Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Its a job. Sometimes, jobs are not fun.

As was once said By David Mitchell in an episode of QI

"The thing that seems unfair to me is the number of people who are expected to pretend they care about jobs they don't care about. You should be allowed to say 'look, I'm fulfilling my contract, you can't put in the contract - also you have to seem like you give a ****'".​

Yeah, I get that, but what I mean is that sex is supposed to be fun, so that disconnect messes it up for me, not them.

Kind of like if you hired a professional friend to hang out with you. I couldn't enjoy that, knowing that they are not actually enjoying it and just in it for as long as the money holds out.
 
Yeah, I get that, but what I mean is that sex is supposed to be fun, so that disconnect messes it up for me, not them.

Kind of like if you hired a professional friend to hang out with you. I couldn't enjoy that, knowing that they are not actually enjoying it and just in it for as long as the money holds out.

I think the industry knows about that.

I've seen sex workers on TV talking about providing 'the girlfriend experience' and how they simulate that experience for their clients. Given how those people were talking about their work, it really looked like they enjoyed their work.
 
Yeah, I get that, but what I mean is that sex is supposed to be fun, so that disconnect messes it up for me, not them.

As long as its fun for the client, then that's OK - she is delivering the product with customer satisfaction. Its up to the sex worker whether or not she enjoys it or not. SWSWSW!
 
I've worked as a recruiter on and off for over 30 years.

The number of people who get actual enjoyment from their job is extremely low.

It's an income.
 
As a former bartender and waiter, I can assure you that I rarely had fun, but you had to pretend to.

Not much different from the "pretend to be my friend" example mentioned above.

The people who think sex is different are projecting their own hangups. Which is fine, I do that constantly. But it's a poor basis for law.
 
I bet if you instituted a universal basic income, you'd be immediately discover a lot fewer women opting into sex work.

Nobody in this thread is renting out their genitals for the fun of it, instead of or in addition to their actual source of income.
 
I bet if you instituted a universal basic income, you'd be immediately discover a lot fewer women opting into sex work.

Nobody in this thread is renting out their genitals for the fun of it, instead of or in addition to their actual source of income.

Depending on the value of 'a lot'.

I've met women, with good careers, lovely homes, etc. who still work part-time as sex workers.

The reward is apparently far greater than UBI.
 
Yeah, I get that, but what I mean is that sex is supposed to be fun, so that disconnect messes it up for me, not them.

Kind of like if you hired a professional friend to hang out with you. I couldn't enjoy that, knowing that they are not actually enjoying it and just in it for as long as the money holds out.


Heh, I agree. Sex that isn't fun for both, cannot be fun for either. At least if you're wired the way I am, and you too as you say.


As long as its fun for the client, then that's OK - she is delivering the product with customer satisfaction. Its up to the sex worker whether or not she enjoys it or not. SWSWSW!


I get what Thermal's saying. For a subset of clients, it won't make for customer satisfaction unless it also makes for employee ecstasy. For that subset, The Atheist's attractive but disinterested professionals won't work.

There's no reason to insist that your car mechanic will dream at night with pleasure about you car, or that your investment consultant enjoys what they're doing, as long as they deliver: but sex is kind of different, at least for some.

I suppose an in-between would be air hostesses smiling at you. Or salespeople generally, the ha-ha-ha kinds. Depending on how well they're simulating friendliness, and depending on your own mood, you might sometimes like it, and most times probably take no note of it. But sometimes, occasionally, depending, artificial insincere smiles and simulated friendliness can make your skin crawl, even while recognizing they're only doing their job. That, except magnified a hundred times, when it comes to sex? For some, at any rate.


(Likely all moot. Because this subset probably won't pay for sex in any case. Or ...thinking this through, if they do, they'll probably stick with one or two girls they believe likes/enjoys them back.)
 
Yeah, I get that, but what I mean is that sex is supposed to be fun, so that disconnect messes it up for me, not them.

Kind of like if you hired a professional friend to hang out with you. I couldn't enjoy that, knowing that they are not actually enjoying it and just in it for as long as the money holds out.


Me neither, but an awful lot men don't seem to be bothered by the fact that they are having sex with women who don't have sex with them because they enjoy it or find them sexually attractive but because they have been paid to ignore the fact that they don't find them attractive or enjoy the activity.
What makes some people want to have sex with unwilling 'partners'?

Many probably don't even mind having sex with women they know are trafficked and forced by the traffickers to have sex for money. Not that there is a big difference between being forced by financial circumstances to have sex for money and being forced by other means to accomplish the same result.

Libertarians seem to think that prostitution epitomizes freedom.

As for buying friendship, the billionaires don't seem to mind paying Clarence Thomas for being their friend, but in their case there is obviously reason to assume that friendship isn't what he's being paid for.
 
Yeah, I get that, but what I mean is that sex is supposed to be fun, so that disconnect messes it up for me, not them.

I think it's worth noting that the client thinks he's got the girl off, because they fake orgasm and tell the guy he's a magical lover and the best they've ever had.

Add to that the girl is checking the time to make sure he doesn't take too long and keeping the condom in place and it's unlikely she's going to get sexual satisfaction from it.

Do we expect nurses to get enjoyment from changing colostomy bags?

I bet if you instituted a universal basic income, you'd be immediately discover a lot fewer women opting into sex work.

I'm sure none of the women I spoke to would agree.

If UBI were instituted in NZ it would be $40-50k pa, maximum. None of the girls earn anywhere near that paltry an amount - the top earner is over $200k, and I have no reason to doubt her word. Even part timers are earning well over $50k. They can have a high income and great lifestyle hours. UBI is a big fat nothing by comparison.
 
I.e. the one or two who are best at pretending.


I don’t know. That’s always possible, sure. But to broad-brush generalize like that seems a bit …cynical?

I haven't actually spoken with a sex worker ever, so, well, I base this only on general principles and nothing else: but I don’t think it’s right that sex workers would necessarily be dishonest, and that people who use their services necessarily dumb!
 
Is there any indication that the people who hire sex workers are not enjoying it? If not, so what's the issue?

Riding roller coasters is supposed to be fun. However, the amusement park workers who help customers get on the rides don't have a lot of fun.

Do flight attendants really enjoy flying? That might have been fun for the first week but soon it becomes routine and boring. Oh the horrors! Let me clutch my pearls!
 
Was that in response to me? I guess either that, else Thermal, given these last few posts.


Is there any indication that the people who hire sex workers are not enjoying it? If not, so what's the issue?


The issue is, as Thermal points out, that some people (I've no idea how common this trait is) are incapable of enjoying sex unless their partner also has a good time.


Riding roller coasters is supposed to be fun. However, the amusement park workers who help customers get on the rides don't have a lot of fun.

Do flight attendants really enjoy flying? That might have been fun for the first week but soon it becomes routine and boring. Oh the horrors! Let me clutch my pearls!


The amusement park employee's pleasure is not the actual main product, in fact as long as her overall demeanor isn't off-putting it is completely irrelevant to the product being offered. But as far as sex workers, and specifically in the case of the subset of people, like Thermal, who are wired not to be able to enjoy sex unless their partner enjoys it too: should this subset use the services of sex workers, and there after a while make clear on what terms they're engaging there: in that case, the pleasure that the provider of the service derives kind of becomes a key part of the actual product being sold. If she were to continue to misrepresent the product she's offering despite that, then that does amount to dishonesty and misrepresentation. And I see no reason to assume sex workers will necessarily be dishonest.


(Not to beat this to death! It isn't as if I'm a psychiatrist or psychologist or social worker specialized with sex workers or anything like that. But at a surface level, basis simple everyday thinking/reasoning, this seems completely obvious!)

(I'm not going to revisit this again --- unless that is I find someone arguing effectively showing my/our reasoning/position is flawed, in which case, sure, I'll revisit this to take this back, absolutely. But this is no more "pearl-clutching", what Thermal discussed, and I as well, than is your own objection reverse-pearl-clutching, or buttock-clenching, or whatever. Just a statement of how it is for some people, and, given the subject being discussed, an idle thinking-through about about how that might make for those people in the context of using the services of sex workers, is all.)
 
I would point that sex work isn't the only job where pretending to be friendly is a big part of it. Hospitality work of various kinds often requires or at least encourages employees to go beyond basic politeness. Plenty of waiters and bartenders who are chatting up customers and laughing at their bad jokes and otherwise performing friwndahip with people they otherwise might not give the time of day.

The example was given of amusement parks, but at the fancier parks (say, Disney) there is often an explicit requirement to be socialiable with park guests beyond politely operating the park.

I likewise assume that sex workers or hospitality workers are necessarily faking it. Some people are simply more gregarious and may find this element of the job not that hard.
 
Last edited:
I would point that sex work isn't the only job where pretending to be friendly is a big part of it. Hospitality work of various kinds often requires or at least encourages employees to go beyond basic politeness. Plenty of waiters and bartenders who are chatting up customers and laughing at their bad jokes and otherwise performing friwndahip with people they otherwise might not give the time of day.

The example was given of amusement parks, but at the fancier parks (say, Disney) there is often an explicit requirement to be socialiable with park guests beyond politely operating the park.

I likewise assume that sex workers or hospitality workers are necessarily faking it. Some people are simply more gregarious and may find this element of the job not that hard.

Seriously.

I mean, any successful salesman will be able to fake it and make it look like they care. Why would we assume anything different from a prostitute? She has to make the customer feel they are getting a good experience or she won't be successful.

This is standard for the service industry. It's about pleasing the customer.

And if you think that men can tell that women are faking it during sex, it's not even worth having a discussion.
 
Was that in response to me? I guess either that, else Thermal, given these last few posts.

Methinks it was responding to someone the rest of us aren't hearing.

The issue is, as Thermal points out, that some people (I've no idea how common this trait is) are incapable of enjoying sex unless their partner also has a good time.

That's it. And I'm wondering if it's "just me", or how many other posters feel this way. Seems like the right thread to approach the subject. Sex, to me anyway, is a mutual good time, where I'm as focused on my partner's enjoyment as my own. The whole thing about "just give her some money and bend her over because that's what she's for" has an objectifying, rapey vibe that doesn't sit well, more so if she's doing it for cash when lacking better alternatives. College women doing it because "they can't find paying work in their fields" is exactly what I mean.

A guy feels like getting it wet. OK. So find yourself a willing lady and knock yourselves out. It's not even that cumbersome to do anymore in the tinder age. "But I want a smoking hottie that I stand no chance with on my own!" Well, that's objectifying. Not an OK excuse, in my book.

Maybe it's just because we don't have "respectable" brothels in the States, that it's so hard to picture. Over here, hookers are for the true creepshows that stand pretty much no chance if left to their own devices. They pay (and treat women like rentable commodities) because they have no alternatives. Well, not without doing a little soul searching, anyway.

The amusement park employee's pleasure is not the actual main product, in fact as long as her overall demeanor isn't off-putting it is completely irrelevant to the product being offered. But as far as sex workers, and specifically in the case of the subset of people, like Thermal, who are wired not to be able to enjoy sex unless their partner enjoys it too: should this subset use the services of sex workers, and there after a while make clear on what terms they're engaging there: in that case, the pleasure that the provider of the service derives kind of becomes a key part of the actual product being sold. If she were to continue to misrepresent the product she's offering despite that, then that does amount to dishonesty and misrepresentation. And I see no reason to assume sex workers will necessarily be dishonest.

Yeah. When Cinderella is sweet to me at Disney, I'm not trying to slip her my phone number. Or, in keeping with the thread topic, inquiring about her rates :D . Nor do I think the waiter/waitress is into me, or a bartender interested in my day. I just leave them alone and tip well, because I get it.

(Not to beat this to death! It isn't as if I'm a psychiatrist or psychologist or social worker specialized with sex workers or anything like that. But at a surface level, basis simple everyday thinking/reasoning, this seems completely obvious!)

(I'm not going to revisit this again --- unless that is I find someone arguing effectively showing my/our reasoning/position is flawed, in which case, sure, I'll revisit this to take this back, absolutely. But this is no more "pearl-clutching", what Thermal discussed, and I as well,than is your own objection reverse-pearl-clutching, or buttock-clenching, or whatever. Just a statement of how it is for some people, and, given the subject being discussed, an idle thinking-through about about how that might make for those people in the context of using the services of sex workers, is all.)

Just had an epiphany. I think that poster is having an imaginary role play argument, to demonstrate how a prostitute and her client cosplay an activity that's not real. Well demonstrated.
 
Seriously.

I mean, any successful salesman will be able to fake it and make it look like they care. Why would we assume anything different from a prostitute? She has to make the customer feel they are getting a good experience or she won't be successful.

This is standard for the service industry. It's about pleasing the customer.

*very slowly* It's not about whether a service worker is faking it. That would be obvious. It's about why a client would even want a faked experience, when the real is not that flipping hard to come by.

And if you think that men can tell that women are faking it during sex, it's not even worth having a discussion.

There's another interesting response to...something no one is talking about. Are you sure you're on the right thread?
 
Depending on the value of 'a lot'.

I've met women, with good careers, lovely homes, etc. who still work part-time as sex workers.

The reward is apparently far greater than UBI.

I think it's worth noting that the client thinks he's got the girl off, because they fake orgasm and tell the guy he's a magical lover and the best they've ever had.

Add to that the girl is checking the time to make sure he doesn't take too long and keeping the condom in place and it's unlikely she's going to get sexual satisfaction from it.

Do we expect nurses to get enjoyment from changing colostomy bags?



I'm sure none of the women I spoke to would agree.

If UBI were instituted in NZ it would be $40-50k pa, maximum. None of the girls earn anywhere near that paltry an amount - the top earner is over $200k, and I have no reason to doubt her word. Even part timers are earning well over $50k. They can have a high income and great lifestyle hours. UBI is a big fat nothing by comparison.

Sounds like selection bias to me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom