Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
I disagree with this quite a bit.For a lot of people it's not in any way simple to get a relation to the point of intimacy.Sure if you're a (semi) good looking or at least well groomed extroverted individual that can handle rejection the dating scene might seem the easiest way, but that is not the case for everyone.

There are also many people in a relation where their libido's are vastly different where one party still enjoys sex and the other does not.

Or whose relation ended and who do not desire a new relation, but do like the physical act of sex.
Masturbation can only replace that partially.

Now personally I also do not feel comfortable making use of a prostitutes services for the same reason as you, but my feelings are irrelevant, apparently there are enough people who do not mind and as long as this is consentual, what's the harm?

Having trouble picturing these socially shy introverts suddenly forgetting who they are and walking up to a complete stranger, stripping down and plowing in. To do so, it seems like they would have to view the prostitute as "not a real person," or all those personal/social anxieties would be front and center, wouldn't they?

And if your libido is not in synch with your partner, would you not be objectifying a sex worker by having them take care of business? Why wouldn't you agree to a throuple arrangement, or open relationship?

I'll answer: because that involves treating everyone like real people. Using the services of a prostitute is intended to make it impersonal and dehumanize it. That's where my problem comes in.
 
I'll answer: because that involves treating everyone like real people. Using the services of a prostitute is intended to make it impersonal and dehumanize it. That's where my problem comes in.

The same could be said about the difference between a home cooked meal and going to diner for a quick burger.
 
You busted me, I have no experience with hiring prostitutes or their current going rate for various services.

No, just comparing rates with AC and Philly. You guys running a Blue Light Special up there or something?

I guess the question is whether or not there's a meaningful distinction between sex workers being subject to economic coercion and pretty much every other wage worker who also go to jobs they don't really care for because they need money to pay their bills.

The number of people with fun jobs that they'd probably do for free if money were no object is quite small, I suspect. I like my job, I'm pretty good at it, and it's quite comfortable, but I'd quit tomorrow if I hit the lottery and didn't have to ever worry about money again.

Are sex workers selling their bodies any more than a construction worker blowing out their knees lugging bags of concrete? Are they suffering blows to their dignity any more than any other customer facing support worker who often has to deal with abusive and crass clients?

We ran through all this at length earlier in the thread.

I pay unskilled workers $25/hrs on my site. But you can give BJs for $20/gulp. Obviously, you can make a days pay in an hour with less physical damage. You need one of those **** jobs you mentioned. And your personal orientation doesnt matter, pecause this is just an impersonal act for good money. Which are you taking? And. Don't. Lie.

The trendy thing is to say prostitution is like any other gig, and a great paying one. Until it's you or someone you value bending over for a line of men. Suddenly "That's Different". Or if your being honest, "GTFOOH, me or my child/parent/partner isn't doing that!"

It's all trendy and accepting till it's you on your knees. Then it's completely out of the question, and it becomes really clear what you think of that work.

One thing I've noticed is that some sex work, like the mostly false promise of getting rich on OnlyFans or whatever, is often attractive because it offers an alternative to lower paid drudgery work. Doing sex work may strike some as more dignified and lucrative than getting screamed at by some small business tyrant working in fast food or whatever other work may be available at any given time.

Taking on a ****** job while pursuing higher education or job training or whatever is common right of passage for younger people, and I imagine a good bit of sex work is not long term and probably pays better than bar backing in some college town.

Uh huh. Since it's so impersonal and no big deal, you ever offer a hummer to a buddy going through a dry spell? Or is that different too?.
 
Last edited:
No, just comparing rates with AC and Philly. You guys running a Blue Light Special up there or something?



We ran through all this at length earlier in the thread.

I pay unskilled workers $25/hrs on my site. But you can give BJs for $20/gulp. Obviously, you can make a days pay in an hour with less physical damage. You need one of those **** jobs you mentioned. And your personal orientation doesnt matter, pecause this is just an impersonal act for good money. Which are you taking? And. Don't. Lie.

The trendy thing is to say prostitution is like any other gig, and a great paying one. Until its you or someone you value bending over for a line of men. Suddenly "That's Different". Or if your being honest, "GTFOOH, me or my child/parent/partner er isn't doing that!"

It's all trendy and accepting ti it's you on your knees. Then it's completely out of the question.



Uh huh. Since it's so impersonal and no big deal, you ever offer a hummer to a buddy going through a dry spell? Or is that different too?.

I'm guess I'm just willing to admit that while I may be sentimental about such things, others may not feel the same way.

I find the idea of visiting a sex worker very unappealing for a variety of reasons, but I don't presume to project my worldview onto others. Attitudes about sexuality vary quite a bit and I'm comfortable with that.
 
Last edited:
Frankly, yes I do think that helps, provided the there is consent and someone not willing to become a prostitute can survive, hence why I support full legalization and social security / UBI.

I guess in some post-scarcity utopia where everyone is always able to find their soulmate(s) the moment they want the profession would vanish, but since that is not the case.


Yes, I already guessed that you looked at this exclusively from the perspective of the john.

A legal prostitute can simply not take a client they do not want and quit if they decide that the emotional component it becoming too much.


No, they can't simply refuse to be prostitutes if "the emotional component it becoming too much." That's were drugs come in. They help overcome the emotional component becoming too much."
 
Yes, I already guessed that you looked at this exclusively from the perspective of the john.




No, they can't simply refuse to be prostitutes if "the emotional component it becoming too much." That's were drugs come in. They help overcome the emotional component becoming too much."

Is there any evidence to suggest sex workers are using drugs any more than the general public?
 
Using the services of a prostitute is intended to make it impersonal and dehumanize it. That's where my problem comes in.


There are two sides to this, and since it's a 'trade' with much pretense, playacting and dissimulation, those two sides aren't always clear to both parties. I don't think the story of the john who thinks the prostitute has fallen in love with him because he has with her is a thing that only occurs in movies.
 
You do see that your example is quite literally referring to them as pieces of meat, right? Off message, methinks.

Not really. Personal services paid with money are generally impersonal compared to one freely given as an act of love or friendship or whatever. It's not really an issue that the friendly bartender is not my friend, or the restaurant cook isn't putting love into the recipe, or that a sex worker doesn't really have any romantic inclinations towards their clients.

People generally understand the distinction between a commodified service and an uncompensated act of service just fine.

People shouldn't treat sex workers as a piece of meat no more than they should be rude to their waiter at a restaurant, but that's just basic politeness.
 
According to Wikipedia, "Drugs and prostitution have been documented to have a direct correlation."
But one problem with prostitution as an object of research is that all parties in the 'trade' have reasons to lie about it.

A lot of this seems downstream of the criminal element of prostitution, which is by no means destiny.

I'd agree with the general idea that taking advantage of low cost sex workers barely scraping out survival often in exploitative criminal arrangements is generally unethical, but sex work doesn't necessarily have to mean drug addicted street walkers.

But I take the point. Without this lower scale, sex-work-as-survival prostitution there would probably be way less supply than demand. I could imagine that higher pay, professionalized and legal (and generally expensive) sex work could still exist ethically, but I doubt there would be much supply of cheap sex work absent these factors of extreme poverty and exploitation.

Decriminalization and regulation seems a better strategy to me than pushing these people into the black market.
 
Last edited:
There are two sides to this, and since it's a 'trade' with much pretense, playacting and dissimulation, those two sides aren't always clear to both parties. I don't think the story of the john who thinks the prostitute has fallen in love with him because he has with her is a thing that only occurs in movies.

Agreed, nothing is strictly black and white, and there are going to be variations and complexities. What bugs me here is the subtext that prostitution is fine and wonderfully high paying and all, but no one here would touch it with a ten foot pole. That's a bear I'm interested in poking a bit.
 
Agreed, nothing is strictly black and white, and there are going to be variations and complexities. What bugs me here is the subtext that prostitution is fine and wonderfully high paying and all, but no one here would touch it with a ten foot pole. That's a bear I'm interested in poking a bit.

Don't know what to tell you. I find places like Hooter's terribly tacky and gross, but apparently there's enough people who feel otherwise to support a nationwide franchise chain. I generally don't like how there's often pressure for servers and other hospitality workers to be cloyingly sweet to clients, and I often find these interactions a bit uncomfortable when service goes beyond basic polite professionalism. Maybe I'm in the minority in that way, but I don't really see getting forced small talk from the bartender or barber as a beneficial add-on to the experience.

There's no accounting for taste.
 
Last edited:
Not really. Personal services paid with money are generally impersonal compared to one freely given as an act of love or friendship or whatever. It's not really an issue that the friendly bartender is not my friend, or the restaurant cook isn't putting love into the recipe, or that a sex worker doesn't really have any romantic inclinations towards their clients.

People generally understand the distinction between a commodified service and an uncompensated act of service just fine.

People shouldn't treat sex workers as a piece of meat no more than they should be rude to their waiter at a restaurant, but that's just basic politeness.


As mentioned before, even the friendliest of bartenders and cooks don't usually suck your ****. It doesn't get really intimate.
By the way, since I worked at the Hotel and Restaurant School of Copenhagen for a couple of years, I know that cooks usually prefer to have as little to do with customers as possible. Waiters take care of that side of it, including the dissimulation. Cooks have no need for that.
George Orwell has a pretty good description of the different attitudes of the two groups in Down and Out in Paris and London.

My students claimed it was still astonishingly accurate.

The waiter’s outlook is quite different. He too is proud in a way of his skill, but his skill is chiefly in being servile. His work gives him the mentality, not of a workman, but of a snob. He lives perpetually in sight of rich people, stands at their tables, listens to their conversation, sucks up to them with smiles and discreet little jokes. He has the pleasure of spending money by proxy. Moreover, there is always the chance that he may become rich himself, for, though most waiters die poor, they have long runs of luck occasionally. At some cafes on the Grand Boulevard there is so much money to be made that the waiters actually pay the patron for their employment. The result is that between constantly seeing money, and hoping to get it, the waiter comes to identify himself to some extent with his employers. He will take pains to serve a meal in style, because he feels that he is participating in the meal himself.
 
As mentioned before, even the friendliest of bartenders and cooks don't usually suck your ****. It doesn't get really intimate.

There are more intimate examples, like masseuses.

Generally speaking, it's rude to request a service that is not on offer and not generally understood to be on offer, sexual or nonsexual. it would be rude to ask a waiter for sex, but it would also be rude to ask a waiter to shine my shoes or wash my car too for pretty much the same reason. Even people in service roles have negotiated with themselves what tasks they are willing to accept and it's a faux pas to presume more than is what obviously on offer.

That seems a universal enough principal.
 
Last edited:
As mentioned before, even the friendliest of bartenders and cooks don't usually suck your ****.

Well, no, that's not their job (coincidental pun).

OK, that's not what they are paid to do. They also don't rub your back like a masseuse would do. They don't put shoes on your feet like a shoe salesman does. They won't cut and shampoo your hair, either.

And I don't know, but will the "friendliest" prostitute suck your dick if you don't pay for it?
 
Agreed, nothing is strictly black and white, and there are going to be variations and complexities. What bugs me here is the subtext that prostitution is fine and wonderfully high paying and all, but no one here would touch it with a ten foot pole. That's a bear I'm interested in poking a bit.


People with libertarian leanings like to pretend to be freedom fighters on behalf of prostitutes, which is also why they like to portray its critics as the bourgeois moralists of another century.
They associate prostitution with sexual pleasure, i.e. the perspective of the delusional john, and are incapable of understanding opposition to prostitution when it is criticism of poverty in the name of both human prosperity and real sexual pleasure.

Hardly anybody seems to get the idea that their own comparison of prostitution with unpleasant menial labour should be a criticism of unpleasant menial labour and not a way to make prostitution seem to be acceptable as a job like any other. The classism of this attitude becomes apparent when they obviously wouldn't want their own daughters to be limited to choosing between one of those two alternatives.
 
Hardly anybody seems to get the idea that their own comparison of prostitution with unpleasant menial labour should be a criticism of unpleasant menial labour and not a way to make prostitution seem to be acceptable as a job like any other. The classism of this attitude becomes apparent when they obviously wouldn't want their own daughters to be limited to choosing between one of those two alternatives.

You say it yourself though, the objection is less about sex work and more about menial work generally and a lack of real agency for the most impoverished.

I'd hate to see my imagined children getting taken advantage as some under-the-table, poorly paid general laborer being exploited by some unscrupulous general contractor. There's plenty of exploitative labor practices in the non sex-work industries too, so focusing specifically on those that occur in the sex work industry seems like missing the broader point about poverty and the inherently exploitative nature of capitalism and the alienation of labor and so on.

People in dire poverty and/or with substance abuse issues being taken advantage of to perform menial jobs for starvation wages is generally an abhorrent practice, but one that is universal and does not only apply to the sex work industry.
 
Last edited:
Well, no, that's not their job (coincidental pun).

OK, that's not what they are paid to do. They also don't rub your back like a masseuse would do. They don't put shoes on your feet like a shoe salesman does. They won't cut and shampoo your hair, either.

And I don't know, but will the "friendliest" prostitute suck your dick if you don't pay for it?


Yes, it's back to that argument, isn't it?! 'But she gets paid to do it, so everything is fine.'
As for your other comparisons, not even the ordinary kind of masseuse, the kind who rubs your back and whose job comes close to physical therapy, sucks your ****. And the shoe salesman doesn't usually put shoes on people's feet in his spare time for pleasure. Nor do other people.

As Thermal has been trying to tell you that is the major difference between prostitution and the jobs you describe, even the ones with some level of physical intimacy like massage.
Pretending that there is no difference takes some effort on your part to make it work.
 
Yes, it's back to that argument, isn't it?! 'But she gets paid to do it, so everything is fine.'
As for your other comparisons, not even the ordinary kind of masseuse, the kind who rubs your back and whose job comes close to physical therapy, sucks your ****. And the shoe salesman doesn't usually put shoes on people's feet in his spare time for pleasure. Nor do other people.

As Thermal has been trying to tell you that is the major difference between prostitution and the jobs you describe, even the ones with some level of physical intimacy like massage.
Pretending that there is no difference takes some effort on your part to make it work.

People who have service type jobs often still perform these services for their friends and romantic partners and it's pretty obvious that there's a distinction between professional clients and an act of service motivated by generosity or friendship or romantic feeling.

A masseuse might give their romantic partner a massage for free and it has a totally different valence than when performing the same act as a commodified service.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom