Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
I bet a lot of women would opt out, if you offered them a universal income.

And I'll tell you that a lot of them would not. In most cases, they will take the UBI, and still do the work.

The few that I know personally (not professionally of course) earn between NZ$2½K and NZ$3K per week. One of them owns a NZ$1.5 million home in Brittania Heights (on the Port Hills), another, a million dollar home in Brougham Street - both are among richest neighbourhoods in Nelson. In one case, the house is freehold, in the other case its all but. The woman who owns the Brougham Street house has been in the game since she quit her job as a chartered accountant at the age of 28. Within three years she bought the house, and now four years later she has all but paid it off. Very few people clear a mortgage on a million dollar house in less than eight years and by the time they are 36!
 
= PC euphemism for john. Makes it sound just like an ordinary customer buying the services of skilled professionals. Perfect!

So much stigmatising language being thrown about in this thread. Sucking dick for money. Johns.
"Sucking **** for money" = correct description of activity, thus inadmissible and badly in need of a PC euphemism. The industry? The trade?

You wonder why sex work is still stigmatised? Language is one reason. We don't refer to plumbers as **** pushers. Why do we refer to sex workers as dick suckers and pussy sellers?
= We obviously can't call the activity what it is! It would be stigmatizing to call it what it is! Let's call them sex workers, for now, until we come up with a better euphemism. Call girls? Ladies of the night? Streetwalkers? No, we need something new, something modern. Maybe something with therapist in it. Or something in Latin that in itself creates a kind of distance to reality. Ejaculation assistant? Nah, too long. This one will require some work.

I bet quite a few would, but the existence of sites like Onlyfans, /r/GoneWild, PornHub Creators and the many, many, many livestreaming sites suggests that there will always be people who will voluntarily **** for money.

'See?! It exists! Which proves that it will always exist!'
(No, it won't. It will exist as long as some people are so poor that they will have to "**** for money," which some other people will then warm their souls by adding "voluntarily," the perfect euphemism for 'no better alternative left due to financial circumstances'. But those circumstances are capitalism, i.e. the natural state of things, so everything's fine.)

The industry would not... er... dry up... because of a UBI, especially if the work is suitably incentivised, which it will.

Yes, the industry was a great choice, the perfect PC euphemism for prostitution.


Notice that, unlike a vulgar expression like suck **** or sell pussy
"**** for money" is perfectly acceptable if only we always remember to add the important voluntarily, which, for whatever reason, isn't necessary when describing ordinary jobs llke voluntarily cutting hair, voluntarily giving physical therapy, voluntarily teaching reading and writing or voluntarily healing and caring for the sick. But in the industry of all industries, the one where trafficked women tend to end up, we can't stress voluntarily enough.
Anything other than that would be stigmatizing.
 
The few that I know personally (not professionally of course) ...


Of course!
Even though it would be absolutely fine to 'know' these voluntary sex workers professionally as a client, it is nevertheless important to stress that one only knows a few personally and definitely not as a client.
The unfortunate stigmatization of language.
 
Of course!
Even though it would be absolutely fine to 'know' these voluntary sex workers professionally as a client, it is nevertheless important to stress that one only knows a few personally and definitely not as a client.
The unfortunate stigmatization of language.

So, we disagree, that much is clear.

I'll again reiterate my position on what I personally think is the way things should be regulated.
Legal prostitution, coupled with a good social security network, universal healthcare and (probably government led) control to prevent victims of human trafficking or addiction from ending up in prostitution involuntary or out of financial desperation.
There should also be good sexual education to destigmatize sex.
Hence I vote for parties that generally follow these lines.

What would your preferred regulation be then?
 
Of course!
Even though it would be absolutely fine to 'know' these voluntary sex workers professionally as a client, it is nevertheless important to stress that one only knows a few personally and definitely not as a client.
The unfortunate stigmatization of language.

[off topic]

Actually, they are/were both customers of mine, but if I were to be a client of either of them, my partner-relationship would be over instantly
 
And here is where we see what it looks like when someone doubles, triples, and quadruples down on stigmatisation.

= PC euphemism for john. Makes it sound just like an ordinary customer buying the services of skilled professionals. Perfect!
That's exactly what it is. Why use a vulgar euphemism?

"Sucking **** for money" = correct description of activity, thus inadmissible and badly in need of a PC euphemism. The industry? The trade?
The industry. You could call it a trade. Not all sex workers suck cock for money, and not all of the work of those that do consists of sucking cock. Not only are you assuming, you are stereotyping, and using the worst possible description of the profession, which if nothing else ensures that your readers are left in no doubt about your attitude towards sex workers. So thanks for sending that clear signal, at least.

= We obviously can't call the activity what it is! It would be stigmatizing to call it what it is! Let's call them sex workers, for now, until we come up with a better euphemism. Call girls? Ladies of the night? Streetwalkers? No, we need something new, something modern. Maybe something with therapist in it. Or something in Latin that in itself creates a kind of distance to reality. Ejaculation assistant? Nah, too long. This one will require some work.
We call them sex workers because it is an accurate description of what they do. Not all sex workers are prostitutes. Porn performers are sex workers. Lap dancers are sex workers. Writers of erotic fiction are sex workers. Would it surprise you to learn that we have had sex workers as regular posters here at this very forum?

'See?! It exists! Which proves that it will always exist!'
(No, it won't. It will exist as long as some people are so poor that they will have to "**** for money," which some other people will then warm their souls by adding "voluntarily," the perfect euphemism for 'no better alternative left due to financial circumstances'. But those circumstances are capitalism, i.e. the natural state of things, so everything's fine.)
Again, you leave us in absolutely no doubt about how much contempt you hold for sex workers. This entire thread has been about breaking the stereotypes about sex workers, including the one that the only reason they do it is because they're poor and they need money for drugs.

Yes, the industry was a great choice, the perfect PC euphemism for prostitution.
Ah yes, let's address "PC", shall we? That terribly useful shorthand for "I don't like being told that I'm not allowed to insult people any more" and "I'll insult whoever I like using whatever language I like and it's their fault for being offended at what I choose to say".

Notice that, unlike a vulgar expression like suck **** or sell pussy
"**** for money" is perfectly acceptable if only we always remember to add the important voluntarily, which, for whatever reason, isn't necessary when describing ordinary jobs llke voluntarily cutting hair, voluntarily giving physical therapy, voluntarily teaching reading and writing or voluntarily healing and caring for the sick. But in the industry of all industries, the one where trafficked women tend to end up, we can't stress voluntarily enough.
You're the one confusing the legal sex industry with human trafficking. Which yes, does happen and yes, is a real problem and yes, must be stopped. But that is not the same thing as legal prostitution as I and The Atheist (among some others) have been describing in this thread since it started.

Anything other than that would be stigmatizing.
Which is something that you are clearly perfectly okay with. What other groups of people do you think it's okay to stigmatise?
 
We call them sex workers because it is an accurate description of what they do. Not all sex workers are prostitutes. Porn performers are sex workers. Lap dancers are sex workers. Writers of erotic fiction are sex workers. Would it surprise you to learn that we have had sex workers as regular posters here at this very forum?

Again, you leave us in absolutely no doubt about how much contempt you hold for sex workers. This entire thread has been about breaking the stereotypes about sex workers, including the one that the only reason they do it is because they're poor and they need money for drugs.


Indeed, part of the rationale for legalizing prostitution in New Zealand was to get it out from under the thumb of the criminal gangs who were controlling it. The women involved were not only in fear of the gangs, they were also in fear of the Police. Since 2003, the vast majority of prostitutes in this country do what they do by choice, not because they are forced to.

Legally forbidding money to change hands for sex is an antiquated, overly moralistic intellectually backwards-thinking philosophy that belongs firmly in the 19th century. It is a philosophy mostly promoted by god-botherers and prudes.... who incidentally, make up a significant number of their clients. I regard most of the people who have disdain for sex workers (at least disdain for the female ones) to be little more than self-righteous closet misogynists.

So, what happens when you make prostitution legal? Well, for a start, the gangs and the criminals are shut out of control of the industry, and the girls are free to pursue their own lives without fear or intimidation, Their profession is legitimized in the eyes of the public. Brothels can apply for government registration. Their workers are protected by police and heath insurance.


What other groups of people do you think it's okay to stigmatise?

Anyone who doesn't agree with him?
 
Last edited:
So, we disagree, that much is clear.

I'll again reiterate my position on what I personally think is the way things should be regulated.
Legal prostitution, coupled with a good social security network, universal healthcare and (probably government led) control to prevent victims of human trafficking or addiction from ending up in prostitution involuntary or out of financial desperation.
There should also be good sexual education to destigmatize sex.
Hence I vote for parties that generally follow these lines.

What would your preferred regulation be then?


My preferred system would be one in which people aren't forced to suck ***** for money by traffickers, pimps or financial necessity. I don't need to ask you what your preferred system is.
 
That awful stigmatization.
You appear to have a problem with the idea of stigmatisation. Why are you pushing back quite so hard on that concept? Do you not believe it is possible to stigmatise groups of people, or do you just think it's okay to do so?
 
I could never understand why prostitution is illegal in the US (generally speaking of course) but pornography isn't.

In my opinion it's the same damn thing, except in the case of pornography, both get paid.
 
That awful stigmatization.

Is no stigmatization at all - it would simply be being unfaithful to my life partner, but you go right ahead expressing your misogynistic views... you have made your low opinion of women quite clear in this thread. If find that unsurprising.

My preferred system would be one in which people aren't forced to suck ***** for money by traffickers, pimps or financial necessity..

Well none of that is happening here, so you shouldn't have a problem with it, should you? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I could never understand why prostitution is illegal in the US (generally speaking of course) but pornography isn't.

In my opinion it's the same damn thing, except in the case of pornography, both get paid.
It's often said that in America you can get arrested for paying someone for sex, unless you have a camera running.
 
My preferred system would be one in which people aren't forced to suck ***** for money by traffickers, pimps or financial necessity. I don't need to ask you what your preferred system is.

I would argue that is what my system would ensure, after all I specifically said that it would have enough financial security for everyone that you can have a basic and survivable income and that due to the legality the police can arrest those forcing people into prostitution, while protecting those that are there voluntary.

So where do you disagree? What would you do different? Because apart from your apparent fear/disgust of fellatio, you never seem to suggest anything practical.
 
And here is where we see what it looks like when someone doubles, triples, and quadruples down on stigmatisation.

You seem to think that using an exact description of the activity is stigmatizing. It isn't.

That's exactly what it is. Why use a vulgar euphemism?


There is nothing vulgar about the word. A john is not really a euphemism: "a mild or indirect word or expression substituted for one considered to be too harsh or blunt when referring to something unpleasant or embarrassing." John is a very precise term for somebody who buys sex from a prostitute. That you would prefer to replace it with a term for somebody who buys anything from anybody is no surprise. You like the abstraction from what is actually going on, the specific activity that is being bought and sold. This is also why you prefer the word sex worker, i.e. because it might be somebody who works as a janitor at a brothel or writes erotic fiction.
That you don't want to call things what they are is obvious. Avoiding the stigmatization by resorting to ever new euphemism is a common practice for people who find reality stigmatizing.

The industry. You could call it a trade. Not all sex workers suck cock for money, and not all of the work of those that do consists of sucking cock. Not only are you assuming, you are stereotyping, and using the worst possible description of the profession, which if nothing else ensures that your readers are left in no doubt about your attitude towards sex workers. So thanks for sending that clear signal, at least.


I doubt that any prostitutes (not your euphemism sex workers) don't suck ***** for money. In the movies, it's usually the first thing they offer from their list of 'services'. That you find clear signals demeaning and stigmatizing isn't my problem. It also isn't my problem that you seem to think that the demeaning activity of selling sex for money somehow goes away if only we'd call it something else.

We call them sex workers because it is an accurate description of what they do. Not all sex workers are prostitutes. Porn performers are sex workers. Lap dancers are sex workers. Writers of erotic fiction are sex workers. Would it surprise you to learn that we have had sex workers as regular posters here at this very forum?


No, I'm not surprised at all. With your definition, anybody could be a 'sex worker'.
An no, we don't call prostitutes sex workers. You do. You probably don't even notice your own contradiction in terms. First, you claim that "it is an accurate (!) description of what they do," and then you make it clear that it is the opposite of accurate. Instead of being accurate, your favorite euphemism for prostitution includes not only porn stars but also "writers of erotic fiction."
I assume cleaners, receptionists and accountants working at brothels could be described as sex workers, too.
Accurate?! No, not at all.
By the way, did you notice the title of this thread?! It isn't sex work.

Again, you leave us in absolutely no doubt about how much contempt you hold for sex workers. This entire thread has been about breaking the stereotypes about sex workers, including the one that the only reason they do it is because they're poor and they need money for drugs.


You are so hell-bent on ameliorating the unpleasant phenomenon of prostitution by coming up with new words for it that you don't even notice how patronizing your attitude is. 'Let's not call it what it is. That would be contemptuous. Let us instead use euphemisms to break the stereotypes.'
It's OK, arthwollipot! You are embarrassed by the phenomenon of prostitution as every normal person should be. You just don't seem to realize that you don't abolish it or make any less unpleasant by coming up with ever new words for it.

Ah yes, let's address "PC", shall we? That terribly useful shorthand for "I don't like being told that I'm not allowed to insult people any more" and "I'll insult whoever I like using whatever language I like and it's their fault for being offended at what I choose to say".


I have not insulted anything other than your delicate sensibility. Pointing out that prostitutes suck ***** is hardly something they are unaware of. It's part of ther 'job' description even though they may refer to it as fellatio in your idealized legal brothels. You are the one who gets offended by reality, which is why you try to protect yourself from those awful, awful words!
But yes, I think it's a pity that it insults you, but I have no intentions to bow to your attempts to distort language with your extremely inaccurate euphemisms.

You're the one confusing the legal sex industry with human trafficking. Which yes, does happen and yes, is a real problem and yes, must be stopped. But that is not the same thing as legal prostitution as I and The Atheist (among some others) have been describing in this thread since it started.


I don't confuse the two at all. That you get confused merely because I mention them in the same sentence is your problem.

Which is something that you are clearly perfectly okay with. What other groups of people do you think it's okay to stigmatise?


You are the one who is so stigmatized by the reality of prostitution that you are offended by anything other than PC Newspeak. As mentioned above, I find it perfectly natural that you feel consternation when confronted with the truth about prostitution, but it is naive to think that you somehow contribute to ameliorating this piece of unpleasant reality by trying to dictate language. It's stigmatizing.
 
Is no stigmatization at all - it would simply be being unfaithful to my life partner, but you go right ahead expressing your misogynistic views... you have made your low opinion of women quite clear in this thread. If find that unsurprising.


Yes, in your world criticizing attempts to idealize brothels is probably seen as misogynistic. :rolleyes:

Well none of that is happening here, so you shouldn't have a problem with it, should you? :rolleyes:


I have no idea where "here" is supposed to be.
Trafficked: An international investigation (TheAge)
Trafficked: Women shunted ‘like cattle’ around Australia for sex work (TheAge, Oct 30, 2022)
 
Whoa! Fast moving thread.

Also, the NZ model is so far removed from how we are familiar with prostitution in the States that it's kind of like if I were to keep describing car polish to you as champagne. It gets hard to process sometimes.

I fully understand that, which is why it's important to get to grips with the NZ model.

It's been legal here for a tidy 20 years and the amount of trafficking, assaults on sex workers and harm to society has been minimised.

Human morality is equally accessible to both sexes.

Yeah... nah.

The argument seems to be following the exact course of abortion - blokes wanting to tell women what to do with their bodies.

I have too much respect for women to try that.

And here is where we see what it looks like when someone doubles, triples, and quadruples down on stigmatisation.

That's exactly what it is. Why use a vulgar euphemism?

Tedious tactic to poison the well. A logical fallacy by any other name.

My preferred system would be one in which people aren't forced to suck ***** for money by traffickers, pimps or financial necessity. I don't need to ask you what your preferred system is.

The workers I spoke to fit none of those.

If you're getting your understanding of sex work from the movies...

That fits the drivel I'm seeing.
 
Stop the personalising of the discussion and other Rule 12 breaches.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom