Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not sure I understand why you think the US blackmarket sex trade is special in any way. I assume it's just as sordid as any other place where sex work is done illegally.

I don't. Which is why I didn't say that. Feels like I need to keep.qualifying that I have an American POV when we are going back and forth between the models. I don't want it to seem.like my impression of American sex work is directed at the New Zealanders model.

I agree it's sad that some people can't (or feel they can't) attract a romantic partner in their life for various reasons. Not sure how them visiting sex workers or not really changes the sadness of their intense loneliness. Seems like a pitiable lot in life regardless. Can't imagine visiting a sex worker occasionally does a whole lot to mitigate the sting of being perpetually lonely, I recall the stories of incels that discover that getting laid doesn't actually solve all their problems in life. (not implying that all lonely people visiting brothels are ardent incel ideologues, it's just a handy example)

Example understood. Yeah, incels have a global outlook problem, more than a getting lucky tonight problem. But legalizing sex work seems to validate their sick outlook. "Yes, women are rentable objects for your sexual gratification. This has our legal stamp of approval". I have a rough time getting past that. Vulgar though I may come off, I actually respect women. A lot.

I'm not sure I understand what's vague about the comparison. Less exploitation and violence seems unambiguously better, even if such schemes fail to achieve a perfect track record. Or do you doubt whether legalizing the sex trade results in less bad outcomes?

I'm on record here favoring decriminalization at the least, but a little ambivalent about full.on legalization. Earlier in the thread, I jeopardized my browser history and looked into NZ and Oz brothels with websites. They seemed entirely like our massage parlors and escort services. Very very much advertising the women like you would a rental car, as opposed to the more refined and rational service exchange being touted here. It looks (admittedly from a distance) like a meat market. Maybe that whole angle just skeebs me out too much. I mean, you can get a forever squeeze or date a different lady every night, but she's a woman, a real human being, not a freaking fleshlight.
 
Last edited:
Example understood. Yeah, incels have a global outlook problem, more than a getting lucky tonight problem. But legalizing sex work seems to validate their sick outlook. "Yes, women are rentable objects for your sexual gratification. This has our legal stamp of approval". I have a rough time getting past that. Vulgar though I may come off, I actually respect women. A lot.

I get the impression that these legitimated brothels have pretty unforgiving codes of conduct for clients, and any incel who didn't know how to mind their manners with a sex worker would quickly be shown the door. Incels often have visible stink lines of misogyny coming off them that most women can clock right away. If they can't act like a half-decent human being I doubt they're going to have a good time.


I'm on record here favoring decriminalization at the least, but a little ambivalent about full.on legalization. Earlier in the thread, I jeopardized my browser history and looked into NZ and Oz brothels with websites. They seemed entirely like our massage parlors and escort services. Very very much advertising the women like you would a rental car, as opposed to the more refined and rational service exchange being touted here. It looks (admittedly from a distance) like a meat market. Maybe that whole angle just seems me out too much. I mean, you can get a forever squeeze or date a different moment every night, but she's a woman, a real human being, not a freaking fleshlight.

Your objection seems mostly aesthetic. The huge difference I can think of compared to your old fashioned craigslist listing is that, in NZ or Aus, you can be reasonably certain the sex worker isn't being coerced by some pimp, isn't some sex trafficked foreigner or runaway teen, and generally is in a pretty square, less-exploitative (as much as that is possible selling your labor) business arrangement. I likewise share your aversion to the idea of buying sex, but you have to admit that the difference in approaches alleviates huge ethical issues that come with the opaqueness of the blackmarket sex trade.
 
Last edited:
I get the impression that these legitimated brothels have pretty unforgiving codes of conduct for clients, and any incel who didn't know how to mind their manners with a sex worker would quickly be shown the door. Incels often have visible stink lines of misogyny coming off them that most women can clock right away. If they can't act like a half-decent human being I doubt they're going to have a good time.




Your objection seems mostly aesthetic. The huge difference I can think of compared to your old fashioned craigslist listing is that, in NZ or Aus, you can be reasonably certain the sex worker isn't being coerced by some pimp, isn't some sex trafficked foreigner or runaway teen, and generally is in a pretty square, less-exploitative (as much as that is possible selling your labor) business arrangement. I likewise share your aversion to the idea of buying sex, but you have to admit that the difference in approaches alleviates huge ethical issues that come with the opaqueness of the blackmarket sex trade.

Yeah, I guess that's ultimately where I gotta land, too. Everyone alive and safe first, and be resigned to the less exploitive alternative but not cheering for it.
 
Almost everyone is a rentable object.

Here in the States we actually have a Constitutional Amendment limiting that.

You just think sex is special. Others don't.

Everything is special. You're special. I'm special. Sex is special.

Do you mean that I think there are special circumstances around sex that make it less comparable to employment? Yeah, I kinda do. Go have sex on your office desk during the workday. See how Security likes it. Offer sex for money to your secretary and let me know how it works out for you.

Too employment specific? Ok. Have yourself some sex in any old public place. Offer some to the paperboy. Tell your wife you'd like to nail her sister. Or brother. Or both. Or their German Shepherd. Hell, just go whip it out and whack off in a restaurant for some solo sex if you like. Then come back and tell me how out in left field my views are.
 
Last edited:
Here in the States we actually have a Constitutional Amendment limiting that.

Against paying people to do stuff for you? Tough legislation.



Everything is special. You're special. I'm special. Sex is special.

Not sure how that's relevant?


Do you mean that I think there are special circumstances around sex that make it less comparable to employment? Yeah, I kinda do. Go have sex on your office desk during the workday. See how Security likes it. Offer sex for money to your secretary and let me know how it works out for you.

Sure, there are public decency laws. And lots of things you can't do at your desk that you can do at home. The fact, however, remains, that some people think sex is a leisure actvity, others think it's a commodity (often those in the higher reaches of society) and others think that it's a sin. You think it has a special place, so you are entirely at liberty to treat it as a special thing. I don't think you're allowed to impose your 'sex is special' view on those who view it otherwise.


Too employment specific? Ok. Have yourself some sex in any old public place. Offer some to the paperboy. Tell your wife you'd like to nail her sister. Or brother. Or both. Or their German Shepherd. Hell, just go whip it out and whack off in a restaurant for some solo sex if you like. Then come back and tell me how out in left field my views are.

I'm not at all saying that your ideas are left field. I'm not even saying they're wrong. I'm saying that others have a different view to you and you don't get to decide that sex is special for everyone just because it's special for you.
 
Against paying people to do stuff for you? Tough legislation.

It should be pointed out that the US Constitution says nothing about prostitution, and it was commonly legal or laws just not really enforced until like the 1950's in the USA. And federally only taking women across state lines for the purpose of prostition is illegal, and that law was due to a white-slavery fear thing.
 
Last edited:
Against paying people to do stuff for you? Tough legislation.

Big chasm between paying someone to do something for you and being a rentable object. People, for instance, are only in the most pedantic sense "objects".

Not sure how that's relevant?

You asserted that I think sex is special. It is. Not sure how your initial assertion is relevant, if we're being honest here.

Sure, there are public decency laws. And lots of things you can't do at your desk that you can do at home. The fact, however, remains, that some people think sex is a leisure actvity, others think it's a commodity (often those in the higher reaches of society) and others think that it's a sin. You think it has a special place, so you are entirely at liberty to treat it as a special thing. I don't think you're allowed to impose your 'sex is special' view on those who view it otherwise.

I'm not at all saying that your ideas are left field. I'm not even saying they're wrong. I'm saying that others have a different view to you and you don't get to decide that sex is special for everyone just because it's special for you.

Ok, it's time for the Challenge Round!

Look back on my postings. See anything missing? That's right, what's missing is me telling anyone else how to look at sex, or how "special" it should be for them, or in fact trying to impose my views at all on anyone anywhere at any time. Christ, I've been agreeing that legalization is a good thing if it keeps bodies safer, even if (like with the needle exchange program) I'm not a fan of the activity it makes safer.

Really don't know why you're telling me not to impose my views when I am not by any stretch imposing them, or suggesting I should be able to. If a poster says something slobberingly stupid like "selling sex is no different from flipping burgers" or "street fighting is actually legal", there's-a-gonna be pushback. But my views are no more than my opinions.

ETA: opinions that I might explain and justify with my reasons,but it doesn't mean anyone else has to accept them. I ask only that arguers understand where I'm coming from and why
 
Last edited:
It should be pointed out that the US Constitution says nothing about prostitution, and it was commonly legal or laws just not really enforced until like the 1950's in the USA. And federally only taking women across state lines for the purpose of prostition is illegal, and that law was due to a white-slavery fear thing.

I was quibbling more on the "object" thingy, in the sense of property
 
Is the language we use the biggest problem facing the legal sex industry worldwide? No. It is not. There are much bigger problems.

Can we help by improving the quality of the language that we do use? Yes, absolutely.
 
I remain curious how easy it would be for a novice would-be sex worker to enter the professionalized brothel business in these places where it's a regulated, above-board industry. It's my hunch that it's really not that easy to make a lucrative living this way, and those that do have a special set of interpersonal skills that accounts for their success (much like any other fancy and well paid hospitality gig).

It's actually very easy.

Some years ago, a woman of 19 I was friends with asked about joining the brothel and started work there. I even came up with her work name of Naughty Natasha, which she advertised under.

Training consisted of a couple of hours with the experienced girls who filled her in on the mechanics of the job - lube usage, never letting a client stay in her for more than 7 or 8 minutes (and how to make sure he didn't go longer), always having a shower with the guy first to make sure he was clean, etc, and she was straight onto her back and raking in the money.

She was making as much as the others within a couple of weeks. She was only reasonably attractive but with a very hot bod.

Interpersonal skills bring them regular work, but if they don't mind a constantly-changing clientele they won't make a lot less.

The Atheist, any thoughts based on your acquaintances with those in the professional, legal sex work biz? Is this easy money for any moderately attractive woman willing to deal with the stigma, or is it more difficult than some presume?

The only difficult part is recognising the sex is just an act. That's something they find out in very short order and those who do stay and those who don't go back to working in an office for 1/3 of the money or less.
 
...snip...

The only difficult part is recognising the sex is just an act. That's something they find out in very short order and those who do stay and those who don't go back to working in an office for 1/3 of the money or less.

I would put it slightly differently, sex for some folk can just be an act, for some folk it also carries an emotional component. If you are one of the later than prostitution is not a career for you. I've known plenty of people - not prostitutes - that sex is "just an act", they'll have sex at the drop of ..er a hat with anything with a pulse and not think about any kind of emotional connection. I suppose you could consider those folk "amateur" prostitutes, they don't make a living from it.
 
Last edited:
Big chasm between paying someone to do something for you and being a rentable object. People, for instance, are only in the most pedantic sense "objects".

This is my point. You referred to the women working in prostitution as:

rentable objects for your sexual gratification.

They're your words not mine. You just think it's somehow that renting out your body for sex makes you a 'rentable object' and renting out your body for manual labour does not. Others don't see the difference.

I accept you're not advocating for anything.
 
This is my point. You referred to the women working in prostitution as:

They're your words not mine.

No, I don't refer to the women that way. I was hyperbolically saying that it is the message to an incel. Pretty sure I have pretty clearly gone to lengths saying I'm not crazy about objectifying women.

You just think it's somehow that renting out your body for sex makes you a 'rentable object' and renting out your body for manual labour does not. Others don't see the difference.

Pretty sure they do. You mentioned yourself that there are "indecency laws" that heavily restrict sexual activity. I mean, we have more laws and rules, both written and unwritten, regarding sex than probably any other act in the human experience. Not so for any other activity. You don't get arrested for carrying lumber in public, or get put on a burger flipping offenders list for years, or shunned at family gatherings for ******* the cat at the dinner table. Sex is different, and very objectively, and pretty indisputably. The thing we have going on in this thread is a weird double standard, where a bunch of posters want to say it's no big deal out of one side of their mouths, while acknowledging it's a big fat hairy deal out of the other.

Let me ask you something, if you don't mind. Do you ever prostitute yourself? I mean, since it's no big deal and all. Stellar money I'm told. So do you, or are you like everyone else on the thread who suddenly finds it's a big deal when applied to them, personally?
 
No, I don't refer to the women that way. I was hyperbolically saying that it is the message to an incel. Pretty sure I have pretty clearly gone to lengths saying I'm not crazy about objectifying women.

Yeah, but that's the impression I garnered from your writing, that you think that prostitution is somehow different to, for instance, manual work. All I'm trying to say is that, for some, for many, perhaps, it isn't, it's the same thing.


Pretty sure they do. You mentioned yourself that there are "indecency laws" that heavily restrict sexual activity. I mean, we have more laws and rules, both written and unwritten, regarding sex than probably any other act in the human experience. Not so for any other activity. You don't get arrested for carrying lumber in public, or get put on a burger flipping offenders list for years, or shunned at family gatherings for ******* the cat at the dinner table. Sex is different, and very objectively, and pretty indisputably. The thing we have going on in this thread is a weird double standard, where a bunch of posters want to say it's no big deal out of one side of their mouths, while acknowledging it's a big fat hairy deal out of the other.

I'm saying it's down to the individual to decide if it's a big deal or not. It's a big deal for you, it's not a big deal for others.

Let me ask you something, if you don't mind. Do you ever prostitute yourself? I mean, since it's no big deal and all. Stellar money I'm told. So do you, or are you like everyone else on the thread who suddenly finds it's a big deal when applied to them, personally?

Well, messing with semantics, I prostitute myself every day, I just sell my brain not my genitals.


To be less flippant, there's a lot of jobs that other people do that I wouldn't or couldn't. I couldn't be a policeman - others feel it's their calling. I couldn't work in a sewer or be a vet - other people do these jobs. I can go on and on with stuff I wouldn't or couldn't do that others can, soldiering, working an an abattoir, cleaning services for murder scenes, nursing, anything involving confined spaces. I'm not about to say that these jobs shouldn't exist because I'm not prepared to do them.

I don't think 'you wouldn't do it, so nobody should' is the slam-dunk argument you think it is.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but that's the impression I garnered from your writing, that you think that prostitution is somehow different to, for instance, manual work. All I'm trying to say is that, for some, for many, perhaps, it isn't, it's the same thing.

Bet "prostituting your brain" wouldn't get you arrested if you did so in public. Or on school grounds. Or have to register with a "mental offender registry".

I'll bet, as I keep saying, that it is objectively and pretty indisputably very very different.

I'm saying it's down to the individual to decide if it's a big deal or not. It's a big deal for you, it's not a big deal for others.

Well, messing with semantics, I prostitute myself every day, I just sell my brain not my genitals.

To be less flippant, there's a lot of jobs that other people do that I wouldn't or couldn't. I couldn't be a policeman - others feel it's their calling. I couldn't work in a sewer or be a vet - other people do these jobs. I can go on and on with stuff I wouldn't or couldn't do that others can, soldiering, working an an abattoir, cleaning services for murder scenes, nursing, anything involving confined spaces. I'm not about to say that these jobs shouldn't exist because I'm not prepared to do them.

I don't think 'you wouldn't do it, so nobody should' is the slam-dunk argument you think it is.

Notice how you didn't answer the straightforward question at all? You talked all about other jobs you wouldn't or couldn't do and why, but avoided the **** out of the one I asked about.

A simple "no, I dislike strangers touching me", or a hundred other short responses, would have been a direct and complete response. I don't even know if you have or haven't now, much less the "why/not?" which is obviously the meatier part. Doesn't matter though. The way you (non) answered was answer enough.

"No, I never did/would work as a prostitute" is the obvious answer for pretty much everyone here. Also, "hell no I wouldn't suggest it to my kids as an alternative to flipping burgers as a college job" is right in there too. The "why not" is the interesting part.

There are pretty much no other jobs you can get paid this well in without training. $50k part freaking time, making your own hours, is no joke. Yet not a soul oh-so-vehemently arguing here has ever considered it. I guess this must be the International Independently Wealthy Skeptics Forum.
 
Bet "prostituting your brain" wouldn't get you arrested if you did so in public. Or on school grounds. Or have to register with a "mental offender registry".

I'll bet, as I keep saying, that it is objectively and pretty indisputably very very different.



Notice how you didn't answer the straightforward question at all? You talked all about other jobs you wouldn't or couldn't do and why, but avoided the **** out of the one I asked about.

Yeah, I did.

A simple "no, I dislike strangers touching me", or a hundred other short responses, would have been a direct and complete response. I don't even know if you have or haven't now, much less the "why/not?" which is obviously the meatier part. Doesn't matter though. The way you (non) answered was answer enough.

"No, I never did/would work as a prostitute" is the obvious answer for pretty much everyone here. Also, "hell no I wouldn't suggest it to my kids as an alternative to flipping burgers as a college job" is right in there too. The "why not" is the interesting part.

There are pretty much no other jobs you can get paid this well in without training. $50k part freaking time, making your own hours, is no joke. Yet not a soul oh-so-vehemently arguing here has ever considered it. I guess this must be the International Independently Wealthy Skeptics Forum.

I'm just trying to impress upon you that the views that you have are not the views that everyone else has. That's all. but I appear to be failing.

I think you're really not getting what I'm saying at all. Partly because I may be expressing myself badly and partly because this is clearly a very emotive issue for you and you don't want to. Probably more the former than the latter, so I'm going to tiptoe slowly away.
 
Last edited:
There are pretty much no other jobs you can get paid this well in without training. $50k part freaking time, making your own hours, is no joke. Yet not a soul oh-so-vehemently arguing here has ever considered it. I guess this must be the International Independently Wealthy Skeptics Forum.

I'm guessing the stigma is a decent part of why this work is so lucrative, because there's a large slice of the population which would not consider this work even if it offered a substantially higher standard of living to the viable alternative jobs. If it were really not seen as that big of a deal I suppose the going rates for sex workers would probably drop more in line with the wages of other service jobs.

The stigma giveth and taketh away. If you're someone who truly has no compunctions about sex work and isn't worried about being outed publicly the wage differential makes this a no-brainer decision compared to other hospitality and service work.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom