

First step to a better world is imposing consequences on bad behavior. Reliably firing people for sexual harassment has done wonders for the culture of the workplace within our lifetimes.
 
Last edited:
I've asked this question a bunch of times. A few posters answer straight, like TG saying he lacks the people skills. Some get very indirect and change the subject. All, though, say "no way Josė, not me", despite what a easy peasy money maker it is ...ahem....laid out to be.

Look at the other jobs posters compare it with: flipping burgers, hauling trash, lugging concrete, grave digging. There's a palpable undercurrent that this is not "respectable" work. As I've said, I'm poking around with that a bit, as I'm not really crazy about it either but I'm not entirely sure why. Sometimes a discussion sheds some light. For me, the "It's just like any other work" thing is falling pretty flat. It's highly unique, compared to other work. I'm sussing out whether it's just "not for me", or if it's "not for most of us", or what.

But those aren't the only things it was compared to. It was also compared to police work and soldiering by 3.14 and care work by me. Your attempt to frame it among only the "less respectable" jobs is highly dishonest even if unintentionally so. It's nothing to do with it being less respectable. I don't think it's less respectable at all, in fact I think it's more respectable than some other things
There's a big difference between any simulation and The Real Thing.
Why?

I don't see a difference beyond the personal choice of those involved.

Unless you're arguing it's morally different, in which case...why?
Movies, Video Games and paintball were brought up earlier (in a slightly different context).

But those are not the same at all. Paintball in particular is simulating killing people. The two are not comparable.
Amongst a group of mature adults, a co-workers OnlyFans page might be treated discretely. It could also be majorly distracting to daily operations with a less refined workforce, much like someone's strong political posturing outside the office might spill over where it is harmful to the workforce.
That's not the fault of the sex worker, that's the fault of their dickhead coworkers.
 
I've asked this question a bunch of times. A few posters answer straight, like TG saying he lacks the people skills. Some get very indirect and change the subject. All, though, say "no way Josė, not me", despite what a easy peasy money maker it is ...ahem....laid out to be.

Look at the other jobs posters compare it with: flipping burgers, hauling trash, lugging concrete, grave digging. There's a palpable undercurrent that this is not "respectable" work. As I've said, I'm poking around with that a bit, as I'm not really crazy about it either but I'm not entirely sure why. Sometimes a discussion sheds some light. For me, the "It's just like any other work" thing is falling pretty flat. It's highly unique, compared to other work. I'm sussing out whether it's just "not for me", or if it's "not for most of us", or what.

If my options were:

A) lug 80lb bags of concrete all day for $15/hr until my back is so damaged I can barely walk and now I get to see just how ****** the US welfare system is.

OR

B) prostitution for 4 or 5x as much money.

You bet your ass I'd give B a try.

I think what you are missing is, is that while most people would choose option C (a well-paying job that doesn't practically kill you), a lot of people don't have that option. Secondarily, there are people who would choose B over C. And who are we to judge them for it?
 
Last edited:
If my options were:

A) lug 80lb bags of concrete all day for $15/hr until my back is so damaged I can barely walk and now I get to see just how ****** the US welfare system is.

OR

B) prostitution for 4 or 5x as much money.

You bet your ass I'd give B a try.

I think what you are missing is, is that while most people would choose option C (a well-paying job that doesn't practically kill you), a lot of people don't have that option. Secondarily, there are people who would choose B over C. And who are we to judge them for it?

:bigclap
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom