Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
*very slowly* It's not about whether a service worker is faking it. That would be obvious. It's about why a client would even want a faked experience, when the real is not that flipping hard to come by.



There's another interesting response to...something no one is talking about. Are you sure you're on the right thread?

Seems like I anticipated your response perfectly.
 
Seems like I anticipated your response perfectly.

OK, I'll try to fill in your imaginary protagonist's argument a bit:

Do you think its not obvious to anyone that a waiter is paid to be polite and friendly to customers? I think that's common knowledge, and indeed expected. The customer is always right and all that. Yet you seem to disagree? Or was your imaginary protagonist arguing something else?
 
*very slowly* It's not about whether a service worker is faking it. That would be obvious. It's about why a client would even want a faked experience, when the real is not that flipping hard to come by.

Movies: A faked experience. You're seeing action happen through the camera, action of a type that you are unlikely to ever be involve in ... LOTS of people go to movies.

Video Games: A faked experience. You're involved in action in which you could probably never be involved in real life; race car driver, fighter pilot, Seal Team Six member, astronaut, etc ... LOTS of people play video games.

Paintball/Laser Tag: A faked experience. Again you're involved in action, this time in person, that mimics real-life action in which you could probably never be involved in real life; the bullets aren't real ... LOTS of people play paintball.
 
OK, I'll try to fill in your imaginary protagonist's argument a bit:

Do you think its not obvious to anyone that a waiter is paid to be polite and friendly to customers? I think that's common knowledge, and indeed expected. The customer is always right and all that. Yet you seem to disagree? Or was your imaginary protagonist arguing something else?

They are... but they still do their job. People still apply for jobs as waiters, and no-one works themselves into a moral tizzy about it... This holds true when you substitute "waiter" with "barman" or "chef" or "plumber" or "electrician" or any other trade or job..... except for "sex-worker"... the moment you mention "sex-worker" the moralizing Mary Whitehouses if this world proceed to get their panties in a bunch in very short order
 
Methinks it was responding to someone the rest of us aren't hearing.



That's it. And I'm wondering if it's "just me", or how many other posters feel this way. Seems like the right thread to approach the subject. Sex, to me anyway, is a mutual good time, where I'm as focused on my partner's enjoyment as my own. The whole thing about "just give her some money and bend her over because that's what she's for" has an objectifying, rapey vibe that doesn't sit well, more so if she's doing it for cash when lacking better alternatives. College women doing it because "they can't find paying work in their fields" is exactly what I mean.

A guy feels like getting it wet. OK. So find yourself a willing lady and knock yourselves out. It's not even that cumbersome to do anymore in the tinder age. "But I want a smoking hottie that I stand no chance with on my own!" Well, that's objectifying. Not an OK excuse, in my book.

Maybe it's just because we don't have "respectable" brothels in the States, that it's so hard to picture. Over here, hookers are for the true creepshows that stand pretty much no chance if left to their own devices. They pay (and treat women like rentable commodities) because they have no alternatives. Well, not without doing a little soul searching, anyway.



Yeah. When Cinderella is sweet to me at Disney, I'm not trying to slip her my phone number. Or, in keeping with the thread topic, inquiring about her rates :D . Nor do I think the waiter/waitress is into me, or a bartender interested in my day. I just leave them alone and tip well, because I get it.



Just had an epiphany. I think that poster is having an imaginary role play argument, to demonstrate how a prostitute and her client cosplay an activity that's not real. Well demonstrated.

Sex work in the US runs the gamut. Some of it is quite tawdry, where the sex workers are engaged in joyless, mechanical like work, and sometimes sex workers have short lists of repeat clients who treat them quite well and have a good rapport. Some sex work is entirely about this relationship, or examples like OnlyFans for online porn which is heavily about parasocial relationships that occur behind the paywall (after all, the internet is full of free porn of all sorts, there's really no reason to pay unless you want to interact more with the creators)

You shouldn't assume that sex work is totally represented by the drug addicted street walker with dead eyes offering $20 blowjobs in the alley.
 
Last edited:
Movies: A faked experience. You're seeing action happen through the camera, action of a type that you are unlikely to ever be involve in ... LOTS of people go to movies.

100% passive, with the exception of maybe Rocky Horror. You could just as well compare to reading a novel. Not exactly comparable to actually banging a sex worker.

Video Games: A faked experience. You're involved in action in which you could probably never be involved in real life; race car driver, fighter pilot, Seal Team Six member, astronaut, etc ... LOTS of people play video games.

99.5% passive. Also a more understandable choice for faking it, as very few of us actually get to be astronauts or SEALs.

Paintball/Laser Tag: A faked experience. Again you're involved in action, this time in person, that mimics real-life action in which you could probably never be involved in real life; the bullets aren't real ... LOTS of people play paintball.

Finally an actual experience, but a substitutive one. You'd kind of all be dead if you were using real bullets, so the fake version is the only real alternative. Not so with sex, that only requires a willing and able partner.

I get your point, though. People like to engage in fantasy, and many, many do so. But to say "I really want to put a hot girl on all fours that I can't manage to do on my own" is not fantasy; it's objectification, and I maintain a bit of a problem with that.

Eta: passivity is not comparable because it's not physical, but imaginary. More equivalent to watching porn in context here
 
Last edited:
They are... but they still do their job. People still apply for jobs as waiters, and no-one works themselves into a moral tizzy about it... This holds true when you substitute "waiter" with "barman" or "chef" or "plumber" or "electrician" or any other trade or job..... except for "sex-worker"... the moment you mention "sex-worker" the moralizing Mary Whitehouses if this world proceed to get their panties in a bunch in very short order

Sounds strange. Can't imagine why they would think so. You're saying that people get upset at the notion that a sex worker puts on a bit of an act? Well...they'd be out of the ******* business (literally) if they were scrolling Twitter or jotting grocery lists while getting plowed, I'd think.

Eta: also disagreed that plumbers are paid to be polite, or in fact be human. They are arrogant and vile creatures
 
Last edited:
Sex work in the US runs the gamut. Some of it is quite tawdry, where the sex workers are engaged in joyless, mechanical like work, and sometimes sex workers have short lists of repeat clients who treat them quite well and have a good rapport. Some sex work is entirely about this relationship, or examples like OnlyFans for online porn which is heavily about parasocial relationships that occur behind the paywall (after all, the internet is full of free porn of all sorts, there's really no reason to pay unless you want to interact more with the creators)

You shouldn't assume that sex work is totally represented by the drug addicted street walker with dead eyes offering $20 blowjobs in the alley.

$20, you say?
 
I bet if you instituted a universal basic income, you'd be immediately discover a lot fewer women opting into sex work.

Nobody in this thread is renting out their genitals for the fun of it, instead of or in addition to their actual source of income.

they would just ask for more money.
and more people would be able to afford it
 
I don’t know. That’s always possible, sure. But to broad-brush generalize like that seems a bit …cynical?

I haven't actually spoken with a sex worker ever, so, well, I base this only on general principles and nothing else: but I don’t think it’s right that sex workers would necessarily be dishonest, and that people who use their services necessarily dumb!


No, not necessarily. I think willing suspension of disbelief would be a better term for it.

I have spoken with three prostitutes, two in Cuba, one in the Canaries. The conversations were very short. They offered their 'services', and I told them I wasn't interested.
Two of them were black. They both accused me of being a racist, which was pretty weird since I didn't say or do anything that could be interpreted as racism other than declining what they were offering. I assume it is a trick of the trade for prostitutes of color: It will allow a john who feels tempted but has scruples to tell himself that he accepts the offer in order to prove to her that he is not a racist.
 
*very slowly* It's not about whether a service worker is faking it. That would be obvious. It's about why a client would even want a faked experience, when the real is not that flipping hard to come by.


There's another interesting response to...something no one is talking about. Are you sure you're on the right thread?

I disagree with this quite a bit. For a lot of people it's not in any way simple to get a relation to the point of intimacy.
Sure if you're a (semi) good looking or at least well groomed extroverted individual that can handle rejection the dating scene might seem the easiest way, but that is not the case for everyone.

There are also many people in a relation where their libido's are vastly different where one party still enjoys sex and the other does not.

Or whose relation ended and who do not desire a new relation, but do like the physical act of sex.
Masturbation can only replace that partially.

Now personally I also do not feel comfortable making use of a prostitutes services for the same reason as you, but my feelings are irrelevant, apparently there are enough people who do not mind and as long as this is consentual, what's the harm?
 
I disagree with this quite a bit. For a lot of people it's not in any way simple to get a relation to the point of intimacy.
Sure if you're a (semi) good looking or at least well groomed extroverted individual that can handle rejection the dating scene might seem the easiest way, but that is not the case for everyone.
Oh my lordy yes. I am constantly astounded, given my levels of introversion and social anxiety, that I have had the action that I've had in my life.
 
They are... but they still do their job. People still apply for jobs as waiters, and no-one works themselves into a moral tizzy about it... This holds true when you substitute "waiter" with "barman" or "chef" or "plumber" or "electrician" or any other trade or job..... except for "sex-worker"... the moment you mention "sex-worker" the moralizing Mary Whitehouses if this world proceed to get their panties in a bunch in very short order


Is is not as if the it's-a-job-like-any-other crowd don't get their panties in a bunch when it is pointed out to them that waiters, barmen, chefs, plumbers, electricians, pilots and air hostesses don't usually have to perform fellatio as part of their services.

I recommend that you don't ask the air hostess for that kind of 'service' the next time you're on a passenger plane.

Germany has legal brothels, and yet:
Dass das Arbeitsamt niemanden in die Prostitution vermittelt, findet Pingler besonders in Bezug auf Hartz IV wichtig: "Da heißt es: Jede Stelle, die nicht sittenwidrig ist, ist zumutbar. Wenn man die Regelung nicht hätte, würde das im Umkehrschluss bedeuten, dass die Arbeitslosen Schwierigkeiten bekommen würden, wenn sie eine Stelle als Prostituierte nicht annehmen würden."
Kein Job wie jeder andere (DW, Dec 24, 2006)
Pingler finds it important that the employment office does not place anyone in prostitution, especially with regard to Hartz IV: "It says: Any job that is not immoral is reasonable. If you didn't have the regulation, that would mean, by implication, that the unemployed would get in trouble if they didn't take a job as a prostitute."
Not a job like any other

Sittenwidrig is a stupid word in this context and Google's translation into immoral makes it worse.
 
I disagree with this quite a bit. For a lot of people it's not in any way simple to get a relation to the point of intimacy.
Sure if you're a (semi) good looking or at least well groomed extroverted individual that can handle rejection the dating scene might seem the easiest way, but that is not the case for everyone.

There are also many people in a relation where their libido's are vastly different where one party still enjoys sex and the other does not.

Or whose relation ended and who do not desire a new relation, but do like the physical act of sex.
Masturbation can only replace that partially.
Now personally I also do not feel comfortable making use of a prostitutes services for the same reason as you, but my feelings are irrelevant, apparently there are enough people who do not mind and as long as this is consentual, what's the harm?


Are you saying that prostitution can replace that fully?!

Economic coercion is still coercion even if it forces some people to 'consent' to having sex with people they don't like, don't feel sexually attracted to and don't enjoy having sex with.
But I guess you see it as convenient that people who "like the physical act of sex" aren't inconvenienced by having to find somebody to have it with who would actually "like the physical act" of having it with them.
That's the point of poverty in a market economy. And that's the harm.
 
Last edited:
Are you saying that prostitution can replace that fully?!

Economic coercion is still coercion even if it forces some people to 'consent' to having sex with people they don't like, don't feel sexually attracted to and don't enjoy having sex with.
But I guess you see it as convenient that people who "like the physical act of sex" aren't inconvenienced by having to find somebody to have it with who would actually "like the physical act" of having it with them.
That's the point of poverty in a market economy. And that's the harm.

Frankly, yes I do think that helps, provided the there is consent and someone not willing to become a prostitute can survive, hence why I support full legalization and social security / UBI.

I guess in some post-scarcity utopia where everyone is always able to find their soulmate(s) the moment they want the profession would vanish, but since that is not the case.
A legal prostitute can simply not take a client they do not want and quit if they decide that the emotional component it becoming too much.
 
Is is not as if the it's-a-job-like-any-other crowd don't get their panties in a bunch when it is pointed out to them that waiters, barmen, chefs, plumbers, electricians, pilots and air hostesses don't usually have to perform fellatio as part of their services.

I recommend that you don't ask the air hostess for that kind of 'service' the next time you're on a passenger plane.

I assume sex workers would just as likely be annoyed if a client made a request that exceeded the clearly understood scope of their work, whatever that may be.

It's the classic "clueless rube at the stripclub asks a dancer out for a date" scenario.
 
Are you saying that prostitution can replace that fully?!

Economic coercion is still coercion even if it forces some people to 'consent' to having sex with people they don't like, don't feel sexually attracted to and don't enjoy having sex with.
But I guess you see it as convenient that people who "like the physical act of sex" aren't inconvenienced by having to find somebody to have it with who would actually "like the physical act" of having it with them.
That's the point of poverty in a market economy. And that's the harm.

I guess the question is whether or not there's a meaningful distinction between sex workers being subject to economic coercion and pretty much every other wage worker who also go to jobs they don't really care for because they need money to pay their bills.

The number of people with fun jobs that they'd probably do for free if money were no object is quite small, I suspect. I like my job, I'm pretty good at it, and it's quite comfortable, but I'd quit tomorrow if I hit the lottery and didn't have to ever worry about money again.

Are sex workers selling their bodies any more than a construction worker blowing out their knees lugging bags of concrete? Are they suffering blows to their dignity any more than any other customer facing support worker who often has to deal with abusive and crass clients?

One thing I've noticed is that some sex work, like the mostly false promise of getting rich on OnlyFans or whatever, is often attractive because it offers an alternative to lower paid drudgery work. Doing sex work may strike some as more dignified and lucrative than getting screamed at by some small business tyrant working in fast food or whatever other work may be available at any given time.

Taking on a ****** job while pursuing higher education or job training or whatever is common right of passage for younger people, and I imagine a good bit of sex work is not long term and probably pays better than bar backing in some college town.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom