Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, it isn't. It's clearly about what a prostitute does: has sex with other people. Would people in these professions be particularly prone to having "issues stemming from lying, trust, guilt and jealousy"?

Sex work would be a poor choice of profession for anyone who values monogamy, that's for sure.
 
Beats me, probably related to the whole puritanical fear of sex generally, especially non-marital sex, that is common throughout history.

The longevity and continued popularity of the world's oldest profession would seem to negate that, and pretty universally.
 
The longevity and continued popularity of the world's oldest profession would seem to negate that, and pretty universally.

And it has been stigmatized for much of that time in many cultures.

Don't play dumb. Plenty of things are stigmatized but remain popular. The War on Drugs is a great example of a total failure of stigma to actually eliminate the stigmatized behavior.
 
To put it more succinctly, as I have been saying since the beginning of the thread: people seem entirely supportive of prostitution for "others". Not so much when it is suggested that they or someone they value is on the..ahem...supply end. Then it's all "GTFOOH, not me or my kids". That throws light on what people really think of the work. As dann more eloquently put it, the subtext is that prostitutes are second class citizens. Not something I'm cool with. I'm not going to sit here and say the work is fine for your kid, but not for mine. And I was fine with one of my daughters literally cleaning toilets as part of managing a sundry shop as a teen.
 
Last edited:
And it has been stigmatized for much of that time in many cultures.

Don't play dumb. Plenty of things are stigmatized but remain popular. The War on Drugs is a great example of a total failure of stigma to actually eliminate the stigmatized behavior.

No, I'm saying that puritanical prudishness is not the root of the fairly universal stigma. All.of history and the planets cultures do not have our relatively recent hangups
 
No, I'm saying that puritanical prudishness is not the root of the fairly universal stigma. All.of history and the planets cultures do not have our relatively recent hangups

Are you suggesting that prostitution is universally stigmatized?
 
To put it more succinctly, as I have been saying since the beginning of the thread: people seem entirely supportive of prostitution for "others". Not so much when it is suggested that they or someone they value is on the..ahem...supply end. Then it's all "GTFOOH, not me or my kids". That throws light on what people really think of the work. As dann more eloquently put it, the subtext is that prostitutes are second class citizens. Not something I'm cool with. I'm not going to sit here and say the work is fine for your kid, but not for mine. And I was fine with one of my daughters literally cleaning toilets as part of managing a sundry shop as a teen.

I can think of a lot of professions I would be squeamish about.

Edit: While having a menial job is often seen as a rite of passage for teens entering adulthood, somehow I doubt you'd be less pleased if your daughters were still cleaning toilets for trash wages well into their adulthood, getting dicked around by a boss with irregular scheduling and all the other exploitative practices that are common in some of the lowest wage jobs. And yet many adults are still performing menial labor for peanuts and expected to live in poverty.
 
Last edited:
I can think of a lot of professions I would be squeamish about

Me too. Not many that are as casually easy and well paying as the one under discussion though. None that would be off the table, certainly, were I in need of a good paying gig with no training needed.

Are you so financially well off that you couldn't use some easy extra cash? Should we be re-educating the homeless about this entrpeneureal career opportunity?

Eta: got me on the edit again: so you are saying that prostitution is practical as an entry level gig for teen girls now? Not being snarky, that's how your comment reads.
 
Last edited:
Me too. Not many that are as casually easy and well paying as the one under discussion though. None that would be off the table, certainly.

Are you so financially well off that you couldn't use some easy extra cash? Should we be re-educating the homeless about this entrpeneureal career opportunity?

You assume being a well paid sex worker is easy, but I suspect it's much harder than you suppose. I'm not very good with people and probably don't have the social skills required to run a hot dog stand at Disney, much less manage the expectations of expensive clients.
 
Eta: got me on the edit again: so you are saying that prostitution is practical as an entry level gig for teen girls now? Not being snarky, that's how your comment reads.

No, I'm saying your standards are warped because working a bad job that doesn't pay much is often seen as acceptable for teens still living mostly off their parents, but the same jobs are seen as grossly inadequate for adults who are trying to live independently.

Again, I dispute your claim that all sex workers find easy success.
 
Last edited:
You assume being a well paid sex worker is easy, but I suspect it's much harder than you suppose. I'm not very good with people and probably don't have the social skills required to run a hot dog stand at Disney, much less manage the expectations of expensive clients.

I think it is likely easier than I suppose, but my barometer for entry level work is gaged by emergency room visits.

Passable people skills are an incredibly common trait, especially with young women. Like you, I am not good with people and would make a lousy gigolo. But I doubt that call girl level role playing is being required by the average client paying $100-150 per smash (iirc the going rates from well upthread).
 
I think it is likely easier than I suppose, but my barometer for entry level work is gaged by emergency room visits.

Passable people skills are an incredibly common trait, especially with young women. Like you, I am not good with people and would make a lousy gigolo. But I doubt that call girl level role playing is being required by the average client paying $100-150 per smash (iirc the going rates from well upthread).

I don't think either of us have the information to make any such conclusions about how easy it is to make a living this way.

Setting yourself up as a 150 per visit call girl may be easy enough, but reliably filling your schedule with safe, reliable paying, and repeat clients without getting arrested may be less simple. It's like any other small business I suppose. Hanging up your shingle is easy, actually attracting enough business to be viable is the hard part.

Edit: i'm reminded of the reports from the self-published, subscription porn site OnlyFans. There's a small minority making a lot of money, and a huge amount making basically nothing (probably before giving up). I believe the figure I saw was that the average sex worker there was only pulling like $150 a month or so, probably not even worth the effort.
 
Last edited:
No, I'm saying your standards are warped because working a bad job that doesn't pay much is often seen as acceptable for teens still living mostly off their parents, but the same jobs are seen as grossly inadequate for adults who are trying to live independently.

Not clear on how a living wage argument is factoring in here? My kid pulled $20/hr and worked long days. Not exactly poverty wages. She could have made much more in far less time smoking pole, if I am understanding the logic here. Did she choose well? I certainly think so.

Again, I dispute your claim that all sex workers find easy success.

It has been claimed repeatedly that a sex worker in Oceana is pulling well north of $50k part time, and up to $200k. The US model is probably not the best to compare to, given the overrepresentation by streetwalkers and rub-and-tugs, due to illegality.
 
Not clear on how a living wage argument is factoring in here? My kid pulled $20/hr and worked long days. Not exactly poverty wages. She could have made much more in far less time smoking pole, if I am understanding the logic here. Did she choose well? I certainly think so.



It has been claimed repeatedly that a sex worker in Oceana is pulling well north of $50k part time, and up to $200k. The US model is probably not the best to compare to, given the overrepresentation by streetwalkers and rub-and-tugs, due to illegality.

Again, pointing out that individual sex workers are very successful does not demonstrate that this is an easy or likely outcome.

For all we know, $20/hr with full time employment may well have been more than a hypothetical inexperienced sex worker could have managed to make.
 
Last edited:
I don't think either of us have the information to make any such conclusions about how easy it is to make a living this way.

Setting yourself up as a 150 per visit call girl may be easy enough, but reliably filling your schedule with safe, reliable paying, and repeat clients without getting arrested may be less simple. It's like any other small business I suppose. Hanging up your shingle is easy, actually attracting enough business to be viable is the hard part.

Edit: i'm reminded of the reports from the self-published, subscription porn site OnlyFans. There's a small minority making a lot of money, and a huge amount making basically nothing (probably before giving up). I believe the figure I saw was that the average sex worker there was only pulling like $150 a month or so, probably not even worth the effort.

But very importantly: the OF subscribers are not smashing her. They are whacking it solo and paying to text the woman, which makes no sense to me either.
 
But very importantly: the OF subscribers are not smashing her. They are whacking it solo and paying to text the woman, which makes no sense to me either.

There are degrees of sex work, but sure. Though I very much get the impression that some of these OF people are mixing in a bit of straight up in-person sex work for some of their more open-wallet subscribers, but that's neither here nor there.

I really have no idea how easy it is to make a decent income as a sex worker. Some people seem to really make it work well, but that's like pointing to Brad Pitt and assuming making a living as an actor is a breeze. The losers aren't going on the internet to tell everyone how little money they made before throwing in the towel and getting a different job.

You'd really need a comprehensive survey of sex workers across, not just cherry picking the mega-successful ones to know. I have my doubts it's such a guaranteed path to easy street.
 
Last edited:
Some of these sex workers seem to be basically the exception to the rule, and it is no coincidence that this exception is what defenders of the sex industry usually refer to in their defense of the industry as a whole: the 'Happy Hooker'.

Sure, I suppose if you assume all prostitutes are drug addled broken people incapable of making their own decisions and all clients are perverts incapable of normal human contact I'd follow your position.

Now I do not deny that drug use is a part of the culture, but in a legal framework you'd actually counteract that as you can get sex workers that are in such a state help.

Part of me is just also realistic. The demand is there. In countries where sex work is illegal the position of prostitutes is far worse than in a country where it is legal. Moreso in countries where drug/alcohol are also illegal, yet prostitution still exists there. And often the authorities in those countries abuse sex workers while ignoring their plight if they would normally seek help.

Claiming prostitution is evil but then decrying any attempt to improve the profession because it is not perfect is maybe a moral high ground, but eventually pointless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom