Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry, it wasn't you who asked the original question, but you stuck your oar in and claimed my link didn't cover violence in UK.

Thank you but I reiterate, why do you think retail violence in the UK is relevant in a thread about legalised prostitution?

Edited by sarge: 
edited to remove content edited from quoted post
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I must have missed the point of the question. "You wouldn't advise your daughter to become a prostitute, therefore...." what, exactly? Prostitution should be illegal? Prostitution is a sin in the eyes of the Lord? Somebody help me out here.
 
I must have missed the point of the question. "You wouldn't advise your daughter to become a prostitute, therefore...." what, exactly? Prostitution should be illegal? Prostitution is a sin in the eyes of the Lord? Somebody help me out here.

I understood the point to be, "would you be happy if your daughter was working, legally, as a sex worker, selling sexual services?". You're not seriously trying to make the case that the question is anything more than a poke at potential double standards being in play in this thread? There is no other outcome than "yes" or "no" and then we move onto "why?".

I hope you're not disappointed that your personal "therefores", aren't a factor.

If I'm wrong then Thermal will correct me.
 
I must have missed the point of the question. "You wouldn't advise your daughter to become a prostitute, therefore...." what, exactly? Prostitution should be illegal? Prostitution is a sin in the eyes of the Lord? Somebody help me out here.

As you implied, it's pretty much just an attempt at some lame moral grandstanding.

I have a 20 year old daughter. She's had sex, I'd assume. She's even had sex with more than 1 person, I'd assume. I don't talk to her about it, but it's not a huge mystery that women, in general, enjoy sex.

I wouldn't be bothered by her working in that field, but I wouldn't suggest it to her for the same reason I don't suggest her to go out and have sex with people. It's her sex life and it's really none of my business. As long as I know she's safe at work, if that's what she wanted to do, and make money due to her looks, then all the more power to her.

And yes, that same attitude goes towards my wife, my sons, my sister, my mom, etc. Though a few of them will have a harder go of it than my daughter, I'd guess.

If I were to walk into an establishment like that, looking to utilize their services, and saw my daughter, or close family member, working there then I just wouldn't request their services. We'd probably both be a little embarrassed and life would go on. Kind of like if I had to buy condoms at a gas station from my aunt or the like. Weird, awkward, but fairly ho-hum.
 
I understood the point to be, "would you be happy if your daughter was working, legally, as a sex worker, selling sexual services?". You're not seriously trying to make the case that the question is anything more than a poke at potential double standards being in play in this thread? There is no other outcome than "yes" or "no" and then we move onto "why?".

I hope you're not disappointed that your personal "therefores", aren't a factor.

If I'm wrong then Thermal will correct me.

Right, a long ass drawn out attempt at a "gotcha".

The fact is there are a lot of jobs we wouldn't pitch to our kids for a myriad of reasons. Prostitution is definitely that way because of the stigma attached in the US, a stigma that Thermal and others here have perpetuated. But also because, at least in my case, I don't know anything about how the process works. I wouldn't be able to offer any guidance. It's also not something I really want to think about because she's my daughter. Does not, at all, mean that there's anything more than that to it. It also just doesn't sound like a fun job, but assuredly there are many who do love it.

The same reason I wouldn't suggest being a gravedigger to my kids. I'm sure some people love it, but in general it's not a gig a lot of people want.
 
I sincerely hope my (hypothetical) children aren't picking their vocations based on my personal moral hangups. I've (hypothetically) raised them better than that.

But yea "Okay so what if it was your daughter" is just emotional trap bait.

There's plenty of jobs I don't want my hypothetical children doing. Guess what that has zero to do with the job being little to be frank very little to do with them actually doing it being a problem.
 
Right, a long ass drawn out attempt at a "gotcha".

That's one way of putting it and you'll get no argument from me. I've already posited what the motivation was in asking upthread.

The fact is there are a lot of jobs we wouldn't pitch to our kids for a myriad of reasons. Prostitution is definitely that way because of the stigma attached in the US, a stigma that Thermal and others here have perpetuated. But also because, at least in my case, I don't know anything about how the process works. I wouldn't be able to offer any guidance. It's also not something I really want to think about because she's my daughter. Does not, at all, mean that there's anything more than that to it. It also just doesn't sound like a fun job, but assuredly there are many who do love it.

That's a "no", and a, "here's why".

The same reason I wouldn't suggest being a gravedigger to my kids. I'm sure some people love it, but in general it's not a gig a lot of people want.

Short Derail - Not entirely sure but here in the UK, the one or two people I've known to have dug a humans grave have been local authority employed, qualified gardeners/landscapers for whom digging a hole, safely, to specification and refilling it is a very small part of their job. I assume it's the same across the country so would have no issues with recommending such a career.
 
Last edited:
I still don't understand the point of the question. Even if I say "no," what difference does that make in terms of whether it should be legal or not?

We have pointed out many careers we wouldn't advise. Let's get something more related. What if your daughter said she wanted to be a porn star? Presumably all the same objections apply. But being in porn movies is legal.

So the discussion is all a red-herring.
 
That's a "no", and a, "here's why".

What are you talking about? You're saying that I'm saying "no" and then telling me why I'm saying "no"? Get that **** out of here lol. You can't tell me what I'm saying.

Seriously.

Short Derail - Not entirely sure but here in the UK, the one or two people I've known to have dug a humans grave have been local authority employed, qualified gardeners/landscapers for whom digging a hole, safely, to specification and refilling it is a very small part of their job. I assume it's the same across the country so would have no issues with recommending such a career.

I don't care.
 
I still don't understand the point of the question. Even if I say "no," what difference does that make in terms of whether it should be legal or not?

As I understand it the question doesn't seek to answer the legality of prostitution in any way, any shape or any form. The point has been fully explained, according to my understanding, up thread. If I'm wrong..... etc.

We have pointed out many careers we wouldn't advise. Let's get something more related. What if your daughter said she wanted to be a porn star? Presumably all the same objections apply. But being in porn movies is legal.

I would advise her that such a career is likely to pay well in some circumstances but probably not so in the long run. I'd tell her that people will judge her harshly for such a career choice and that she is very likely to be taken advantage of and despite the legality of it all she will be swimming in murky waters with a lot of sharks. I would tell her I don't think it is a great career move.

So the discussion is all a red-herring.

If you mean "distracting", then I agree. If you mean "misleading" then I don't.
 
I still don't understand the point of the question. Even if I say "no," what difference does that make in terms of whether it should be legal or not?

We have pointed out many careers we wouldn't advise. Let's get something more related. What if your daughter said she wanted to be a porn star? Presumably all the same objections apply. But being in porn movies is legal.

So the discussion is all a red-herring.

No it's bait.
 
What are you talking about? You're saying that I'm saying "no" and then telling me why I'm saying "no"? Get that **** out of here lol. You can't tell me what I'm saying.

You wrote it, own it. It's that bitty where you start "But also because,"

So, you can get **** out of here.... "lol".

Seriously.

Indeed

I don't care.

Why did you go to all the trouble of denigrating grave diggers then?
 
You're not seriously trying to make the case that the question is anything more than a poke at potential double standards being in play in this thread?

First, legality was an issue from the beginning. "Laws" is literally the first word in this thread.

Second, I'm still trying to understand the point, and your post has not clarified the matter. Could you please elaborate on exactly what this "double standard" is?
 
You wrote it, own it. It's that bitty where you start "But also because,"

So, you can get **** out of here.... "lol".

Your strawman and lack of reading comprehension isn't my problem. It's odd that you pulled this from what I said, but not surprising,

Why did you go to all the trouble of denigrating grave diggers then?

Ah, more strawmen. You're terrible at this. I didn't peg you as having such miserable reading comprehension skills.

I didn't "denigrate" anyone. I said it wasn't, one of a zillion, jobs I'd recommend my kids having. That you need to twist everything around to try and get a "gotcha" from every post is really strange.

Almost like, since you have no actual argument, you just need to resort to fallacies. Odd.
 
First, legality was an issue from the beginning. "Laws" is literally the first word in this thread.

Quite, but it wasn't germane to the question.

Second, I'm still trying to understand the point, and your post has not clarified the matter. Could you please elaborate on exactly what this "double standard" is?

I think the question was designed to make those who insist that legalised prostitution is just another job admit that, despite that being the case, they'd rather their own progeny weren't involved in trading sexual services for cash. That's the potential double standard.

I'm sure you knew that though.
 
Your strawman and lack of reading comprehension isn't my problem. It's odd that you pulled this from what I said, but not surprising,



Ah, more strawmen. You're terrible at this. I didn't peg you as having such miserable reading comprehension skills.

I didn't "denigrate" anyone. I said it wasn't, one of a zillion, jobs I'd recommend my kids having. That you need to twist everything around to try and get a "gotcha" from every post is really strange.

Almost like, since you have no actual argument, you just need to resort to fallacies. Odd.

I don't have an argument, you're quite correct. I was supporting "The Question". The question was asked and you answered it negatively and gave reasons why you did so. Why you're so shy of those facts is beyond me?

There's no "gotcha" from me and I can't see where you get that idea from.
 
Quite, but it wasn't germane to the question.



I think the question was designed to make those who insist that legalised prostitution is just another job admit that, despite that being the case, they'd rather their own progeny weren't involved in trading sexual services for cash. That's the potential double standard.

I'm sure you knew that though.

Every job is unique.

I know people who when they go to work, they have to where full-fledged haz mat suits, with blast-proof shields. That's not just like any other job, either.

So ok, we agree that s3x work is different from being a cashier at the local grocery. Wow, real insight.
 
I didn't look at any of your links, despite the many hours you may have spent looking for some sort of pathetic "gotcha". This is thread about prostitution and the celebration of NZ being a world leader in legalising it (despite them being some 600 odd years late). If you want to start a thread about retail workers being abused, feel free. This is not the place.
:rolleyes:
And yet you were the person to interject regarding service industry violence...
 
I still don't understand the point of the question. Even if I say "no," what difference does that make in terms of whether it should be legal or not?

We have pointed out many careers we wouldn't advise. Let's get something more related. What if your daughter said she wanted to be a porn star? Presumably all the same objections apply. But being in porn movies is legal.

So the discussion is all a red-herring.

Totally a red herring. The argument for legalization is primarily that it moves prostitution from the black market to the legit market which minimizes(not eliminates) the negatives associated with prostitution currently.

Legal markets allow participants access to the legal system. Violence is discouraged, worker protections exist, participants can have contracts and resort to courts instead of violence. It incentivizes legal participants to narc on the illegal participants rather than the opposite. Legalization minimizes harm to participants and nonparticipants alike.

I can say that and still say, I don't want my children to be prostitutes or pimps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom