Prostitution

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your bank still uses paper? Jeez. I haven't had to fill out a withdrawal slip since the ATM was invented.

No paper withdrawals for me either, except for the times I need more than the machine can dispense per day. Deposits can be made via ATM, and takes an extra day or so in processing time to be credited to the account, but half the time my local machine is down or out of envelopes, so I go inside.

In my biz, maybe a third or so of my customers prefer to deal in cash. It's actually a little annoying, because if they give me a paper check, I can scan it on my mobile banking app and the deposit is done. Cash has to be walked to the brick and mortar joint.
 
The following has all been explained previously at various times, so here we go again :rolleyes:

Firstly, your idea of simple registration resulting in some kind if national database of sex-workers would be a non-starter - it would fail right out of the gate. Why? Because there have been far too many data breaches over the years, many of them government ones, with people's personal data such as medical records and social security records getting into the clear. I can't see sex-workers trusting officials with their personal data. Most of them would rather work illegally and unregistered for cash, than register with the government and risk their personal details being revealed.

Fair point, data breaches revealing personal information are a legitimate threat. But wait; isn't pretty much all of our information already on a variety of data bases here in the 21st century? Tax and social Security information are both online, banking is online, credit cards, amazon...the list of online databases that can be breached goes on and on. The one I am proposing is the same one used by contractors of all types all over NJ, and has never been breached. So I'd say it's as safe, or safer, as any other database that we all use.

Secondly, some kind of special registration for sex-workers is not necessary anyway, at least in New Zealand, because it would be entirely redundant...

Ok, again, fair observation. But keep in mind, I am not talking about applying this proposed model in New Zealand. You guys have a system that works for you already. Great! High-fives all around. But I think the US would fare better with a less trusting setup.

Arthwollipot mentioned collectivism versus individualism as societal descriptors, and I agree. I said way back ITT that I think there are crucial cultural differences (not America is "special"; just different) at play. When Australia experienced the horror of Port Arthur, they reacted very differently compared to how the US reacted to Sandy Hook. I think the aggressive individualism here is better kept in check by the stricter registration that I am suggesting.
 
Then the law is irrelevant. Your constant hammering on about how super-perfect US law is is utterly irrelevant. It doesn't matter at all how good the laws are, or what model of law is in place, if people are going to break the law.

The above is an absolute textbook Perfect Solution Fallacy.

I am not insane: again, stop the personal attacks. This is becoming tiresome.

Again with the reading too much in. I am not calling you insane. If you punch up "sane definition", as I just did on my phone using Firefox mobile, the second common use definition is "having or showing sound judgement;reasonable". Merriam-Webster, in it's first definition, says "RATIONAL". That is a very common usage, and how I meant it. You are bending over backwards to act offended, now.

Let's get this straight, then:
You don't approve of the Australian laws because some people there may be working without licences.

No, that is not at all what I said and is factually untrue.

You contrasted this with the US, where you said it was impossible for people to work without licences.

No, that is not at all what I said and is factually untrue. I also just clarified that for you at length in the post you are quoting, so there is no fig leaf to hide behind.

You are now saying that it is possible for people in the US to work without licences.
You have thus shot down your own argument, such as it was.
Correct?

No, that is not at all what was said and is factually untrue.

No. What is happening is that you say something, I ask you to supply evidence, then you angrily proclaim that you never said any such thing, and only a madman could possibly have read your words to mean exactly what they say, and round we go again.
You have been doing this repeatedly, and I have no doubt we will see more in the future.

As I said, I went into this one in detail because it is so representative of our conflict. Since you seem to think you are ducking it, let's try it again:

You said that I claimed there were no contractors working in NJ without licenses. As proof, you quoted where I said that in order to be a legal contractor, you must be registered.

I am asking you again to explain how your factually untrue extrapolation follows from my entirely true statement. If you refuse to address this, there is no point in continuing this exchange.
 
Fair point, data breaches revealing personal information are a legitimate threat. But wait; isn't pretty much all of our information already on a variety of data bases here in the 21st century? Tax and social Security information are both online, banking is online, credit cards, amazon...the list of online databases that can be breached goes on and on. The one I am proposing is the same one used by contractors of all types all over NJ, and has never been breached. So I'd say it's as safe, or safer, as any other database that we all use.

Inland Revenue does not get hacked, they just don't. They have the occasional data beach, usually by someone sharing some personal information in an insecure way, but they have never been hacked from the outside and had the personal data of tens of thousand of people shared publicly. Neither has ACC.

Ok, again, fair observation. But keep in mind, I am not talking about applying this proposed model in New Zealand. You guys have a system that works for you already. Great! High-fives all around. But I think the US would fare better with a less trusting setup.

Arthwollipot mentioned collectivism versus individualism as societal descriptors, and I agree. I said way back ITT that I think there are crucial cultural differences (not America is "special"; just different) at play. When Australia experienced the horror of Port Arthur, they reacted very differently compared to how the US reacted to Sandy Hook. I think the aggressive individualism here is better kept in check by the stricter registration that I am suggesting.

Morons will be morons!
 
Then the law is irrelevant. Your constant hammering on about how super-perfect US law is is utterly irrelevant. It doesn't matter at all how good the laws are, or what model of law is in place, if people are going to break the law.

The above is an absolute textbook Perfect Solution Fallacy.

Utter rubbish!!

To label something that someone says "a perfect solution fallacy", they must have actually offered a solution to some problem in the first place. Cosmic Yak hasn't even suggested a solution in the bit you quoted, let alone anything perfect.

FYI, the perfect solution fallacy is a related informal fallacy that occurs when an argument assumes that a perfect solution exists or that a solution should be rejected because some part of the problem would still exist after it were implemented.

A good example of a perfect solution fallacy is gun-nuts claiming that since banning assault rifles does not guarantee there will be no school shootings in the future, it should therefore not be implemented.

All you have done is latched onto a piece of terminology without having the slightest understanding of what it means.
 
FYI, the perfect solution fallacy is a related informal fallacy that occurs when an argument assumes that... a solution should be rejected because some part of the problem would still exist after it were implemented.

Then the law is irrelevant... It doesn't matter at all how good the laws are, or what model of law is in place, if people are going to break the law.

I just love it that you don't see it when you have literally just quoted it.
 
I just love it that you don't see it when you have literally just quoted it.

I love it when you so clearly demonstrate that you have no ******* idea what you are talking about.

Please show the EXACT part of Cosmic Yak's post where he is offering a solution of any kind. No bull-****** No feeble elaboration. No pathetic explanation. Just quote the actual words, and only the words!
 
I love it when you so clearly demonstrate that you have no ******* idea what you are talking about.

Please show the EXACT part of Cosmic Yak's post where he is offering a solution of any kind. No bull-****** No feeble elaboration. No pathetic explanation. Just quote the actual words, and only the words!

Moving the goalposts already?

You said...and I just quoted you...that "a solution should be rejected because some part of the problem would still exist after it were implemented."

CY said...and I just quoted him...that "then the law (the solution) is irrelevant...because people are going to break the law (the problem that would still exist)".

You want to borrow a shovel to help dig yourself in deeper?
 
Moving the goalposts already?

You said...and I just quoted you...that "a solution should be rejected because some part of the problem would still exist after it were implemented."

CY said...and I just quoted him...that "then the law (the solution) is irrelevant...because people are going to break the law (the problem that would still exist)".

You want to borrow a shovel to help dig yourself in deeper?


Again, I will explain this to you in baby steps... one... word... at... a time!


NO.... SOLUTION.... WAS.... SUGGESTED.... OR.... IMPLIED....

Therefore, your claim that what Cosmic Yak said was a Perfect Solution Fallacy is FALSE!

I would offer to lend you a shovel, but since you're in construction (so you say) you should have a selection of your own to choose from.
 
Moving the goalposts already?

You said...and I just quoted you...that "a solution should be rejected because some part of the problem would still exist after it were implemented."

CY said...and I just quoted him...that "then the law (the solution) is irrelevant...because people are going to break the law (the problem that would still exist)".

You want to borrow a shovel to help dig yourself in deeper?

...I believe you have just committed the McNamara fallacy.
 
...I believe you have just committed the McNamara fallacy.

ThumbsUp-Wayne.gif
 
A couple of recent articles that seem to warrant necroing this thread. First, a clear indication of what I was saying earlier in the thread about existing laws protecting sex workers:

Queensland Law Reform Commission recommends widespread changes to sex work laws to decriminalise the industry

Queensland will decriminalise sex work after a major review found it should be treated as a job, not a crime, and regulated the same as other businesses.

Currently, sex can only be legally sold in about 20 licensed brothels across the state or by people working alone.

The Palaszczuk government asked the Queensland Law Reform Commission to review and recommend a framework for a decriminalised sex work industry.

...

A summary of the QLRC's report said current laws "stigmatise" sex workers, increase their vulnerability to exploitation and violence, are difficult to comply with, and create barriers to accessing health, safety and legal protections.

It has outlined a recommended framework it says aims to treat sex work businesses "the same as other lawful businesses" with the same general laws applying.

"Sex work businesses should be neither unfairly disadvantaged nor unfairly privileged," the summary report said.

"Special laws that single out sex work are not needed since laws of general application are fit for purpose."

Second, what happens when someone abuses a sex worker. There's a fair bit of detail in this report, so content warning for sexual abuse:

Canberra man found guilty in ACT Supreme Court of sexually assaulting sex worker

A Canberra man has been found guilty of sexually assaulting a sex worker at a Mitchell brothel in February 2021.

Darrell Michael Hudson, 31, was on Monday found guilty of 10 offences including sexually assaulting and choking the woman and punching a hole in the wall.

The list of offences also included three counts of sexual intercourse without consent and three acts of indecency. He was found not guilty on four of those charges.

...

Hudson's bail was continued and he'll be sentenced at a later date.
 
A couple of recent articles that seem to warrant necroing this thread. First, a clear indication of what I was saying earlier in the thread about existing laws protecting sex workers:

Queensland Law Reform Commission recommends widespread changes to sex work laws to decriminalise the industry



Second, what happens when someone abuses a sex worker. There's a fair bit of detail in this report, so content warning for sexual abuse:

Canberra man found guilty in ACT Supreme Court of sexually assaulting sex worker

It really is about time sex work was recognized as just another profession.

I hope and expect our government to move towards this sometime in the future, though we might have to wait a bit because I can't the that God bothered and Fundy Christian Luxon moving this along if he and his mob get elected to power in October.
 
Second, what happens when someone abuses a sex worker. There's a fair bit of detail in this report, so content warning for sexual abuse:

Hopefully, he'll spend a long time behind bars.

It really is about time sex work was recognized as just another profession.

I hope and expect our government to move towards this sometime in the future, though we might have to wait a bit because I can't the that God bothered and Fundy Christian Luxon moving this along if he and his mob get elected to power in October.

The legislation is pretty good as it stands, particularly after Megan Woods' redefined the independent contractor rules.

My fear is that bald **** and his far-right evangelical pals who make up most of their caucus will try to outlaw it all over again.
 
An anecdote on legal prostitution, straight from the mouths of those in the game. I took a notebook with me, so I'm fairly sure this is an accurate record of my visit to a brothel. Not as a customer!

The brothel is a corporate entity that doesn't have a street frontage or neon lights, so all clients come through bookings on the internet or phone, or referred by a group of taxi drivers and barmen at the local business club.

I was there at late morning tea, not long before noon, when the first clients start dribbling in.

The girls there consist of:

White girls:
A psychology master's student, age 24, utterly stunning brunette.
A solo mother, 28, attractive but not terribly bright bottle blonde. Surgically enhanced breasts.
A former receptionist aged 20. Not classically pretty but very tall (185 cm) with a figure that other women would kill for. Surprisingly smart brunette.
A buxom long-term prostitute of around 40-45. Dyed red hair, probably grey underneath. Pretty tough-looking chick, but attractive enough if you like them like that. Does BDSM as well as usual services.

Others:
A Pasifika business graduate aged 26 who's been unable to get a decent job in the city. 22, amazing figure and easily the prettiest and smartest girl there. Has been at this brothel for four years.
Two Chinese women in their 20s who speak very little English. Great figure x 2.

The most important thing about this brothel is, if you want a laugh, spend an hour with the girls - they are truly hysterically funny.

They all feel that any exploitation being done is by them on stupid men. They know what they're doing, take very little to zero enjoyment from the sex and make a fortune in income, which is why they're doing it.

They work with police instead of against them. Crooks like to go to hookers, and cops are well aware of that, as are the girls.

No attacks have occurred on any employee of the brothel in at least the 5 years the older woman has worked there. They have security on site and the guy on duty when I went is one big, cheerful Samoan bloke who looks like he spends his time off pulling trees out of the ground and snapping them in half.

I would recommend any politician looking to change the law better keep a close eye on his gonads, because the girls were absolutely adamant they will not allow it to become illegal. The older member of the crew is well-placed on the committee of the collective and is 100% certain life is safer for sex workers now than ever before.

One fascinating thing came up - blokes with disabilities. Because of their profile and discretion at this brothel, they service a surprisingly large number of disabled blokes who have rich families and who pay for a monthly or fortnightly (and one weekly) sex session for him. None of them had any problem with it and the master's student suggested there should be an allowance for the not-so-rich disabled to get a sex service as part of their essential services, which seems entirely reasonable to me. I think being able to get a root is a fairly basic human right, and I bet there aren't many women around who choose to have a relationship with a bloke in a wheelchair whose diaper needs changing every couple of hours.
 
An anecdote on legal prostitution, straight from the mouths of those in the game. I took a notebook with me, so I'm fairly sure this is an accurate record of my visit to a brothel. Not as a customer!

The brothel is a corporate entity that doesn't have a street frontage or neon lights, so all clients come through bookings on the internet or phone, or referred by a group of taxi drivers and barmen at the local business club.

I was there at late morning tea, not long before noon, when the first clients start dribbling in.

The girls there consist of:

White girls:
A psychology master's student, age 24, utterly stunning brunette.
A solo mother, 28, attractive but not terribly bright bottle blonde. Surgically enhanced breasts.
A former receptionist aged 20. Not classically pretty but very tall (185 cm) with a figure that other women would kill for. Surprisingly smart brunette.
A buxom long-term prostitute of around 40-45. Dyed red hair, probably grey underneath. Pretty tough-looking chick, but attractive enough if you like them like that. Does BDSM as well as usual services.

Others:
A Pasifika business graduate aged 26 who's been unable to get a decent job in the city. 22, amazing figure and easily the prettiest and smartest girl there. Has been at this brothel for four years.
Two Chinese women in their 20s who speak very little English. Great figure x 2.

The most important thing about this brothel is, if you want a laugh, spend an hour with the girls - they are truly hysterically funny.

They all feel that any exploitation being done is by them on stupid men. They know what they're doing, take very little to zero enjoyment from the sex and make a fortune in income, which is why they're doing it.

They work with police instead of against them. Crooks like to go to hookers, and cops are well aware of that, as are the girls.

No attacks have occurred on any employee of the brothel in at least the 5 years the older woman has worked there. They have security on site and the guy on duty when I went is one big, cheerful Samoan bloke who looks like he spends his time off pulling trees out of the ground and snapping them in half.

I would recommend any politician looking to change the law better keep a close eye on his gonads, because the girls were absolutely adamant they will not allow it to become illegal. The older member of the crew is well-placed on the committee of the collective and is 100% certain life is safer for sex workers now than ever before.

One fascinating thing came up - blokes with disabilities. Because of their profile and discretion at this brothel, they service a surprisingly large number of disabled blokes who have rich families and who pay for a monthly or fortnightly (and one weekly) sex session for him. None of them had any problem with it and the master's student suggested there should be an allowance for the not-so-rich disabled to get a sex service as part of their essential services, which seems entirely reasonable to me. I think being able to get a root is a fairly basic human right, and I bet there aren't many women around who choose to have a relationship with a bloke in a wheelchair whose diaper needs changing every couple of hours.

More than anything else, I think this is what makes me uncomfortable with the idea of prostitution (personally, not globally). Sex has always been about mutual fun, and if it's not mutual, it feels a little rapey, transactionally agreed or not. One of the painfully few good pieces of advice I got when I was young was "ladies first", if you're feeling me, and I have the hardest time conceptually unplugging from that.
 
I was there at late morning tea, not long before noon, when the first clients start dribbling in.

I would have thought the clients dribbling out to be more likely :D

More than anything else, I think this is what makes me uncomfortable with the idea of prostitution (personally, not globally). Sex has always been about mutual fun, and if it's not mutual, it feels a little rapey, transactionally agreed or not. One of the painfully few good pieces of advice I got when I was young was "ladies first", if you're feeling me, and I have the hardest time conceptually unplugging from that.

Its a job. Sometimes, jobs are not fun.

As was once said By David Mitchell in an episode of QI

"The thing that seems unfair to me is the number of people who are expected to pretend they care about jobs they don't care about. You should be allowed to say 'look, I'm fulfilling my contract, you can't put in the contract - also you have to seem like you give a ****'".​
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom