Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
They're not "tricks". They're business transactions and legally provided services.

...which in common parlance is called tricking or hooking or any of a dozen other figures of speech occasionally employed to not repeat the word "prostirution" over and over like a broken record.
 
We.....can't compare legalized prostitution in two first World countries in the same time frame? Just absolutely no basis for comparison? Ok.
Chalk and cheese. Thinking that they are in any way comparable is part of the reason you can't understand what it's like here.

Nevada brothels are barely legal at best, thoroughly entangled with organised crime, and practically unregulated. Brothels in Australia and New Zealand operate entirely within the law, under the legal protections and regulations that all service workers benefit from. Which includes, by the way, being protected by State and Federal Workplace Health and Safety legislation.
 
...which in common parlance is called tricking or hooking or any of a dozen other figures of speech occasionally employed to not repeat the word "prostirution" over and over like a broken record.
Using professional language goes a long way towards legitimising the industry in peoples' minds. Sex workers, not "hookers" or "whores". Contracted services, not "tricks". Clients, not "Johns".
 
Chalk and cheese. Thinking that they are in any way comparable is part of the reason you can't understand what it's like here.

I don't recall saying I can't understand what it's like there.

Nevada brothels are barely legal at best, thoroughly entangled with organised crime, and practically unregulated. Brothels in Australia and New Zealand operate entirely within the law, under the legal protections and regulations that all service workers benefit from. Which includes, by the way, being protected by State and Federal Workplace Health and Safety legislation.

Which is my point. Even when actually legal, my fellow Americans can't get this to work. They are barely trying. My guess is that it is because the whole gig is not desired by the clientele to be above board. Connoisseurs of the services aren't hearing about dramatic price increases, so it doesn't take off. The workers may like the idea of better pay and protections, but methinks they will suddenly find they have priced themselves out of their own market.

Tough to find reliable data, but I see estimates of 1-2 million working girls in ye olde States, compared with 22,000 in Oz and just 3500 in Kiwiland. Seems like the dramatically smaller market in your hemisphere might be too small to scale over here? We could probably swing a comparable amount of legal sex workers. Say, about 300,000, adjusted for population? What happens to the rest, whose clients ain't paying $500/hr under any circumstance?

I doubt our client base would jibe with legalization. The vast majority of sex work would remain as-is.
 
Last edited:
Using professional language goes a long way towards legitimising the industry in peoples' minds. Sex workers, not "hookers" or "whores". Contracted services, not "tricks". Clients, not "Johns".

This may be a cultural thing, but to many American ears, it sounds dishonest to rebrand that way. A drug dealer does not gain credibility by calling himself an undocumented pharmacist. He just makes it clear that he is full of ****.
 
This may be a cultural thing, but to many American ears, it sounds dishonest to rebrand that way. A drug dealer does not gain credibility by calling himself an undocumented pharmacist. He just makes it clear that he is full of ****.
In my experience, that may be the initial response, but as the culture changes it becomes more and more normal. To my Australian ear, hearing about hookers turning tricks with johns sounds crude and demeaning.
 
I doubt our client base would jibe with legalization. The vast majority of sex work would remain as-is.
There will always be a market for high-end sex workers. What it would phase out of the market would be the $50 hand jobs in filthy alleys. And that would be a Good Thing, in my opinion.
 
You walk into a brothel (why not, its safe/sane legal) and find a family member working there (child/spouse/parent..) what do you do?
 
You walk into a brothel (why not, its safe/sane legal) and find a family member working there (child/spouse/parent..) what do you do?

Sell the story to a porn producer.

There have been so many ridiculous non-questions and scenarios in this thread that I feel quite justified posting non-serious responses.
 
You walk into a brothel (why not, its safe/sane legal) and find a family member working there (child/spouse/parent..) what do you do?
If it is as close a family member as a child, spouse or parent, I'm pretty sure I'd already know they were working there. Otherwise we've got some serious communication issues in this family. And I'd honestly be more upset about that than about the nature of the job they've taken.

Also, what lionking said.
 
Everybody is different though. It’s a fact that some women don’t feel any inkling of that whole social bonding kit and kaboodle thing around the sex act. Any such women who find sex aerobic and fun can have a great ******* time capitalizing on that if they live in one of the places that sex work is legal and safe.
No. The whole point of warning somebody off something is that they don't perceive the problem with it. If one looks at this through materialist, individualist eyes that view some Roussean notion of liberty as the highest good and humans as blank slates, then the damaging nature of prostitution is invisible.
 
Last edited:
That's rich.

You specifically asked what danger retail staff faced compared to sex workers, you were told, then complained that it wasn't strong enough evidence.

Now that it's been provided in detail you don't want to look.

Brilliant!

Did I? Where? Could you quote me asking that question?

I did wonder why a link to retail violence was felt to be relevant in a thread about violence to sex workers. Did you confuse this?
 
Oh my darling little baby
What will you grow up to be?
Prime Minister of England?
Or the King of Italy?
We waited thirty years or more
To see what he would be
He's now a dustman in Chiswick
Oh dearie, dearie me

- Spike Milligan
 
As it is just after my retirement I have been reflecting on the jobs I’ve done. I’ve been a cleaner many times, one which involved cleaning floors on my hands and knees. I once made shaving cream. I’ve been threatened many times (and I have formed the belief that you will never be assaulted by someone who threatens you, but by those who don’t). I had jobs that caused me great harm.

I find it hard to feel outraged at someone who works willingly as a prostitute in a safe and supportive environment. It’s a lot better than many jobs I’ve had.
 
The premise of the question is set to avoid those kind of "technical" avoidances, though. Say she is of age. Bad economy. No real good paying jobs out there (a very real world scenario for a lot of us right about now). Would you ask her if she had considered this high-paying line of work? Why or why not?

If the subject came up, I most likely would. We told her from pre-puberty that whether or not she chooses to have sex is entirely her decision, so I'd be quite comfortable that she'd decide for herself if it was appropriate.

See, that's interesting. Was there something about this woman that made you think she would be down to do this kind of work, or would you pretty much suggest it to anyone who was in need of cash? If none of my ******* business, just say the word, of course.

I never considered her as a prime prospect to sell her body but she asked me how she could make money fast and I suggested it as a valid option. This is going back to just after it became legal.

When she decided to go ahead I even picked her business name for her - Naughty Natasha.

I suspect many boyfriends or partners would find themselves not quite so open-minded as they previously thought when faced with that, yeah. When I'm looking for a new car, I don't ask my wife to turn a few tricks to get the luxury package.

Not much demand for old sheilas anyway!

While we have ricocheted around between job safety and other concerns, I'm thinking here about the double standard in play (women whose well being we are more emotionally invested in). As others have said, tricking seems fine in the abstract, with the usual consenting adults doing so legally caveats. Just can't imagine a frame of mind where I'd bring up the option to my daughters or wife. And if it's not ok for women I love, why should I accept it for others?

My much older late brother was a puritanical wanker who used to actually ask his daughter if she still had her cherry - in those exact words. She used to come and stay with us so she could bonk her boyfriends in safety and secrecy.

I really do see mechanical sex as no different to working in a butchery shop or hair salon. Prostitution is 99% acting and 1% sex.

I'm not saying your attitude is wrong, just different to mine.

Did I? Where? Could you quote me asking that question?

Sorry, it wasn't you who asked the original question.
Edited by sarge: 
removed rules/12 content
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do you talk to your kids about the possibilities inherent in being a garbage collector? If not, why not?

I don't think I did but that was because my son was pretty fixed on his career path from a young age and pursued it into adulthood. I did suggest the RAF as a pilot or the armed forces as an officer due to his excellent grades. He's 35 now and on his own with regard to career choices.

I might not specify, "garbage collector", if my grandson should ever come to me for advice but again, like with my son, it would depend on how well he was doing academically. If he was struggling then I'd happily discuss manual labouring jobs. Why ever wouldn't I?

Why did you select "garbage collector"? With an average UK salary at £23k it's not the worst paying job and it's certainly a lot cleaner due to being heavily mechanised these days.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom