Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Given the content of the OP, do those opposed to legal prostitution believe that those ladies discussed in the OP, assuming accurate reporting, just don't know their own minds and that they simply need a little help in understanding that they just don't have the information, uppringing or intelligence to make an informed decision about what they want..?
 
I have no idea where "here" is supposed to be.

Try reading the OP... http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=13866959&postcount=1

TheAtheist is posting from New Zealand- the same country as me.

So, "here" is New Zealand, a country that has legalized Prostitution, where the vast majority of sex workers CHOOSE to do what they do, where..

- they can be employed at a registered Brothel, or go into business for themselves - no pimps!!!!
- they can work legitimately, within the law including paying income taxes*
- they are entitled to ACC benefits*
- they can make Kiwisaver contributions*
- are eligible for subsidized medical care*
- can get private health insurance (without having to lie on their application)*
- the Police don't arrest them, they protect them!

* like any other regular employee

On the very rare occasions when there has been any kind or trafficking of girls over the past 20 years, the trafficker has been caught almost immediately. Why? Because other sex-workers are no longer afraid to report illegal operations to the Police.
‎
‎
 
Last edited:
Given the content of the OP, do those opposed to legal prostitution believe that those ladies discussed in the OP, assuming accurate reporting, just don't know their own minds and that they simply need a little help in understanding that they just don't have the information, uppringing or intelligence to make an informed decision about what they want..?

They need a man to mansplain to them that what they are doing is morally repugnant... I guess?
 
Fishing for sugar daddies must be a competitive industry. I bet a lot of women would opt out, if you offered them a universal income.

That's probably true for a lot of jobs. Universal basic income would probably require a lot of not very fun jobs to radically improve their compensation and/or work conditions if they no longer had a ready supply of desperately impoverished people to draw from. "Take this job or starve" is the implied threat that is the foundation of many lousy jobs. Ideally UBI would radically change this dynamic and give previously poverty wage workers much more practical ability to turn down undignified, underpaid, or otherwise unacceptable work.
 
Last edited:
You consider your regulation to be practical?!

Yes, hence why I tried to clarify how I think prostitution should be regulated.
I know you disagree, you've made that clear.

So again, what policies do you think should be in place to create the situation you want?
 
I bet quite a few would, but the existence of sites like Onlyfans, /r/GoneWild, PornHub Creators and the many, many, many livestreaming sites suggests that there will always be people who will voluntarily **** for money. The industry would not... er... dry up... because of a UBI, especially if the work is suitably incentivised, which it will.

So much stigmatising language being thrown about in this thread. Sucking dick for money. Johns.

It's like you honestly don't hear yourself. "**** for money" has the arthwollipot stamp of approval, but "suck dick for money" is a moral shortcoming for others to use? I mean seriously, man.

You wonder why sex work is still stigmatised?

I do not.

Language is one reason.We don't refer to plumbers as **** pushers. Why do we refer to sex workers as dick suckers and pussy sellers?

Speak for yourself. No, wait: I refer to them as far worse.

For most of my work history, I was a carpenter, then a carpentry contractor, and now more of a general contractor. I referred to myself and others as "nail bangers" on occasion, not to be depreciating, but simply as playful crudeity. When a **** job needs to be done, I appoint a "**** boy" to do it, often myself. My wife picked up on it and will sometimes call me the "**** boy" when she wants me to do a dirty job.

So what's the upshot of all that? A lot of us express ourselves in blunt, crude and colorful language. All.The.Time. Euphemisms are solely for the dishonest. So if you think it's fine to say a woman ***** for money, but are offended by saying she sucks for money, you might wanna dismount that high horse and have a bout of introspection.
 
It's like you honestly don't hear yourself. "**** for money" has the arthwollipot stamp of approval, but "suck dick for money" is a moral shortcoming for others to use? I mean seriously, man.



I do not.



Speak for yourself. No, wait: I refer to them as far worse.

For most of my work history, I was a carpenter, then a carpentry contractor, and now more of a general contractor. I referred to myself and others as "nail bangers" on occasion, not to be depreciating, but simply as playful crudeity. When a **** job needs to be done, I appoint a "**** boy" to do it, often myself. My wife picked up on it and will sometimes call me the "**** boy" when she wants me to do a dirty job.

So what's the upshot of all that? A lot of us express ourselves in blunt, crude and colorful language. All.The.Time. Euphemisms are solely for the dishonest. So if you think it's fine to say a woman ***** for money, but are offended by saying she sucks for money, you might wanna dismount that high horse and have a bout of introspection.

People are generally able to pick up the subtle nuances of an insulting term used with friendly intent and one meant with animus, though there's always the risk of overstepping with such things.

For example, it's quite clear to me you're using these stigmatized terms for sex work with a derogatory intent.

Your focusing on oral sex speaks more to your own discomfort with female sexuality, and the whole thing smacks of "Madonna-whore complex" than anything else, but that's getting way off topic.
 
Last edited:
And here is where we see what it looks like when someone doubles, triples, and quadruples down on stigmatisation.

That's exactly what it is. Why use a vulgar euphemism?

"John" is a vulgar euphemism? While it's a somewhat outdated descriptor, it's one that prostitutes used to use themselves. IIRC, they coined the term.

The industry. You could call it a trade. Not all sex workers suck cock for money, and not all of the work of those that do consists of sucking cock. Not only are you assuming, you are stereotyping, and using the worst possible description of the profession,which if nothing else ensures that your readers are left in no doubt about your attitude towards sex workers. So thanks for sending that clear signal, at least.

Damn brah. If you think that's the worst possible description of that work, I need to take you for a night out. Even to my imaginings, that would actually be one of the more genteel and common servicings.

We call them sex workers because it is an accurate description of what they do. Not all sex workers are prostitutes. Porn performers are sex workers. Lap dancers are sex workers. Writers of erotic fiction are sex workers. Would it surprise you to learn that we have had sex workers as regular posters here at this very forum?

Now it's getting ridiculous. No, a writer is not a "sex worker" any more than a waitress who shows a little cleavage is. For that matter, am I a sex worker if I wipe the blood off my face to flirt with a customer? Is my daughter who waited tables a sex worker in your eyes if she was flirted with by a resteraunt patron?
 
Last edited:
People are generally able to pick up the subtle nuances of an insulting term used with friendly intent and one meant with animus, though there's always the risk of overstepping with such things.

For example, it's quite clear to me you're using these stigmatized terms for sex work with a derogatory intent.

Your focusing on oral sex speaks more to your own discomfort with female sexuality, and the whole thing smacks of "Madonna-whore complex" than anything else, but that's getting way off topic.

Look at any of my posting history. I use crude, colorful, and hyperbolic language on virtually any topic. If you translate it here as uniquely derogatory, you're tipping your own hand.

Eta: as I keep saying, I dislike euphemisms. You know what my Municipal Sanitation Engineers call themselves? The Trash Men. Because, like me, they are not ashamed of what they do and feel no compulsion to put on phony airs. Being blunt keeps you grounded.
 
Last edited:
Look at any of my posting history. I use crude, colorful, and hyperbolic language on virtually any topic. If you translate it here as uniquely derogatory, you're tipping your own hand.

Do you describe your own romantic partners as the piece of ass that sucks and ***** back at your place, or is that only reserved for women engaged in sexual activity you don't approve of?

If you'd describe your own partners as a cum dumpster then I guess you have a point about it just being the Thermal house style ;)

Strikes me as crass, but there's no accounting for taste.
 
Last edited:
I still want to know why those actual prostitutes discussed in the OP are wrong about their own job.
 
I remain curious how easy it would be for a novice would-be sex worker to enter the professionalized brothel business in these places where it's a regulated, above-board industry. It's my hunch that it's really not that easy to make a lucrative living this way, and those that do have a special set of interpersonal skills that accounts for their success (much like any other fancy and well paid hospitality gig).

The Atheist, any thoughts based on your acquaintances with those in the professional, legal sex work biz? Is this easy money for any moderately attractive woman willing to deal with the stigma, or is it more difficult than some presume?
 
Last edited:
Do you describe your own romantic partners as the piece of ass that sucks and ***** back at your place, or is that only reserved for women engaged in sexual activity you don't approve of?

If you'd describe your own partners as a cum dumpster then I guess you have a point about it just being the Thermal house style ;)

Strikes me as crass, but there's no accounting for taste.

Genuine lol, took me a bit to stop laughing

But to your point: again, look at my postings. Never ever not even once do I refer to them as cum dumpsters, pieces of ass, or even whores. NEVER. I call them prostitutes, sex workers, and occasionally hookers (which I am told they refer to themselves as by our Kiwi correspondent). Your assumptions about me judging the workers are dead wrong. My interest in this thread all along has been client side.
 
Are they?

That's the general impression I get from some of the posters here.

Absent some other compelling argument, I'm happy to take the word of those that employed in safe, well regulated prostitution that they want it to stay that way. Others seem to think that prostitution is a de facto bad thing. I'd like to know why the workers in the OP are mistaken about their own lives.
 
Last edited:
Look at any of my posting history. I use crude, colorful, and hyperbolic language on virtually any topic. If you translate it here as uniquely derogatory, you're tipping your own hand.

Eta: as I keep saying, I dislike euphemisms. You know what my Municipal Sanitation Engineers call themselves? The Trash Men. Because, like me, they are not ashamed of what they do and feel no compulsion to put on phony airs. Being blunt keeps you grounded.
This is why you're one of my favorite posters. Particularly the ETA.

It's surreal when pearl clutchers use more or less the same terminology as you. Go figure.
 
That's the general impression I get from some of the posters here.

Absent some other compelling argument, I'm happy to take the word of those that employed in safe, well regulated prostitution that they want it to stay that way. Others seem to think that prostitution is a de facto bad thing. I'd like to know why the workers in the OP are mistaken about their own lives.

Can't speak for others, but I'm on board with anyone having safer conditions. Kind of like the needle exchange program- if it's going to happen, let's keep the participants alive and healthy. Better for them individually, and better for society.

From the States, though, prostitution is such a sordid gig that the very idea of a clean and fun version sounds like legalizing heroin. "It's a great time, y'all, now that it's legal and regulated!" It sounds like it would be a good arrangement for some, but the majority are still susceptible to the problem aspects.

The Athiest and smartcooky have given their observations about workers they know. Sounds like the ladies are doing pretty well for themselves, yeah? But then we hear about the sad sacks that are their clients, and how the women consider themselves the ones taking advantage of the men. Thats...I dunno...kind of sad to me. I got lucky in marrying a wonderful woman. It's kind of disheartening to hear about guys who sound like they have literally given up.

And then we trot out the statistics and news stories. Something like 90% of NZ prostitutes still report being raped and otherwise assaulted at work. Children are still slipping through the cracks in the trade. At some point, I feel like we have to weigh this out: is legally sanctioning this gig a net plus or minus? I'm not sure.
 
Last edited:
Can't speak for others, but I'm on board with anyone having safer conditions. Kind of like the needle exchange program- if it's going to happen, let's keep the participants alive and healthy. Better for them individually, and better for society.

From the States, though, prostitution is such a sordid gig that the very idea of a clean and fun version sounds like legalizing heroin. "It's a great time, y'all, now that it's legal and regulated!" It sounds like it would be a good arrangement for some, but the majority are still susceptible to the problem aspects.

Not sure I understand why you think the US blackmarket sex trade is special in any way. I assume it's just as sordid as any other place where sex work is done illegally.

The Athiest and smartcooky have given their observations about workers they know. Sounds like the ladies are doing pretty well for themselves, yeah? But then we hear about the sad sacks that are their clients, and how the women consider themselves the ones taking advantage of the men. Thats...I dunno...kind of sad to me. I got lucky in marrying a wonderful woman. It's kind of disheartening to hear about guys who sound like they have literally given up.

I agree it's sad that some people can't (or feel they can't) attract a romantic partner in their life for various reasons. Not sure how them visiting sex workers or not really changes the sadness of their intense loneliness. Seems like a pitiable lot in life regardless. Can't imagine visiting a sex worker occasionally does a whole lot to mitigate the sting of being perpetually lonely, I recall the stories of incels that discover that getting laid doesn't actually solve all their problems in life. (not implying that all lonely people visiting brothels are ardent incel ideologues, it's just a handy example)

And then we trot out the statistics and news stories. Something like 90% of NZ prostitutes still report being raped and otherwise assaulted at work. Children are still slipping through the cracks in the trade. At some point, I feel like we have to weigh this out: is legally sanctioning this gig a net plus or minus? I'm not sure.

I'm not sure I understand what's vague about the comparison. Less exploitation and violence seems unambiguously better, even if such schemes fail to achieve a perfect track record. Or do you doubt whether legalizing the sex trade results in less bad outcomes?
 
Last edited:
Can't speak for others, but I'm on board with anyone having safer conditions. Kind of like the needle exchange program- if it's going to happen, let's keep the participants alive and healthy. Better for them individually, and better for society.

From the States, though, prostitution is such a sordid gig that the very idea of a clean and fun version sounds like legalizing heroin. "It's a great time, y'all, now that it's legal and regulated!" It sounds like it would be a good arrangement for some, but the majority are still susceptible to the problem aspects.

The Athiest and smartcooky have given their observations about workers they know. Sounds like the ladies are doing pretty well for themselves, yeah? But then we hear about the sad sacks that are their clients, and how the women consider themselves the ones taking advantage of the men. Thats...I dunno...kind of sad to me. I got lucky in marrying a wonderful woman. It's kind of disheartening to hear about guys who sound like they have literally given up.

Genuine thanks for a considered and well thought out response.

And then we trot out the statistics and news stories. Something like 90% of NZ prostitutes still report being raped and otherwise assaulted at work. Children are still slipping through the cracks in the trade. At some point, I feel like we have to weigh this out: is legally sanctioning this gig a net plus or minus? I'm not sure.

I see what you're saying, but I don't believe the problems you describe would be lessened by the trade being outlawed and would only be expanded. It may be that more regulation or oversight is needed, but I can't see how the problems you describe would be lessened by making the transaction an illegal one rather than a regulated legal one.
 
I see what you're saying, but I don't believe the problems you describe would be lessened by the trade being outlawed and would only be expanded. It may be that more regulation or oversight is needed, but I can't see how the problems you describe would be lessened by making the transaction an illegal one rather than a regulated legal one.

Often in places that still outlaw sex work, there's an acknowledgment that focusing enforcement on the sex workers themselves only increases the sketchiness of the black market sex trade, and often an intermediate harm mitigation strategy is to focus law enforcement primarily on traffickers, pimps, and clients rather than arresting sex workers.

That said, full decriminalization and regulation seems obviously the much more effective strategy to drag this industry into daylight and clean it up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom