Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, it's back to that argument, isn't it?! 'But she gets paid to do it, so everything is fine.'
As for your other comparisons, not even the ordinary kind of masseuse, the kind who rubs your back and whose job comes close to physical therapy, sucks your ****. And the shoe salesman doesn't usually put shoes on people's feet in his spare time for pleasure. Nor do other people.

As Thermal has been trying to tell you that is the major difference between prostitution and the jobs you describe, even the ones with some level of physical intimacy like massage.
Pretending that there is no difference takes some effort on your part to make it work.

There is ALWAYS a difference. Even the other jobs I mentioned are different from everything else. That is never the question. The question is where is the line?

Claiming "Prostitution is different from other jobs" isn't addressing the point. A waiter does not have to clean toilets, either. To claim that one is considered acceptable and the other is not is just begging the question of why.
 
You say it yourself though, the objection is less about sex work and more about menial work generally and a lack of real agency for the most impoverished.

I'd hate to see my imagined children getting taken advantage as some under-the-table, poorly paid general laborer being exploited by some unscrupulous general contractor. There's plenty of exploitative labor practices in the non sex-work industries too, so focusing specifically on those that occur in the sex work industry seems like missing the broader point about poverty and the inherently exploitative nature of capitalism and the alienation of labor and so on.

People in dire poverty and/or with substance abuse issues being taken advantage of to perform menial jobs for starvation wages is generally an abhorrent practice, but one that is universal and does not only apply to the sex work industry.


No, I don't say it's more about one and less about another.
The universality of the conditions of poor people and the alternatives they are offered is the scandal.
You are one of the few defenders of prostitution in this thread that I think might be able to recognize that the conditions that make some people see prostitution as an alternative to being taken advantage of in other "exploitative labor practices" doesn't really work as a recommendation of the "sex-work industries." On the contrary.

'But people are also taken advantage of in "non sex-work industries"' is a particularly weird kind of what-aboutism in defense of prostitution as 'a job like any other'.
 
No, I don't say it's more about one and less about another.
The universality of the conditions of poor people and the alternatives they are offered is the scandal.
You are one of the few defenders of prostitution in this thread that I think might be able to recognize that the conditions that make some people see prostitution as an alternative to being taken advantage of in other "exploitative labor practices" doesn't really work as a recommendation of the "sex-work industries." On the contrary.

'But people are also taken advantage of in "non sex-work industries"' is a particularly weird kind of what-aboutism in defense of prostitution as 'a job like any other'.

My point is that my ethical qualms about sex work are not intrinsic to sex work, but instead are about poverty and exploitative labor practices which can apply to many industries.

I really don't have any issue with well compensated, "white collar" sex work per se. So long as the workers involved are making a reasonably free decision with reasonable alternatives then it's not an issue to me.

Some of these sex workers seem to be basically sole proprietors of their entire operation, which strikes me as being less exploitative than the masses of people selling their labor to capitalists under unfavorable terms.
 
There is ALWAYS a difference. Even the other jobs I mentioned are different from everything else. That is never the question. The question is where is the line?

Claiming "Prostitution is different from other jobs" isn't addressing the point. A waiter does not have to clean toilets, either. To claim that one is considered acceptable and the other is not is just begging the question of why.


The difference between prostitution and the other jobs is clear: In the other jobs, they don't have to suck your ****. Your effort to abstract from the actual difference is obvious when you come up with the argument that there are differences in general between different jobs.

On the other hand, it is no coincidence that you choose cleaning toilets as the alternative to prostitution: a job that may also be unpleasant to some extent. That it isn't an activity that people usually engage in for mutual pleasure with people they love doesn't seem to occur to you.

And depending on the establishment, waiters may sometimes be asked to clean toilets and maybe get paid extra if they do. To suck *****, very, very rarely, and I think they can sue if it is even suggested.
 
My point is that my ethical qualms about sex work are not intrinsic to sex work, but instead are about poverty and exploitative labor practices which can apply to many industries.

I really don't have any issue with well compensated, "white collar" sex work per se. So long as the workers involved are making a reasonably free decision with reasonable alternatives then it's not an issue to me.

Some of these sex workers seem to be basically sole proprietors of their entire operation, which strikes me as being less exploitative than the masses of people selling their labor to capitalists under unfavorable terms.


Some of these sex workers seem to be basically the exception to the rule, and it is no coincidence that this exception is what defenders of the sex industry usually refer to in their defense of the industry as a whole: the 'Happy Hooker'.
 
Some of these sex workers seem to be basically the exception to the rule, and it is no coincidence that this exception is what defenders of the sex industry usually refer to in their defense of the industry as a whole: the 'Happy Hooker'.

Well yeah, I concede that it's hard to imagine any low cost prostitution existing that's ethical. I suppose in my ideal world the entire industry would contract quite a bit if you removed the supply of the most extremely exploited sex workers.

That said, I'd say the same of the current US agricultural system, which relies heavily on underpaid migrants of dubious citizenship status. One could imagine an agricultural system that doesn't rely entirely on exploiting Central and South American migrant laborers, so I wouldn't assert that farming is an inherently unethical industry just because that's the form it currently takes in the US.

It seems more coherent to attack certain exploitative practices than to write off entire industries as inherently sinful and unredeemable.
 
Last edited:
People who have service type jobs often still perform these services for their friends and romantic partners and it's pretty obvious that there's a distinction between professional clients and an act of service motivated by generosity or friendship or romantic feeling.

A masseuse might give their romantic partner a massage for free and it has a totally different valence than when performing the same act as a commodified service.


Are you trying to tell us that prostitutes suck ***** for her friends and relatives motivated by generosity?
Come on! You know better than this!
 
Are you trying to tell us that prostitutes suck ***** for her friends and relatives motivated by generosity?
Come on! You know better than this!

I'm saying a prostitute might engage in sex acts with a romantic partner for free and otherwise have normal romantic and sexual lives outside their work, just like other people who aren't sex workers.
 
Well yeah, I concede that it's hard to imagine any low cost prostitution existing that's ethical. I suppose in my ideal world the entire industry would contract quite a bit if you removed the supply of the most extremely exploited sex workers.

That said, I'd say the same of the current US agricultural system, which relies heavily on underpaid migrants of dubious citizenship status. One could imagine an agricultural system that doesn't rely entirely on exploiting Central and South American migrant laborers, so I wouldn't assert that farming is an inherently unethical industry just because that's the form it currently takes in the US.

It seems more coherent to attack certain exploitative practices than to write off entire industries as inherently sinful and unredeemable.


In Denmark, they are usually from Eastern Europe. So are many of the prostitutes, I think, in particular the trafficked ones.
And just to make absolutely sure that we agree on this: You do know that hobby gardening for fun, even to help a friend, is very different from agricultural exploitation, don't you?!
 
I'm saying a prostitute might engage in sex acts with a romantic partner for free and otherwise have normal romantic and sexual lives outside their work, just like other people who aren't sex workers.


That's a mighty big might, and I don't think you have actually looked into this!

Most women (78%) reported that, overall, sex work affected their personal romantic relationships in predominantly negative ways, mainly relating to issues stemming from lying, trust, guilt and jealousy. A small number of women reported positive impacts from sex work including improved sexual self-esteem and confidence. Just under half of women were in a relationship at the time of the study and, of these, 51% reported their partner was aware of the nature of their work. Seventy-seven percent of single women chose to remain single due to the nature of their work. Many women used mental separation as a coping mechanism to manage the tensions between sex work and their personal relationships. Member checking validated the accuracy of the questionnaire data.
The Impact of Sex Work on Women’s Personal Romantic Relationships and the Mental Separation of Their Work and Personal Lives: A Mixed-Methods Study (PubMed 2015)
 
That's a mighty big might, and I don't think you have actually looked into this!

Seems like most of the issues seem to stem from the stigma of sex work rather than the sex work itself.

Seems like a vicious feedback loop to point to the consequences of a stigma to support the stigma itself. Most of the comments in Table 3 seem to reflect a fear that male partners in their life would react poorly to knowing they were sex workers, though some seem to indicate a level of internalized shame about the work.

But sure, I expect that it's not great to be a sex worker and constantly feel like you need to lie about being a sex worker, even in places where such work is legal and regulated. Perhaps it's impossible for this kind of work to ever be destigmatized, I don't know.
 
Last edited:
Seems like most of the issues seem to stem from the stigma of sex work rather than the sex work itself.


No, it doesn't. It says explicitly that it is "mainly relating to issues stemming from lying, trust, guilt and jealousy." And that would only be the 23% who were in a relationship. Does the need for "mental separation as a coping mechanism" sound as if it is due to "the stigma of sex work rather than the sex work itself"?

Seems like a vicious feedback loop to point to the consequences of a stigma to support the stigma itself.


You are the one who claims that it's caused by the stigma and not the activity of prostitution itself. Can you come up with any studies to make it at least seem likely?

By the way, my hairdressing mother occasionally cut the hair of friends and family. I never heard her mention having to use "mental separation as a coping mechanism" when doing so. Feel free to think that this is because hairdressing isn't stigmatized, but I think there is reason to assume that it is because cutting people's hair isn't usually quite as intimate and emotional as sucking people's *****.
 
No, it doesn't. It says explicitly that it is "mainly relating to issues stemming from lying, trust, guilt and jealousy." And that would only be the 23% who were in a relationship. Does the need for "mental separation as a coping mechanism" sound as if it is due to "the stigma of sex work rather than the sex work itself"?

They "lying, trust, guilt, and jealousy" component is clearly about how potential male partners might react to them being sex workers, aka stigma.
 
Are you trying to say something here or just stating the obvious. Do you dispute that stigma is an important factor in society?

No, I am just entertained by watching others bobbing and weaving around an issue.

Why do you suppose there is a stigma attached to it at all?
 
Last edited:
No, I am just entertained by watching others bobbing and weaving around an issue.

Why do you suppose there is a stigma attached to it at all?

I suspect an "appeal to popularity" is afoot.

There's a stigma because a lot of people seem to think sex work is bad, ranging from mildly distasteful to outright immoral.

The history of sexual stigmas is quite mixed, so it's probably best to plainly state your objection.
 
Last edited:
They "lying, trust, guilt, and jealousy" component is clearly about how potential male partners might react to them being sex workers, aka stigma.


No, it isn't. It's clearly about what a prostitute does: has sex with other people. Would people in these professions be particularly prone to having "issues stemming from lying, trust, guilt and jealousy"?

For example, jobs relating to animal control, corrections, and addiction counseling could be perceived as either physically or socially tainted. These occupations are extremely important and valuable occupations for society, but since there can be stigmas attached to them, it can make it difficult to both retain current employees and recruit new ones.
Rise of Employees In Stigmatized Occupations (June 26, 2018)


This one's from Quora ... and India:
My vote goes to such professions which are in fact frowned upon in India, but respected abroad as it involves dignity of labour.
1. Sweeper/washerman/garbage collector/window cleanerWhich jobs/professions, while being useful and also essential, still unfairly carry a social stigma? (Quora)


(I also think that the Indian has misunderstood something about 'abroad': Those four professions aren't respected in Western countries.
I'll admit that I am wrong about this when I hear about a Disney series where the Hannah Montana character is a sweeper/washerwoman/garbage collector/window cleaner instead of a famous pop singer, a superhero or a princess.)
 
Last edited:
I suspect an "appeal to popularity" is afoot.

There's a stigma because a lot of people seem to think sex work is bad, ranging from mildly distasteful to outright immoral.

The history of sexual stigmas is quite mixed, so it's probably best to plainly state your objection.

Reasoning is independent of popularity.

Eta: your edit appeared as I was posting.

Saying "because people think sex work is bad" is just restating that there is a stigma. I asked why the stigma would exist in the first place
 
Last edited:
Reasoning is independent of popularity.

Eta: your edit appeared as I was posting.

Saying "because people think sex work is bad" is just restating that there is a stigma. I asked why the stigma would exist in the first place

Beats me, probably related to the whole puritanical fear of sex generally, especially non-marital sex, that is common throughout history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom